HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

angoragoats

890 karma · joined January 17, 2023

YC is managed by a bunch of fascist-supporting jerks.
submissionscomments
angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
I am speaking about free speech (lowercase, in the colloquial sense), not Free Speech (the constitutional right). In the context of this type of free speech, if you have two identical posts, and one is behind a login wall and one isn’t, the one not behind the login wall is objectively more free.
angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
He is a hypocrite, so he defines it however is convenient at the time. But I think my interpretation is a reasonable one for someone calling themselves a free speech absolutist.
angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
Sorry, I don’t think my question was clear. What I was really asking was how would an LLM kill someone? Meaning, via what mechanism? Because all of the possibilities I can think of involve a human doing something that probably shouldn’t be legal, first. In those cases we should hold that human responsible for murder, and again not attribute agency to the machine.

The original post said the LLM would “want to kill us.” My argument is that if this happened, it’d be a human wanting to kill us, using an LLM to launder responsibility.

angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
I assumed the parent post was referring to the Constitutional meaning when they said "Yes, we all know what 'free speech' really means and it has nothing to do with X," but if I misunderstood then I apologize!
angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
> Sometimes they do different things than what I asked for. Sometimes it requests permission for system operations like file system access that are totally unnecessary for the task.

Yes, I've seen this. Forget about the word "want" for a second. Can you help me understand how this amount of "below 100% adherence" could possibly rise to the level of "attempts to kill a human being"? Because that's what we're discussing here.

> When people say a spring "wants" to return to its initial length, they are not engaging in philosophy. They are using a linguistic shorthand to simplify an physical explanation.

Of course. The difference is that no one would mistake a spring for a thinking entity. In the case of LLMs, for some reason people do mistake them for thinking entities, so my argument is that it's important that we don't use terms that would reinforce that misconception.

angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
> "Freedom of speech" means you are allowed to express your opinion without fear of being censored or persecuted for it.

This is one way to define it, yes, but Musk is a self-described “free speech absolutist” which I would argue means that he feels speech should be maximally free.

> It is not the same kind of "free" as in "no cost".

I have never meant it in that way, and I’m not sure why you thought I did.

> To access Twitter, you have to pay for it. Either by purchasing a subscription or viewing ads.

This is possibly pedantic but this statement as written is false. I can view single tweets just fine, and I don’t see ads.

> Think of it as having to buy a newspaper before being able to read it. That doesn't stop the paper's editors from being able to criticize the government.

That analogy doesn’t really work here, IMO. My only point is that it’s objectively true that speech behind a login wall is less free (as in freedom) than speech not behind a login wall, and so a (non-hypocritical) “free speech absolutist” should always prefer the latter.

angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
I would argue that when he is talking about "free speech" he is always referring to the more general, non-US-Constitutional meaning of the phrase; i.e. the freedom to say what you want without being censored. So when a discussion about free speech on Twitter comes up, I assume that's the kind of free speech we're discussing. To bring in the the more narrow, first amendment meaning of the term is just a distraction or diversion.
angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
Yes, it is. It seems self-evident to me that the speech on Twitter is more free when it isn't behind a login wall. How could it not be? If you'd like to provide an actual counter-argument, I'd be happy to consider it.
angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
The repo being archived happened after that UPDATE post that you mention. So the project has gone from suspended, to un-suspended, and now it's suspended again (and the repo got archived this time).

Edit: I see I'm being downvoted for just providing facts, so here's some evidence: you can see on the main project page that the repo was archived on 11 Sep[0]. Looking in the commits, the "UPDATE" message was commited on 6 Sep[1].

[0] https://github.com/zedeus/nitter

[1] https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/commit/1428b4c2b4246f92a7e5...

angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
The phrase "free speech" does not typically mean "free as in beer," rather it means "free as in freedom," so in this case you're conflating the two meanings of "free" in English.

The fact that Twitter is login-gated makes it objectively less free as in freedom.

angoragoats··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
Twitter is heavily login-gated, to the point that I can't see Twitter threads at all unless I have an account. I do not wish to make an account. Services like Nitter/XCancel allow me to read those threads, making that speech more free.
angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
Why should we stop anthropomorphizing the text generation algorithm? Because it leads to psychosis and to making hyperbolic, dangerously wrong statements like “pray they don't want to kill us.”
angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
A spring does not want to do anything. An LLM does not want to do anything.

> These machines have done plenty of things not prompted for.

Like what?

angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
How is this a clear violation of antitrust law? And have any of the leaders of these companies said that they are asking for government permission for this reason?
angoragoats··on Due to concerns about malicious applications, GPT2 will not be released (2019)
How, exactly, is a deterministic text-generation algorithm going to “want to kill us” when it’s not capable of having desires, emotions, etc? If it does attempt to kill us, shouldn’t we be blaming those humans who instructed it to do so?

Put another way, could we stop anthropomorphizing the text generation algorithm, please?

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
Ah, I see you're still misunderstanding what I say. If you'd like to come back and actually engage with what I'm saying, ask for clarifications, or answer the hypothetical I posed, I'd welcome it!

Have a good one.

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
I do not agree to disagree, since I think your responses were either incorrect or not addressing my argument at all, but since you're not even attempting to engage anymore I'm happy to move on.
angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
> This language has been used in this way for 70 years. These are the words that are used to discuss these things. Are you suggesting this plan has been in the works for 70 years?

No, I am stating that the term “machine learning” as used in the Samuel paper and continuously used by researchers and programmers in that context up until the present is distinctly different from the word “learning” as used in public-facing LLM chatbot product copy and press releases. And as far as I’m aware, “reasoning” and “thinking” have no historical analogues, they were just invented to describe something that is distinctly not reasoning or thinking in any prior sense of the words.

> I have a question - if I made mechanical teeth and described its actions as "chewing", would I be trying to deceive you?

No. If I designed an algorithm for mimicking grammatically-correct speech, which given a certain input produces (deterministically) a superficially plausible, fluent response, and described its actions as “thinking,” would I be trying to deceive you?

angoragoats··on Whistleblower warns Postal Service mail ballot system has catastrophic problems
This statement as written is false. If you disagree, please show me where Massachusetts has a free ID card available to anyone who wants it. The only people in MA who can get a free ID are the homeless.

Yes, MA has other options for proving identity for voting purposes. But it does not have a general-purpose free ID card. If you’re going to be argumentative, and state that something “is a fact” multiple times, please make sure you’re correct before posting.

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
> You are ascribing intent where you have no evidence or proof

As I said already, the evidence is in the language they use, unless you think that OpenAI employees are dumb enough to genuinely believe that an LLM is “thinking.” (By the way, I’d love to see an historical, academic use of that term, which you’ve conveniently neglected to mention.) Anthropomorphizing their product benefits them.

> Those terms continue to be used in the community. They weren't used just once, 70 years ago.

I never said they weren’t used anymore or that they were used once. Once again, you’re not actually engaging with my argument, which is that the language they’re using is chosen specifically to fool people outside the community.

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
I am not arguing that any of these terms are novel, so this doesn’t address my argument.

Even if I agree that LLM makers are using these terms in the way they were originally defined (which I don’t), my point is that they’re specifically being used to help falsely attribute agency to the algorithm when there is none, and especially to convince members of the general public who aren’t familiar with computer science papers from 70 years ago.

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
Jail time for executives and nothing less.
angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
Yes, it is, for the reasons I stated in my comment, and you only need look at any OAI/Anthropic press release to see evidence of this in the language they use.

The LLM now reasons better! Set the thinking level! It learns!

All of these phrases are designed to give the impression that the LLM is an autonomous entity, when it is no such thing.

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
I don’t think plausible deniability works this way; the black box is still controlled by them and therefore still their responsibility. They are still liable for its actions and the OAI board should be charged with a felony/felonies for this.

Plausible deniability is “I was away from home when my gun was used to murder someone.” This is, at best, “oops, I pulled the trigger accidentally.”

angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
One of the main purposes of LLMs is to launder responsibility/culpability for (possibly nefarious) actions in the eyes of the public. The average person has no idea how LLMs actually work and think it’s plausible that an “agent” could go rogue without any human instruction. Terms like agent, thinking, reasoning, etc reinforce the misconception that the LLM has a mind of its own.
angoragoats··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
Sam Altman and the rest of the OAI board should be charged with violating the CFAA for this action.
angoragoats··on DigitalOcean joins Omarchy as a Founding Corporate Patron with $3M
Thanks for checking! I don't use products from any of these companies, with two exceptions: I use Stripe as a consumer when I need to buy something on a site which uses them for their payment processing, and I use Cloudflare as a consumer when a site I visit uses them; in general it seems completely impossible to avoid CF and still use the internet.

I certainly don't use any of them for side projects or other business purposes, and now I won't be using DigitalOcean for those purposes either.

angoragoats··on DigitalOcean joins Omarchy as a Founding Corporate Patron with $3M
Well, time to find a new VPS/DNS provider, I guess…
angoragoats··on I resigned from Anthropic today
Yes, exactly this. Externally, I have absolutely zero evidence that anything this person describes will come to pass, and I do have evidence that LLMs are not capable of many of the things that he mentions. So this seems like perhaps this person has drank the kool aid and is still not thinking clearly.
angoragoats··on I resigned from Anthropic today
A self-sustaining reaction is exactly what happens with the fissionable material inside the nuclear weapon[0]. It seems like you’re trying to be pedantic on terminology here, but if you’re saying that a self-sustaining reaction is as un-scientific as a perpetual motion machine, you’re simply incorrect.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticality_(status)

← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →