2,320 karma · joined May 12, 2014
Dividends vs. Buybacks are two totally different types of financial engineering.
The first accretes in a well-understood, and manageable way, while the second nebulously meddles in a multi-factor way, one by creating a float constraint (these shares are usually treasuried on the company balance sheet), and two a demand inflator through the company coffers entering the market chatter. Both dividends and buybacks are monsters that require regular feeding to keep tame; however, the buyback monster is arguably way more frightening if it becomes angry in the current hedge (option) everything world, compounded by reducing float.
That's just the first decision. The second decision to fund (and accelerate) the buyback process through debt is again financially brilliant, but at the levels Apple used to finance the buybacks (and has continued the process) - is confusing to a long term strategy.
What's the plan? How does hitting the debt-buyback wheel affect one's demeanor? Just keep securizsiting on the cash cows? When picking New Product A with 2 year useful life, one time revenue injection vs. a monthly fee service that is probably already tackled by our users (developers) quite well, which do we bias towards? What about finally loving up on PWAs?
What happens when people look at our 2.5trn market cap, fueled in a large way by these buybacks, and think why not spread that wealth around? It invites every armchair quarterback (hello, mirror) to tell you how to run the company's very visible success... it's operationally brilliant, but not all that aware of the next generation of customers and leaders.
If this sounds interesting, I'll fully flesh out a longer form explanation at some point. Tying this back to the point, the anti-trust cases are the most important decision we will make as a species for the next 100 years. To my novice mind, these are simply avoided (and corrected) by understanding the current motivations of Apple and what should really change... i.e. 'why do we really need to do these buybacks? Is this really the best stewardship to our long term business success (helping people make the best stuff, period.)?' The upcoming regulatory challenges will directly tell the solution makers, most of us on HN, how and where to participate, and if we must reinvent the wheel because the first one lost its way a bit and became too golden, that's a sad loss.
I like to think of this as Steve checking in with Tim's mother about how much he works -- i.e. Tim will arrive at the most 'correct' answer, but at a long term cost... these financial buy backs are technically brilliant, but how much organizational fatigue is created focusing on these initiatives?
[Edit] To finish the thought: these buybacks create an organization that makes Apple+ and services their primary initiatives, rather than focusing on documentation, and focusing on the circle of life of their current offerings (killing some products in favor of focus in others, moving the personal computing industry into the next great creation generation).
Would love to hear from boots on the ground if this aligns with the actual experience.
Would love to associate this comment’s context to the songs we hear
I ask because it is almost as if you see the bricks change shape at Apple trying to fill the missing piece... they know they need that influence, it’s just not there, and honestly, I want to be a part of an organization that operates in the post-kicked out Steve aura.
So my inner self says that these are red herrings, or false flags set by 'real players' to lead the stampede into your living room.
It feels like there's never been a better 'cover' than r/wallstreetbets for firms with real capital to put material volume behind names that would in other scenarios be extremely suspect, or near manipulation. Now you can say, 'see, retail said they like AMD, AMC, etc... (THE STOCK)" because, yes, some random user with karma can now be the input to your 'algo' to move $name_of_stock, or generally, SPY calls / 'poots' in size wildly impossible otherwise.
Humbly, I think it's brilliant
[Edit] to put this comment in context of my response to another poster, I believe the macro can be independent of the micro (aka many little names can get blown up while your main indices maintain some sense of normalcy).
Could you explain, indirectly or without identifiers, why now is different than back then?
More so that we all don’t miss out on those new opportunities!
Only very recently had a heard a parable that began to challenge the idea that to do deep good, one must materially suffer...
However, I'm no where near cured, and hearing your take definitely helps.
I've seen a lot of professions where in depth reporting still requires humans in the loop, and I think that will always be the case.
There's a small hope I have that one day writing will be a bit more like programming -- as in selecting a 'class' for a structure of a section / paragraph / thesis you want to communicate, which then provides typed functions for potential inputs -> outputs, freeing up human brain cycles for more interesting ideas.
> if you're not ready to write extensive reports.. it's probably 75% of the job
Do you happen to have a system for building these out? As a techie, I imagine you've tried something like text-expander or similar... but I see a lot of people unsatisfied that they end up building their own tools.
Infuriating.
Anyone who does this is not a dumbshit, those who get in their way probably are.
OP: would love to make your acquaintance, email is checked in profile.
Just a weird looking TAM (small as all get out and competitive market) is all I can chalk it up to - or I’m a crappy story teller
Sadly, as others have said, the unknown matrix server is tough, and further, the SMS hack is both a blessing and a curse - easy to use but unencrypted and mega-tracked by phone providers et. al
A “food desert” doesn’t account for the person who consistently orders two flavors in their tall iced coffee (usually equates to 6+ oz of simple syrup); that’s a choice — and a severe negative externality.
I think the same but with a different tack. If you get an infectious disease from another person, and that person didn’t want the disease either and wouldn’t want to spread it, then why are they?
How do people not know they have Covid and are giving it to their friends, coworkers, etc?
^ This line will get many officers to back down. It's calm, reserved and true. They will then argue with you and you just repeatedly point back to, 'I see what you're asking and you're trying to do your job, but I don't see our judge / warrant / district attorney / etc. I will now go about my day, thank you.'
I shuddered a bit reading this. By this logic, at any point where I am dependent on someone else for my survival in passage (say an airplane) the principle in the relationship (the pilot or airline) has a right to kill me?
If that’s the logic, then we can squarely see that we have chosen to punish those who have any responsibility in that situation. Re: wrongful death