HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

answerly

1,298 karma · joined November 2, 2008

Co-Founder, InboundScore.com (YC W1).

Email me at joe@inboundscore.com

submissionscomments
answerly··on Ask HN: Advice on evaluating perceived search engine effectiveness
We track average click position for each query and use that as a measure of effectiveness. We evaluate any changes based on the impact to that metric.
answerly··on Can Bing steal Google's traffic by using Adwords?
It presumably makes sense for Bing to buy ads on any keyword that leads to a profitable customer acquisition opportunity.
answerly··on Can Bing steal Google's traffic by using Adwords?
http://www.businessinsider.com/yahoo-spends-90965-per-day-on...

http://www.businessinsider.com/top-100-google-advertisers-by...

That second link pre-dates Bing's launch, I believe. You'll see Yahoo and Ask.com in the top 15. Much of the top 20 are product, travel or local search engines.

answerly··on Ask HN: What are some good examples of entrepreneurs being resourceful?
Brian Chesky from AirBnB offers up a bunch of great examples in this talk from Startup School.

http://www.justin.tv/startupschool/b/272180383

answerly··on Can Bing steal Google's traffic by using Adwords?
Bing, Yahoo, Ask and dozens or hundreds of smaller, niche search engines already spend millions of dollars per month on Google Adwords.
answerly··on Hah PetFlow Raises $5 Million To Sell Pet Food Online
>Companies like this could've easily succeeded even 10 years ago if the old-school dot-com companies hadn't blown all their capital on super bowl ads and aeron chairs.

Maybe. There have been a lot of innovations in the consumer Internet business that have enabled the successes of businesses like diapers.com...

1) Internet adoption rate is 2-3x higher now than it was in 1998. Companies like Pets.com weren't just building their own brands, but also educating everyday people about the Internet.

2) There were no self-serve distribution channels like SEM or affiliate marketings that had any scale. Google was founded the same year as Pets.com and Adwords didn't surface for a few years after that. The only ads you could buy were CPM banners, integrated sponsorship deals (AOL bankrupted several companies with these types of deals) and offline media like TV commercials. Additionally, media buys were a lot less accountable. I was selling online ads at this time and some of my clients weren't even tracking registrations by source let alone sales on their website.

3) Businesses like Amazon and Zappos have helped create a completely different model for logistics that simply didn't exist 10-12 years ago. There is a reason that Pets.com had to spend tens to hundreds of millions on infrastructure for warehouses, etc.

answerly··on Hah PetFlow Raises $5 Million To Sell Pet Food Online
These guys are the founders of Azoogle (now Epic Advertising) which is a very large CPA marketing network. They are not only very successful entrepreneurs but understand customer acquisition, LTV, etc. Pets.com jokes aside, these are very analytical guys and are well positioned to make something like this work.
answerly··on Ask HN: Startups and Past Contributions
This line from the linked Chris Dixon post sums it up pretty well:

"Remember that an equity grant is typically for the next 4 years of work (hence 4 years of vesting)."

answerly··on Ask HN: What would happen to Google's revenue if Firefox came with an adblocker?
Thats exactly right. More than 85% of Mozilla's revenue comes from an ad rev share with Google.
answerly··on A very real and sad start up story
It seems like the most likely scenario is that they burned through the VC cash and couldn't raise more, so they were forced to sell. If the VCs had some high liquidation preference it could easily explain how the common shareholders and early investors (like his dad) were wiped out.

It is obviously a total bummer that his dad lost $100k in the process. But, he tries to make it sound like he was tricked out of his pension or something. This was a very high risk investment where the most likely outcome would be a total loss.

answerly··on Ask HN: Best Books about Startups
The New New Thing by Michael Lewis
answerly··on Ask HN: What's the best strategy to relocate to the Bay Area?
We are hiring right now- I'd love to chat. I'm also an SF native so can give you some general perspective on the bay area as well. Feel free to email me any time. joe@answerly.com
answerly··on My Start-Up: 3000 unique users a day, only 3 offers?
I'd just stop if I were you. Dismissing every helpful piece of advice out of hand makes you seem like a very unreasonable person.

Good luck with your startup. I hope everything works out for the best.

answerly··on My Start-Up: 3000 unique users a day, only 3 offers?
>But the initial comment sounded like I should stalk people, corner them, and in general be a jerk. I refuse to do that.

Thats a pretty big leap from my initial suggestion of asking one of your existing LinkedIn contacts to introduce you to one of their existing LinkedIn contacts that may be able to help you out.

You've got some good food for thought and advice from others throughout this thread. I'd suggest taking a time out, coming back and reading through the 30ish posts here with as objective an eye as possible.

answerly··on My Start-Up: 3000 unique users a day, only 3 offers?
Unfortunately, your belief in this regard is the exact opposite of what investors tend to suggest when asked how they can be reached. Investors want a genuine introduction from a single trusted source like a portfolio CEO or another investor that they have done deals with.

The good news is that entrepreneurs typically really like helping out other entrepreneurs with advice and connections when they can. But, entrepreneurs also tend to very, very busy running their startups. So, leaving it up to someone else to take the initiative in order to secure the outcome you want may not be the best course of action.

answerly··on My Start-Up: 3000 unique users a day, only 3 offers?
For example...

I just looked up your LinkedIn profile and you have a contact that is connected to 5 entrepreneurs that I happen to also know who have raised seed funding. Have you tried reaching out to that person to get intros to those entrepreneurs (4 of which have raised money in the last 3-6 months)?

answerly··on My Start-Up: 3000 unique users a day, only 3 offers?
Just to contribute a data point:

We were lucky enough to be accepted to YC a couple batches ago. It took us about 2 months of constant pitching and investor wrangling to close our seed round after demo day.

It is great that the original post brought you some initial visibility. It is not clear to me that you have done much to proactively capitalize on that.

answerly··on Ask HN: Who do you trust when it comes to sharing your ideas?
I try to share with anyone that will listen. My ideas tend to improve when I am forced to verbalize them. Also, getting external feedback at the earliest stages is really valuable to me.
answerly··on Time for a new Twitter tag
^ is often used by accounts that have multiple users. For example check out the way bank of america support reps "sign" each tweet with ^ and then initials:

http://twitter.com/bofa_help

answerly··on Any bad experiences with Y combinator?
I've never heard of a negative YC experience either. I'd guess I've met at least one founder from roughly 40% of all YC startups. This includes some companies that have failed or been absorbed into other YC startups.

YC was/is certainly an amazing experience for us.

answerly··on Advice for YC Applicants: Better Last-Minute than Late
We submitted our application within about an hour of the deadline last year. I was so convinced that we wouldn't be accepted for an interview that I didn't explicitly tell Jason (my co-founder) we were applying. We were both very happy with how things turned out!
answerly··on What are Google's Traffic Acquisition Costs?
I think they have been reporting aggregate numbers like this for a while. IIRC TAC as a % of revenue has been consistently decreasing over the last several years.
answerly··on What are Google's Traffic Acquisition Costs?
From the linked earnings summary:

"The majority of TAC is related to amounts ultimately paid to our AdSense partners, which totaled $1.52 billion in the third quarter of 2010. TAC also includes amounts ultimately paid to certain distribution partners and others who direct traffic to our website..."

So, primarily adsense but also likely includes the other methods of distribution you referenced.

answerly··on Ask HN: Considering quitting my day job to work on my startups
>but it's still a large gamble.

I know it seems like a big gamble room your current vantage point, but it really isn't. You are an entrepreneurial developer in a tech economy where that skill set is at a premium (at least in startup hubs like the bay area). It seems like the worst case scenario is that you end up getting a job at another startup if your projects don't work out.

Good luck!

answerly··on Ask HN: how to find angels/early investors in NYC?
I think YC is the best place to get a YC-sized investment. Have you considered applying? Lots of (most?) YC companies relocate from somewhere else for the batch. Some stay in the bay area and some move back home afterwards.

There is a YC event in NYC next week, in fact: http://alexisohanian.com/ask-y-combinator-anything-yc-qa-ses...

answerly··on Ask HN: How do I manage equity and dilution in a lifestyle business?
All things being equal between this theoretical opportunity and another with a more attractive compensation structure, no.

If I believed that there was a longer term value to the equity that could make up for the shortfall in cash compensation, maybe.

But, the specific case you've laid out leads me to believe that there isn't significant growth potential in this business. Am I interpreting that wrong?

answerly··on Ask HN: How do I manage equity and dilution in a lifestyle business?
>First, the likelihood of anyone besides me being here for four years is pretty small...

That is the point. If your employee leaves before they have vested their shares they don't get to keep them.

>but it's still very likely a company death, if someone with 50% of the company leaves.

No, not necessarily. Founders of successful companies leave after several years of service all the time (happened recently with Xobni, for example).

>Do you have a link where I can read up on what profit sharing means and how that differs from equity? I do not know these things.

There are lots of resources if you just do a quick Google search. The basic idea is that your employees would get a % of profits you generate in a given year rather than equity.

>If you could get a job on the open market that paid $130K in salary and benefits, would you instead work for some crazy guy for $30K cash plus another twenty grand in equity?

No. Not because I wouldn't want to work for equity (I have done that before) but because there doesn't be a clear path to liquidity of those options. You've described this as a lifestyle business which typical means no imminent source of liquidity for shareholders. This is why I suggested exploring a profit sharing structure.

If you are saying that this is a business that can't support livable compensation for employees for the foreseeable future, then I think there are bigger issues though.

Sorry if I am not fully understanding what you are getting at.

answerly··on Ask HN: How do I manage equity and dilution in a lifestyle business?
> I think the way it works in most startups is that you agree to an equity split, and if one founder leaves, the company dies or you buy him out and that's that.

It is increasingly common for founders to have vesting schedules to prevent this exact issue. If the founders have a four year vesting schedule and one founder bails after year one, then they forfeit the un-vested equity.

>Now, each time they go out for another round of funding, their old investors are diluted by the new shares created to sell to new investors.

Yes and no. It depends on the valuation. A previous investor's absolute ownership percentage may decrease in subsequent funding rounds. But, if the valuation increase outpaces the rate of dilution the previous investor winds up ahead. For example, Peter Thiel's ownership in Facebook has been diluted in subsequent funding rounds but the value of his investment has increased many times over based off of the increased valuations.

>My thought is that every 6-12 months or so, we simulate another round of funding.

This sounds overly complicated. Rather than the equity gymnastics, why not implement a profit sharing program for your employees? This seems more appropriate anyway since it sounds like you are focused on running this as a lifestyle business for the long haul.

If you are set on providing equity, then why not just create a standard employee option pool (i.e. carve out 10-20% of shares outstanding to allocate employees)? With four year vesting you take very little risk.

answerly··on The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe
I have evidence as this is essentially what happened to us. We purchased .ly variant of our domain name through an authorized Libyan registrar about 10 months ago. It was seized back without explanation a few days later. When I contacted the registrar I was told that the domain was available for "four figures" through domains.ly (an aftermarket .ly reseller service that is operated by the same authorized registrar we used to purchase the domain initially). The domain wasn't critical, so we didn't pursue it any further.
answerly··on Ask HN: I need help 'guessing' initial startup cost
As others have mentioned below, there are probably at least one or two intermediate steps between where you appear to be now (earliest stages of business planning)and being in a position to raise a significant financing round. You'll need a product and probably some initial traction with users and, hopefully, revenue.

That said, you can calculate a rough monthly burn rate by adding together the estimated monthly salaries of the employees you referenced in your post and increase that number by 130-150%. This roughly accounts for all the operating expenses. If you need guidance on salaries try checking out resources like salary.com.

You'd probably want at least 18 months of cash in the bank. This gives you a year to execute and six months to focus on sustainable profitability and/or additional later stage financing.

So, monthly burn rate x target number of months of cash in the bank is your target financing amount.

Hope this helps.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →