HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anthuswilliams

985 karma · joined September 15, 2010

anthuswilliams at gmail dot com
submissionscomments
anthuswilliams··on A senior engineer's guide to the system design interview
There's nothing 'unnecessary' about it. If you can't talk about technology in an interview for a software engineer, what else do you have to go on?
anthuswilliams··on The economics of thinness
The article seems pretty clearly to indicate that this is far from "just a special case". It cites data that show that the rewards to thin women relative to fat ones far outpace the differences in reward for men on their own axes of attractiveness.
anthuswilliams··on Why are clinical trials so expensive? Tales from the beast’s belly
No, in fact it is quite common to do "open label" clinical studies in which patients know what drug they are getting and no one is given the current standard of care. This is especially common in cancer, where the standard of care is so poor, and in rare diseases, where the patient population isn't large enough to admit such a comprehensive study.

It is harder to have the same statistical confidence of efficacy and safety in such studies, but clinical researchers try to address those issues by varying e.g. dosage quantities, time in between doses, etc.

Source: place I work is currently doing studies of this nature, and in general such studies seem to be well-understood and accepted by the FDA.

anthuswilliams··on Ask HN: What does your mother tell people about your work or employment?
My mom used to say I "worked for Google" (back when that was considered respectable) when I participated in Summer of Code one year.
anthuswilliams··on The bottom is dropping out of Netflix
I don't personally pirate much, but I take umbrage at you characterizing it in this way. You seem to think that the issues of accessing media without subjecting yourself to user-hostile behaviors are wholly orthogonal to the issue of accessing media without paying for it. They aren't.

Imagine a hypothetical universe where, in order to watch one of your movies, people had to a) pay you $1 and also b) let you punch them in the nose. Then, when people sensibly start pirating your content instead because they don't want to get punched, you loudly proclaim that they are stealing the $1 you are owed.

That's what's happening here. People want to watch your content, and are willing to pay for it. But they don't want to pay for it AND get punched in the nose. They pirate because your distributors, and by extension you yourself, have made it impossible to watch your content (and pay you!) in any other way.

I get that your natural rejoinder will be "if the content is not worth being punched in the nose, just don't watch it!" Which is fair. Debatable, but fair. Just don't come here pretending that all you have asked for is the reasonable sum of $1 when you are actually demanding that your customers subject themselves to the indignity of your fist.

anthuswilliams··on On Being Indispensable
In the article they said

> I had a hard time thinking strategically about product. I was too busy supporting the entire organization on all things related to the product.

so that's a pretty clear indication of what was missing. Instead of being able to recognize broad industry trends and come up with broad product evolutions that meet those needs, this person is stuck answering quibbles about particular customers or particular implementations.

anthuswilliams··on Ask HN: How do you manage your companies knowledge base?
SO itself offers a private version of its project for this purpose.
anthuswilliams··on Career advice nobody gave me: Never ignore a recruiter
There are so many comments from people who report being inundated on LinkedIn by recruiters. I don't have a LinkedIn account, and I _never_ hear from recruiters. My name is out there; I'm on other developer-centric social networks and generally have no compunction about giving out my email address and phone number, and I literally don't have this problem. I have over a decade of experience in many different software engineering roles, so I assume I would be a plum prize for unscrupulous recruiters. (I used to receive messages like these, but they dropped off around 2013. I assume this is roughly the point that recruiters realized that they could focus on LinkedIn to maximize their conversion.)

So, serious question: why do you have a LinkedIn account? I know there is theoretical benefit in maintaining connections to professional acquaintances, but in sticking to email and a few alumni Slack channels, I have never felt limited in that department. What is the benefit of your LinkedIn account and why do you keep it?

anthuswilliams··on Green Lumber Fallacy in Software Engineering
The maximum number of stockholders for a private corporation is 2000, and it excludes stock awarded as part of employee grants, so that point is not a factor. But your other points still aptly demonstrate the utter lunacy of this idea.
anthuswilliams··on Green Lumber Fallacy in Software Engineering
Agreed. This idea could only by put forth by someone who has never had to do the work involved in hiring a software engineer.
anthuswilliams··on Ask HN: Show your failed projects and share a lesson you learned
I spent a few years trying to bootstrap an app for independent pharmacies. The basic idea was a kanban board for patients whose prescriptions were coming due for refills. Pharmacists would use it to coordinate calls out to patients to proactively refill their prescriptions a few days before they were due to run out. This gave them time to fix insurance snafus, get renewals from doctors, etc, and they could lower their inventory costs by only stocking drugs when they knew patients would come to purchase them. Moreover, most insurance companies are following Medicaid in implementing a program where they rate pharmacies based on the degree to which their patients are adherent to their prescribed medications and use this rating to adjust how much they paid the pharmacy for the drugs they issued. So the product also helped to pharmacies improve this rating by ensuring patients picked up their medications on time (which is the only means whereby these agencies know if patients are adherent).

I could go on and on about the problems:

1) I (and the two other programmers I was working with) had a job. The pace at which we rolled out features and bugfixes was glacial, even when customers were clamoring for them. And this statement is just about improving the app; it doesn't even consider the other tasks involved in running a business, on which I was even less excited to spend effort.

2) Pharmacy management software is a fragmented market, and almost every player is impossible to integrate with. Since our product didn't do the insurance, billing, inventory management, etc. it meant we had to integrate with them. We started out by telling people to run them side by side and manually make changes to both our app and that of their vendor. Not a great pitch. Looking back, I wish I'd invested in this from the get-go, instead of trying to do it after building the app.

3) The product required pharmacies to change their entire workflow to even realize the benefits. Which is fine, but we sold it as a software thing that worked magically, and didn't invest at all in helping customers use it successfully.

4) Our cofounders (pharmacists) were not interested in running a SaaS company. They viewed the app as their strategic advantage in their own pharmacy, and dragged their feet on the customer outreach we hoped they would take ownership of. I felt like they were actively working against me. This was the biggest issue, and what caused me to finally decide to close it down. Someone else in this thread made a statement of "I went from the prototype guy to the only one who cared." and that statement really resonates with me. In retrospect, I had the opportunity to structure the deal as more of a product/customer one than a cofounder one, and I wish I had been smarter about that.

I still think it was a great idea, and we built a slick app. I just failed on the sales and customer outreach side of the business. The app still exists in a zombie state, and a few customers still use and pay for it. I haven't done anything on it other than renew SSL certs since 2019.

anthuswilliams··on Avoiding bot detection: How to scrape the web without getting blocked?
I'm not the poster you're replying to, but: Facebook collects asks for your phone number for security/account recovery reasons, but then turns around and uses it to market to you.
anthuswilliams··on Tech salaries fall in Bay Area, New York City, rise in Austin, San Diego
"Tech salaries" is a broad enough category that this sort of bias could very much still be present, particularly if the research by Hired wasn't controlling for level, seniority, etc.

I didn't read the report by Hired that this article was based on (because it's useless blogspam) but I did search for the word "control" to see if they were controlling for these sorts of confounding variables, and I came up empty-handed.

anthuswilliams··on Why nobody hires junior developers and what happens next
I interpreted the parent's post to mean they are encountering resumes which list neither internships NOR unrelated work experience.
anthuswilliams··on SWE interviews should be paid
Impostor syndrome is a thing. And if you're paying money, people will opt out because they don't want to feel like they're defrauding you. This viewpoint is strikingly common.
anthuswilliams··on SWE interviews should be paid
The article makes a lot of unsubstantiated claims, but one that catches my eye is the idea that paying people to interview is more inclusive because it allows companies to issue challenges that are more representative of the actual job. But are there actually any data out there that support this claim?

This is a common canard. I can see how it might make some intuitive sense, but it appears to be utterly mistaken. When I brought up the idea at my current workplace, we ended up choosing not to pay candidates, because almost 100% of our female software engineers declared that they would not have started an interview process where they were being paid unless they were VERY certain they were qualified for the role.

anthuswilliams··on Tech Companies with Four-Day Work Weeks
Meh. I mostly see it as a regression to the mean. Over the years, Silicon Valley has shown itself as being willing to bend over backwards to the young and childless, sponsoring conference tickets, corporate getaways to tropical islands, happy hours, etc. All of those things are a material benefit to a certain type of person in an earlier stage of life, but are of limited or negative value to a new parent.
anthuswilliams··on There Are Aliens, but Probably Not Here
The third scenario here is equivalent to the "God tells us we're in one of two universes" experiment. The only difference between the two scenarios is that, in the latter, the two universes "exist", but if God had said "there were two universes and I destroyed one; you inhabit the one which remains; which is it?" our answer wouldn't change.

The fourth scenario is more interesting because we've admitted the distribution of p is unknown to us. You note that if p is uniform, all intelligent lifeforms should conclude they live in a universe where p is high, but I'm not certain of that. It seems to me that this logic only works if you conclude there is _one_ universe for each possible value of p. But if, for each possible value of p, the multiverse contains universes for each possible outcome of a Bernoulli trial with probability p, then we can't conclude anything at all. To see this, notice that the number of Lucky universes (where p is high) is uncountably infinite, just as the number of Unlucky-Lucky universes (where p is low but a miracle has occurred) is uncountably infinite.

I haven't thought this next part through as deeply, but I believe this problem compounds given the unknown distribution of p. This is because subjectivist models of probability (e.g. Bayes' Theorem) are heavily influenced by the distribution of the prior when we have only observed one trial. And in cases like this one, where the only trials that _could_ be observed are successes, I believe it's all but entirely driven by the distribution of the prior. (You could imagine a hyperprior - a distribution of distributions of p, but I don't think we have any good reason for deciding what that would be either).

Anyway, thanks for this. I love geeking out about epistemology.

anthuswilliams··on There Are Aliens, but Probably Not Here
This is a very thoughtful rejoinder, thanks.

> If X occurred, and is more likely under hypothesis B than A, then X is evidence for hypothesis B, otherwise you don't have a consistent system of probability.

The point is, this idea breaks down when neither hypothesis would exist if X had not occurred. This differs from other questions of probability because the conditional probability of an event is predicated on the ability of an observer to ask about it. We should indeed be indifferent between the two hypotheses, if our own existence is all we have to go on. (This might seem strange, if you think of hypothesis B as having 100x the prior probability, but the point here is that we really don't have a basis for a prior at all.)

> Now you can further imagine that God comes down from heaven and tells you that in fact both of these two universes actually exist, and they are the only two universes that exist, so you are definitely in one of the two, but doesn't tell you which one. Is your posterior probability now 50% between the two?

No, of course I would assume I was in universe B. This is a very different question. Instead of "what is the nature of our universe" the question is "of the two existing universes God has described, which do I occupy?"

anthuswilliams··on There Are Aliens, but Probably Not Here
This article makes a familiar error in thinking that I routinely see when it comes to the subject of extraterrestrial life. It goes like this:

1) There exist billions and billions of stars, each of which can be thought of an independent Bernoulli trial with probability P as to whether intelligent life exists in that star system.

2) P must be a non-negligible quantity, because we ourselves exist

3) Therefore intelligent life "must" exist elsewhere in the universe due to the sheer number of trials.

This is an epistemological error that echoes the sort of error made by proponents of intelligent design. They conclude that the chance of thinking beings evolving is prodigiously unlikely, and therefore our existence is proof of a creator.

But in fact, you cannot post-hoc conclude that our existence says anything at all about P, because if we didn't exist, there would be no one to ask the question. Therefore the fact that we are wondering about the value of P means our existence is an implicit axiom of the logical system itself. One way to think of it is there could be infinitely many possible universes with no life at all, and by definition the question of P can only discussed in the one branch, in all that lifeless space of possibilities, where thinking beings actually exist. So P could, in fact, be made arbitrarily small, and Earth could indeed be the only place in the universe with intelligent life.

Note that this doesn't claim that extraterrestrial life _doesn't_ exist. It merely points out the truth in all of this P-hacking: that we have no evidentiary basis for believing one way or the other.

anthuswilliams··on The Amazon Rainforest Now Emits More Greenhouse Gases Than It Absorbs
Sorry, I should have realized the punctuation would be interpreted this way, but I didn't. I didn't intend it as a literal quote of the article, rather a paraphrase of its claims.
anthuswilliams··on The Amazon Rainforest Now Emits More Greenhouse Gases Than It Absorbs
That's fair. But in return, I offer the counter-argument:

When you double count like this, you are implicitly assuming deforestation ALLOWED the polluting business to occupy the new land, and they wouldn't have polluted to the same degree elsewhere (because it wasn't available, wasn't as profitable, or something else).

A totally reasonable claim! I could explore it further. But IMO one should make this claim in good faith, make it clear what you're proposing, not engage in this kind of statistical sleight of hand.

I am totally opposed to deforesting the Amazon. But I'm sick of political participants that think it's OK to lie to people, simply because the implications of the lie favor some greater truth.

anthuswilliams··on The Amazon Rainforest Now Emits More Greenhouse Gases Than It Absorbs
No. Double counting is an effect of ascribing the emissions.

When you ascribe the effects to the Amazon, you combine the two. As a simple exercise, imagine that the deforested land had been left fallow, and the CO2 emitting business had set up shop at a different plot of land. You wouldn't ascribe the CO2 emitted by the business to the Amazon, and therefore, when you DO ascribe it to the Amazon, you are double-counting the effect.

None of this is to say that it's okay to deforest the Amazon. I just hate it when people lie with numbers for the sake of a catchy headline.

anthuswilliams··on The Amazon Rainforest Now Emits More Greenhouse Gases Than It Absorbs
What the article is saying here is, --ignoring the rest of the Amazon (A), if you take the amount of CO2 what would have been sequestered if the forest had been left alone (B) and then add it to the amount of CO2 emitted by whatever business interests thereafter occupied the land (C) you get a large number of greenhouse gases! Such that, when you subtract that from the amount of CO2 the Amazon would have absorbed if not for A, you get a negative number.--

They're double counting the deforestation. There's nothing else to see here.

anthuswilliams··on Be in a field where tech is the limit
One problem you see a lot in biotech, is that "bio" and "tech" tend to form separate poles of the company, and there is little cross-contamination between the two. I[0] think being on site is an important counterweight to that phenomenon. I think it's what has made us successful so far.

We've been doing a lot of remote work during covid and I have definitely noticed the decline of water-cooler solidarity. We still do hire remote engineers and data scientists, but only in cases where they are the literal top of their field.

[0] Standard disclaimers: I work at Recursion, have drunk the Kool-Aid, etc etc

anthuswilliams··on Be in a field where tech is the limit
I'm a software engineer at Recursion, and Imran is telling the truth. I was on my way to posting a comment just like this when I saw this.

If you're exploring the world of AI for drug discovery, IMO, it's important not to fall for the trap of companies that just do "AI on public available data". That's just the same "the fundamental problem of software is a lack of ideas" phenomenon the article was talking about. You want to meld software and data science skills with the fundamental work of whatever industry you want to be the vanguard of.

Seriously, if you're in the market, check out Recursion. My contact is in my bio also, and I'll answer any questions Imran can't (or won't :p).

anthuswilliams··on Writing tools I learned from The Economist
It's more than just being upfront about their bias. It's also the way they avoid descending into demonizing and name-calling. Even when discussing leaders of whom they clearly disapprove such as Recep Erdogan, Jair Bolsonaro, and Donald Trump, they don't come right out and declare them as "lunatics". Instead, they try to write dispassionate analysis which often drives readers to the conclusion that they are lunatics. This might seem a subtle distinction, but it is a marked departure from the shrill tone of many other media outfits.
anthuswilliams··on Writing tools I learned from The Economist
The leaders are the only part of the magazine I skip these days.
anthuswilliams··on Police playing music while being filmed, seemingly to trigger copyright filters
The parent is not "straight up saying" anything like what you claim they are.
anthuswilliams··on 23andMe to merge with VG Acquisition Corp. to become publicly-traded company
The sponsors of the SPAC set aside for themselves a big chunk of the shares of the newly combined entity. So in general, the company gets a worse price than it would if it had gone public via an IPO.
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →