HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

antonovka

1,517 karma · joined July 29, 2009

submissionscomments
antonovka··on Atlas Beta Program Launched
You're right, I don't think it's a fair trade -- I'm not going to pay money to beta test your admittedly unstable, rough-hewn software.

I'm not telling you this to be offensive. I'm doing so because it's clear you're alienating people who would both test and evangelize, and I think that's an unfortunate waste for a product I think has great potential (but is much, much too veiled in secrecy and a general lack of public information).

If you think the opinion isn't valuable, you're also just as free to ignore it as you see fit (... but given that I've contributed patches to Cappuccino in the past, I'm pretty surprised you don't think I'm in your 'target audience' just because I'm not excited to pay $20 AND test your software for free.)

antonovka··on Atlas Beta Program Launched
Well, it's as unlikely to cost $1000 as it is to cost $20. That being said, Atlas is completely optional. Everything built with Cappuccino to date did NOT use Atlas. And this will always be a viable option.

You wouldn't be the first company to start with these intentions, only to eventually widen the open source/commercial split, where features never reach the open source edition. It's a possibility, however remote you might consider it, that we have to anticipate and plan for.

If the tools save time and money, we'll buy it, but we also have to consider potential lock-in costs a very real part of the price.

This beta is not intended to get large exposure. It's intended to get a group of people who we are confident will be dedicated to helping us make Atlas a better product.

If we're supposed to be helping you, it seems inappropriate to charge.

antonovka··on Atlas Beta Program Launched
Less than $1000? For any per-seat pricing that nears $1k, Atlas needs be so much better than the current tools that it'll shoot sunshine and rainbows out of our asses while we're using it.

Investing in Atlas is making a heavy investment in technology solely provided by yourselves: Obj-J and Cappuccino. The foundation being open source may alleviate some concern there, but to do so, the open source foundation will need to be of sufficient quality and usefulness that we feel we can work without your IDE in the future.

I'm also VERY surprised that you're charging for an expiring beta. Doing so will greatly limit user exposure, and I'm pretty uncomfortable with paying for the privilege of testing your software.

You're not Apple -- developers don't need to pay for the ability to test/update their software for an upcoming OS release.

antonovka··on Rogue Amoeba abandons iPhone because of App Store approval insanity
Yes -- Apple makes direct review contacts available to larger companies, permits them to break certain portions of the SDK agreement, and provides assistance and status information while navigating the (much more friendly) review process.

They also provide leg-ups by negotiating feature of their applications, etc.

antonovka··on Tell HN: Apple paid my iPhone money, with exceptional service
To those apologists who said Apple couldn't fix this issue rapidly if they were sufficiently motivated by negative press or otherwise -- you were wrong.

It took many months, but something finally motived Apple to move.

antonovka··on Schneier on Security: Is Antivirus Dead?
Only if you're aware that the virus is running, and it doesn't do something disastrous in the meantime (eg, sniff your keystrokes while you enter a bank account number or log into the hospital records system).
antonovka··on About that Cranky IT guy.
I agree. If you have a privileged position, it is your responsibility to ignore anything personal you come across -- insofar long as it's not illegal or forbidden by established company policy.

I wouldn't hesitate to reprimand and/or fire a system administrator that repeated (much less joked about) any personal information they came across in the course of their duties.

On the other hand, as an employee, I think it's also your responsibility to assume that any of your communications may be monitored by someone less polite than you would prefer, and to act accordingly.

antonovka··on About that Cranky IT guy.
You have to reasonably expect any work communications to be open to monitoring, be it accidental, intentional, or ancillary. The "IT guy" could be monitoring the DNS cache logs for the purpose of debugging, and if your request for www.russiandancingdolls.com comes along, he'll see it, and if he has any sense of decorum, ignore it.

Given that, if you have something to hide, don't do it at work. It's no use being pissed off about it -- it comes with the territory of shared infrastructure.

antonovka··on Zero-day flaw found in web encryption
They're a useful alternative/addition to Kerberos infrastructure, especially with PKCS#11 smart cards.

I think that x509 client auth is probably underused due to the lack of good, free implementations of CA software to manage those certificates.

antonovka··on Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fiasco)
Dustin might be brash, but he is pointing out obvious problems. It makes no sense to bash him for being 21 and not having yet been turned into a so serious, cynical corporate designer.

If you're trying to get something useful done, the point isn't to be right, but rather, to convince others of your position.

If you're trying to draw attention to yourself at the cost of others, ranting publicly is a fine strategy. To quote the original article: Fire your entire design team, if you have one. Hire an outside design firm ... as quickly as possible. Your in-house team is obviously incapable of building a good experience.

It's this brazen self-promotion and a lack of maturity and decorum that causes individuals to "bash him for being 21 and not having yet been turned into a so serious, cynical corporate designer".

antonovka··on WTF is up with Dell?
The purpose of a quote is to negotiate a better price.

I know, which is why I said exactly that in my post =)

That said, I prefer vendors that simply charge everyone the same reasonable price, rather than having such a large profit margin that they can afford to:

1) Pay a sales team to finagle over quotes.

2) Slash their prices on demand.

Obviously, things are a bit different when you're buying in truly massive quantities.

antonovka··on WTF is up with Dell?
I love up-front non-predatory pricing. I hate wasting my time with salespeople, though sometimes you can work out a better deal with them.

My preferred vendor is Silicon Mechanics: http://www.siliconmechanics.com/

They sell SuperMicro equipment, they list prices, estimated power draw, etc, all up-front. You can add machines to your shopping cart, checkout, and you're done.

They've always provided us with fantastic customer service, and stepped up to replace/repair anything that didn't work right, even if the cause wasn't entirely clear (such as a hard drive issue that could have been OS related, but turned out to be a Seagate firmware issue).

antonovka··on It's OK Not to Write Unit Tests
I wonder why the apparent point of failure is so far removed from the actual point of failure. With my work that is rarely the case, and I wonder which of us is the anomaly.

Neither of us, it just sounds like we just work on different software with varying levels of complexity.

antonovka··on It's OK Not to Write Unit Tests
I'm not sure what to take away from this post.

Unit tests just saved my bacon when I accidentally introduced a serious bug in refactoring some network-related code.

The bug wouldn't have shown up outside of production in some very specific cases, but it would have had a serious customer impact.

Unit tests catch these things for me all the time. Every 5 minutes I spend writing tests easily saves me 30+ minutes I'd spend debugging when some code 6 levels down from the apparent point of failure caused the issue.

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
Also, "transition". There is no transition for Linux.

ARM netbooks? That said, part of why there's no 'transition' is that providing easy-to-use (for consumers) third-party application binaries is this side of impossible given the lack of stable APIs across distributions and releases.

I can't see any possible difference for the fatelf solution and the package manager and scripts solution for an end user. It's not about the ease of use, because there is no difference.

I can drag-install any third-party application I want to download, and I can expect it to work on any machine. The author doesn't have to wait to get it packaged by a distribution, set up a package repository, etc. I don't have to wait 3-12 months for the latest version.

I can drag it over to my PPC iMac, and it'll work there, too.

How is that not 'different'?

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
But it was the wrong solution and the technical merits must trump other concerns.

Your post is very long, but I'm curious to hear why universal binaries are the wrong solution?

On the Mac, it's the cornerstone of their transparent multi-architecture support.

Apple (and previously NeXT) inarguably demonstrated its value and ease-of-use over the past 20 years. Producing x86-32, x86-64, armv6, armv7, and PPC binaries all from the same source code -- and having them work the first time -- is incredibly simple on Mac OS X.

NeXTSTEP (the OS) ran on 68k, x86, PA-RISC, and Sparc processors, and it was equally easy to build software that ran on those machines.

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
What you are demonstrating is the userland toolchain.

No, what I'm demonstrating is an end-to-end architecture-transparent platform, which includes a complete userspace toolchain, a universal binary format, and necessary kernel and dynamic linker support.

What was suggested above is an improvement by not requiring meddling with the kernel

I'm not sure I understand how "meddling" in the kernel is a bad thing when it provides for user-transparent execution of multi-architecture binaries, including transparent emulation of binaries that lack support for the host architecture.

It's not as if it's complex or dangerous to parse the Mach-O or FatELF formats, and if you take a page from Mac OS X or qemu, you can even do transparent emulation in userspace.

Nothing prevents a userland toolchain for Linux from supporting what you are describing above without kernel modifications.

How is it useful to build an easy-to-use multi-architecture binary if the kernel can't actually execute it?

Why are you afraid of doing simple parsing[1] of the binary? The kernel already does this -- how do you think ELF loading and shell script execution works?

I can imagine this conversation 30 years ago[2] -- "Why should we add shell script shebang parsing/execution support to the kernel? Why not just glue together loader executables that load the shell script"

[1] The dead simple Mach-O universal binary loading code: http://fxr.watson.org/fxr/source/bsd/kern/kern_exec.c?v=xnu-...

[2] The introduction of shebang in UNIX: http://www.in-ulm.de/~mascheck/various/shebang/sys1.c.html

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
Somebody has to test and debug your app on actual PPC hardware.

Our Xcode-supported unit tests transparently run three times -- once for x86_32, once for x86_64, and once for PPC. The PPC run occurs within Rosetta (ie, emulated).

If the tests pass, we can be reasonably sure everything is A-OK. In addition, we can do local regression testing under Rosetta (but it's rarely necessary -- usually everything just works).

The only native PPC testing we do is integration testing once we reach the end of the development cycle.

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
How are shell scripts and flakey logic an improvement on Apple's cross-platform development/usage model?

  gcc -arch i386 -arch ppc -arch x86_64 -isysroot <SDK path> example.c -o example
Done.

  > file example
  example: Mach-O universal binary with 3 architectures
  example (for architecture i386):	Mach-O executable i386
  example (for architecture ppc7400):	Mach-O executable ppc
  example (for architecture x86_64):	Mach-O 64-bit executable x86_64
I can even transparently run PPC binaries on my x86 Mac.

Universal binaries are a core component of this easy-to-use (for developers and users alike) architecture independence.

antonovka··on FatELF is no more. Linux developer community owned Ryan Gordon.
This is just a hack, nothing more.

Well, it is the cornerstone of Apple's highly successful and entirely transparent transition from PPC to x86, including drag-and-drop application installation/uninstallation. Couple it with Apple's compiler drivers and well-designed multi-architecture SDKs, and it becomes dead-simple to support multiple architectures and OS releases. Just build your binaries with -arch i386 -arch ppc -isysroot /Developer/SDKs/MacOSX10.4u.sdk

It also supports Apple's transparent selection of armv7/armv6 binaries on the iPhone 3GS.

I'd say it's pretty useful, and not really a hack at all.

The only arguments I've heard against it involve package managers and shell scripts, which demonstrates such a remarkable lack of understanding of ease of use and user behavior that I don't even know where to start, other than to say: This is why popular adoption of Linux on the desktop is not going to happen any time soon.

antonovka··on The 37signals Podcast
This sort of wide-eyed devotion is their PR. You're not going to replicate it in your own company by buying into it.

From the article: I don't use an alarm clock. Lately, I've been naturally waking up at 6:38 every morning. I used to wake up at 7:31 every morning, which is actually when I was born. So that was kind of creepy.

How self-indulgent must you be before you agree to a piece like this?

antonovka··on California to withhold a bigger chunk of paychecks
This is absolutely unacceptable. I'll be adjusting our withholding allowances to account for the change.

California needs to spend less, not quietly raid my bank account.

antonovka··on The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals
I believe it is a contest, because we have a limited amount of time on earth.

Well, you have enough time to comment here. Is this really a better exploration of the human condition (or whatever it is you want to achieve through reading) than non-fiction books?

If you could do either A or B and you believe B is better, then why would you do A?

In reality, fiction and non-fiction are not mutually exclusive unless you're obtuse enough to make them so. They're not even clearly distinct in their value or purpose.

antonovka··on The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals
Do you believe the human condition cannot be explored through nonfiction?

No.

Would you entertain the idea that perhaps it may be possible to explore the human condition deeper and more profoundly through nonfiction than through fiction?

It's not a contest.

Find me a fiction book more profoundly descriptive of the human condition than The Divided Self by RD Laing.

You don't believe his book is an exploration of his own personal perspective on reality and meaning?

antonovka··on The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals
Think of it this way. If you only read fiction for the rest of your life, could you program a computer? Could you build a house? Could you understand quantum mechanics or any myriad other practical skills? Probably not.

My practical skills are only useful in their relation to my human condition, both of which warrant exploration.

This of course is my opinion, but if I had to choose between a future life of only fiction reading or a future life of only nonfiction reading, I would choose nonfiction.

Fortunately for all of us, that choice is entirely unnecessary, and I've no problem suggesting that anyone who actually dismisses either fiction or non-fiction is demonstrating a remarkable, frightening lack of insight.

antonovka··on The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals
It's not real. At best it is anecdotal. It's a story. It's imagination. It's entertainment.

Why are ideas presented in the form of non-fiction any more "real" than ideas presented in the form of fiction?

Even the most literal non-fiction remains an expression of the author's opinion and ideas.

It's a very expensive form of entertainment when you value your time.

I find what I learn from well-chosen fiction and non-fiction to be equally valuable, and I value my time quite a bit.

I also would be very surprised that anyone who has time to comment here doesn't have time to read a fiction (or non-fiction) book.

antonovka··on The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals
I will come out and say it: categorically dismissing fictional books as "not real" (and therefor uninteresting) is both strange and stupid.

Fiction can be as real as the author wishes to make it, as an endeavor to elucidate their ideas and insights regarding the 'real world' through the telling of a story. I'd never be so audacious as to state "I hate non-fiction, there's very little to learn from boorish, presumptuous, and poorly considered interpretations of the author's reality"

This sort of navel-gazing article is uninteresting and of questionable real-world value, reminiscent of breathless puff pieces on the (soon to be forgotten) luminaries of .com technology that were so popular in the mid to late 1990s.

antonovka··on Scamville: The Social Gaming Ecosystem of Hell
I didn't realize that it's a "which is more wrong" contest...

At least the children are arguably less culpable given the age of majority.

antonovka··on Scamville: The Social Gaming Ecosystem of Hell
While I don't like her tone, I listened to her entire response and she seemed to address Arrington's issues pretty effectively.

Only if you've never worked at a game company selling virtual currency. The idea that only 5 incidents of children stealing their parents credit card or cell phone number occurred across 105 million transactions over two years is laughably ridiculous in the extreme.

Those numbers were clearly pulled out of the "shit, doubleshit, and bullshit" hat. We ran a similarly sized game and were inundated daily with complaints from parents whose children had stolen their credit cards and cell phones to buy coins in our games.

Maybe since the children are being scammed via third party, the parents don't know who to complain to?

antonovka··on The Outsiders
You sound like an indulged child, not a misunderstood genius.

I am at the 'upper bounds' as well, but I don't attempt to batter others over the head with my vocabulary and pride, and I've learned that I'm just as vulnerable, alone, and human as anyone else. Setting yourself apart on the basis of a standardized test is just sophomoric justification for misanthropy and depression.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →