HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

antonovka

1,517 karma · joined July 29, 2009

submissionscomments
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Here Apple is dealing with someone who basically invented a fictitious company in a different country (! ! !) and is now trying to collect on payables. What do you expect to have happen? I actually believe vessenes --- he may just never get paid. I wish him the best.

I'm curious -- what reporting to the government/legal paperwork do you see Apple as doing that makes the payout legally more difficult due to the use of a fictitious name?

In the U.S., using a fictitious name is incredibly simple -- is it really that much more complicated in the U.K.? Why is this suddenly an "oh my god" situation?

What is possibly preventing Apple from changing their records to use his personal name?

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I manage a business, and we do invoice. Like any other business, our customers pay late. What I don't have is individuals who owe us money stonewalling our requests for communication/resolution on a late invoice.
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
3+ months of little-to-no communication, stonewalled by front-line support and having to e-mail sjobs@apple.com before getting any response is "by the book"?

I get the impression that you're arguing (and users are downvoting) from the vantage point that Apple is a reasonable organization. They are most certainly not.

The only organization I know of that beats Apple and the AppStore when it comes to Kafkaesque bureaucracy is US Immigration Services.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I have no trouble blaming Apple for failing to resolve an outstanding debt after many months of poor communication with the individual to which they owe.
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Since Apple isn't at fault for the original mixup, they have no responsibility to help resolve their outstanding debt in a reasonably timely manner? It has been months.
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
He (for some reason) made up a fake company in a country he doesn't even live in.

Which, if true, Apple never actually verified existed in the first place. Seems a bit odd to be pushing for it now.

I can't really blame him, either. The sign-up is confusing, the legal requirements are often poorly specified, and it's to do something that seems to makes sense (I want a fictitious name, I'll create the company later) that's actually a really bad idea given Apple's requirements.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Hey Google, please change the account associated with this adsense publisher ID please, make it point to my bank account in this here other country and please pay me pronto or I'll go public on you.

It took the original poster 3 months to even get a response from Apple. The issue remains unresolved, and if they remain unresponsive to his plight, it will likely remain so for some time.

Your hypothetical situation is not even remotely equivalent.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
The 'for no apparent reason' sort of proves that already. So if you had would you blame apple ?

If Apple put up their usual bureaucratic wall, ignored our requests, or required multi-week/month turnaround times to resolve the issue -- then yes, I would blame Apple.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
The two resolutions -- verifying him as a suitable corporate officer, versus floating him a personal 11k loan -- are so widely different, I can't even begin to fathom what your point is?
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I'm sure they can't, actually.

All that's necessary is verifying that the individual in question is an suitable officer of the corporation.

As long as you stick to the form and procedure in place things will run smoothly and you'll be fine.

Unless Apple decides otherwise. We've had payments come in months late for no apparent reason, and didn't see resolution until Apple received a spate of bad press.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Immediate needs need an immediate solution, not one that may or may not happen.

I'm not sure I see the problem in starting with the step that costs very little (a few hours of time) and could potentially immediately resolve the situation?

There's nothing to stop you from looking into job alternatives, borrowing money from family, etc, in the meantime.

So they will take this one step at the time. Also, going 'public' on a company for a mess of your own making isn't very nice.

Apple isn't very nice. Sometimes you have to play hardball to get the necessary things done.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
News cycles move quickly, and companies like to be able to defuse negative stories by making steps towards resolving an issue before more reporters pile on -- even if it means PR promising something on behalf of the organization. Since it only takes a few hours to put together a post, why not start there?

See what happens, then think about employment. If he goes back to his previous employment (or a new employer), is he simply going to quit again in 30 days when the issue is resolved?

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
When it comes to support, there is always another supervisor.

You've clearly never dealt with Apple or the AppStore ;)

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I suspect that the money is effectively lost to you. and that you should withdraw the app (if you can) and re-register honestly and clearly as yourself.

Are you seriously claiming that -- if they were so inclined -- Apple couldn't safely resolve this issue within an hour or two?

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I disagree. If you've already e-mailed, called, and otherwise attempted to cajole Apple through the usual channels, try the last option left to you before you put hat in hand and go back to your former employer -- go public.

The only thing that breaks down Apple's bureaucratic walls is bad press. Create some now -- and hopefully get access to a real human to resolve your issues. Once you've put this out there, then consider going back to work to tide yourself over.

Sit down -- today -- and write a blog post. Be clear, be concise, and make sure the chronology is clear. Focus on the excitement of making your money, and your difficulties in dealing with Apple's faceless bureaucracy. Whatever you do, don't rage at Apple, use profanity, or write anything that would be construed as blatantly unprofessional.

Once you've written it, ask some (native English speaking) friends to review it. Once you get their sign-off, submit (or ask them to submit) to reddit, ycombinator, etc. If you have any friends in the Apple-related press, mention it to them too.

antonovka··on Google Groups is Dead
I've been finding myself saying the phrase "I wish they'd move this project away from google code and onto github" quite frequently lately.

Funny, I usually find myself saying "I wish they'd move this project away from github, provide a proper API-stable versioned release, properly document the project and APIs, and otherwise behave like a well-maintained open source project" a lot lately. =)

If they did all that, then I wouldn't need to fork the project, maintain any local patches/modifications, etc.

antonovka··on Big Cellphone Makers Shifting to Android
As an iPhone developer, I desperately want it:

1) It forces Apple to compete for developer mindshare, improving our lot.

2) It provides an open platform that we can begin to support (and possibly migrate most of our mobile development to).

The OS and APIs aren't as nice, but being able to use most JVM-compatible languages is a big win. I've been holding my breath for a while, hoping that Android would gain traction and we could alleviate some of our reliance on Apple's draconian platform. It sounds like this is now happening.

antonovka··on The curious pricing of the 27" iMac
I have used Linux since 1994. I have written software for Linux. I had a job that was to support Linux. I still run Linux on servers where there's no other option.

I don't like it; I don't think it works well. It doesn't do what I want -- the desktop software options are incredibly lacking, getting anything working is like pulling teeth, and relying on a distributor like Debian or Ubuntu for all my software means that I get stuck either using outdated software or running against an unstable release of the OS -- either way, I spend way more time thinking about the OS than doing my job.

In terms of stability, the lack of stable releases, poor code quality of the kernel, and reliance on distributors to patch and maintain their own kernels really shows through in the number of kernel panics and other issues I see. I can't recall the last time one of my FreeBSD servers or Mac OS X desktops crashed.

Problems I have with Linux are nonexistent with OS X, so that's what I use.

antonovka··on Nokia suing Apple over the iPhone
If there were no patents, Apple would have no financial incentive (and that's the only incentive public companies have) to invest so heavily in all of the technologies in the iPhone, as they could easily be copied by others.

No financial incentive other than, you know, a need to compete in order to sell their product? It's not as if you can just photocopy a phone and wind up with the software written and hardware designs necessary to reproduce it -- and if you can, how novel are the ideas?

It's disingenuous to state that Apple relied on Nokia's IP (that they would have otherwise kept trade secret), especially given that it's almost certain that Apple engineers ignored existing patents as much as possible when developing the iPhone to avoid additional liability.

antonovka··on Introducing BERT and BERT-RPC: GitHub's new serialization and RPC protocol
It makes usage quite a bit cleaner for some target languages, but it's also optional.
antonovka··on BERT and BERT-RPC 1.0 Specification
Which seems to come down to "we don't like explicit protocol definitions via IDLs, think they are somehow incompatible with dynamic typing ethos, and didn't understand that Protobuf/Thrift can very easily be leveraged to provide dynamic self-describing messages without having to define a whole new encoding/protocol specification".

See also:

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=895607

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=895280

antonovka··on How We Made GitHub Fast: A detailed look at GitHub's new architecture
It's a phenomenally bizarre way of solving the problem. Not only do you have to maintain patches to sshd (which increases maintenance costs and makes deploying security updates considerably more time consuming), but you also risk introducing security bugs in sshd itself.

There are already plenty of external solutions to this problem that do not involve patching vendor-shipped software, and writing your own is not difficult.

Here's one -- http://code.google.com/p/splatd/

Will synchronize public keys from LDAP to local hosts, automatically create home directories, delete user's home directories when their accounts are deactivated after a grace period, etc -- and you don't have to patch sshd.

antonovka··on Introducing BERT and BERT-RPC: GitHub's new serialization and RPC protocol
This is just silly:

I just can’t. I find the entire concept behind IDLs and code generation abhorrent. Coming from a background in dynamic languages and automated testing, these ideas just seem silly.

The point of IDLs is to provide a stable, exact, portable and succinct definition of an inter-application protocol. In defining the protocol explicitly in a language neutral way, it is easier to ensure conformance and correctness of implementation.

As a side effect, it does make code generation easy, allows one to optionally apply static typing to ensure that messages are always correctly formed, and ensures a _DRY_ approach across the board.

You could just as easily implement poorly defined interfaces using Protobuf or Thrift -- nobody says that you actually have to use an IDL, and the serialization format doesn't require it as long as you keep the messages self-describing. Moreover, a lot of effort has gone into making Protobuf (and even Thrift) as efficient as possible -- yet another serialization format is wholly unnecessary.

[Edit] Google even outlines one way to implement self-describing messages using the existing protobuf standard in the project documentation: http://code.google.com/apis/protocolbuffers/docs/techniques....

Other methods including simply encoding fields as tuples of (name, value) -- protobuf includes value types in the field encoding.

antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
Nothing wrong, you can organize your own conferences in whatever way you like.

... and you can lose out on the participation of a valuable subset of contributors. This isn't a moral issue, it's a question of maturity, decorum, and being inclusive.

But if you act morally outraged at what others do in the conferences they organize, don't expect much sympathy.

Likewise, if you're a socially ignorant asshat, don't expect people to like you.

Or come to your conferences.

Or invite you to speak at theirs.

antonovka··on Lua makes accessing REST APIs from the iPhone dead simple
Apple doesn't seem to notice unless you're using a widely-known toolset that they can easily detect, and even then, they miss quite a bit.

Not that this means it's a good idea to include an interpreter under the assumption that Apple won't notice -- if they do notice & care, you'll find you will no longer be able to update your app.

Apple has also demonstrated a history of caring about certain violations at the most inopportune times -- lots of camera applications broke when 3.0 was released, and Apple wouldn't let the authors release updates, since the only way to implement the required functionality was through undocumented API.

antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
No, I think that the lack of women in IT is partially due to an endemic lack of social inclusion, amply demonstrated by hiring strippers to give lap dances at a technology conference.
antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
Well, my wife is also in technology (a developer, not games) and isn't fine with it. I'm glad you're OK with it, but there's nothing wrong with those that aren't.

As a man, I'm not fine with the perception these ridiculous stunts create -- that men in technology are so socially retarded that we need organizers to hire strippers and booth babes for us.

You wouldn't see this behavior at another professional conference -- you'd see it from a subset of the attendees AFTER the conference, where it's appropriate.

antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
I'd add a third point:

- It makes male programmers look socially inept, weak, and sophomoric. I don't like the perception or suggestion that I'll appreciate bought eye-candy at a technology conference.

antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
I have this feeling that we're just going to have to agree to disagree.

That may be, but before you abandon the question, I suggest watching that Google Techtalk.

antonovka··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
And it's certainly why people fight to ban gay marriage. Don't you see that, "Women find stripping offensive, it drives them away, don't let that happen" is the same thing as "We find homosexuality offensive, we can't let that happen"? Those who feel they're on the moral high ground will do all kinds of things to impose their morals on others.

Moral relativism is equally as tired as absolutism.

Hiring strippers for a technology event is a simple question of social graces, class, and creating an inclusive environment -- not morality.

← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →