HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

apeytavin

173 karma · joined December 24, 2021

submissionscomments
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Oh yeah, my bad, thanks for noticing
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
This does not sound negative to me and actually is great to read because this is definitely in the list of potential use-cases so we could make a video for it!

As for humidity, we don't have a sensor for it yet BUT the platform was made to be extensible specifically for this so it's easy to add one (see https://docs.innate.bot/main/robots/mars/extending-mars)

Thank you!

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
We spent a lot of sweat to make it all transferable from one robot to another easily. It is our goal that we all have robots that feel alive and that we can all develop together.

Happy to have you onboard!

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
What would you define as "complex"?

This kind of architecture is very similar to what Physical Intelligence used for Pi-0.5 (a VLM triggering a VLA in different areas), albeit to a smaller size for now.

You can also see some example (autonomous!) use-cases here: https://docs.innate.bot/welcome/mars-example-use-cases

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
emoji-salute sir
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
The agentic OS allows to abstract away from ROS2 by creating the concept of "skills" that can be triggered by the agent; you don't really have to care anymore about defining nodes or racing conditions between them, our framework is a lottle simpler in that way. Triggering a skill is the equivalent (almost) to triggering an action in ROS2 btw.

But the interest of it is how it is packaged and that it can be triggered by this VLM-based agent called BASIC that we created.

This agent has a special kind of architecture which gives it spatial memory, capability to react in time, and ability to navigate. This means that skills can be triggered in the right place at the right time, like a true entity. BASIC can interrupt skills in execution depending on how you configure it. So that if it's chilling navigating around and it sees you, it would interrupt navigation and get to you, shake hands and ask if you need help instead of finishing the task without reacting.

Hope this helps!

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
There's several things but for example, there is no LiDAR on it nor even a good place to put one. If you're going to navigate around, without a LiDAR or good compute for VSLAM (which is very hard to setup and VERY demanding in compute), you will very quickly get lost. At this point the Kiwi is only for very local navigation (and you will still have IMU drift).

There is also a possibility for it to tip the base if the arm is fully extended. And the SO-101 has quite poor repeatability.

The base is also slow to move, and depending on which surface you are the omniwheels can get dirt in quickly.

Finally, external compute means you need in particular to teleoperate from your computer, so you have to be far from the robot and not necessarily in the same orientation than it which is very, very uncomfortable. This app system we made is one of the things people love the most about MARS.

Ah, and RGBD really does matter for navigation AND for learning (augmenting ACT with depth yields better results).

The wheels are indeed these ones, and the camera on the video is a luxonis oak-d wide, pretty expensive but comfortable to work with. However, the version we're shipping includes a much cheaper stereo-depth camera that we calibrate ourselves - I can't get you the reference right right now cause it's late at night but feel free to reach out on discord

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
If we could sell it without we would for sure, but this is a current technological limitation. And we make extra easy to connect to it anywhere still, from your phone. Several components of the robots do not need this cloud service, and because the OS is accessible to you, you could even replace it with your own of doing things.

For this one, it's just the only feasible way we found to bring the kind of experience we created to folks.

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
That would not make it a complete product and would always require a complex setup whenever and wherever you want to use it.

This one is really, really convenient and intuitive. Turn it on anywhere, even outside, it just works. Even when I want to dev on it, it's super convenient.

On some level I truly believe robotics has to become more "complete", we can't always just piece things together, it makes it very hard to have a beautiful product.

I realize this is more of a philosophical answer, but I also think it is the right one to take this field to the next level

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
of course
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Absolutely, the link I sent you has these specs you mentioned listed.

And yeah, I agree this mid-market is indeed tough, but this is the upper price I was looking for when I started with my AI background and bought a similar-price turtlebot then struggled to put a cheap arm on it. Anything under this is really bad for algorithms, although you can reduce it with just the arm and clamping it to your workspace as you suggested but then you don't have mobility.

I will keep your comment in mind, and thank you for the thoughtfulness. You might be interested to know that we intend to show something bigger not long from now. But this is, as you said, more for investors.

For now I'm content if there's enough people that want this one

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
The example you gave is exactly this. The driving around in the example use-cases shows an example of going from room to room and execute policies in context:

https://docs.innate.bot/main/welcome/mars-example-use-cases

I take from your comment that the full capabilities of the robot are not properly represented and I take a note to film longer ones. And it can definitely do what you just asked. And multiple times in a row. I will note that it depends on the training quality of course.

On speed of movement, I now realize we didn't mention it anywhere so I added it in the overview but it's pretty fast. 0.7m.s-1 for the base, and the arm can be tormented quite a bit. Just took this video for you:

https://youtu.be/H-gAaTKLm9c

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
I can assure your this was a strong consideration of ours and all assets underwent a very strict regime. There is definitely more than other types of website but it's in the median of other robots websites with significants amount of videos.

Not to say I dismiss the comment, definitely looking at it cause it might come from somewhere else. Just that I yet don't see what is the bottleneck.

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Hey, OP here, just sharing that I only wrote the first answer to your comment, not the next one. Wouldn't want to dismiss your issue!

I have been running performance checks during the morning and tried with other browsers, used the debugging tools. I can see why it could be slow but I definitely need more trials to understand where it comes from. Bear with us while we're on it :)

and as i said earlier, this is really helpful for us to know so thank you

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
The jitter is some demos is arguably because of bad connectivity, we will retake those.

You can see however in these demos: https://docs.innate.bot/main/welcome/mars-example-use-cases

that it is indeed pretty smooth.

Also, sorry the arm specs were not there! You can now have them at: https://docs.innate.bot/robots/mars/arm

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Our servos come from Asia. If you can find a platform with everything we have for around $1k BOM happy to review it but we've been pretty deep in picking our components.

Also, fair to say that if indeed you're the kind of person who likes to assemble all of this yourself, you're not directly in our target :)

This is more for AI / software folks who don't want to have to assemble and calibrate everything and risk having an arm that is not repeatable and thus can't actually properly learn. We have seen many folks spend a weekend or more trying to put these together and end up with a barely working platform and then be disgusted of AI robotics

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
So far folks have been getting it but i see the point. I guess we'll see if a renaming makes sense later
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
One of our objectives here was to fix everything that we don't like about the SO-101 and the Kiwi, which have several hardware and software flaws in our view. Including, yes, the constant need for a computer to simply run your robot.

The training does require external GPUs (but we provide that infra for free, straight from the app!), but the onboard jetson can run models trained though, as you can see in the examples. Everything you see in the vids is running onboard when it comes to manipulation, because we use a special version of ACT made specifically by us for this robot, that also includes a reward model (like DYNA does).

We have developed this system to also be able to run the other components smoothly so it also does SLAM, and has room for more processing even when running our ACT.

Now indeed this cannot run Pi-0 but from our experience - and the whole community in general - VLAs are not particularly better than ACT in the low data regime, and need a lot more compute.

As for community-level datasets, yes this is the plan. Anything you train can already be shared with others - just share the files. We didn't develop a centralized place for sharing datasets and behaviors but it is on the plan.

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
As a side note, the previous generation of research platforms for that size made in Asia were the Turtlebots, which go for that same price, but without GPU, arm...

I would say the problem is that most manufacturers, including chinese, sell you platforms that are not reliable enough for AI manipulation, and there's a race to the bottom for it, to which we try not to participate to

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Actually the BOM cost required to make something stable that can execute manipulation tasks well enough is around $1k+ hence our price. You will find very cheap robots that can pretend to do what this one can, but in practice won't work well enough.

As for the unitree robot, this one is not unlocked for development, does not have onboard GPU, and does not have an arm. If you want it, check the price they give, it's very prohibitive.

You could attach a cheap arm to it but it would also not be stable enough for AI algorithms to run it. We're researchers ourselves, we would have made it cheaper if we could, but then you just can't do anything with it.

Our platform will deliver the experience of a real AI robot, anything cheaper than that is kind of a lie - or forces you to assemble and calibrate, which we do for you here. It is just the nature of trying to deliver a really complete product that works, and we want to stand for that.

EDIT: You can take a look at our autonomous demos there, you need something reliable for these: https://docs.innate.bot/welcome/mars-example-use-cases

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
On BASIC: Yes it does require an internet connection and until we figure out how this works for you it will remain free of use!

It is required to run them, not to create them. And it's not about running "pick_up_socks", this one can already run on your robot. BASIC is required to chain it with other tasks such as navigating to another part of your house and then running another skill to drop the sock somewhere for example

Thank you for the remark, we will make it clearer in the docs

As a consequence: The robot does not necessarily require Internet to run, but if you want it to chain tasks while talking and using memory, yes it does.

As for the googly eyes, give me a minute...

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
Fixed it! It was only possible to use a given number of times
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
we also provide interfaces for IK

and much higher interfaces for interaction and ai manipulation. Like directly recording episodes of training data so that the arm can use a VLA instead of simple IK.

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
On the battery, at least 5 hours when idle, and 3 when moving at least

On the motors, these are dynamixels from robotis, and we provide all three of position, velocity, and effort on the low-level SDK (in ROS2 too)

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
i don't know if it is that necessary for just phone control, wdyt?

do you have anything plug-and-play for jetson nano?

apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
you're the first person to mention that to me and it's very very helpful actually. can i contact you to see what you see?
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
webrtc for video stream is what we have in the pipeline for improving the stream yep!
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
yeah it's a tribute
apeytavin··on Show HN: MARS – Personal AI robot for builders (< $2k)
the video stream will get a lot of improvement for sure! the teleop is pretty good already i believe, but happy to chat further. feel free to dm / join discord
apeytavin··on Launch HN: Innate (YC F24) – Home robots as easy to program as AI agents
We do not ship to the UK for now, right now we're limiting ourselves to US for simplicity reasons and to iterate fast with our customers.

As for the tech stack, you'll have a lot of access, the only thing you would not be able to see is the cloud agent - although in time we might also open-source it!

Page 1 of 3Next →