HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

apocalypstyx

879 karma · joined November 21, 2016

submissionscomments
apocalypstyx··on What's wrong with social science and how to fix it (2020)
I'm not a communist, so I have little trouble in denouncing or disliking Stalinist Russia, Maoist China, etc.

I also, however, find these sorts of discussions completely disingenuous, however, in that it is conveniently left unmentioned how many millions might or might not be calculated to have died because of capitalism, cultures that have been destroyed, etc.

No one is actually willing to lay everything on the table for examination.

apocalypstyx··on What's wrong with social science and how to fix it (2020)
Are you really sure about where you're ideas come from?

I remember the Christian anti-Harry-Potter craze when I was a kid. Preachers would have hour-long television programs about how this, this, and this were in those books. But none of it was. I knew. I had read them.

I have never trusted what others wanted to convinced me a book was 'about' since then.

Education (so far as I see it) should leave one, as best is possible, with an understanding of a body of work. To agree or disagree with that body of work is a separate affair. What those preachers and what people like James Lindsay want, so far as I am concerned, is a so-called understanding that leads to an end other than understanding in and of itself. Quite simply, if someone were to read Lindsey's work and come away thinking that X, Y, or Z in fact had a point, I doubt he would be happy with that outcome.

apocalypstyx··on What's wrong with social science and how to fix it (2020)
In order to even do science we must first make certain non-falsifiable assumptions, fundamentally. This is a basic point of metaphysics and epistemology.
apocalypstyx··on What's wrong with social science and how to fix it (2020)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_Marxism_conspiracy_th...
apocalypstyx··on Sperm counts worldwide are plummeting faster than we thought
The thing is, all of these issues stem from patriarchal systems.

(assumption) men will be employed (therefore) child support is their responsibility.

(assumption) men are strong independent (therefore) there is no need for assistance.

(assumption) men are made for war (therefore) men are to fight war.

(assumption) men are stronger, more aggressive [see war], etc (therefore) women [being weaker] must be the victims.

(assumption) fathers are severe and disciplinary (therefore) mothers are nurturing and better suited to child rearing.

(assumption) sexual intercourse is an act desired by and initiated by men who are defined by their ability to penetrate (therefore) women can only be penetrated [see also aggressiveness] and men who are penetrated are lowered in status to be nearer the category of woman.

apocalypstyx··on Sperm counts worldwide are plummeting faster than we thought
Personally, I have a hard time putting much stock in the opinion of those who use exclamation points.
apocalypstyx··on How an early oil industry study became key in climate lawsuits
An interesting question might be perhaps --- when is there a dereliction of duty? We tend to think in terms of 'just vote them out', however, there is this category of active ignorance that can't truly be established as seemingly actively maliciousness, a category of behavior that ultimately undermines social structures such as government in a way we haven't accounted for prior.

In North Carolina, for example, in 2012, a law was passed that sea level rise could only be predicted from historical trends and only projected within a 30 year period with regards to the coast development policy.

https://www.npr.org/2018/09/13/647559482/north-carolina-coas...

apocalypstyx··on Open Library
The problem is a great many of them now are paid next to nothing and with recent developments in the industry expected to take on more and more of the work and costs themselves as publishers cut back on promotion and editing services. And it terms of labor, publishing is an industry that stands on the backs of unpaid interns and underpaid workers (as with the recent Harper Collins strikes). Academic publishing is even worse, with authors also seeing little to nothing (and in some cases having to pay) and books costing more than $50 (and often times above $100) when many of them have also started using print on demand.

So the real question is, are writers getting paid now?

Well, a minuscule number make Stephen King money, a handful make a full-time living, and the vast majority, at most, make pocket money and have full-time work in other areas, all while the publishing industry hoovers up more and more rights.

apocalypstyx··on Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia fundraising banners
It appears many do not know the actual definition of ad hominem. The definition of the term is out there to be looked up.
apocalypstyx··on Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia fundraising banners
> socially constructed (along with other norms you may have heard about, like gender identity) and since they are socially constructed they are culturally relative.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-construction-natur...

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-institutions/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epistemology-social/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-ontology/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-knowledge-soci...

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-ontology/

apocalypstyx··on Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia fundraising banners
Is there any evidence that common sense is either common or sensical?
apocalypstyx··on Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia fundraising banners
You're going to quote James Lindsay, the guy who refers to critical theory as 'race marxism'? This source is so biased Ma'at's feather never had a chance.
apocalypstyx··on Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia fundraising banners
Foucault and Duchamp are the two boogeymen of the 20th and 21st centuries.
apocalypstyx··on AI-designed camera only records objects of interest while being blind to others
The real problem is that humans have always deluded themselves that some technology was a 'truth technology'. It's been done with everything from typewriters to cameras. However, the camera has always lied, always rendered a counterfactual to a hypothesized truth state, denied access to fundamental reality. That a camera may now lie in a slightly different fashion does not alter that.

Are you going to believe your lying eyes?

apocalypstyx··on Why I’m Cryptophobic
As an intermediary, currency requires a minimum amount of social relations. Its value, if it can be said to have one, lies in its use as an indirect measure of the degree of faith in a particular set of social constructs.

The reason I use the post-apocalyptic scenario is exactly because of this rupture of social relations. It is not the ghost of the previous civilization trying to reconstitute itself. It is a place in a wilderness onto which people might stumble. (Admittedly, this might not be communicated well and too informed by my early secondary consumption of old western movies.)

Without this broader social context, the concept of trade becomes purely localized. My needs are not serviced by an explicit diffuse network which is conceptualized as an aspect not just of society but constitutive of reality. Operating on a faith, we take the conceptualization as reality and can accept, in our lives now, intermediary exchange: I firmly believe that by accepting an electronic transfer to my bank, I will be able to buy sweet and salty food that is engineered to appeal to my dietary obsessions as bequeathed by a combination of evolution and social conditioning.

In the midst of such a thought experiment, however, I am not guaranteed to encounter another haggard individual in this hypothesized godforsaken world for a very long time. Neither am I guaranteed that any individual I meet will have such social relations as to value such an intermediary, either.

Intermediary exchange is only viable once the pool of social relations grows beyond a certain bounds.

The function of my acceptance of any system is the fulfillment of my needs, to some degree. In such a scenario, the only way those needs can be serviced is an equivalence of exchange. In this case, food is required for immediate survival, the tools of procuring such, and shelter, etc. Intermediaries, in such a scenario, provide no guarantee to provide such. So such must be acquired directly. I can eat beans. To take the gold assumes, incorrectly, I can obtain another can or equivalent. That incorrect assumption is a holdover from the fundamental and all-pervasive faith we are at present steeped in and that must be maintained for our reality to function.

apocalypstyx··on Why I’m Cryptophobic
>economies can crash. Gold can not, thus is it valuable.

The thing about money is that it is a technology. But unlike other technologies, such as an electric toothbrush, for instance, it has an additional quirk: without belief, it doesn't work. Regardless of whether or not I believe in electricity, an electric tooth brush turns on and off; if the participants in an economy don't have faith in the economy, the economy falters. Money's value lies in this belief, whether it is the belief that I can buy groceries or pay taxes. It is a faith that is a function of utility: there is the interdependence of the gods' delivering and my belief that they will; should the gods not deliver sufficiently, my faith wavers; likewise, if enough of the faith of the masses wavers, the gods fail to deliver.

Gold is like an old god: its faith has a lot of coinage. However, its rule is not necessarily omnipresent.

Scenario: we are in a post-nuclear apocalypse. I have a small trading post and a can of beans; you have a solid gold coin. Challenge: convince me why I should take the coin.

apocalypstyx··on The Last Question by Issac Asimov [pdf]
One can be lecherous from the age of 15 onward and never actually get to know any women, so the two aren't mutually exclusive (actually, the first might contribute to the problem of the second.)

Oh, I know all too well of his numerous sexual assaults. When it gets to the stage that Harlan Ellison makes it a point to get between him and women as they're going up a set of stairs...yeah not great, not great at all. I don't want to downplay it in the least.

apocalypstyx··on The Last Question by Issac Asimov [pdf]
Having read Asimov's autobiographical inserts in anthologies such as Before the Golden Age and The Early Asimov, I get the idea that young (as in prior to the age of 30) Asimov suffered from a problem similar to many male mangakas: their exposure to girls/women is so minimal as to be almost non-existent (in the case of mangakas, of course, this comes primarily from the work schedule), and with such a paucity of experience, they flounder to construct such characters except within the bounds of extreme stereotype.
apocalypstyx··on The Last Question by Issac Asimov [pdf]
I think the largest part of it is having grown up in fundamentalist evangelical christianity -- the rapture and all that.

I view such SF as a secularized render of such conceptualizations -- along with the concepts of the singularity, etc.

Much of Asimov's work does this. Many of the robot stories are simply recastings of old Jewish folk legends about golems.

In one sense, I don't have a problem with recasting old fiction into a newer mold. Such is a mainstay of cultural development.

However, there is a particular vain which I do find pernicious.

It calls itself 'science' fiction, but is prejudicial to the concept.

Such operates as a palliative to a condition that seemingly cannot be resolved: our knowledge that the universe, so far as we understand the laws of physics, the knowledge that science has given us, will come to an end. One way or another, our species is headed for extinction. For the species to choose death at a massive drug orgy this weekend is indistinguishable from the obliteration of this planet by meteor in a hundred or a thousand years is indistinguishable from the engulfment of this planet by its expanding and dying sun is indistinguishable from the heat death of the universe.

Though concepts of 'souls' are bandied about in Christianity (and in all appropriated from the ancient pagan Greeks the early church fathers so admired), an examination of the actual deployment of the theology indicates that more generally the bodily nature of an eternity is fundamental. But a purely materialistic understanding of the universe cannot seemingly grant such a possibility of a bodily eternity (whether simulated or not).

And if the individual can be in some way assuaged as to their lack of access to such an eternity, they are typically comforted so by the concept of the eternal continuity of the human race (or its ensuing evolutionary descendants) as a process in the universe.

Rather than a palingenetism in which some 'golden age' is reborn and the true knowledge of 'god' returns, the timeline has been inverted: we do not recede from 'god' but are distant from 'god' because we are still on approach. In a way, it is the full acceptance that 'god' is crafted by Man. We will make 'god', the AI, etc, who will stand beyond the boundaries of the universe, beyond time and space.

apocalypstyx··on The Last Question by Issac Asimov [pdf]
There is no single piece of science fiction I despise more than this story.
apocalypstyx··on A privately funded killer asteroid spotter
Entropy (like the house) always wins. (Unless we're wrong about physics.)

If I remember correctly, life actually increases the rate of entropy. So, conceptually, the more life, the faster the universe approaches heat death.

apocalypstyx··on A privately funded killer asteroid spotter
Then the nature of the universe (so far as we understand it) is "bad".
apocalypstyx··on Social media break improves mental health
All social media is immoral except my social media.
apocalypstyx··on Your real biological clock is you’re going to die (2018)
> We all know we're going to die

Not so sure about that. Ernest Becker wrote a book on the subject titled The Denial of Death (though some take issue with psychoanalysis, whether post-Freudian or not).

Even when we tacitly admit to the seeming fact, we still hedge in that our family, religion, culture, species, knowledge, or stories will continue into an infinity that (so far as we know) doesn't exist (this ignores, of course, notions of an afterlife, which can be seen as fulfilling the same need under different constraints). The universe (again, so far as we now) is hurtling towards heat death, and ultimately, producing a billion more generations and having one big humanity party this weekend capped off with Kool-Aid all amounts to the same.

Even then, infinity isn't really such a good anti-depressive. It's just that, unlike other animals (again, so far as we know) we have to craft such psychological defenses against our own analytic mental processes in order to fulfill the more fundamental drive of biological reproduction.

apocalypstyx··on Weird Science
The question might be whether intrinsic motivation is inescapable.

"From the start of this book I have had occasion, in various contexts, to refer to the overwhelming elation felt by scientists at the moment of discovery, an elation of a kind which only a scientist can feel and which science alone can evoke in him. In the very first chapter I quoted the famous passage in which Kepler announced the discovery of his Third Law: ‘...nothing holds me; I will indulge my sacred fury...’1 The outbreak of such emotions in the course of discovery is well known, but they are not thought to affect the outcome of discovery. Science is regarded as objectively established in spite of its passionate origins. It should be clear by this time that I dissent from that belief; and I have now come to the point at which I want to deal explicitly with passions in science. I want to show that scientific passions are no mere psychological by-product, but have a logical function which contributes an indispensable element to science. They respond to an essential quality in a scientific statement and may accordingly be said to be right or wrong, depending on whether we acknowledge or deny the presence of that quality in it."

--- Michael Polanyi

--- Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy, p140

apocalypstyx··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
I will also add that it was likely a mistake to reference any laboratory-observed phenomena whatsoever, replicable or otherwise, with regard to such a topic. It would seem likely for there to be a bias against such references extant prior to any given proposition, the conflict between the common notion of the 'sterile' lab and 'bountiful' nature. Also, as with the case of Calhoun's experiments, zoo observations of 'alpha' wolves, or prior unrecognized variances between male and female experimenters with regards to rat subjects and pheromone exposure[1], there are more than enough 'plot holes' to provide psychological ammunition for the automatic dismissal of inconvenient propositions.

[1] https://www.mcgill.ca/newsroom/channels/news/scent-man-23549...

EDIT:

Even so, it would have helped even more if my original example hadn't been functionally useless.

apocalypstyx··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
I never focused on the social role as causatory[1]. All I wanted was a quick, easily searchable, not-overly technical example of reproductive variation in a population over time. What is known of Calhoun's experiments still satisfy that requirement. I have tried to dispel the social aspect in two posts so far and have completely failed. Obviously, that the connection of such in the broader imagination is to a degree which I underestimated continues to haul in baggage that is sinking my intentions.

Would it have been better to talk about bivalves[2] and baboons[3]?

I would generally prefer bivalves to baboons.

But then I would be accused, again, in trying to illustrate a general phenomena or principle, of drawing a line to some vector of particular conflux between species A and H. sapiens, ala the domain of Jordan Peterson's lobsters.

The problem is, I am afraid, in such discussions as these, my posts will have to account down to the punctuation, lest one correction will need be issued or question be raised, in which case the totality of the thing is blown to the proverbial kingdom come by its (and my) inability to account for the sum totality of a minute portion of the universe. (A trivial failing, I admit, but one I have to own up to.)

Except perfect is never going to be good enough.

It's similar, after a fashion, to having to deal with young earth creationists. Yes, but where is the transitionary fossil between H. habilis and H. erectus? The counter claim will then arise that there are differences in opinion as to whether H. ergaster is a precursor to H. erectus or categorizable in terms of inclusion with H. erectus.

The question is: why do I put in the effort?

Maybe because silence, inaction, is always likely in support of something. Neutrality can likely only exist at minimum if the subject and phenomena are not extant within the same light cone. Practical considerations might allow for a smaller distance, but might as well be thorough.

Ultimately, I have to be fine with misstepping. Failure, after all, in the end, is the only option.

Returning to Calhoun a moment, since I might as well ride the derailment off the cliff (semper desistas semper exieris[4]), the final outcome of Newton's Flaming Laser Sword is that swaths of reality functionally cease to exist. Of course there is epistemic content. That content is not applicable within a scientific framework, that is very true. But something, unless the entirety was fabricated, did happen. Maybe Calhoun purposefully funneled the experiment into his result, The Mad God of Universe 25. Maybe he was the Harry Harlow of rats. But the basics of it are that reproductive rates changed and the population collapsed. Maybe it was from disease. Maybe it was from inbreeding. Maybe it was from the food. Maybe it was from the design of the enclosure. Maybe one day Calhoun decided to climb into the enclosure and stomp them all. Maybe it was all these things together. It's not much. But 'pretty much zero' is not zero.[5] As almost everything I tend to post proves, close enough doesn't cut it.

-------

[1] Yes, I am aware this is not a 'real' word, and I don't care. Another few hundred years and it will be a word. It's been independently derived too many times.

[2] https://jpswad.people.wm.edu/Martins%20et%20al%202018%20-%20...

[3] https://www.princeton.edu/~baboon/publications/2003AJHB.pdf

[4] I won't claim this is grammatically correct. My latin classes were more than two decades ago.

[5] (Bees, interestingly enough, can be taught the concept of zero, which puts them ahead of human toddlers.)

apocalypstyx··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
Which is in part why I stated: Though simplistic applicability of this to human society, in the ways that have been done in the past, should probably be discouraged.

But you are likely correct; I should have been stronger in my warnings.

Unfortunately, however, it could be taken that I was indicating the wholesale applicability of a possibly one-off event as explanation to broader and seemingly repeated phenomena (leveling and/or declining population rates in so-called developed countries), rather that just as a possible single extreme instance of population and reproductive instability as generalized example.

My interest is confined strictly to the rat populations themselves. The particulars of the designs involved and for the issues that were introduced by them, I think that to be the more interesting part.

Any applicability to human sociology I would regard as ridiculously erroneous at this stage. (Or perhaps any stage. We tend to cross-associate species too much sometimes.)

Though, I wonder if reproducibility may not, here, be as useful as we think. It is of course necessary for such to scientific, or at least scientifically studied. Repeatability, however, is not a prerequisite of existence. It is a question of how high a degree of variability exists within the flow and inter-relation and outcomes of population-wide phenomena among social species.

apocalypstyx··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
Does a bee think about winter? Does a tree? Or do they react in response to stimuli with evolved, complex behaviors? Does a bear go out and gorge itself to gain weight because it thinks that's the best way to get through winter or does it do so because changes in weather/seasons signal a set of immediate compulsions which have broader survival advantages?

We can even grant that honey bees, for instance, do appear to have some type of awareness of time and space, as indicated by their communicative 'dances'. However, there is a vast gap between encoding approximate seconds to kilometers (in human terms) and the time relations of the heat death of the universe.

Intelligence, self-awareness, these are all things that have developed in various species to varying degrees. And new data generally keep showing that we have previously underestimated just to what degree that is the case.

However, it has yet to be shown that bees (or any other animal) are compelled to instantiate and perpetuate social interactions with the point of advancing propositions such as "people who live in the future matter morally just as much as those of us who are alive today."

> billions of years ... survive through the winter

That's G.R.R Martin levels of winter.

EDIT:

I don't want to make it seem as if am I discounting the ability for the deployment of forethought by other animals. There is, however, the issue of any 'horizon of time'. Bees can work to restore a hive in the middle of winter because it is potentially conceptualized, in some fashion, to be necessary. A crow can interface with multiple interlocking scenarios in order to achieve an outcome (usually food). We have cooperative behavior: one monkey distracts the tourist, the other steals the food, etc. However, there seems to be little evidence for any other species having such a notion of time as to extend much more beyond immediate concerns in an active sense. Longer phenomena, such as the reproductive cycles of cicadas, is more linked to environmental factors and internal molecule clocks than it is to what could be defined as conscious relations.

This is not also to say that some species may also have (or in the future have) undergone convergent evolution with regards to this type of mental processing, just that it doesn't generally seem to be the case.

apocalypstyx··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
There's a difference in the individual level and the species level. An individual does not necessarily have to be concerned with direct propagation to participate in propagation. A bee that kills itself stinging something that is attacking the hive potentially increases the overall survival of the genes which it shares with the hive, even at the expense of its own particular genes. An individual human who assists in the aid of other adult members or children in the group, even though they themselves do might not mate successfully, does something similar.

It is all-consuming in the sense that it is fundamental to life by definition. (Unless we are to posit some organism arising from proto-life and just 'hanging out' until the end of the universe.) And it is the second half fundamental to evolution -- the other being death.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →