HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

archangel_one

1,730 karma · joined June 10, 2010

submissionscomments
archangel_one··on Changing My Mind On Microsoft
> Again, why do you (and others) keep comparing today's Linux/Android/OS X OS with a 10-15 year old Windows OS.

You argued that Windows was targeted solely because of its high market share. I'm drawing a comparison to another platform with high market share; there simply wasn't anything comparable ten years ago. And it is not obvious to me that it's not a valid comparison; Microsoft were a huge company who had been developing Windows for fifteen years at that point. Android is a lot younger, so you could just as well expect it to be less mature and therefore less secure.

And yes, I know it is possible to run it without being compromised. You obviously knew what you were doing; millions, even tens of millions of others didn't know and wound up with their computers zombified into botnets. That wasn't all because of their ignorance; there were times when a newly installed XP machine would be compromised less than fifteen minutes after being connected to the internet, which wasn't enough time to install the patches it needed. That can't be considered that user's fault, especially when they've just sat through half an hour of being told how they're installing The Most Secure Version Of Windows Yet!

> Of course they had to do all that. The Windows users back then were generally not very savvy...

Now you are missing my point. Microsoft didn't have to do anything. They could have built an operating system that was harder to use but more secure. I contend that it's even conceivable that they could have built an operating system that was roughly the same for ease of use, but still more secure; maybe they'd have been slower to market or had to compromise elsewhere. The point is that security was not a priority for them for years, they obviously just weren't that concerned. That may ultimately have been the right path for them, because they arguably didn't pay a high price really, but I don't personally consider it the technically best course.

> My point is that what is possible today, was not possible 10, 15, or 20 years ago both from a tech and user point of view... Just because someone can do OS security good today, dosn't mean you can blame someone else for not doing it good decades ago.

I think this is where we fundamentally disagree. I don't see why you think security is only something that can be achieved now and why it couldn't be ten or fifteen years ago. In the Unix world, people have known not to run as root for decades; Microsoft chose to ignore that for a long time and ultimately have been forced to shoehorn it back in for Vista. They could have done that in XP, if not long before; it certainly had the capability for it, they simply cut that out of XP Home and chose bad defaults for XP Pro.

archangel_one··on Your public IP address, via Google Search
WFM, I see "Your public IP address is 2620:0:1042:1:...."
archangel_one··on Changing My Mind On Microsoft
> > Windows security issues are everywhere and it did not need to be so. > Sorry, but that's mostly due to the desktop market size and Windows' share of it.

No, it's not. It's mostly due to Microsoft ignoring security for years because it wasn't important to them. They didn't have to have everyone running as root by default in all versions of Windows before Vista (AFAIK in XP Home you can't actually set up restricted users). They didn't have to have lots of open ports offering things like RPC to the world. They didn't have to have all files executable by default, based solely off the hidden part of the filename in AnnaKournikova.jpg.exe.

There are now supposed to be 300M Android devices worldwide, which is within an order of magnitude of Windows' numbers 10 years ago, and you don't see Android phones being compromised remotely within fifteen minutes of being connected to a network. There's no equivalent of Blaster or Sasser or anything close to that level.

It's partly due to Windows' market share that it got targeted so heavily, but those opportunities wouldn't have been there if they hadn't ignored security for so long.

archangel_one··on Gabe Newell Wants to Support Linux, Because Windows 8 is a 'Catastrophe'
Not many application executables in Windows are in your PATH, so cmd is not going to find them. Even for the ones that are, you have to type the name of the .exe which is not necessarily obvious; eg. Visual Studio -> devenv.exe.
archangel_one··on Show HN: A RottenTomatoes for Books
I have to agree with this; I like the site, but a quick search for a few books that sprung to mind turned up either a pile of irrelevant results (as someone said above, sort out your stopwords; if I search for "The Gunslinger", "The Girl who Kicked the Hornets Nest" is not relevant) or nothing at all once I started trying distinctive title (Cryptonomicon, Accelerando). I'm keen for someone to do a better job on book recommendations for me, but I think this needs a lot of improvement before it'll do the trick.
archangel_one··on 'with' gets better with python 3.1
Also, dict comprehensions. You can fake them in 2.x, but the syntax is ugly and cumbersome.
archangel_one··on 'with' gets better with python 3.1
Despite the numbering, 2.7 was released a year after 3.1. It added a bunch of features that helped compatibility with 3.x.
archangel_one··on 0 XP: The Zynga Counterrevolution
I hear that Shadow of the Colossus is a bit like this. At least, there aren't lots of enemies to grind through, and I don't think there's much in the way of XP as a result.
archangel_one··on Shell social media oil spill a 'coordinated online assassination'
I was trying to stay fairly clinical about it because it's pretty controversial. But yes, I did have a good giggle when I first saw it on The Yes Men Fix the World.
archangel_one··on German Scientists Create Aerographite, the Lightest Material in the World
Same concept as the full-body suits that competitive swimmers wore for a few years (IIRC they are now banned) which made them more buoyant than they would have been without.
archangel_one··on Shell social media oil spill a 'coordinated online assassination'
And traditional media - their Bhopal apology hoax was done via a TV interview.
archangel_one··on [dead]
Jobs was already CEO again long before he had terminal cancer. Yahoo (presumably) knew Mayer was pregnant when they hired her, and made the decision anyway. Big difference.
archangel_one··on The agony of feeling no pain
Or just being given some serious painkillers.

I had my wisdom teeth out a year or so ago, and after that I chewed big holes in my lip and tongue because I couldn't feel that I was biting on them. I imagine that's more or less what happens to them, all over their body, all the time.

archangel_one··on Keeping the Trans Pacific Partnership from changing our copyright laws
I'm pretty sure it's been possible to buy them in the past (certainly PS2's were region locked by default) but it was also pretty easy to get a region-free player if you wanted.

Also, I suspect they may have legal protection now; I was under the impression that the poxy copyright amendment bill of a couple of years ago added something along those lines, but I don't remember specifically enough to be sure (since I no longer live in NZ it's a bit less relevant).

archangel_one··on Firefox: Can this Web browser be saved?
Does it need saving? The graph they link to shows Firefox down slightly at about 26% market share (although with a little uptick at the end, belying the rumours of it being "ruined" and its reputation "killed") but holding pretty steady overall at what must be several hundred million users - most of us would be fairly happy with numbers like that. Meanwhile IE is plummeting, and I don't think "the real battle" is between it and Chrome any more. The kind of momentum their trajectories are taking suggests that IE can't hope to take back the no.1 spot any time soon, and in fact appears likely to be competing with Firefox for third spot soon.

So no, I don't think it needs saving. Not having 90% market share doesn't make it a failure, especially for a not-for-profit organisation like Mozilla.

archangel_one··on Why don't users want to see adverts they might be interested in?
Too many negative experiences with overeager matching algorithms. Yes, it's helpful to show me ads for spades if I'm searching on Google for "buy spade", but Amazon will not stop suggesting things to me that it thinks I "might" be interested in. They seem surprisingly bad at it too; I looked at a TV costing around £500, and subsequently got an e-mail every few days containing a list of their entire stock of TVs, without any consideration of price. If I'm looking at one worth £500, I'm probably not interested in a TV that costs £150 or one that costs £1500. They do badly on ebooks too, where the recommendations just seem to be "other books by the same authors you've already bought from", which I barely need; what I'd like are suggestions of similar books from other authors that I don't know about yet.

I feel like I don't mind seeing ads that I'm interested in, but there is a difference between that and being shown hundreds of ads that I might be interested in. I guess a sufficiently smart recommendation algorithm could theoretically overcome that eventually, but it seems to be a pretty hard problem since it's apparently not been well solved yet.

archangel_one··on CERN experiments observe particle consistent with long-sought Higgs boson
> Why should it mean anything special for creationists?

I guess maybe this is a misconception based on the media having come up with the stupid label of "the God particle"?

archangel_one··on The Next Microsoft
They're not really re-exploring it, they had Home/Pro versions of XP as well. They've always drawn the line between the two, although it used to be a lot more pronounced since 9x and NT were totally different codebases whereas now they're just arbitrarily partitioning their market. I assume the 9x/NT split was decided not to be effective since they ended up moving to a single codebase.
archangel_one··on Ford’s electric supercharger
Not everyone gets around exclusively on the autobahn. I used to live in New Zealand and most of the inter-city roads there are small twisty roads with hills, not flat multi-lane autobahns. I would suggest that 60HP is not really adequate to get a family of people up the Brynderwyns.

Granted though that many people (myself included) have/had a car with more power than they really need, although I am not convinced that it's so wrong to want to enjoy the act of driving a bit.

archangel_one··on Windows 8 Pro Upgrade to cost $39.99
You can install the MS upgrades on a blank hdd too, can't you? It's been some years but I thought they just used to ask for a disk from the "qualifying upgrade" product to be inserted during install.
archangel_one··on Bringing Bash's powerful command line editing to Microsoft Windows' cmd.exe
it is not a matter of hardware. On my ex-work desktop (2.8GHz quad core, so fairly quick) it used to take a good 5-10 seconds to be ready from a cold start. Yes, subsequent starts were faster, but it's a flipping shell, it shouldn't need hefty hardware to start quickly!
archangel_one··on Cheeky - It's Australian for Artificial Intelligence
I think it's a bit unfair to say he cheated. He didn't break any rules, even if his program wasn't really in the previous spirit of the competition - but it also sounds like they needed a bit of shaking up anyway.

From the Loebner Prize page: "The winner of the annual contest is the best entry relative to other entries that year, irrespective of how good it is in an absolute sense". Sounds like his entry certainly was deserving of the annual contest, even if it's not a general AI solution.

archangel_one··on WakeMate (YC S09) runs out of cash, co-founder allegedly spams users
Exactly. I agree that there's a grey area in there, but this isn't one. This is clearly data and not experience.
archangel_one··on WakeMate (YC S09) runs out of cash, co-founder allegedly spams users
It seems fair that they wouldn't want to encourage this sort of thing; founders/employees of a company can't just start a new company and use information from the existing one to start it up. Criminal charges seem pretty heavy, but it seems like what was done here wasn't right.
archangel_one··on Will the Americans with Disabilities Act tear a hole in Internet law?
I don't think that is a good metaphor. There is a significant difference between forcing a company to provide equal service to everyone regardless of skin colour and forcing them to provide additional services for the benefit of disabled people. In the former case they'd just be being racist and nasty by refusing to serve black people with their existing product, in the latter they may not actually have this additional service - eg. they may not have closed captions for their video yet, or there may be technical restrictions on why they cannot provide them, etc.
archangel_one··on Station Maps - a collection of 3D maps of London Underground/DLR stations
Yes, I find the signage for the Victoria line at King's Cross is particularly bad - they try to send you around to the east end of the platform for some reason, when the west end is normally much closer. This tool is fantastic for visualising what that comparison actually looks like.
archangel_one··on How Google's Marissa Mayer Prevents Burnout
I think you're right, I certainly don't see much of that kind of thing around here now (there probably are some engineers pulling long hours, but they're the exceptions and it's not generally expected). Could be partly related to the location, although I haven't seen evidence of people doing 80+ hour weeks in other offices yet either.
archangel_one··on Anandtech: Macbook Pro with Retina Display Review
I think you've rather missed his point - it has nothing to do with how good the car is to drive or not, it's a judgment on what buying the car would say about your aspirations. As usual from Clarkson, it's extremely opinionated and nobody sensible would take it as the final arbiter on anything, although it is a unique and fairly perceptive take on the car.
archangel_one··on Parsing huge XML files with Go
OpenStreetMap is another example that uses huge XML files. I'm not sure I really like the idea, but it does happen, and if you need the data then you have to be able to deal with it somehow even if you don't like the format.
archangel_one··on You Should Downvote Contrarian Anecdotes
Those are examples, not anecdotes.
← PreviousPage 9 of 20Next →