HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arduanika

1,478 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
arduanika··on Editor's Note: Retraction of article containing fabricated quotations
Okay. I've been harsh on Ars Technica in these comments, and I'm going to continue to hold an asterisk in my head whenever I see them cited as a source going forward. However, at least one thing in this apology does seem more reasonable than people have made it out to be: I think it's fine for reporters at an AI-skeptical outlet to play around with various AI tools in their work. Benj Edwards should have been way more cautious, but I think that people should be making periodic contact with the state of these tools (and their pitfalls!), especially if they're going to opine.[1]

We don't know yet how widespread these practices are at Ars Technica, or whether this is a one-off. But if it went down like he says it did here, then the coincidental nature of this mistake -- i.e., that it's an AI user error in reporting an AI novel behavior story at an AI-skeptical outlet -- merely makes it ironic, not more egregious than it already is.

[1] Edit: I read and agreed with ilamont's new comment elsewhere in this thread, right after posting this. It's a very reasonable caveat! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47029193

arduanika··on Editor's Note: Retraction of article containing fabricated quotations
No reason to trust that the comment section is any more genuine than the deleted fake article. If an Ars employee used genAI to astroturf these comments, they clearly would not be fired for it or even called out by name.
arduanika··on Verizon imposes new roadblock on users trying to unlock paid-off phones
Careful before trusting that any of the quotes in an Ars Technica article are real! Default assumption should be that it's all hallucinated unless you've checked it personally. They don't check it in-house.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059

arduanika··on Platforms bend over backward to help DHS censor ICE critics, advocates say
Careful before trusting that any of the quotes in this article are real! Default assumption should be that it's all hallucinated unless you've checked it personally. They don't check it in-house.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059

arduanika··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me – more things have happened
I mean, I'm even more frustrated by this in Scott's original post:

> If you are the person who deployed this agent, please reach out. It’s important for us to understand this failure mode, and to that end we need to know what model this was running on and what was in the soul document. I’m not upset and you can contact me anonymously if you’d like.

I can see where he's coming from, and I suppose he's being the bigger man in the situation, but at some point one of these reckless moltbrain kiddies is going to have to pay. Libel and extortion should carry penalties no matter whether you do it directly, or via code that you wrote, or via code that you deployed without reading it.

The AI's hit piece on Scott was pretty minor, so if we want to wait around for a more serious injury that's fine, just as long as we're standing ready to prosecute when (not 'if') it happens.

arduanika··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me – more things have happened
Equivalently: Our standards "may have" been low enough that this was just fine, actually.
arduanika··on Ars Technica makes up quotes from Matplotlib maintainer; pulls story
This error by Ars is a whole new layer on top of that story.
arduanika··on OpenAI has deleted the word 'safely' from its mission
Comparing machines to human slaves is false, confused, and tasteless, all at once. Get your priorities and your categories straight.
arduanika··on A shortage of tenors
Worrying!
arduanika··on Single bone in Spain offers first direct evidence of Hannibal's war elephants
It's more like, the surviving written histories and the archaeological record are each giving us only a part of the real truth. It's as if they're both grasping in the dark at two different parts of the same elephant.
arduanika··on Why is Singapore no longer "cool"?
Cool? Out of all the major world commercial hubs, wasn't it always the hottest and muggiest?
arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Okay, understandable under the circumstances. In this case, I really did just want to know more. I did not know about the use of this phrase in the Russia/Ukraine context, so the only touchpoint I had was aliens. It was a confused guess, not a joke.
arduanika··on We mourn our craft
Yes, that was the reference!

Possibly too obscure. I can't tell whether I'm being downvoted by optimists who missed the joke, or by pessimists who got it.

arduanika··on We mourn our craft
No true programmer is excited for the future.
arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Hmm. Do you think that kristjansson was using it just to mean state-backed thugs, or were they also claiming some Russia link?

(They haven't responded, and I've been downvoted for even asking the question. I am genuinely confused. I'll admit I don't follow this all very closely, but I want to understand what the phrase means here.)

arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Sarcasm, right, I hope? Or do you actually work with YC in some capacity?
arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Eh, that part's not so weird. Not weird to forget that HN is weird in this particular way. I just wanted to clarify it for myself & for anyone reading.
arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
> (unless you have gone back and deleted the comments, haven't checked yet!)

Minor point: I'm pretty sure that HN comments cannot be deleted/edited after about an hour. Very different from most web forums in this regard, and worth keeping in mind when digging into past discussions! Maybe the rules are different for a superuser like tptacek here with lots of karma, but I doubt it.

Correct me if I'm wrong.

arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Hmm, you completely lost me at "little green men". What/who is this referring to? Extraterrestrials?
arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
I don't think anything in the article, or in Patrick's general work, makes strong claims about a trend. Fraud may be getting worse as you say, but that is not his beat. He tends to depict fraud as eternal, and wants to shed light on it as a technical problem to solve.

Also, there are real dangers to blackpilling about fraud. "Everybody is doing it" is exactly what one says before doing fraud oneself. In reality, there are a lot of people out there doing the right thing every day.

arduanika··on Fraud investigation is believing your lying eyes
Fair enough. But the reason that "the right" is not letting go of the story is:

1. The fraud was not in fact being investigated seriously enough until this kid, even while lacking the basics of journalism as Patrick describes here, forced the issue.

2. This is just another example of the decades long trend where more and more bad patterns and outcomes can persist for far too long because the normal checks are fended off with spurious accusations of racism.

There's some variation on how "the right" would handle (2). The center-right wants to shore up our culture of color-blindness to patch these vulnerabilities. The far-right wants to do away with egalitarianism altogether, and just go back to plain old racism. If we can't figure out the former, we might well end up with the latter.

(My reading is that Patrick falls squarely in the "center-right" here, fwiw. Then again, it can be hard to decode his exact subtext from under all the polite circumlocutions. Reading his stuff is something of an acquired skill and/or taste.)

arduanika··on Man who videotaped himself BASE jumping in Yosemite arrested, says it was AI
That tracks. BASE jumping and representing yourself share a common philosophy towards risk.
arduanika··on Opus 4.6 uncovers 500 zero-day flaws in open-source code
It might mean nothing to you, but tptacek's words means at least something to many of us here.

Also, he's a friend of someone I know & trust irl. But then again, who am I to you, but yet another anon on a web forum.

arduanika··on [dead]
Just wait. Mean reverts to the mean.
arduanika··on Cannabis usage in older adults linked to larger brain, better cognitive function
Dude, but what about like, correlation versus causation, man?
arduanika··on Naples' 1790s civil war was intensified by moral panic over Real Analysis (2023)
War often pushes people to the limit
arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
I suppose I can understand the impulse. It's fun to tear down idols, and sometimes necessary.

As I said in a different comment, I'll try to come back to LL with an open mind some other time, hopefully on a different topic.

arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
I'm not appealing to them out of nowhere. I'm rejecting Pullum's dismissal of them at the end of TFA. You can learn a lot more from them, than from what I've seen of this blog.

As to this new link...what a load a willful misrepresentations. Misses the point entirely. The rules in PatEL are not literal laws. They are merely pointing the way toward something.

For example, from the very top:

> So, Orwell writes "it is generally assumed", which is passive. Why didn't he say "people generally assume", or "we generally assume", both of which are perfectly grammatical...

Beaver's proposed variants are also passive, spiritually, in my sense above. Who is "we"? A good author chooses between these not based on which one is literally passive, but on other considerations like flow and sound.

Maybe there are Orwell fans out there who have read PatEL too literally, and need to be disabused? Maybe this blog is good for those kinds of people? But from what I've seen so far of LL, it's a bunch of smug dunks that nobody asked for.

arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
There is a link right there in TFA that explains what happened to the bus. The bus was not your Audi. It did not spontaneously combust. The bus was involved in a conflict that was a hot-button issue even back in 2011, and the quoted headline "Bus Blows Up in <CITY>" was blatantly excluding information. Language exists in context.

When the commenter above says "functionally passive", he is getting at something that lies outside of any strict grammatical sense. It is not a matter of ASTs, IRs, or anything of the like. It might be less confusing to phrase this as "spiritually passive". We're using "passive" not in the technical sense but in the normal, colloquial meaning of the word.

Normal people often use the grammatical term "passive voice" to casually mean "this sentence does that 'passive' thing where it omits key info about agency and responsibility". This casual usage makes a lot of sense, because the technical "passive" is our most useful tell for the spiritual "passive". Granted, anyone who takes a moment to think it over can see that there are counterexamples, and that this tell is merely a loose correlation, not an ironclad correspondence. Normal people are okay with this sort of situation.

Pedants are within their rights to be annoyed by this usage (and perhaps genuinely confused, though I doubt that this is common). There is certainly no law against being angry or snide whenever a word has multiple, related meanings. But TFA is just plain wrong when it claims that the passive voice "has nothing to do with lacking energy or initiative, or assuming a receptive and non-directive role." It is entirely related -- by correlation. Correlations are not foolproof logical rules, but people can see them and use them.

Moreover, normal people can see when Orwell or Strunk & White point out a correlation. They can read intelligently to understand what Orwell and Strunk & White really meant, and how it applies to actual headlines and sentences. And finally, they can read Pullum here call Orwell's essay "overblown", and decide for themselves whether Orwell is overstating the dangers of official language, how it can serve to dehumanize and deflect, or whether, more likely, Pullum is overstating this stupid nitpick about what "passive voice" ackshually means.

arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
Okay, I trust your recommendation. Maybe I'll come back to it in a couple days when I'm in a less grouchy mood.
← PreviousPage 5 of 21Next →