HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arduanika

1,478 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
arduanika··on MAID in Canada
> How else is it supposed to work?

Like literally any other good or service.

arduanika··on Is 4chan the perfect Pirate Bay poster child to justify wider UK site-blocking?
Well-paced article. The exposition sounds bleak, but then Betteridge's law creeps up slowly over the middle of the article, and the piece crescendos toward a final showdown.
arduanika··on Why is choral music harder to appreciate?
Yes! I had a chance to sing in this once.

But it definitely suffers from every one of the reasons for obscurity listed in TFA, on steroids.

arduanika··on Why is choral music harder to appreciate?
A classic! The Allegri Miserere gets used whenever a movie soundtrack needs some sacred choral music. That floating soprano line between the sections is something else.
arduanika··on Is 4chan the perfect Pirate Bay poster child to justify wider UK site-blocking?
Well sure, but no true NGO supports it.
arduanika··on Being “Confidently Wrong” is holding AI back
The latter, I think.

Randall Munroe has called this abomination "an insult to life itself". But that might be quoting him out of context.

arduanika··on Why is this hard?
Excellent.

This part especially:

"Some developers can fit substantially more in their memory. I have come to believe that hinders them at least as much as it helps them. When you are at your limits, you are forced to simplify the situation in order to resume forward progress. The more regularly you are forced to do that, the better the chance that you are keeping the situation under control."

It reminds me of how Bill Gates said he'd rather hire lazy developers, because "a lazy person will find an easy way to do it." Maybe even better would be to hire lazy developers with poor working memory.

arduanika··on Everything is correlated (2014–23)
Or, exercise more and you will eat more. Drat.
arduanika··on Everything is correlated (2014–23)
Quoted repeatedly by Mr. Plinkett in his new drop yesterday.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xeMak4RqJA

arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
Okay, I find this much more reasonable than what you wrote initially.
arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
Ah, okay. I understand where the "some" was coming from now. Leaving my earlier comment as-is to keep the chain coherent, but I now see that it wasn't conspiratorial.

Let me see if I can put my point a little more politely. There is basically no economic difference between dividends and buybacks, apart from some tax technicalities. When people talk as if dividends are good and pure whereas buybacks are somehow evil and decoupled from reality, it is almost always drivel.

You seem to have a notion that shares, in their untampered state, should be "conduits to return money to shareholders via dividends". But it really makes ~no economic difference whether the shareholders get direct returns via dividends, versus indirect returns via buybacks.

And I really don't understand what connection you see between this minute distinction, and your point about Palantir being a "nearly sovereign entity". Perhaps you could spell that out.

arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
No, all shareholders are essentially getting money returned.

"Higher value shares for utility at their own discretion" = negotiable securities = money.

This conspiratorial "some" is...not a good sign that you're well calibrated enough to tell me what long-dead companies Palantir is or is not like. I'll take my critiques of Palantir from people who understand what they're talking about.

arduanika··on The contrarian physics podcast subculture
Is nis0s your real name? Why not?

Anons criticize published research all day long on X and other social media. Should they be banned? Or just the ones you don't like?

Btw, there's nothing in this article about an anon criticizing research that was "published" in the academic sense. There's the critique that Tim and his anonymous co-author did of a YouTube video. Is that the "published research" you're referring to? Is the 95% of a YouTube comment section that is anonymous operating in bad faith?

> this field is poorly understood by 98% of the commenters, so it’s impossible to decide who is wrong or right based on the science alone

Which is why you need trustworthy proxies. To quote TFA:

> Scientific disagreements are intricate matters that require the attention of highly trained experts. However, for laypersons to be able to make up their own minds on such issues, they have to rely on proxies for credibility such as persuasiveness and conviction. This is the vulnerability that contrarians exploit, as they are often skilled in crafting the optics and rhetoric to support their case. Indeed, Weinstein and Hossenfelder’s strong personalities and their sowing of distrust in institutions enable them to persuade others of the correctness of their views when they deviate from those of experts. Thus, I include this section to show that even if one were to rely on social cues alone, there is in fact no controversy about the illegitimacy of Geometric Unity among those who are close to Weinstein or who are qualified to judge. The success of physics grifters has relied on the fact that they make more noise than those who have quietly moved on.

Now as to your defense of Hossenfelder...in that process of filtering out the noise, we rely on intermediaries. When the intermediaries get it wrong, or waffle about matters that should be clear, their reputation rightly suffers. You can call this "comeuppance" if you like, but it's simply a natural part of the sensemaking process.

arduanika··on The contrarian physics podcast subculture
Tim Nguyen has put an extraordinary effort into finding the truth in this entire long exchange, and it's been mostly thankless.

His appearance on Decoding the Gurus was a highlight of the show's early seasons.

https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/special-epis...

Perhaps you would agree with Weinstein and Hossenfelder that physics today is broken. But that does not in itself prove that the people peddling alternatives aren't even worse.

arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
Index funds aren't supposed to save you from a market setback. In a correction or crash, you will lose money. They merely save you from the total ruin that can come with leverage, or from thinking you can outplay the stocks or options market as an amateur.

I'm glad to see OP's comment voted to the top, b/c it models good thinking. He knows what he doesn't know, and so he sticks to index funds.

Also -- I don't know anybody who still buys S&P 500 funds, now that there are broader funds available. None of the funds for Canadians that GP listed is limited to the S&P 500, so it's unclear why you would respond as if that's the index he's talking about.

arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
This is true.

Bernays did more to end the Great Depression than Keynes, and to prevent its recurrence post-war. Sad truth.

arduanika··on Margin debt surges to record high
> "money returned to shareholders"

> buybacks

I'm not sure you understand what a buyback is, and given that display of ignorance, I don't see why anyone would care about your (entirely unrelated) observation about Palantir.

arduanika··on Have you ever noticed that people dressed better in the past?
Come on. When you write code, do you believe that there are standards of quality that vary between codebases?

Do you think that we're unique among crafts, in having taste?

arduanika··on Have you ever noticed that people dressed better in the past?
But fashion is interested in you!

And there's not much selection bias in the old footage you see of crowds walking city streets at the turn-of-the-century.

arduanika··on Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode
The anti-social social network
arduanika··on Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode
Frankly, you'd need to make vim even harder to exit if you want to compete with the big players in this space.
arduanika··on I'm worried it might get bad
I do too. :)

But your earlier line about meds didn't even make sense in this context, if you think it through.

Now you have my upvote.

arduanika··on I'm worried it might get bad
I want to upvote this because I agree with your points, but can't because the last line is needlessly rude to the author.
arduanika··on Why are there so many rationalist cults?
Oh come on.

Anyone who's ever seen the sky knows it's blue. Anyone who's spent much time around rationalism knows the premise of this article is real. It would make zero sense to ban talking about about a serious and obvious problem in their community until some double blind peer reviewed data can be gathered.

It would be what they call an "isolated demand for rigor".

arduanika··on Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act
If the incessant banner ads said, "Hello, this is a special plea from Jimmy Wales, get in, we're saving the Brits from themselves", then maybe I'd actually donate.
arduanika··on Try and
Likewise. A really cool site.

The English language has so many little quirks. You can try to document them all, and it's a fun endeavor, but you can't try and document them all.

arduanika··on Try and
I'm also a native speaker from the US. Non-native speakers often have extra insight into the nuances of language, and I think skrebbel's headcanon here is really interesting.

I almost see "try and" as a form of "manifesting", of optimism, of believing that you will succeed. This would sort of comport with what he's saying.

But any difference is subtle, and most native speakers won't notice it, beyond maybe the more formal register of "try to".

arduanika··on GPT-5: "How many times does the letter b appear in blueberry?"
Sure. Language is squishy, and psychometrics is hard. Nevertheless...

"Intelligence" refers to a basket of different capabilities. Some of them are borderline cases that are hard to define. The stuff that GPT-5 failed to do here is not.

Things like knowing what a question means, knowing what you know and don't, counting a single digit number of items, or replying with humility if you get stuck -- these are fairly central examples of what a very, very basic intelligence should entail.

arduanika··on GPT-5: "How many times does the letter b appear in blueberry?"
If you open your mind up too far, your brain will fall out.

LLMs are not intelligence. There's not some groovy sense in which we and they are both intelligent, just thinking on a different wavelength. Machines do not think.

We are inundated with this anthropomorphic chatter about them, and need to constantly deprogram ourselves.

arduanika··on GPT-5: "How many times does the letter b appear in blueberry?"
Because the damn things are marketed under the word "intelligence". That word used to mean something.
← PreviousPage 9 of 21Next →