HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arjie

10,978 karma · joined January 30, 2013

Roshan George

roshan@arjie.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/roshangeorge; my proof: https://keybase.io/roshangeorge/sigs/6EQyu7jh7oa-KjkTAQBoJJ61fE2RBiZ546abgZc6zsM ]

Blog: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog

I use https://overmod.org to manage highlight/block

submissionscomments
arjie··on A farewell to Arc browser
Enjoyed using it to start with but soon returned to Chrome. Now I have a personal browser/terminal hybrid I use. Lots of the ideas from arc were good. Sidebar tabs, splits, page editability.
arjie··on Google cleared 300 hectares of Finnish forest
About a square mile, and the problem is procedural nonsense about the timing of paperwork rather than the paperwork actually showing a problem. Storm in a teacup.
arjie··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
What a delightfully Reddit post. Credentials. Mental disability. Prognostication of certain doom. A disappointing lack of sexual orientation or minority status but one cannot demand too much.
arjie··on A Markdown File Should Just Open
This essay could have been a prompt. I have a markdown viewer. Comes out of the same codebase as my json viewer https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-04-30/Personal_Sof...

I felt the same but if you put it into Claude code Opus 5.5 can build you a program that will open faster than anything you’ve ever used before if you ask for it. I asked for it and it’s instantaneous. Faster than literally any other macOS app.

It opens and displays a markdown file faster than bitwarden’s chrome extension displays its fill UI.

The future is almost here. Formats and so on are on the threshold of irrelevance in the next few years for this kind of consumer use. It’s hard to even tell if the time it takes us to summarize a text will be the time a future agent takes to write a specialized program that extracts what you need from the file. “Native” support will soon be irrelevant.

Even my solution is yesterday’s solution.

arjie··on When Do We Become the Person We Ought to Be?
In a sense, Sunday mass is just an all-hands where you're told the CEO's vision and you get to think about how aligned you are with the vision.
arjie··on Today's PHP security release, and how we're strengthening security
Good to read HN. I brought down my PHP sites prior to release and replaced with static versions. Thanks for alert.
arjie··on Someone Opened a CashApp in Her Name. She Faces Years in Prison
I agree. The onerous nature of KYC rules is the mechanism usually used to correctly assign the problem to the person who did not run KYC well. What actually happens in these scenarios? It seems to me that the victim here should be able to sue CashApp for claiming to represent her, but that’s unlikely to work, right?

It is definitely strange if I walk up to someone and claim to be a lawyer for their employer who needs their badge. Is the employer the victim of identity theft? Doesn’t seem convincing to me.

arjie··on The Lucrative World of Literary Scams
Just seems like a variant of romance scams.
arjie··on The Other Epidemic: Trying to get off benzodiazepines
This isn’t true for everyone. I have witnessed people whose curves are more gradual. Their performance exceeded mine and the gap increased with increasing duration. The principal difference I’d say is task focus. After many hours my attention falters, but I know people whose attention diminishes more gradually.

I could see someone like that using more hours productively. In a sense, someone who is awake 18 hours lives 12% more life than the 16 h me.

arjie··on The Other Epidemic: Trying to get off benzodiazepines
I cycled modafinil/adrafinil and caffeine. For me it was a much stronger focus effect than caffeine and a much weaker effect than amphetamine. However, I developed an intense case of the hives after use which occasionally (1/2y) recurs without use with no prior history. This is not an uncommon side effect according to the doctor who I reported this to.

In my case I experienced no physical dependency on any of the drugs and chose to stop because I wanted to perform other experiments. I’d say it’s about half a decade now since.

I do know others who get weakened impulse control but I just get hyper focus of various degrees.

arjie··on They Fled Trump's America. Now They Regret It
Europe is best either visited or retired to if you're American. Your wealth will take you a long way there.
arjie··on Security advisory: Critical remote code execution vulnerabilities, update now
Wow, that's a terrible one. Shut down old apps (that I'd forked and upgraded to latest) I had that were PHP. Sadly, my blog was on Mediawiki and so I've got to turn that off too. Tomorrow we learn.

EDIT: Ha, Claude just took the blog and rendered all pages and now it is a static site! I'll restore the Mediawiki once I can fix the issue.

arjie··on Archive of Our Own
Thank you. Do you still have your archive? I'd email you if you had address on profile.
arjie··on What shall I teach my son?
Grand thoughts always meet reality poorly. Does Spaceship Earth mean that you live in the forest to be surrounded by the greenery or live in a high-rise to preserve the greenery? Do you allow the other to exist to preserve Spaceship Earth? Environmental organizations in San Francisco treat this question like Shiri's Scissor. It is not so easy to coordinate people - disagreements on the specifics can easily fragment coalitions.
arjie··on Archive of Our Own
Makes sense. Somewhat strange (but not too strange since it's not standardized) they don't have a Crawl-Delay except for Slurp. Why not on User-Agent: *

Confusing. Would even prefer a commented crawl delay that specifies in human language since then I could special-case it.

arjie··on Archive of Our Own
Just data hoarding tendencies, faster and better search, etc.
arjie··on Sixteen years after Deepwater Horizon, deep sea life shows few signs of recovery
I read the source

> Available evidence rules out natural phenomena as likely drivers, suggesting a large-scale pollution event and its associated mitigation measures most likely precipitated the declines...That the declines began shortly after the Deepwater Horizon oil spill points to that event as the most parsimonious explanation. These findings suggest that despite its immense size the deep-pelagic biome is vulnerable to human-induced disturbance and possesses limited resilience to facilitate recovery.

This means "the oil spill caused the declines". That is what this means in English.

arjie··on Archive of Our Own
There's no way to just download all of it, is there? You have to scrape it slowly? I don't mind doing it that way, but flat downloads would be pretty neat. How do mirrors work? Do they run read-through caches?
arjie··on Why do we have so many meetings?
One thing that I've been wondering is if I could somehow transmit everything in my head somehow automatically into text so that an LLM can reasonably respond to almost everything about what I'm doing and how updated live to other people. Perhaps it could escalate the things that matter to me and meetings would be transformed so that others could pull things out of me faster than having to talk to me. I might even be completely obviated by sufficient encoding of self.

Perhaps the visible actions and text I write are all holographic-principle-like sufficient encoding of my invisible prior thought given sufficient information. Curious to see!

arjie··on Voxtral 3
Interesting. I've found the Voxtral series pretty nice actually. Good transcription and diarization which is the primary personal use-case where I want to turn podcast content into text since I read faster than I listen. The older ones were pretty cheap too and had the nice property that they don't hallucinate text when there's no speech.
arjie··on Facebook Pages require paid subscription to post more than two links per month
I created a new public group and posted three links from my blog to it in the space of 2 minutes without being charged https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KtUvHF02lx4

Therefore "Facebook now charging to post more than 2 links a month" is false. It appears that this is some restriction applied to organic marketing.

arjie··on DeepSeek just open-sourced its inference engine
I see. So there's a risk that the EC or CJEU make a determination against the existing system because of the non-independence ruling of the FTC. So the movement away to regional providers is because no one wants to be caught surprised if the EC/CJEU make such a determination. Interesting. It must be early stage because from what I can see the most spend is still on the big two, but this does bode well for Mistral and EU-based open model hosts. Lots of room in the 20%.
arjie··on DeepSeek just open-sourced its inference engine
That's true and the Chinese vendor market for most things is sufficiently decentralized that individual vendors do act with a lot of self-interest rather than government-interest, but it would strike me that a provider whose key operatives are travel-controlled by the government of the place they live in are not in that category. I imagine having your passports held by the Chinese government assists in alignment.
arjie··on DeepSeek just open-sourced its inference engine
For data residency reasons? You can meet data residency requirements on AWS, I'm pretty sure. Mind sharing which condition blocked it in your experience? Mostly curious because in the US there isn't that much interest in on-prem deployments because it's easier to scale up and upgrade using the cloud and it's easier to use AWS because you don't have to run a new compliance process for each part of the stack.
arjie··on Show HN: Jev Cards, Can you beat a vision model at a picture quiz?
Would prefer if the audio button was at the top right of the page etc.
arjie··on Credit where credit is due
Nothing wrong with LLM textual content per se. Current LLMs simply cannot produce sufficient quality of it. And the problem is that P(garbage|LLM) is so high that P(LLM) means you're going to extract a small amount of content from it.

However, there is another problem: first-party content becomes unreliable. "I looked at X and when I did Y, I noticed that a dropped by b%". Vast amounts of such content can be generated that are now plausible. Humans were not so good at producing sufficiently convincing information here, but LLMs are, so my heuristics required to filter down input to manually review are no longer effective.

For my part, I try to write human-directed content when intended for humans, but I have a large machine-curated knowledge base of machine-written content that I consume through a machine intermediary. In some future, I'm sure that machines will perform better at communication, and so the writing will improve, but the provenance of first-party information cannot be solved now. I hope someone figures out a new mechanism to transmit facts to others interested in those.

arjie··on I no longer care to work on any Ruby gems so I've archived all my repositories
Hmm, that may well be true but I don't model with any of those packages. I model with `build123d` or `openscad` using Claude Code to do the heavy lifting. I describe what I want, measure and make up ideas and learn a little terminology (fillet, chamfer) and then the machine builds me the concept that I then print and deploy into action[0].

My life has been improved immeasurably (our home is filled with attachments and affordances built on-demand by Claude), and no new software was created that anyone else would see. It is entirely possible that these tools fail to create a Photoshop/Blender replacement and yet replace Photoshop/Blender.

My wife started out building in Blender[1] but these days even she uses Claude Code and mostly ideates. The nature of LLMs might not be "they can build you something better than Photoshop in a day" but that "where we're going we don't need roads".

0: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-01-11/Modeling_Wit...

1: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-01-15/Modeling_Wit...

arjie··on Namecheap just seized and disabled all my domains
Haha, god damn it. I just got done getting all the way off Squarespace after Google Domains pushed me there. It's just a pity not everything is supported by Cloudflare. Okay, anyway, the solution if you're stuck with Namecheap for the moment seems to be to proactively do whatever this ID verification is. Does anyone know? If anyone has managed to do this proactively then I'd love to follow their instructions.
arjie··on Footage of the Flock search that a judge ruled was uncosntitutional
Right instinct for the criminal, wrong tool to search. You have to let some number of meth dealers kill people. It is the price of a free society. The ideal amount of meth in a society is not zero.
arjie··on Florida's HOAs and condo associations are making the housing crisis worse
Certainly if you had prompted the LLM that's a reasonable position. But you believe that the addition of an LLM to a human who would otherwise abuse statistics to produce outcomes they desire is to result in statistics that are more likely to be true? So if I took a spam email and passed it through an LLM this would make it more reputable?

It would seem to me that the addition of the LLM to the mix is likely to result in output that is more likely to be aligned to the human writing it and less likely to be aligned with me, as the reader, conditional on the human being the kind who abuses statistics one way or another.

But everyone's epistemics are different. Reality will tell us over time where we land with our methods.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →