HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asciilifeform

3,974 karma · joined February 21, 2007

submissionscomments
asciilifeform··on Tacocopter - Flying Robots Deliver Tacos To You
Nah, everybody knows that drones can only be used to deliver drugs and bombs.

Commercial UAVs being illegal in the US, "might as well hang for a sheep as for a lamb."

asciilifeform··on Self-contained, Internet-less Wikipedia machine.
I would dearly love to see a ruggedized, solar-powered version of this device created for our descendants.

In case industrial civilization, well.. fails to go the distance. A Wikipedia-equivalent volume of paper is rather bulky and fragile.

asciilifeform··on Frighteningly Ambitious Startup Ideas
But don't miss Mencius Moldbug's rebuttal of Hanson's Futarchy:

http://bit.ly/7gFYD

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> "Foundations matter" is pretending to be profound without substance

Please take the time to read my article. The kind of pieces you get when something breaks or needs reworking does matter.

> Is everything fucked because we all use mice & keyboards?

I do not myself believe this, but there are those who do, and their arguments are worth paying attention to.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> With HTML/CSS/Javascript you can make something to run almost anywhere.

With gargantuan effort.

And your creation will still appear distorted in unpredictable ways to many users.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Steve Jobs demolished Apple and replaced it with Next.
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> I was only mocking the author for wanting both ubiquitous debugging as a top-7 must have conputing feature, while at the same time decrying complexity and pining for a simple system.

There is no contradiction between the two:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elektronika_BK

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> It's almost funny, until you read his seven tenets of computing and find that any program which encounters any error should enter a debugger, so you can fix it and carry on. I think that would drive anyone insane.

You prefer inexplicable crashes? Now these are enough to drive someone mad.

And if you do prefer them, wire your debugger to a Blue Screen of Death emulation.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Finally, a breath of sanity on HN.
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Why not with a magnetized needle, too?
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> I'm not sure what you were doing in 96 or so

I was a boy. A boy playing with Hypercard. As hinted at rather transparently in the article.

> But anything truly useful beyond that was just as complex as anything else.

Complexity of interface is different from complexity back-stage.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
So doing "it" right is a physical impossibility, then? Care to say why?
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Thanks!

Also there is an extra eval (the first one is unnecessary, I think.) But I am too lazy to revise the screenshots.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Hypercard is different from systems like Director in what isn't there: the cancerous complexity.
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
This wasn't meant to be a general statement about the opinions of original creators.

I happen to respect that particular inventor (Kalashnikov). And I agree with the reasons he gave. (Going into them here would be going too far off subject. Google is your friend.)

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
The "natural" language is actually the weakest part.
asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Quite a few things are detectably similar to Hypercard. Even MS Visual Studio.

None of them have the love-at-first-sight appeal. Most seem like an unbearable ordeal once you've used the real thing.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> This doesn't seem to be anything special about Hypercard.

Tell that to the thousands of otherwise non-programming people who developed real, useful applications (some of them best-selling) in Hypercard.

> it's going to be something else over the JS/CSS/HTML stack

Like building a castle on a swamp. Foundations matter: http://www.loper-os.org/?p=55

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
The distinction between a "troll" and an actual human with unpopular opinions is lost on you?

You aren't the only one: http://www.loper-os.org/?p=91

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
Mikhail Kalashnikov did not regard the 74 as an improvement. The project was moved forward against his objections.

And HyperCard did indeed end up reincarnated as cheap imitations, just like the Chinese Type 56. The analogy holds.

Can't comment on the other two -- small arms aren't really my field.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
I am not a troll. Everything I write is deadly-serious.

And I do not submit my articles to this site, although I do read it when they inevitably end up here. Complain to the person who does.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> the WWW was coming.

In 1998?

> it's spirit certainly lived on in Visual Basic, Borland Delphi, Macromedia Director and a bunch of other things.

I have used all of these, and beg to differ. The spirit of HyperCard was that of radical simplicity, and it does not live in these systems.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
> Apple has poured tons of resources into making development for its devices simpler...

"Simple" and "pleasant" are different things. Digging a trench deep enough to bury a car is "simple."

> Has this guy played with Interface Builder lately?

Yes, actually I have played with it.

It makes me want to vomit. The whole NextStep stack does, in fact. Because I have used OpenGenera. And HyperCard.

> if somebody has wanted to do a proper visual programming environment in the vein of HyperCard, what in the last 13 years has stopped them?

Here's a example from an unrelated field. The Kalashnikov rifle is more than half a century old. Why has nothing replaced it as the world's most popular weapon of war?

Often, complexity and full-featuredness is precisely what people don't want.

asciilifeform··on Why Hypercard Had to Die
No such luck. The Web architecture inherently sucks:

http://philip.greenspun.com/research/internet-haters

asciilifeform··on Violated: A traveler’s lost faith, a difficult lesson learned
The polite "everything is beautiful" emails suggest against meth addicts. And it seems like too much work for a run-of-the-mill sadist.
asciilifeform··on Violated: A traveler’s lost faith, a difficult lesson learned
The apartment-trashing was entirely senseless. The motive was clearly not theft, for example.

The simplest hypothesis is that the purpose of the crime was to create outrage - in order to destroy the reputation of AirBnB and its business model. It may yet succeed in doing so.

asciilifeform··on Violated: A traveler’s lost faith, a difficult lesson learned
Cui bono?

Hotels.

It seems likely that this "mysterious" crime was paid for by an organization serving the interests of hotels.

asciilifeform··on Mozilla building mobile OS to battle Chrome
I wish people would stop calling the act of scraping together a new linux distro "writing an OS."
asciilifeform··on Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter
Stop telling people to stop calling idiots idiots.
asciilifeform··on Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter
> the evolutionary steps that are the necessary prerequisites to getting to where we are now.

Where under your car's hood have you stuffed your horses?

← PreviousPage 4 of 26Next →