HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ashdksnndck

752 karma · joined May 16, 2025

submissionscomments
ashdksnndck··on AI outperforms law professors in Stanford Law study
Same is probably true of humans. In a conversation, we often respond from instinct, then work backwards to a rationalization only when asked. For more considered thoughts, if we’re lucky, we can remember our “reasoning traces” but that’s as deep as our introspection goes. Unless we’re neuroscientists, we don’t even know how many neurons we have, let alone have any understanding of how they generate our thoughts. Motivated reasoning impairs our introspection further, and then dishonesty and communication errors prevent us from relaying the limited remaining information to each other.

Model interpretability work has advanced a lot. Arguably we already can explain AI decision-making better than human brains.

ashdksnndck··on Different attitudes towards AI in California's university system
I think unions in industries where their workers are at risk of eventually getting replaced by AI are pretty universally against it, because protecting the jobs of members is the whole purpose of a union. It’s like how the teamsters are against self-driving cars.
ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
My predictions:

1) If the AI companies do end up running half the economy, we will have discussion for the rest of the human history about how the public got scammed by not being able buy in earlier at a lower price and how the late IPOs set in stone the oligarchy.

2) If the AI companies crash and burn, we will have discussion for several years about how everyone involved in running and financing them is a scoundrel who needs to go to jail for scamming us by selling us stock.

ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
For a moment step into the theory of mind of the AI believer. That’s the common mindset in finance today. You believe that AI is displacing white collar work, and soon with robots it will displace physical work. Your personal job is to help set the rules for stocks to be included in the index. You believe that the point of indices is for passive investors to automatically be invested in the diversified set of top public companies (weighted by market cap). During previous economic shifts, where companies went public early and were already in the index during their growth phase, passive investors broadly benefited from that growth. These new AI companies have stayed private much longer, meaning that the index has missed the opportunity to “buy low” and build up a stake so far.

You believe that the owners of the leading AI companies stand to become owners of most wealth. Furthermore, that we are at an inflection point where the value of these companies rises so rapidly that delays in index investment will set in stone a permanent inequality, where early tech VC and other private funds own a huge portion of the economy. The few-$T downside risk of AI bubble popping this year feels to you like a minor concern compared to index funds being shut out of this wealth due to some arbitrary rules, which have been changed before and can be changed again. Delaying investment in these huge public companies feels like a more dangerous decision than buying in when they become public.

In short, there are two possible stories here:

1) Wall Street is AGI-pilled and thinks AI companies will be worth many trillions of dollars

2) Wall Street expects the AI bubble to pop and is trying to make the public into bag holders by selling a few hundreds of billions of dollars in the IPO

I think the second story actually doesn’t hold together, because Wall Street is making a bunch of correlated bets. The IPO cash is just one more source of capital, and much of it going to be used to make investments which are also correlated bets.

ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
I believe the (apparently AGI-pilled?) folks running the indices are more afraid of the public’s pitchforks in the scenario where the AI stocks go public at $3T value, then increase to $30T before the index rules dictate they buy in. Hence the rule change to prevent that from happening.
ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
It’s a category error to compare the equity value of Twitter during its purchase to the amount of cash to be raised by SpaceX during its IPO.

Twitter has about $13B of debt, and about $1.5B of annual interest payments (that’s how much cash it actually needs to come up with this year). SpaceX has a planned IPO market cap of $2T and plans to raise $75B cash during the IPO.

ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
If you intend to remain a passive investor, keep doing what you’re doing. If you have conviction that AI boom will bust and you want to become an active investor, follow the advice from other comments on how to prevent these companies from being part of your portfolio. If you're going to become an active trader, I suggest thinking about both upside and downside risks and look beyond the local echo chamber.
ashdksnndck··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
The twitter debt is a negligible portion of the money at stake here. It’s a footnote compared to the trillions of dollars in wealth that are moving around. We are only talking about it because the internet commentariat has special interest in twitter. Not worth wasting time thinking about it if you are deciding how to allocate your portfolio.

Nevertheless it is part of a pattern of weird deals in Elon’s companies. He’ll do anything to move the goalposts and turn his failures into successes. There is no norm he won’t violate, no boundary he won’t cross.

ashdksnndck··on Anthropic confidentially submits draft S-1 to the SEC
I don’t believe similar scores on small bounded tasks mean models are interchangeable. I’ve found that heavy token-burning workflows are good for my productivity (letting multiple sessions run async working of different stuff). Claude ultracode is an easy example to point to, but there are tons of harnesses out there doing similar things. I find using a higher quality model matters because it affects how far it can get unattended before heading the wrong direction. I’ve tried using the cheaper/faster models and it’s a real downgrade (or completely useless). A model that’s even smarter with longer time horizon would be even better for my productivity. I don’t think we are at the ceiling for model quality or price. My employer pays a lot for my tokens but it’s still a lot less than they pay me.

I agree Anthropic faces some risk they could get commoditized, but on the other hand if things go well they could end up leading adoption into more industries. There are upside and downside scenarios. Recursive self-improvement is obviously an important unknown and could lead to winner-take-all.

ashdksnndck··on Anthropic confidentially submits draft S-1 to the SEC
The narrative is that inference on existing models is profitable. All of the profits and many billions of additional capital invested go into training the next model, which is some multiple more expensive to train than the last. Each new model generation also leads to more revenue growth. Newer models are more compute-efficient when distilled (so could possibly be higher margin) but also they work on longer time-horizon tasks and can make greater use of test-time compute which increases token counts. So the inference ROI on each model can pay back the cost of training it, but future growth demands put all that money and more into training the next model. The numbers we’d need to prove whether this is true are not public, but it makes sense and fits what info we do have.

Theoretically, if training more expensive models stops resulting in better capabilities or isn’t economically viable, the labs can shift gears into making profit on old models. A lot of future growth is priced in so this would lead to a collapse in share price if it happens anytime soon.

There’s a story out that Anthropic might be profitable this quarter. This is in one sense bad news - it means that the company wasn’t aggressive enough about acquiring capacity last year, because they didn’t foresee how fast their inference business would grow. Anthropic is now forced to make suboptimal choices about serving existing users vs. training the next model (need to scrounge for capacity by paying other players like SpaceX). And as a Claude Code user I feel like I’ve been affected by that, what with the random outages and performance degradations.

ashdksnndck··on Erin Brockovich made a map to track data centers around the country
> I do think the tech industry would be wise to do more outreach and less sneering, though.

The industry is actually doing real work on water issues in response to these complaints. Big tech companies are funding projects that will allow them to replenish more water than their datacenters consume. This isn’t actually that hard of a goal for them to meet, because as we know, the amount of water we’re talking about isn’t much on a national scale. Regardless, this will mean companies making some positive change in the communities where they build datacenters.

Anyway, all of this is a distraction compared to the real problem of carbon emissions. It confuses me that environmentalists are getting sidetracked by the water use distraction here when more natural gas and coal plants are coming online.

ashdksnndck··on The real cost of owning a home
When I bought my house the realtor gave me a free home warranty for a year (a $600 value vs the tens of thousands in commission they got paid). The old washing machine broke during that year and the home warranty did replace it, so on paper I got good value out of the policy.

However, I think it was on the phone with the company waiting on hold for about four hours total to process the claim. That was without any dispute or confusion, it’s just how long the process took. The person on the other end of the line would ask me one question, then put me on hold for another 15 minutes before asking the next question. I got the impression they are actually handling multiple customers at once and switching between us. I can only imagine this system is designed to deter folks from making claims. I was afraid to delay the call any longer by inquiring about whether there were multiple replacement models I could pick between. I received a $600 model from a manufacturer I wouldn’t have chosen.

If I’d paid $600 for that home warranty, I would not be a satisfied customer. I certainly wouldn’t recommend home warranties as a time-saver. It would be much easier to directly purchase products and services from people with some incentive to obtain my business.

ashdksnndck··on Project Glasswing: An Initial Update
I’ll try to steelman this comment. Anyone who uses coding tools knows that the output is heavily affected by details of the task you give it. The same model can give you garbage code or genius code for the same problem with slightly different framing. So it’s not necessarily a limitation in the model’s training that causes it to output security bugs. The model might be great at writing secure code, but you need a different harness to elicit that behavior.

Counterargument: just because the problem can be fixed without training, doesn’t mean training isn’t a possible solution.

ashdksnndck··on How to convert between wealth and income tax
In 2020, there was a campaign (prop 15) to legalize increases on the property tax rate in California that only applied to commercial and industrial properties. Intuitively, the constituency for prop 15 should be very similar to a wealth tax on $0.5M+, since the set of people owning commercial/industrial real estate in California are mostly a subset of people with $0.5M+ wealth. What actually happened is there was heavy opposition and prop 15 was narrowly rejected by the voters. Organizations opposing the proposition included the American Legion, the NAACP, and California Beer and Beverage Distributors.

Arguably, there’s a disconnect where the people who lead civic organizations don’t have a great deal in common with the median member. They might be wealthier and generally more plugged in to power structures. They might not support policies that are in the best interest of members they represent, especially people who have a hard time representing themselves.

Anyway, if your goal is to get a policy enacted, it’s not enough for your policy to be theoretically good for the median voter. You need a winning political coalition.

ashdksnndck··on Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket
This is a familiar style in abstracts. Weird as it sounds, it’s normal to have some language implying the reader is a hermit living in a cave. If it sounds like something an AI would say, maybe it’s because models have been trained on academic papers?
ashdksnndck··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
“More blood” seems to imply that somebody has already been hurt or died from Waymo driving into floods, but I don’t think that is the case?
ashdksnndck··on I believe there are entire companies right now under AI psychosis
I have personally had success telling Claude that some AI-written system is too complicated and ask it to rewrite it in a more logical way. This sometimes results in thousands of lines of code being deleted. I give an instruction like that if I see certain red flags, eg:

1) same business logic implemented in two different places, with extra code to sync between them

2) fixing apparently simple bugs results in lots of new code being written

It’s a sign I need to at least temporarily dedicate more effort to overseeing work in that area.

I somewhat agree with the AI psychosis framing of the OP. It takes some taste and discipline to avoid letting things dissolve into complete slop.

ashdksnndck··on The map that keeps Burning Man honest
To be clear, what you’re supposed to do is dump your trash in places you’re allowed to dump it.

If you have a lot of trash, most economical option is often to go to the public transfer stations or landfills in the Reno area (but that only works if they are open).

Also, there are services on the side of the highway that accept trash for $N per bag. Only give your trash to someone if you can see the dumpster it’s going into and the dumpster is not full. There have been scams where people charged to accept trash and then just left it there to get blown around the desert. Alternatively, you could drive your trash all the way home and let your local utilities handle it. But when I’ve had my cargo trailer piled with leaking garbage bags I’ve wanted to get rid of it ASAP.

ashdksnndck··on The map that keeps Burning Man honest
The org has huge amounts of food and water. It won’t be fine dining but nobody is going to starve.
ashdksnndck··on I am worried about Bun
The people in that community have been talking about superintelligence for decades and it’s part of an ideology. It’s not some recently-invented story for headlines.
ashdksnndck··on I am worried about Bun
> Basically the prime bet that they made (that one needs extremely expensive hardware to have useful AI) has already failed.

I thought the prime bet was that the winning lab who reaches takeoff through recursive self improvement will make a galactic superintelligence. Not saying I believe this but the people running the labs do. Under this scenario if you are a few months behind at the pivotal time you might as well not exist at all.

ashdksnndck··on Apple Says Mac Studio and Mac Mini Will Be in Short Supply for Months
The basic 16GB Mac mini is also hard to buy. I bought one used not to save money but because I couldn’t find any store online with it in stock.
ashdksnndck··on Apple Says Mac Studio and Mac Mini Will Be in Short Supply for Months
Mac mini has first-class access to iCloud, photos, iMessage etc. So if you are deep in the Apple ecosystem you might prefer it for that reason. I have a windows gaming desktop that I could use as a server for openclaw/cowork but I realized I simply don’t trust that system enough to give it access to all the personal stuff I’m giving to the AI. I trust Anthropic and Apple. I don’t trust whatever junk is running on my gaming desktop.

If you want to run local models, another advantage is Apple’s unified memory architecture. The biggest Mac mini has 64gb ram and Mac Studio has up to 512gb. Compare this little box to what monster Nvidia gpu system you would have to buy to get the same memory there. And how much your PG&E bill would go up. That doesn’t account for the shortage of basic $600 Mac minis though.

ashdksnndck··on Ramp's Sheets AI Exfiltrates Financials
I suppose Ramp must try to become Excel before Excel becomes Ramp. Don’t want to end up like Slack and have to work for Marc Benioff.
ashdksnndck··on Changes in the system prompt between Claude Opus 4.6 and 4.7
I sometimes prompt with leading questions where I actually want Claude to understand what I’m implying and go ahead and do it. That’s just part of my communication style. I suppose I’m the part of the distribution that ruins things for you.
ashdksnndck··on Author of "Careless People" banned from saying anything negative about Meta
Many of the juicy stories from the book have no supporting evidence other than the claims of the author. Their credibility is all we have to go on here. If someone wrote a message here saying that they were a fly on the wall at the publisher’s office where they had a workshop inventing these stories to sell more books, you’d be right to question their motives.
ashdksnndck··on AI got the blame for the Iran school bombing. The truth is more worrying
Same commenter, 3 hours later, defending bombing of children:

> Parents are solely responsible for bringing their children on stolen land. There were indigenous children living there that were murdered.

ashdksnndck··on AI got the blame for the Iran school bombing. The truth is more worrying
Ok, it sounds the principle here is if any land was stolen in the 20th century the people who live there now aren’t citizens (regardless if they are children or not) and deserve to be bombed? I hope nobody tells the balkans.
ashdksnndck··on AI got the blame for the Iran school bombing. The truth is more worrying
You believe that anyone who lives on stolen land is not a citizen and deserves to be bombed? Americans live on stolen land too, as does much of the rest of the world population.
ashdksnndck··on AI got the blame for the Iran school bombing. The truth is more worrying
Iran and its proxies frequently target civilians. They would make an exception for the US?
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →