746 karma · joined May 16, 2025
If you’re trying to distribute aid resources or something, it would be worthwhile to get an understanding of who is suffering the most. But if someone is just having the normal human experience of feeling sorry when they hear another person is hurt, there is no benefit to intentionally cultivating schadenfreude to shut that down. That’s not an instinct we should encourage in each other.
Ultimately if you have a GPU that can fit X parameter model at Y raw tokens per second, you want the smartest weights. If the frontier closed model is Z% smarter or “more valuable” you would be willing to pay up to Z% margin for the right to use it. Hence whether you are running open or closed model depends on pricing strategy of the frontier labs, also whether the frontier labs are able to diffuse their own models better than open labs can.
Anthropic is indeed trusting Google and other companies they rent compute from. Distilling or stealing the weights would be a contract violation, and would wreck other business relationships. I would be less worried about Google doing this, and more concerned if there is some sketchy neocloud in a van offering suspiciously low pricing.
You want to drive across town. You, only willing to deal in certainties, must decide ahead of time whether you will get in a crash. If you determine won’t get in a crash, you make the drive, pedal to the metal. If you determine you would crash, you stay home.
Me, willing to deal in probabilities, make the drive at the speed I feel reasonable and wear a seatbelt.
I want to believe reasons why this won’t work, but it feels like cope. It would be smart to be prepared for the world where knowledge workers get replaced by AI and also prepared for the world where AI is a bubble that pops.
The goalposts on what neural nets can possibly do have already moved past chess, go, protein folding, coding, poker, math, the Turing test…
Technology. Don’t what to be too specific about where I work.
> Was the team disbanded specifically because of your productivity with AI?
Company has laid many people off, and moved many into new lines of business. I don’t know how management decided who went where. I don’t get the impression I’m a special case or anything.
You might ask: how could this possibly pencil out for my employer? Answer: I’m the only person left on what used to be a team.
Actually I felt since 4.5, it was “good enough” for basic coding (and competing models have reached that level as well). The big improvements since then have been longer-horizon tasks. Giving it a vague description of a problem, then come back hours later and find it did a better job than I would have. And since 5.5 I haven’t encountered any more load bearing seams.
Maybe it’s slow, but I’m not interacting with the models in a live chat anymore for most work. I’m giving them tasks to do async. The limiting factor is actually my bandwidth reviewing their output.
The only lawyer language I can remember was the warning on the ticket that I might die. I don’t think I ever encountered any contracts or similar.
Obviously, if you’re the kind of person who often drives 100+ miles day after day, then L1 charging isn’t going to meet your needs. Those people should budget for an L2 charger at home. Otherwise, upgrading your home charger is a fun optimization for nerds, but not a prerequisite to own an electric car.