5,337 karma · joined April 8, 2013
Contact: - https://spenc.es/contact/
Socials: - bsky.app/profile/spenc.es - github.com/asimpletune - instagram.com/asimpletune
Interests: Books, Education, Open Source, Programming, Travel, Writing
---
FOSS Commenting system for static sites: https://r3ply.com/
Book club: https://b00k.club
Amazon has always been about cash flow over profits. So they don’t really need to make money if that’s not yet one of the goals.
Imagine we trained an AI on everything ever written, but the catch is we’ve restricted the training data to the year, let’s say, 400 BCE and earlier (Ignore the fact that most of what was written then is lost to us now and just pretend that’s not issue for our thought experiment) The AI is also programmed to seek new knowledge based off that starting knowledge.
Also pretend that this AI has an oracle it could talk to that would help the AI simulate experiments. So the AI could ask questions and get answers but only in a way that builds ever so slightly off what it already knows.
Making any progress at all in this experiment and discovering new knowledge is what we’re after and “new knowledge” would be defined as some r that’s demonstrated using some p and q as propositions, where r is neither p or q, and r is also correct in terms of 2025 knowledge.
If the AI, with the aid of the knowledge it started with and the help of the oracle to let it ask questions about the world and build off that knowledge, can ever arrive, or exceed, 2025 knowledge then it’s at least generally intelligent and equal to a human. Although the bar could maybe be even less.
It loses, however, if it never advances, gets stuck in a loop, or in some other sense can’t make progress.
This is intelligence: to proceed from things everyone agrees on and ask questions and formulate assertions that depend on propositions holding true, and in the process demonstrate new things that were not already part of common belief.
I don’t know how this experiment could be done in real life with an LLM for example but this is a story version of what I mean in my original comment.
Do you think think this would work: a little icon that opens a pure html disclosure element with instructions and a design with text laid out sort of in the shape of an email.
“(Text only instructions) Send an email like this:
To: <site>@r3pl.com
Subject: <page_or_comment_url>
Body: <write your comment here, be careful to not accidentally leave your email signature>”
For example, I do this with my website. I receive comments via email (with the sender’s addresses hashed). Each page/comment-list/comment has its own rss feed that people can “subscribe” to. This allows you to get notified when someone responds to a comment you left, or comments on a page. But all notifications are opt-in and require no login because your rss reader is fetching the updates.
Since I’m the moderator of my site, I subscribe to the “all-comments” feed and get notified upon every submission. I then go review the comment and then the site rebuilds. There’s no logins or sign ups. Commenting is just pushing and notifications just pulling.
example https://spenc.es/updates/posts/4513EBDF/
I plan on open sourcing the commenting aspect of this (it’s called https://r3ply.com) so this doesn’t have to be reinvented for each website, but comments are just one part of the whole system:
The web is the platform. RSS provides notifications (pull). Emailing provides a way to post (push) - and moderate - content. Links are for sharing and are always static (never change or break).
The one missing thing is like a “pending comments” cache, for when you occasionally get HN like traffic and need comments to be temporarily displayed immediately. I’m building this now but it’s really optional and would be the only thing in this system that even requires JS or SSR.
This is still limited in what you can do though. For example you can’t use this to forge messages from other people’s Gmail accounts.
> When the message is forwarded, the original DKIM signature usually remains untouched as long as the email content and headers covered by the signature are not modified
It does seem surprising the To: header isn’t one of the headers that is covered by the dkim signature. They should just change how their signing is configured, and email clients should warn when the email is legit but the intended recipient could have been changed.
It’s like trying to explain what one may see hear or feel when their on vacation at an exotic new location by talking about the train tracks that brought you there.
So when you’re reading you’re not downloading packets that add up to some kind of point. Instead, in the absolute best case scenario, you’re simulating the experience, according to the author’s recommended doses, of someone else “acquiring” knowledge. This “someone else” is the nameless reader the book was written for but they are not you.
On the other it's those of us who’ve read in the old school style, for fun, in private that are more convinced of the opposite than anyone. If anything getting summaries might be the worse of both worlds because one might be left with the false impression of understanding where there is none.
Anyways, as was pointed out elsewhere in the thread, even English majors and other serious literary people often have no idea what they’re talking about, which just goes to show that people who were going to read will do it regardless of what else is happening in their life, and people who weren’t going to read will not read even if it’s their major. In this sense, LLMs don’t really change anything. The same person operating the tool will continue to be the same person in either case.
I am truly sorry to even be thinking along these lines, but the alternative mindset has been made practically illegal in the modern world. I would 100% be fine with there being a world library that strives to provide access to any and all information for free, while also aiming to find a fair way to compensate ip owners… technology has removed most of the technical limitations to making this a reality AND I think the net benefit to humanity would be vastly superior to the cartel approach we see today.
For now though that door is closed so instead pay me.