HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

atdrummond

6,272 karma · joined December 9, 2012

e: da.kanish at gmail p: 2179190535

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/atdrummond; my proof: https://keybase.io/atdrummond/sigs/uUXLQDKmo4zwTS8yzPrkHxHh_Yt0cGda_NzDDY46lLw ]

submissionscomments
atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
They don’t need a bed or a room. You can camp quite comfortably throughout the city all year long thanks to the mild weather.

It’s a very different situation than being homeless in cities with more typical seasonal weather patterns; I nearly lost a number of toes due to frostbite when I was homeless in Saint Louis during a major blizzard. San Francisco’s climate and permissive camping policies help absolve a lot of the housing related issues that are involved with being homeless.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
My problem when I was homeless wasn’t that I was poor. My problem was that I would never be able to manage assets properly until I get my mental house in order and started prioritizing things properly.

There are plenty of homeless people who are in a poverty trap, as you describe, but I think it oversimplifies the situation to argue the arrow of causality only goes one direction for all homeless people.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
I didn’t state any numbers. I don’t know. All I have is anecdotes from myself and others who work in this space.

That said, you don’t think even 1 in 9 people being out of staters puts pressure on programs? That as more people see how you can migrate and live far more easily than in Midwestern/East Coast cities, that those numbers won’t increase? That there isn’t a negative psychic impact to homeless people who are actually trying to get out of the system having to live around many others who are content to collect their scrip?

I’m skeptical the number is that low but even if it is, I don’t think it is the non-issue you think it is. I think it reveals quite a lot about the preferences of the homeless who both originate from within, and outside, California.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
I’m not at all against unconditional cash grants. I work for a non-profit that does just that.

What I am against is a totally unstructured program where they hand cash out knowing that 90% of it goes into an open air drug market that they make no attempt to shut down or control.

I’m not arguing for work requirements or time limits. People who are legitimately struggling will fall through the cracks. But I don’t think it is insane or inhumane to require people to work with supportive assistance and be put on a pathway to supportive housing.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
As someone who ended up homeless despite not fitting the typical profile - and has volunteered hundreds (possibly thousands) of hours in the space - you dramatically overstate the case for involuntary homelessness.

There couldn’t be a more significant difference between the homeless populations in places like SF and in other cities in the US with more sensible policies. There’s massively more people in California who are there because they’re voluntarily opting into a lifestyle where all of their capital expenditures are provided by taxpayers and they don’t have to do anything to maintain them other than to remain homeless. Many of these people may seem insane due to their drug use but their mental issues are a result, not a cause; they’re still rational actors responding to a perverse set of incentives.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
From the many hundreds of homeless people I’ve met in SF, there’s been a massive increase of out-of-state movement. That said, they seem to mostly come of their own volition - they realize the combination of the nice weather and massive resources available means they have a pretty maintainable lifestyle.
atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
I don’t think the feds are to blame.

SF and similar CA cities have set up a program that encourages people to move there because it makes being “homeless” an actual possible lifestyle choice. Even an enjoyable one.

atdrummond··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
That’s because Cali’s approach is insane.

They give you hundreds a month in cash grants (some make $1k a month in SF) and require you to make NO alterations to your lifestyle.

I was amazed when living in SF how many of the homeless are not locals. Not even Californians! I myself lived on the streets for a number of years and have dealt with addiction issues. It is absolutely insane how we’ve stopped treating homeless people as humans with potential and aspirations and assume that all they can be is a vacuum for drugs and cash. There’s no other conclusion to reach about how policy makers truly think about this class of people with the way the incentives of these “support” programs are structured.

atdrummond··on Pro-cash movement warns that people could be losing more than they bargained for
I love using cash for Grab in Singapore, seeing as non-residents are capped on how much they can spend on a card weekly (and it is an extremely low amount).
atdrummond··on Pro-cash movement warns that people could be losing more than they bargained for
CC certainly has the capability for extremely granular and personal details. For now, this is usually restricted to hotel stays and airline trips. But the tech exists to encode quite a bit of information about both sides of a transaction and its nature.
atdrummond··on Tokyo’s trash-collecting samurai takes a fun approach to cleanup
Vermont has them as well (or at least did when I lived in Burlington a few years back).
atdrummond··on Why do recipe writers lie about how long it takes to caramelize onions? (2012)
I’ve cooked with him a few times (he gave classes at our family’s cookery shop) and he’s the real deal. Colourful doesn’t begin to describe his actual background, though.
atdrummond··on Poverty Is the 4th Leading Cause of Death in the US, Research Shows
Have you talked to her finance team? Is she part of the major hospital networks you already visit?

If that $600 isn’t your copay but instead the whole cost out-of-network, there is almost certainly a way to get that put on a 12 month payment plan or something similar.

atdrummond··on Poverty Is the 4th Leading Cause of Death in the US, Research Shows
I’m very skeptical of this. I have been homeless in metro America and a huge number of the people I was homeless with (as well as their families) would be no healthier with an additional $10k, $20k, $30k etc., a year.

Activists like to claim that “food deserts” are a supply side phenomena but I promise they exist due to a lack of demand for the food those in suburbs or luxury high-rises prefer. A larger budget just means the vast majority of these people will purchase Pizza Hut instead of Caseys/7-Eleven.

atdrummond··on Poverty Is the 4th Leading Cause of Death in the US, Research Shows
Not sure but none of the medical care I’ve received should actually be expensive. Every medicine I’ve ever been prescribed is generic, every emergency procedure would have been covered by state funds had I not paid.

The fact that very few institutions pursue me at all for these supposedly owed funds tells me none of them are close to teetering on the brink of insolvency.

As someone who as also had healthcare in single payer (the NHS) and presently pays both the government (Estonia) and private insurance (Estonia and US), I have zero problem paying for the general upkeep of the country’s medical system.

I simply refuse to believe that because some life saving care was “out of network” the cost to treat me actually ballooned from thousands to millions. It’s an artifact of a system that’s not designed for uninsured/underinsured participants.

atdrummond··on Poverty Is the 4th Leading Cause of Death in the US, Research Shows
I have an ER bill of $100k+ owed to Stanford for the better part of a decade (amongst an huge number of other more recent bills) and they still see me for regular booked appointments and ERs.

It works less well for specialist offices owned by doctors themselves but I’ve found the large hospitals are disinclined to outright deny service, for a multitude of reasons.

Re: nutrition, is there a clinic outside your normal network that might offer that? You may have to wait longer but I’ve been able to see no-cost specialists in St Louis, Chicago and the Bay Area through various neighborhood clinics. I’m always happy to help too - feel free to drop me an email and I can connect you to some resources in your area.

Most importantly, best of luck with all of this.

atdrummond··on Poverty Is the 4th Leading Cause of Death in the US, Research Shows
Just don’t pay it. I wish I had been told this instead of flushing thousands upon thousands down the toilet in a futile attempt to keep the balance at $0. The system is designed to be adversarial and your best tactic as a patient is to delay, delay, delay and fight every single bill.

I have had seven operations for Crohns, a back surgery, and treatment for ongoing Leukaemia. I have lived in a half dozen different jurisdictions for health care and I’m only alive thanks to the excellence of the US medical system. Doesn’t make the financial side of it any less onerous, sadly.

atdrummond··on A statistical analysis of the work of Bob Ross (2014)
Isn’t the point of Bob Ross the journey of painting, less so than the result? In that sense, it shouldn’t be surprising that originality isn’t a variable he’s optimizing for with his output or television programme.
atdrummond··on I lived in LA and commuted to Berkeley by plane to save on rent
Nope. If you’re doing this regularly you get to know the hacks to get through customs/security/etc quickly. I would always knock off at least two of the following on every trip: museums, restaurants, parks, architectural sites.

Plus I had enough miles and a flexible enough schedule that if I did miss a flight, I’d just book a reward flight home a few days later and make a proper trip out of it.

atdrummond··on I lived in LA and commuted to Berkeley by plane to save on rent
At this time (late 2000s, early 2010s) you could purchase open jaw fares (say ORD-NRT-CGK/CGK-NRT-STL) and between the open jaw/double open jaw and sometimes a fuel dump, get an economy ticket for less than $400. I would generate typically 40k-50k+ miles at a time, meaning I was getting essentially a free economy round trip between US and Europe for every flight.

So basically I was pocketing a minimum of a few hundred bucks in profit per flight and visiting quite a few SE Asian locations, even if it was 8/10/14 hours at a time. I’d work on the flights and I saved up enough miles to have visited over 100 countries by the time I finished university at 23.

EDIT: This is still possible to do but much more difficult now that most US carriers only give mileage based earnings for their partner flights. The golden days of this arbitrage are long gone.

atdrummond··on 12-Year-Old to Graduate from College with Five Degrees
Yes, there are a few states (these schools tend to be public) with such programmes. North Carolina was the pioneer of this model.
atdrummond··on I lived in LA and commuted to Berkeley by plane to save on rent
Yep. I would routinely fly weekend trips from the Midwest to Jakarta on my weekends in college just to get AA miles. The views of FT posters should be taken with a massive grain of salt - we’re not normal.
atdrummond··on 12-Year-Old to Graduate from College with Five Degrees
I had the opportunity to go to college at 10 and again at 13. I’m very glad I went instead to a math and science boarding school (IMSA) instead. The networking alone I was able to do there has been incredible for my adult life. Add on the ability to pursue independent research projects at a level equivalent to grad school and I was able to maximize my intellectual interests while still improving my personal skills and growth as a human being, not just an achievement machine.

If I had gone to uni and graduated with a PhD before 18 I know exactly how I would have ended up. With few friends, low career prospects, and extremely low odds of improving that situation.

atdrummond··on TikTok is now banned in Montana
Given how much distrust there is of DHS/FBI among Trump supporters/GOP base, I’m not sure this is true; especially with many neocons returning to the Democratic Party they came from originally.

Elected GOP officials are a completely different beast from much of their own base.

atdrummond··on Ask HN: Suing Facebook in small claims?
Was your email to legal@ a demand letter? I’ve sent demand letters to that email previously and had my issues, both times, sorted within 48 hours.
atdrummond··on Urban Density and Home Prices
I would argue Eugene’s market is heavily influenced by Nike and UOregon (and recently remote worker flight from downtown Portland) and as such, drawing a line directly from its lack of density to lack of affordability strains credulity for me.

This relationship between density and cost reverses for nearby towns like Springfield even though they share many of Eugene’s characteristics.

atdrummond··on What do historians lose with the decline of local news?
Picking an episode with Adam Conover is a great way to discourage people from listening to the podcast.
atdrummond··on Change my mind: Density increases local but decreases global prices
Bingo
atdrummond··on More Americans are using fake license plates
I was beaten to near death in the Tenderloin near the KFC/Taco Bell on Eddy.

To this day (despite this occurring in December 2021) there have been no arrests made. The police have names, video, witnesses and audio of one participant bragging about the assault.

The former DA had zero interest in prosecuting and the current one is suffocating under the backlog left to them.

This is not how a well functioning city - let alone a high trust one - operates. And it’s not just about statistics - an assault in SF, where it is likely the culprit won’t be arrested and certainly won’t be sent to prison, is significantly more damaging than a similar assault in a properly policed and actually adjudicating municipality.

atdrummond··on More Americans are using fake license plates
There’s absolutely a transition occurring from a country that is still mostly high trust to one that is low trust.

See: the sizable contingent in SF who believes that open air drug markets and rampant violent crime are simply the price one must pay to live in cities.

It doesn’t have to be this way.

← PreviousPage 5 of 32Next →