1,886 karma · joined October 4, 2012
In 1978, TSR produced "Advanced Dungeons & Dragons", the first of many attempts to clean-up and rationalize the game's basic system. It appears to me that this is where they first factored out race (i.e., [human, half-elf, elf,...]) as a separate PC characteristic.
From my cursory search, Tolkien seems to have often referred to dwarves, elves, and whatnot as "peoples" and used the word "race" for different subgroups of those. He at some point wrote (in a letter, not in the stories) that that at least elves & men were able to interbreed on ocassion, and thus were technically the same species. But he was mainly interested in the drama around half-elves, and left open questions about dwarf/elf and hobbit/ent pairings for later explorers...
If you have complaints about how language has evolved, you may contact Richard Stallman and ask him for advice.
I worked in particle physics for years and never once saw an electron. :-)
The geometric Langlands conjectures are a _lot_ more specific, and a lot more focused. They're a big deal, because they're a toy model for the arithmetic Langlands conjectures, which are a generalization of the machinery that proved Fermat's Last Theorem and would give an effective method for dealing with a lot of number theory problems.
Your point stands though: mathematicians are indeed able to cope with path integrals. But several of the models -- qed, Higgs, electroweak, basically everything but qcd -- used in particle theory suffer from a fatal flaw, the Landau pole. They can only exist as incomplete approximations to something else.
Big question for me is why was he doing crimes for such low stakes. It's like seeing a faang engineer rob a 7-11.
Woit himself is working (pretty casually to my eyes) on some mathematical reformulations of the Standard Model. He's not advocating aggressively for these ideas, and I'm pretty sure if you asked him, he'd say there's no evidence that any one idea should dominate the research landscape the way string theory did. None of what exists out there is particularly compelling. (This is one of the reasons people worked so much on strings. It's the best of a bad lot.)