HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aussiesnack

400 karma · joined September 13, 2022

Account abandoned.

Realising the HN 'mod' policy is just an arbitrary application of individual and highly parochial (US/SV) tastes leads ineluctably to total lack of interest in contributing.

submissionscomments
aussiesnack··on How to Annotate Everything
The complexity and medium-specificity of all this just shows that computer-based annotations (considered as semi-permanent artifacts) aren't worth the trouble. Our systems aren't ready for them, and will only become so when we have some kind of interoperable standardised protocols or data formats. Possibly never, but certainly not now.

Until our systems have reached some sort of maturity (not guaranteed of course), consider annotations as transient, and if an ongoing artifact is needed, incorporate them into notes or papers or whatever in your long-term format of choice.

aussiesnack··on Ask HN: LastPass Alternatives
I just don't have the security expertise to make the judgement, and, let's face it, that's true of most of us. Which is of course why you're asking, but you're not guaranteed to get answers from people you know to be any more knowledgeable than you. Somewhere you have to rely on good old human trust.

Finding the info re where to place your trust is tricky. I happen to have been personally recommended 1Password by a genuine security expert who uses it for his family, and that's about the best I can do. I know Agilebits pays for regular 3rd party security audits / pen tests. I guess you could look further into those. I know they're financially sustainable so can afford the expertise they need (which is part of why I think subscription a good model for software like this - I want Agilebits to be on a long-term secure footing). As far as we know publicly, they also have an excellent security record (which LastPass didn't even before the recent breach).

[edit - there's more info here https://support.1password.com/security-assessments/]

aussiesnack··on Green hydrogen is the centerpiece of Australia’s clean-economy growth plan
That would have been a reasonable judgement in the previous decades. Perhaps not so much now. There is a change of mood, and attitudes towards the fossil fuel industry, reflected by this years' change of government. The recent intervention into the gas market simply wouldn't have happened a few years ago.

To be sure the fossil fuel industry is still a danger here and will stop at nothing to curb the growth of renewables. But its political power has taken a hit.

The simple colour code naming of hydrogen production methods is well established enough now for it to be pretty hard for the industry to pass off 'brown' or 'blue' etc as green (though they will try deceptively to market both as 'good enough'). And 'green hydro' is genuinely carbon emission free in both production and use.

aussiesnack··on Green hydrogen is the centerpiece of Australia’s clean-economy growth plan
> I think you're both right. Introducing H2 as a fuel only helps matters if the energy used to produce the H2 is not from fossil fuels, and probably hurts otherwise.

That's "green hydrogen" by definition - ie. what this article & discussion is all about. The gp is simply mistaken, and the coal analogy is ridiculous. Whether green hydro turns out to be economic/scalable is a separate matter.

aussiesnack··on Green hydrogen is the centerpiece of Australia’s clean-economy growth plan
Green hydrogen production creates zero operational carbon emissions. The brown/black coal comparison is silly.
aussiesnack··on Green hydrogen is the centerpiece of Australia’s clean-economy growth plan
"Australia", understood as a nationwide polity attending to its aggregate interests, barely exists. The part of it that decides what happens to resources (ie. the resource owners and client governments) doesn't give a crap about value-adding, because it can make scads of cash from exports without having to deal with much in the way of messy labour relationships, etc.

There are some signs of change however. The resource industry is currently looked at with more suspicion than I've seen here before. Time will tell.

aussiesnack··on Green hydrogen is the centerpiece of Australia’s clean-economy growth plan
No. Clean coal doesn't really exist, whereas green hydrogen does.

Agree however that the messaging around it has great greenwash potential. That was deffo Australia's previous fed government's intent with it.

aussiesnack··on 2022 was the year of Linux on the Desktop?
This is something those "defending" the harder-to-use/learn thing always bring up. As if affordances must always be relative to prior knowledge. But they're not (always) - some things just are harder to use than others (at least relative to a specific meaning of 'use').

Programming languages - you could argue Rust isn't hard to learn, by pretending that everyone claiming it is are just having trouble adjusting from javascript. But that breaks down when you realise the Rust learners finding it hard are actually polyglot programmers who are finding it harder than all the many other languages, in multiple paradigms, they have already successfully learned.

Similar with Linux - I find it harder to 'use' in a certain sense (the sense most people mean - which is getting all the ordinary hardware & software stuff working) than the others. You'll tell me it's unfamiliarity, but it's just not - my first Linux was Slackware on floppies, and I've used it alongside Windows and MacOS now for decades. I choose it for my primary OS for other reasons, but ease of use certainly isn't among them. I still have to fiddle more with it .

aussiesnack··on 2022 was the year of Linux on the Desktop?
I use Linux (Fedora in my case) as my primary (actually sole non-mobile right now) OS, with software dev as my focus. Its the best for my purpose, though I've used both MacOS and Windows extensively so I have a reasonable awareness of the relative tradeoffs.

I do find the Linux community often insufferable though. Also often extremely helpful however. I guess communities also have their tradeoffs.

aussiesnack··on 2022 was the year of Linux on the Desktop?
Apologies if that seemed directed at you personally, which wasn't my intent. Attribute it to HN trigger-finger.

It is a general and widespread phenomenon though that anyone who has been less than positive towards Linux on HN or anywhere will recognise. I don't think it reflects animosity towards users of mainstream OS's so much as defensiveness, particularly from strongly self-identified Linux advocates. Which is all a bit daft, because it's (a) perfectly obvious that Linux has plenty of problems (how could something as vast as an OS not?), and (b) that doesn't make it any less the clear choice for some classes of user (like myself).

aussiesnack··on 2022 was the year of Linux on the Desktop?
The apparently innocent "sharing" of positive experiences - so sweet! so nice! - is from Linux self-identifiers all too often a very crude backhanded "you're wrong about the problems you claim to have with Linux, and if you're not wrong, then you're at least thick or lazy".
aussiesnack··on 2022 was the year of Linux on the Desktop?
True and annoying. Writing as a f/t Linux user (Fedora Workstation on a laptop), and I appreciate where it shines enough to choose its particular set of tradeoffs for myself. But there's no doubt Linux users can be annoyingly obdurate about its deficiencies. Similar things crop up in tech circles all the time - eg. Rust programmers informing people having trouble learning Rust that there's nothing hard about it.
aussiesnack··on On why I gave up drinking in my early twenties
Can't argue with that.
aussiesnack··on On why I gave up drinking in my early twenties
I'm a drinker in principle, as in not being a teetotaller, but am just not attracted to drink very often. I probably have less than a bottle of wine and half a dozen beers a year. Same with drugs. I've tried most of the common ones, including those considered very addictive, but was never tempted to make a habit of any of them. Likewise food - I'm not an over eater and am in my late '50s the same weight I was 3 decades ago (though a little fitter since taking up running, which along with other sporty activities I abjured with exaggerated horror in my youth).

None of this has taken the slightest effort or even any consideration to be honest. Neither is this easy sobriety a consequence of some sort of well-managed successful life (au contraire - it's a mess).

Perhaps some of us just have naturally temperate temperaments.

aussiesnack··on Show HN: Obsidian Canvas – An infinite space for your ideas
It's the messianic fake novelty and loathsome invented marketing terminology that I'm objecting to. You can unfussily make notes, using your own emergent organisation exactly like people have done for centuries at least. Tech can add searching and organisational niceties, and it makes sense to use them. Obsidian is good at this (I use it).

Or, alternatively, you can do exactly the same thing and get terribly zealous about it as a grift, or a way to mask the fact that your notes are all about notetaking systems and just add nothing to the sum of human (or even your own) capability.

I'm not arguing against the activity of taking notes, nor working with different representations and arrangements of them to discover what emerges, nor against note-taking software, just all the timewasting blather that goes with it. "Second brain" (probably TM'd somewhere) is by the way only a dull grey businessy echo of Andy Clark's (much more interesting) 'extended mind' theme.

aussiesnack··on Freeform: a new app designed for creative collaboration
The freeform canvas was what made Microsoft Onenote seem so compelling to start with, at least potentially. They stuffed it up of course. But I was always surprised other apps didn't pick up that particular baton.
aussiesnack··on Show HN: Obsidian Canvas – An infinite space for your ideas
The value of whatever style of note-taking suits your work and personal style has been well understood for centuries. All the productivity piffle has added nothing to it, though it has earned a few bucks from book sales, youtube ads, and merch.
aussiesnack··on Show HN: Obsidian Canvas – An infinite space for your ideas
It's decent note-taking software with useful features and a storage medium that's currently in favour. If you have a use for such a thing, it's one of the best options available right now.

But that's all. You can forget all the "second brain"/zettelkasten stuff. It's just marketing gumpf used to build careers prattling about notetaking methods (dressed up as something fancier).

aussiesnack··on Show HN: Obsidian Canvas – An infinite space for your ideas
Sure - it's a long time since I used it so I'll take your word for that. But it demonstrates the principle.
aussiesnack··on Ask HN: Programs that saved you 100 hours? (2022 edition)
When I used IntelliJ, for the languages it understood best (then Java and Kotlin), it felt very little like editing text. The sense was much more like interacting directly with an AST. I rarely had to use standard 'text' editing features (oriented around word/sentence/para entities). This was an emergent affordance from all the many language-oriented facilities (all available via keyboard shortcuts) offered, rather than one specific feature.

I actually don't use IntelliJ now for reasons not germane here. I'm on neovim, mostly with Rust and javascript/typescript). This is great in many ways but the ergonomics of editing, even with LSP integration, are much more like editing text, which is more distant from my mental model of the code.

aussiesnack··on Show HN: Obsidian Canvas – An infinite space for your ideas
I haven't tried any of the community plugins - if any of them come close to what you want, why not file issues outlining what needs improving? I've only used Obsidian tangentially, but from 10000ft it does look like the app tends to incorporate the best plugin ideas over time, so this route might get what you want into the app eventually.

Emacs org-mode does demonstrate that it is possible to create a usable interface for text-mode tables.

aussiesnack··on Evidence that the evolution of mammals began in the Southern Hemisphere
Peer review doesn't include tests of nationalism, nor biographical investigations. Bias is neither ignored by following the evidence (which is precisely what can indicate it!), nor exposed by wild claims about the nationalism of non-default US/Euro scientists.
aussiesnack··on Evidence that the evolution of mammals began in the Southern Hemisphere
My comment was satire, which is all the topic deserves because it's ludicrous. The 'suspicion' you speak of has nothing to do with assessing scientific claims. They stand alone on the evidence presented, and as later tested against competing claims. Later, if the claims don't stand up, someone may well when writing fiction/biography/history/journalism choose to use the writers' background as part of their plot. But it's all irrelevant to science qua science.

The assessing motivations game has no role to play here, and no destination for that matter. You could spend the next millennium trying to determine whether this particular piece of research was published in an Australian journal for nationalistic reasons (and whose reasons?) vs whether it just so happened that a piece of Australian research got published in Australian journals (gosh!) vs whether the putative 'research must be reviewed by peers from outside the region' rule (created in an HN thread) was equally applied to default US and EU based researchers. None of it would illuminate the truth or otherwise of the proposed idea.

aussiesnack··on Evidence that the evolution of mammals began in the Southern Hemisphere
Our biggest animal dangers here are humans, horses, and cows. In that order.
aussiesnack··on Evidence that the evolution of mammals began in the Southern Hemisphere
So I take it you'd be equally suspicious of all the prior work from the Northern Hemisphere that claimed mammalian origins to be there? I guess that's reasonable. Western Europeans and North Americans are the default humans/scientists after all, and are completely objective about their central place in everything, even pre-human evolution.
aussiesnack··on Ask HN: Anyone tired of everything being a subscription now?
I don't have many subscriptions (most of my software is FOSS, and I don't do media streaming), but the few I have I'm quite happy about. None of them are corporate behemoths, they create quality products that I like to use, as far as I can see from the outside they're decent companies that treat their employees well. I quite enjoy the fact that I can make a small contribution to these products/companies continuing to be sustainable.

And I'm at the extreme end of anti-capitalism. I'd prefer to see everything employee/citizen-owned. But in the world we actually live in today, I see no inherent problem with subscriptions.

There can be contingent problems. I won't, for example, subscribe to any music streaming services because they give musicians an unfair deal. But that's little to do with subscriptions per se.

aussiesnack··on Paul Graham is leaving Twitter for now
Perhaps not your intent, but you have hit on the entire social media mindset, distilled.

TV debate long ago decided that every complex human concern can be profitably reduced to a crass binary which can be argued about in front of a camera for the audience's thumbs up or down.

Social media democratised this decerebrate approach. A thumbs up or down from your tribe. Mastodon, Post.news et al only replicate the Twitter model.

It doesn't matter which platform PG, or anyone else, is on. They're all worthless distraction. Fiddling while Rome burns etc.

aussiesnack··on Request for Startups: Climate Tech
Yes and no. Sure, tech solutions are superficial and can only ever be partially successful. But we know how to build tech. We do not know how to manage 8 billion people stuffed into a couple of hundred unruly 'sovereign' nations. Certainly not to the extent necessary to hold back trivial desires created by corporations/marketing, which now form the core of most world cultures.

I have no idea whether or not it's possible to create a viable network of global human cultures which can constrain themselves to live as part of reality (what some call 'nature'), but I'm pretty sure if it is, it's no less than a century away. Probably longer. And we don't have that much time to stop fouling the nest.

I see climate change tech as a stopgap. Without it (BAU), or with fantasies of immediate revolutionary change, we're fucked. Tech might help keep society viable long enough to create what's really needed, in a century, or two, or three.

aussiesnack··on Request for Startups: Climate Tech
What's odd about that? Capitalism, of which VC is the pointy end, is unapologetically nihilistic.
aussiesnack··on Ask HN: Can I make an entire web with web assembly and rust at this point?
You can. There are an increasing (if not bewildering) number of Rust-based web frameworks. Some even now come with fine-grained reactivity (a la Svelte, Solid et al) and server-side rendering of components. Chris Biscardi covers a range of them in this yt playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWtPciJ1UMuBpRg1KbXqx...

Whether you should or not I have no idea. I've put out a few appeals in Rust circles for examples of substantial real world use, but haven't come up with anything that convincing. It looks to me like it's early days yet, with many competing projects exploring the design space, but none being truly established.

I could be wrong and maybe there are some using these frameworks for real work. But it all smells a bit experimental to me.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →