HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

avianlyric

7,497 karma · joined March 4, 2016

submissionscomments
avianlyric··on Tokenomics: Quantifying Where Tokens Are Used in Agentic Software Engineering
Pricing on SToA models probably won’t fall, there’s no reason for the frontier labs to lower their prices.

But we’re seeing lots of open weight models that are either pretty close to SToA, or more importantly, perfectly capable of doing all the low level token insensitive grunt work when writing code. Pairing them with SToA models for long horizon task management, and you’ve got a very cost effective system.

The frontier labs have put little effort into cost efficient inference, they don’t need to, but folks like DeepSeek clearly are, and have achieved some impressive cost improvements. Given DeepSeeks models give you 70% of the capabilities for 30% of the cost, expect people to start moving lots of workloads to providers that provide cheap inference for open models, and huge competition to appear to provide that cheap inference. It’s truly commodity LLM inference.

In turn expect more companies to focus on building inferences efficient models, because someone that can build a model that provides 70% of SToA capabilities for 10% of the token cost, immediately eats up huge amounts of the available inference market.

Another factor in all this, is it’s becoming increasingly clear that building custom agents/workflows for LLM to operate in, is required to get the best out of these models. That means people are implicitly building the infra needed to use multiple model types and evaluate workflow performance end-to-end. Which in turn means they have everything they need to plugin in future, cheaper, inference providers and quickly evaluate if they can change their model provider.

avianlyric··on OpenAI frontier models and Codex are now available on AWS
Pace of data creation ignores the fact that the majority of the big gains in LLM “intelligence” has come from scraping and feeding in the huge amount of public data that already exists.

Unless we’re producing data on the order of an entire new internet every couple of years, then it’s hard to see how LLMs can achieve further huge leaps in capability compared to training on effectively 0% of the internet vs 100% of the internet.

avianlyric··on OpenAI frontier models and Codex are now available on AWS
Contractual obligation, external third party audits, and above all, AWS’s reputation.

AWS isn’t going to risk their reputation, and thus huge chunks of their business, just so a few AI labs can get some extra training data. That’s an insane risk with zero upside for AWS. AWS knows full well they will make insane quantities of cash without breaking legal contracts with companies who pay them billions each year for infra.

avianlyric··on BambuStudio has been violating PrusaSlicer AGPL license since their fork
You’re making the assumption that customer product prototypes are the only prototypes produced by 3D printers.

There’s plenty of other more valuable things that are prototyped using 3D printers, such as high end commercial machines, or components that go into those machines.

I suspect that getting hold of STLs from US defence manufacturers would be extremely valuable. Why bother trying to capture a copy of your enemies technology, when they’ll happy just send you all the prototype STLs. Even if it’s not defence, don’t you think access to prototype components from EUV machines from ASML would be crazy valuable to Chinese companies trying to close the gap between Chinese and Western chip fabrication technologies?

avianlyric··on Higher usage limits for Claude and a compute deal with SpaceX
Proper utility scale gas generators come with proper utility scale pollution controls to make sure nasties like fine particulate and NO is filtered or properly reduced into some much less harmful to human health.

CO2 is bad for us long term. But there are plenty of other nasty combustion products that are extremely bad for humans in the short term. Which is why we have pollution and air quality regulations.

Portable generators don’t meet any of the stronger requirements that utility scale systems have to meet, because it’s assumed they’re only operated in small numbers for short periods of time. They’re not designed to safe to operate in large numbers over long periods of time in the same place. For that you need proper pollution controls

avianlyric··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
They have done. The Three Mile Island accident happened when it was being operated by Navy vets [1]. Simple training isn’t enough.

During the investigation of the accident the Admiral that built and ran the Navy nuclear program was asked how the Navy had managed to operate accident free, and what others could learn. This was his response:

> Over the years, many people have asked me how I run the Naval Reactors Program, so that they might find some benefit for their own work. I am always chagrined at the tendency of people to expect that I have a simple, easy gimmick that makes my program function. Any successful program functions as an integrated whole of many factors. Trying to select one aspect as the key one will not work. Each element depends on all the others.

So recreating that accident free operating environment requires a lot more than just training. It would require wholesale adoption of the Navy’s approach across the entire industry. Which probably doesn’t scale very well. Not to mention the Navy operates much smaller nuclear reactors compared to utility scale reactors, and has extremely easy access to lots of cooling water, which probably gives them a little more wiggle room when dealing unexpected reactor behaviour.

[1] https://jackdevanney.substack.com/p/tmi-lessons-what-was-lea...

avianlyric··on I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it
It’s always been true. If you want to build a limited distribution app Apple has mechanisms for private distribution which is used by companies for internal apps etc

They don’t want the App Store filled with app that can’t be used by the vast majority of people that might see and download it.

avianlyric··on Apple fixes bug that cops used to extract deleted chat messages from iPhones
Because it’s a pain in the arse to design, manufacture and build a specialist device just for use in your stores.

I’m sure Apple could do everything that box does and more. But why bother designing, building and manufacturing your own specialist device when someone else already sells a perfectly good tool that does the job.

Don’t forget this is for use in a retail store by people who will have been given 5mins training on how to use the device. You want something that just requires a person to plug two phones in and hit a big “go” button. And it needs to work 99% of the time with zero messing around.

avianlyric··on Apple fixes bug that cops used to extract deleted chat messages from iPhones
You can implement either approach on iOS as well.

But if you have strong end-to-end encryption for messages, then you don’t have to care about the transport anymore, you assume they’re all compromised. At that point you might as well use the push notification system as your transport, given both OSs allow applications to intercept the push notification locally and decrypt it before it’s displayed to the user.

avianlyric··on Apple fixes bug that cops used to extract deleted chat messages from iPhones
Through an OS service yes, but not a hosted backend service. Obviously that service has store the notification in plaintext (although everything on an iPhone is encrypted at rest, but notification crypto keys have to stay in active memory for the lock screen to work), otherwise it wouldn’t be able to display the notification text.

Apple support applications sending encrypted notifications, where the OS launches the app the decrypt the notification body locally and pass it back to the OS for display.

avianlyric··on The world in which IPv6 was a good design (2017)
Isn’t the whole point that when the client roams it opens a brand new L3 connection to the server, then sends over L4 packets to reconnect the L4 session over the new L3 link. Thus keeping L4 session state separate from L3 routing mechanics.

As for L3 packets going into the void. Yeah they’re gonna get lost, can’t be helped. But the server also isn’t going to get any L4 acks for those packets. So when a new L3 connection is created, and the L4 session recovered, the lost packet just get replayed over the new L3 connection.

avianlyric··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
Why are you comparing a single phone manufacturers market position to the market position of an entire OS?

iOS vs Android isn’t relevant when discussing hardware. It’s Apple vs Samsung etc. iOS doesn’t need majority market ownership for Apple to completely dominate their hardware competitors in a market.

avianlyric··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
But they’re still the largest individual player in just about every market they’re in. So there’s clearly a strong demand for iPhones.
avianlyric··on We have a 99% email reputation, but Gmail disagrees
You don’t want people reminding you that their about to charge you money and give you an opportunity to cancel the subscription?

Surely that’s a lot less hassle for all involved than having to get your bank to issue chargebacks on subscription renewals you forgot about?

avianlyric··on JVM Options Explorer
gofmt isn’t really comparable to the JVM, but it is a really strong expression of the opinionated tooling GoLang has.

While gofmt is “just” a formatting tool. The interesting part is that go code that doesn’t follow the go formatting standard is rejected by the go compiler. So not only does gofmt not have knobs, you can’t even fork it to add knobs, because the rest of the go ecosystem will outright reject code formatted in any other way.

It’s a rather extreme approach to opinionated tooling. But you can’t argue with the results, nobody writing go on any project ever worries about code formatting.

avianlyric··on France pulls last gold held in US
Gold is very dense. 10 Tonnes of gold takes up less than a cubic meter of volume.

Moving tonnes of gold doesn’t look like huge pallets of gold with tarps over them like a James Bond movie. It looks like a handful of supply crates.

I imagine that the French Navy visits NY ports of a regular basis. Pretty normal for Navy’s to sail into the ports of allies during peace time. There would be nothing unusual about a French Navy vessel sailing into NY loading up with some supplies and leaving.

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=10tonnes+of+gold

avianlyric··on Why the US Navy won't blast the Iranians and 'open' Strait of Hormuz
If a carrier can launch fields of drones and missiles, then whatever land mass your attacking can launch more, given they obviously have a lot more space.

The change in dynamic here isn’t a function of carriers or their abilities. It’s a change in the cost of drones and missiles. The cost of a “good enough” drone and missile is now so low that opponents of the US can simply build the thing faster than the US can build and deliver them. In effect the technological advantage is that carriers represented for a long time has been completely neutralised.

avianlyric··on Thoughts on slowing the fuck down
> Bridges are partly a design problem but mainly a build problem.

I think this vastly underestimates how much of the build problem is actually a design problem.

If you want to build a bridge, the fact one already exists nearby covering a similar span is almost meaningless. Engineering is about designing things while using the minimal amount of raw resources possible (because cost of design is lower than the cost of materials). Which means that bridge in the other town is designed only within its local context. What are the properties of the ground it's built on? What local building materials exist? Where local can be as small as only a few miles, because moving vast quantities of material of long distances is really expensive. What specific traffic patterns and loadings it is built for? What time and access constraints existed when it was built?

If you just copied the design of a bridge from a different town, even one only a few miles up the road, you would more than likely end up with a design that either won't stand up in your local context, or simply can't be built. Maybe the other town had plenty of space next to the location of the bridge, making it trivial to bring in heavy equipment and use cranes to move huge pre-fabbed blocks of concrete, but your town doesn't. Or maybe the local ground conditions aren't as stable, and the other towns design has the wrong type of foundation resulting in your new bridge collapsing after a few years.

Engineering in other disciplines don't have the luxury of building for a very uniform, tightly controlled target environment where it's safe to make assumptions that common building blocks will "just work" without issue. As a result engineering is entirely a design problem, i.e. how do you design something that can actually be built? The building part is easy, there's a reason construction contractors get paid comparatively little compared to the engineers and architects that design what they're building.

avianlyric··on The next generation of electricity is almost here
> I mean, how many lights and how many refrigerators could one house possibly have?

Once-upon-a-time a "bright" bulb consumed 80W of power. Today we achieve the same light output with 8W of LEDs, and order of magnitude decrease in power consumption. Multiply that by every home, every street light, every office build, every airport, hospital and stadium. That kinda improvement in efficiency adds up very quickly.

Sure plenty of developed countries have deindustrialised, but most the heavy industry that been lost was lost before mass electrification. Arc furnaces, large scale aluminium production etc. These are all pretty modern technologies. If you look at the UK the only major steel foundry left is a gas fired blast furnace, we basically have zero arc furnaces, because we deindustrialised before the damn things we're being used for large scale steel production.

Electrification of heavy industry is a surprisingly recent trend, and is only really happening in countries that aren't deindustrialising, and view continual process improvement in heavy industry as an important long term activity.

avianlyric··on The next generation of electricity is almost here
Until recently total electrical power consumption in developed nations has been practically stalled for decades, despite continued growth in economic output, and greater demand for electricity consuming devices. Mostly because as the usage of electricity has gone up, it’s been entirely offset by endless improvements in efficiency.

So you have two opposed forces in action. Rapidly increasing demand for electricity consuming services, and rapidly increasing efficiency of those services. It also helps that a lot of that additional demand is only possible due to increased efficiency. Imagine if every phone was as power inefficient as an old Pentium 4. They would last about 30 mins and burn your hands in the process.

Even with datacentres and AI, there is huge economic pressure to increase the efficiency of the devices involved, and there’s been no slow down in year-on-year increases of compute/W, even if the total amount compute per chip isn’t as rapid as it used to be.

avianlyric··on iPhone 17 Pro Demonstrated Running a 400B LLM
You also have the problem that if the both the ultimate answer to life the universe and everything, and the ultimate question to life the universe and everything, are know at the same time in the same universe. The universe is spontaneously replaced with a slightly more absurd universe to ensure that both the question and answer become meaningless.

To quote the message from the universes creators to its creation “We apologise for the inconvenience”. Does seem to sum up Douglas Adam’s views on absurdity of life.

avianlyric··on Ireland shuts last coal plant, becomes 15th coal-free country in Europe (2025)
Oh no somebody told China about the future. That’s why they sell everyone cheap PV panels, and are now building out the equivalent of the entire UKs existing solar and wind capacity every year. Plus they’re getting faster.

In 20 years time China gonna be entirely powered by renewables while we’re still having this silly argument about what the future is going to look like.

avianlyric··on Ireland shuts last coal plant, becomes 15th coal-free country in Europe (2025)
How is coal cheaper and easier than buying and deploying solar panels and batteries. Both of which require basically zero additional infrastructure to deploy.

Last I checked mining and transporting coal required quite a lot of heavy industry equipment to do even vaguely economically.

If coal was cheaper and easier than other sources of energy, then the US would be building more coal power plants. But even with the Trump administration placing its weighty thumb on the scale to try and “save coal”. Coal plants are still being shutdown due to simple economics.

If existing plants can compete with renewables, to hard to understand how adding the cost of building new plants is going to change that.

avianlyric··on Ireland shuts last coal plant, becomes 15th coal-free country in Europe (2025)
Yes, many of which are expected to never actually be used. Accidental result of how China does its provence based infra funding.

Right now China is building out more solar and wind per year than than the entire total deployed solar and wind in the entire UK, and they’re only getting fast. Their ability build renewables now vastly outstrips their historical coal buildout and their rising energy demands. They’re well on their way to achieving net zero far faster than anyone thought was possible.

avianlyric··on MacBook Neo
The large iPad Pros have the advantage of using OLED displays rather than an LCD. Give the iPad screen an automatic power advantage because all of the light generated by the screen is emitted at the user, unlike an LCD where a substantial chunk of the LCD backlight is absorbed by the LCD layer.
avianlyric··on MacBook Neo
It basically is an iPhone or iPad, but with a keyboard. It’s really only the display that’s gonna consume significantly more power than its iPhone/iPad equivalent.
avianlyric··on The EU moves to kill infinite scrolling
> You are in a great place in your life, if your most significant problem is caused by not liking a stupid meme and a breakfast photo your friends posted on a random Tuesday...

Or you’re in a terrible place in your life, and the small endorphin release from liking stupid memes and breakfast photos is how you try and escape from terrible things that haunt you day-to-day.

avianlyric··on A brief history of barbed wire fence telephone networks (2024)
There’s nothing inherently deadly about AC nor anything inherently safe about DC. If there’s enough voltage available to drive current through your body, then electricity is deadly regardless of if it’s AC or DC.

In general AC tends to be a little safer than DC, because the voltage is constantly reversing, which means it’s constantly passing through 0V, creating moments where you don’t have current driving through your body and forcing all your muscles to contract. Those 0V crossings create moments where you can let go of whatever is electrocuting you. DC on the other hand has no such 0 crossings, if there’s enough voltage there to drive current through you, then all your muscles will be stuck contracting until either the power is turned off, or until they’re all so fried they’re not physically capable of contracting anymore.

avianlyric··on Europe's $24T Breakup with Visa and Mastercard Has Begun
> Because mastercard/visa don't personally bear any risk they are very happy to process refunds and chargebacks in the customer's favor.

That’s not how chargebacks and refunds work. Mastercard and Visa are not involved in the vast majority of disputes at all, it’s entirely handled by the card issuer and card acquirer. Mastercard/Visa only get involved in cases where network party has broken one of the technical rules of the network. For cases of missing or faulty goods etc, Mastercard/Visa do nothing except transport the messages used by bank/merchant to litigate the dispute.

When Mastercard/Visa are forced to step in and make an arbitration decision, they charge a hefty fee (hundreds of dollars) to the losing side to do so. So they have no issue with people raising disputes, it makes them a lot of money.

> Amex can see what I purchase but knows very little about me otherwise. I like this separation, and I like that it's hard for the government to get a complete picture of my financial affairs.

This is naive, all banks and credit card issuers are required by law to perform KYC (Know Your Customer) to ensure they know exactly who they’re transacting with. It’s trivial for the state to buildup a complete image of your financial situation by sending a small number of court orders to banks and financial entities to turn over all their records on you. That’s ignoring the automated tax reporting that banks also have to do.

avianlyric··on Europe's $24T Breakup with Visa and Mastercard Has Begun
Mastercard and Visa also use immediate settlement models and basically always have done. The settlement buffer between end parties is created entirely by entities that are all basically banks.

There’s nothing special about Mastercard and Visa rails that prevents you recreating all the functionality that the broader ecosystem provides, without Visa and Mastercard. Hell all of that functionality could be provided by exactly the same companies and banks that provide it for Visa and Mastercard networks.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →