HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

axguscbklp

252 karma · joined January 16, 2020

submissionscomments
axguscbklp··on Electrons May Well Be Conscious
Discussions of consciousness tend to frustrate me a bit. So many otherwise smart people, for some reason, simply do not understand the hard problem of consciousness. They'll say things like "well, consciousness is just a given pattern of physical stuff" but they do not realize what to me is an obvious objection - to say that consciousness is equivalent to a given pattern of physical stuff does not explain why that pattern of physical stuff is not simply present without any consciousness associated with it. I can imagine a being that is physically identical to a human in every way, but is not conscious - there is no reason to think that intelligent behavior requires consciousness. So what is the difference between such a being and a conscious human, if the two are physically identical?
axguscbklp··on The Interruptible Programmer (2010)
>I think the style in which I practiced my craft for the first 15 years of my career was much the same as every other enthusiastic developer: you put a ton of hours in. 12-16+ hour days, evening and weekend coding marathons, pizza in the keyboard, crunch times, 3am debugging sessions where you just can’t go to bed because you can feel the source of that bug just beyond your fingertips, dammit, desperate last-minute sprints to deadlines where you manage to slot that last piece in, Jack Bauer-like, just before the world goes to hell.

Uhh... does anyone other than maybe 1 in 100 developers actually do this? I think that many more than 1 in 100 developers are enthusiastic... but I doubt, whether they are enthusiastic or not, that significantly more than 1 in 100 developers or so act like the above. If I'm going to work 12-16+ hour days, I'd better either be in love with the company or have a good reason to expect that I could cash out and be rich as fuck at some point.

axguscbklp··on Second-Guessing the Modern Web
React, Redux, Webpack, 90% line coverage testing requirements...

I understand intellectually, sort of, kind of, often not really..., why those things came to be... but for fuck's sake, they have really sucked the joy out of my web development.

It feels so much more free and fun to just sit down and hack some vanilla HTML/CSS/JS.

The modern web development stack has attained "bondage and discipline" levels rivaling those old Java enterprise edition stereotypes.

axguscbklp··on Uber loses $2.9B, offloads bike and scooter business
Here's what I don't get about the robotaxi stuff - did the company and the investors ever actually believe that the robotaxi stuff was even close to viable, or was it just a scam all along? To me it seems obvious that fully self-driving cars are almost certainly, at best, several decades away - and, if it turns out that fully self-driving technology really does require artificial general intelligence, it's quite plausible that humanity actually will never build fully self-driving cars. This isn't something that I've just realized recently - I've thought for several years now that full self-driving is almost certainly at best quite far away. How did it happen that thousands and thousands of rather smart people fell for the delusion that there was any realistic chance of implementing full self-driving any time soon? Of course it's not just Uber in question, it's also Tesla, Waymo, and so on.
axguscbklp··on Eerie emptiness of ERs worries doctors: where are the heart attacks and strokes?
Thanks for the explanation. Yes, that makes sense. I originally, for some reason, thought that you were saying that the government could pay the entire country to stay home indefinitely - on re-reading your comment, I see that this is a rather silly misreading on my part of what you actually wrote.
axguscbklp··on Eerie emptiness of ERs worries doctors: where are the heart attacks and strokes?
>the government could (if it were so inclined) pay people to stay home indefinitely

I'm a bit skeptical, and would be even if instead of "indefinitely" we were just talking about a couple of years. I'm not necessarily disagreeing, but I'm curious about how the math would work out, in your opinion.

axguscbklp··on I got my first $50/mo customer
I wonder how many people in this thread are upset by Cyberleads selling people's emails and GitGardener making people's Githubs look better... but at the same time commit piracy all the time and make all sorts of excuses for it.
axguscbklp··on The Inevitable Coronavirus Censorship Crisis
You have a point but to be fair, maybe he genuinely changed his views as he saw the "sector of society we used to describe as liberal America" develop, over the last few years, a larger and larger subset that can fairly be described as a hysterical cult.

This last decade has, it seems to me, seen quite a rise in hysterical cultism on both major sides of the American political spectrum.

axguscbklp··on Urbit OS 1
>Does "socialism" ever mean "free-market capitalism"?

I would say no.

>It often seems that libertarians are on the receiving end of the "Nazi" label because they object to socialism or government intervention in markets.

I think this happens mainly for three reasons. 1) Some people support socialism so furiously that they genuinely think pretty much everyone who opposes socialism is part of the same group of "reactionaries", etc. 2) Some people dislike libertarians and try to smear them by calling them Nazis. 3) A certain subset of self-identified libertarians has had, historically, and continues to have now, an involvement with populist conservatism and with right-wing regimes such as Pinochet's. There is also a subset of self-identified libertarians who promote racism, a subset who lean socially conservative, etc.

Some self-proclaimed libertarians oppose socialism so furiously that they view right-wing dictatorship as being a better option. Personally, I'd say that people like that are not libertarians at all, but they continue to self-identify as libertarians nonetheless.

axguscbklp··on Tesla Q1 2020 Update
The polls do seem to show that the lockdowns are popular, but I feel like I have detected a real shifting of sentiment on social media recently. I think that my sample does reflect something about reality since I even have noticed the shift on places that just a few weeks ago were staunchly pro-lockdown.

I do not know how to reconcile my experience with the polls, though.

axguscbklp··on Urbit OS 1
I agree that calling Nazism left-wing is a misrepresentation, and it's one that is almost always used in bad faith. However, if by "socialism" we mean "a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole", then it's fair to call fascism a combination of nationalism and socialism. As far as I understand, Mussolini started out as a socialist, but a bit later in life he rejected international socialism and instead embraced the combination of a form of socialism (in the sense given above) with nationalism. Fascism is not socialism, but it does incorporate socialist elements and was influenced by the socialist movement.

Now, if one insists that the term "socialism" be restricted to political and economic systems that do away with (or try to do away with) hierarchy then yes, fascism is not socialist, since fascism explicitly values hierarchy.

So basically, it depends on what one means by "socialism".

axguscbklp··on Tesla Q1 2020 Update
Musk might just be venting on Twitter, as another commenter has suggested, but one way or another these tweets might turn out to benefit him. From what I can tell based on both personal and online interactions, it seems to me that U.S. public sentiment has been shifting against the lockdowns recently - and not just among some fringe protester groups, but among all kinds of demographically and ideologically different groups. Musk's tweets might appeal to those people and make him more popular. I'm no fan of, for example, Musk's lies about self-driving technology being just around the corner. But say what you will about Musk, he has a powerful talent when it comes to publicity.
axguscbklp··on YouTube removed a viral video of two doctors calling for an end to quarantine
That sounds pretty plausible to me as another explanation.
axguscbklp··on YouTube removed a viral video of two doctors calling for an end to quarantine
I wonder why Google's decision-makers decided to censor stuff that doesn't follow WHO guidelines. Is it because they actually care about the mass of the population? Is it because they want to minimize the economic damage caused by the crisis? Is it because they're scared to get sick themselves? Is it because they want to avoid possible legal liability? Is it due to political pressure on them? Is it because they want to exploit the crisis for reasons of politics and social engineering? Some combination of the above?
axguscbklp··on Millions of Americans can't afford food, rent and other basics, report finds
Not sure about that. From what I understand, the German economy was recovering nicely and the Nazis were doing poorly in elections in the late 1920s. Then the Great Depression hit.

Nazi share of the vote in German federal elections from 1924 to the Nazi seizure of power in 1933:

  May 1924 -   6.5%
  Dec 1924 -   3.0%
  May 1928 -   2.6%
  Sep 1930 - 18.25%
  Jul 1932 - 37.27%
  Nov 1932 - 33.09%
axguscbklp··on Off road, but not offline: How simulation helps advance Waymo Driver
>how many years of experience is needed to drive on public roads without supervision

If, as I strongly suspect, full self-driving requires artificial general intelligence, Waymo's algorithms will not get there no matter how long they run simulations or even how many real road tests they do.

axguscbklp··on Off road, but not offline: How simulation helps advance Waymo Driver
My prediction is that self-driving cars will not dominate the public roads until sometime between 40 years from now and never.
axguscbklp··on Off road, but not offline: How simulation helps advance Waymo Driver
Waymo's simulators are doing 100 years of playing video games per day. They're not doing any driving.
axguscbklp··on Some overwhelmed parents are abandoning at-home schooling
I think this might be a great thing for those kids. They'll actually get to experience reality outside of the rat race for a bit longer than they otherwise would have.

Based on what I've seen, I'd say the following... Kids who love book learning do it voluntarily, for fun, whether or not they're formally in school. On the other hand, kids who don't love book learning don't get much from it one way or another no matter how hard the parents try, unless the parents resort to measures so overbearing that the kids become psychologically deformed as a result - and even then, those overbearing measures only work on some kids.

axguscbklp··on If Andromeda Were Brighter, This is What You’d See (2014)
I was going to say much the same thing until I saw your comment, which already expressed what I was going to. This has also struck me for a while as being interesting.
axguscbklp··on 2M chickens to be killed in US processing plants due to lack of employees
>Animals die in nature all the time, in much worse ways than the clean deaths they would get in a meat processing plant.

Animals who live in nature might also live more fulfilling lives before they die than animals that live in the average meat processing plant.

axguscbklp··on In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% without symptoms
>How do you feel about the right-wing media that was obsessively critical about Obama for strangely irrelevant things such as his choice of mustard or color of suits?

I feel that it was idiotic propaganda.

>It seems to me that almost all of the criticism of Trump is well justified by his incoherence, rudeness, anti-intellectualism, blatant nepotism, lack of structure, refusal to divest, repeated untruthful statements, lack of logical consistency, questionable policies, and apparent tendency towards cronyism.

The problem as I see it is too many Trump haters go beyond the many valid reasons to hate him and instead, due to conscious or subconscious bias, start to do things like take things he says out of context, or read more into those things than is necessarily justifiable, or try to paint him as a uniquely evil figure even though we have had presidents in recent memory who literally supported death squads in third world countries... etc.

axguscbklp··on An average family in Tokyo can own a new house for $850/month
Are those neighborhoods safe, or are they the kind of places where you have to regularly worry that you might get physically assaulted?
axguscbklp··on An average family in Tokyo can own a new house for $850/month
>Or alternatively it's in bad neighborhoods. (bad is relative if you are from the US)

I've never been to Japan, but I imagine that a bad Japanese neighborhood is incredibly safe compared to a bad U.S. neighborhood. In a bad U.S. neighborhood one has to regularly take precautions in order to not be physically assaulted or even killed by other people.

>your house will most likely look like this: https://www.ii-ie2.net/dat/5ba1164d.jpg

Looks pretty amazing for less than $1000/month.

That said, of course I'm not thinking that Japan is some paradise. What I hear/read about their justice system and their stifling conformist culture doesn't sound very good to me.

axguscbklp··on In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% without symptoms
The media is not monolithic, but a large subset of it is fervently against Trump, against Trump supporters, and against Republicans in general. The worse the pandemic and shutdown get, the more this subset of the media can use it to bash Trump, Trump supporters, and Republicans. Generally speaking, the worse the economy gets, the less likely that the incumbent president will be re-elected. I don't think that this media slant is the result of a conspiracy, though, at least not for the most part. I'd guess that probably most of the slant comes from subconscious bias, not conscious intent.

I'm against Trump too, for various reasons - for example, I don't like his authoritarian mindset, his stance on torture, his stance on surveillance, and his foreign policy towards Iran - but I'm not a fan of the constant hysterics of the anti-Trump media either. Some of those people would claim that Trump was somehow being deceitful and evil even if he just said that 2 + 2 = 4.

There are, I'm sure, other sources of media bias on this matter as well, but this is the one that immediately comes to my mind.

axguscbklp··on We Are Living in a Failing State
Well, my point isn't to let Trump and his gang off the hook. I'm no fan of them. But this article strikes me as a hit piece, not an objective bit of editorializing.

>And let's not forget how the Trump administration persecuted a carrier captain for protecting the crew after finding out the epidemic was spreading within the ship.

Those Navy personnel volunteered to potentially kill foreigners on government orders and to give up some of their civil rights at least for the duration of their service. It's one thing if some of them wanted to endanger military security for the sake of letting the wider public know about abuses - which is what Snowden did, and is something that I support. It's another thing if people who volunteered to potentially kill people on government orders want to endanger military security just to try to save their own lives.

axguscbklp··on Why are Soviet math textbooks so hardcore in comparison to US textbooks? (2017)
Thanks for the tip about "showdead". I totally agree that there's a big danger, if one follows the strategy I described, of personal bias making one confuse "intelligent" with "what I want to be true" or with "what I enjoy because it is contrarian". However, I am aware of this danger and work to mitigate it in various ways. Also, I should mention that I don't think that grayed-out comments are 0.5 likely to be highly intelligent - I'd say it's more like about 0.1 or 0.2. Overall, I think that the benefit of prioritizing grayed-out comments, to me, has been worth it so far.
axguscbklp··on Why are Soviet math textbooks so hardcore in comparison to US textbooks? (2017)
Personally, I gravitate towards grayed-out comments. I think that they tend to be likely to be on one or another extreme side of the intellectual bell curve. Basically, they end up grayed out because either they are too dumb or too smart for the average Hacker News user. So if I manage to run an effective mental filter to discard grayed-out comments that are on the low side of the intellectual gray curve, then gravitating towards grayed-out comments makes it more likely that I am exposed to content that is in the highest intellectual range of Hacker News comments as a whole.
axguscbklp··on We Are Living in a Failing State
Yeah, from what I can tell the U.S. currently has fewer COVID-19 deaths per capita than Belgium, Spain, Italy, France, the U.K., the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, or Ireland. Of course, part of the reason for this might be the timing of when COVID-19 hit the U.S. as opposed to when it hit those countries. But it certainly doesn't seem to me that the U.S. has been doing wildly worse, at least when it comes to the death toll, than most wealthy Western European countries. Germany is a big outlier, with about half the deaths per capita so far when compared both to the U.S. and to most of its wealthy Western European neighbors.

It could also be argued that, even if the U.S. ends up having a COVID-19 deaths per capita rate that is similar to that of Western Europe, people in the U.S. will have a harder time dealing with the economic aftermath of the crisis due to weaker social safety nets. Probably a lot will depend on how efficient the U.S. emergency stimulus measures end up being.

The author of the article tries to connect the COVID-19 crisis to the U.S.'s political divisions and to the failures of the Trump administration, but I am not sure that he succeeds. There are many nations that have less political bickering than the U.S. does and have more technically competent and less divisive people in charge of their governments than the U.S. does, but have nonetheless been suffering from the crisis as much as the U.S. has been suffering.

There are plenty of good reasons to criticize U.S. political partisanship and to criticize the Trump administration, but this article strikes me more as intellectually shallow anti-Trump complaining or propaganda, not as a serious and unbiased analysis of the political state of the U.S. and how that state relates to the COVID-19 crisis.

axguscbklp··on Temporal circuit of brain activity supports human consciousness
I wouldn't say it's impossible, although honestly I cannot even begin to imagine how consciousness could lie inside known or even knowable physics. But if people want to try, more power to them. I'm open to my suspicion being wrong.
← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →