HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

axguscbklp

252 karma · joined January 16, 2020

submissionscomments
axguscbklp··on Temporal circuit of brain activity supports human consciousness
Not because it is too complex, but because I suspect that there may be something to consciousness that is outside of knowable physics. There is no reason to assume that scientific investigation is in principle capable of getting a grip on all of reality. That does not mean that consciousness is some mystic woo-woo, it just means that scientific investigation may in principle be limited. Consciousness might well turn out to be impossible in principle to tackle using mathematical modeling, reproducible experiment, theories of physical mechanisms, etc. - but that would not mean that consciousness is not real. It does not require scientific inquiry to show that consciousness is real. Subjective experience is immediately obviously real, as subjective experience.
axguscbklp··on Temporal circuit of brain activity supports human consciousness
>if you're an atheist [...] you can't really avoid the conclusion that it must all be a side effect of processing or information somehow

Why? I'm an atheist-leaning agnostic, but I think that the hard problem of consciousness might well turn out to be impossible for scientific investigation to tackle.

I cannot think of any valid logic that would show that "there are no gods" implies "consciousness is a side effect of processing or information somehow".

axguscbklp··on Temporal circuit of brain activity supports human consciousness
On the other hand, I think that many people are emotionally invested in believing that science must be capable of solving the hard problem of consciousness even though there is no reason to assume that science is.

It is perfectly possible that the hard problem of consciousness is in principle and forever beyond the reach of scientific investigation.

axguscbklp··on YouTube tightens rules after David Icke 5G interview
It is objectively censorship, it's just not government censorship.
axguscbklp··on YouTube tightens rules after David Icke 5G interview
Doesn't mean I have to like them when they do.
axguscbklp··on Coronavirus and Credibility
Obama killed civilians overseas and presided over massive NSA surveillance of US citizens. Trump also kills civilians overseas and presides over massive NSA surveillance of US citizens, but that doesn't make it any better that Obama did it.
axguscbklp··on The JavaScript Black Hole: A playbook for ethical engineering on the web
Yeah, JavaScript has problems but come on, just the fact that it has closures and first-class functions (and did a lot to popularize both, for that matter) makes it pretty cool in my book. It's a fun and powerful language.

The author also trots out the standard go-to argument of JavaScript haters. He writes that JavaScript "has deeply ingrained quirks and bugs which can never be fixed without breaking the millions of scripts that have made peace with the existence of those bugs and depend upon the well-known workaround" and he links to https://github.com/denysdovhan/wtfjs, a typical list of JavaScript's well-known type-casting quirks, etc.

Pretty much all languages have little quirks. Actual JavaScript programmers usually learn how to avoid JavaScript's quirks pretty quickly and easily. In my experience, people who fixate on JavaScript's quirks generally do not understand the language very well. If they did, they could criticize more substantial things about JavaScript than just things like "[] == ![]; // -> true".

axguscbklp··on The JavaScript Black Hole: A playbook for ethical engineering on the web
>JavaScript frameworks such as React and Angular have transformed the web, bringing us fully-fledged client side applications with functionality that could only be imagined just a decade ago.

It's not like one couldn't create a fully-fledged client side application before Angular and React.

axguscbklp··on The Man Who Got No Whammies (2015)
>"He didn’t understand the value of good, hard, honest work," his older brother, James, later bemoaned. "He thought those people were fools."

I wouldn't call people like that fools, and pretty certainly the world would fall to pieces without them. That said, I don't think I can really blame anyone too much for not valuing good, hard, honest work in this world where many people are simply born rich and many others become rich by gaming the system and/or screwing people over.

axguscbklp··on Coronavirus and Credibility
Strange that you got downvoted. NSA collection of American data fits any reasonable definition of "conspiracy against the population" that I can think of.
axguscbklp··on Yet another novel I will no longer write
Yeah, I lost a bit of respect for Stross' intelligence when I read that part about elite panic. Stross also doesn't seem to understand that just because a person prepares for the possibility that the masses might become violent doesn't mean that the person necessarily thinks that outcome to be the most likely one - it's just better to be safe than sorry.

>The elite are fine in a disaster and they know it.

Only if the disaster is relatively manageable. History has many examples of elites being killed during political upheaval.

axguscbklp··on Yet another novel I will no longer write
The vast majority of Jewish people who died in the Holocaust were not elites - however, it is true that German resentment against rich and influential Jewish people in politics, business, the media, and arts played a huge role in leading to the Holocaust. Anti-Jewish sentiment in pre-WW2 Germany was not very different from anti-Jewish sentiment today. Already back then, as still is the case now, antisemites tended to target their ire against Jewish people's disproportionate influence over politics, the economy, media, the arts and so on. The fact that most Jewish people are not rich and influential does not dissuade those types. For many or most antisemites, resentment against rich and influential Jewish people soon swells into a generalized resentment against almost all or all Jewish people. So, for example, the Nazis ended up killing huge numbers of poor Eastern European Jews who could not be described in any way, shape, or form as elites. But this does not mean that the resentment did not originally largely stem from resentment against well-off and influential Jewish people.

In my experience, most antisemites are fairly stupid* and it is hard for them to understand the logic which says "just because a small subset of a certain ethnic/cultural group has disproportionate influence over the society in which they live does not mean that every member of that ethnic/cultural group has disproportionate influence over that society".

This fallacy is sort of like thinking that, because most NBA players are African-American, it means that most or all African-Americans must be really good at basketball. Rather obviously flawed logic.

*Certainly not all, though - the more intelligent ones probably contribute the bulk of antisemitic literature.

axguscbklp··on Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library
Probably not necessarily, since content creators who are already rich don't really see their lives much affected by piracy. But content creators who are not rich need to sell product in order to put food on the table and keep a roof over their heads, so in that case yes, as far as I can tell, there is a moral harm.
axguscbklp··on Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library
"screw copyright" = "screw a large fraction of content creators"
axguscbklp··on Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library
>do you think it makes any difference to the victims of that harm whether you know that you are causing that harm, or are consoling yourself with ideological contrivances

No, it makes no difference at all as far as I can tell, except in the probably irrelevant sense that my dislike of justifying my piracy might have some small influence upon others.

I made my initial comment mainly because I wished to explore the question of how much anti-copyright rhetoric is actually based on selfish ulterior motives rather than on principled ideology.

axguscbklp··on Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library
I agree that pirating vs. not pirating a given item of content is rather binary. What I mean by "I try to limit my piracy" is that I try not to pirate too many distinct items of content.
axguscbklp··on Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library
Given that this is a time of emergency, I think that definitely a good argument can be made for relaxing copyright laws. That said, many commenters on this subject are extending the discussion into a general discussion on the value of copyright, and there I cannot fully agree with the notion that copyright is a bad thing.

I pirate stuff too (although I try to limit my piracy) but one difference between me and many other pirates is that I know that I am sometimes hurting people when I pirate. I don't try to console myself with ideological contrivances designed to help me avoid feeling responsibility for causing harm to others.

axguscbklp··on On Killing Tanks
The disparity of power between NATO and Serbia was so great that NATO had no need to resort to measures that would endanger and hurt civilians to the degree that the attacks on the Serbian power grid and media did. Even the conflict inside Kosovo could have been resolved by putting boots on the ground. But NATO nations did not want to risk their soldiers, so they killed Serbian civilians instead.

>Russia and the Syrian targeted hospitals regularly for years and while it get coverage people in the US didn't care much able it.

Probably true, but I'm just talking about the media uproar, whether or not the uproar had much effect among the US public.

The idea that targeting civilian infrastructure is ok because that infrastructure is also being used to support an opponent's military effort seems to me like a slippery slope.

axguscbklp··on The Geopolitics of American Fear
>Weapons make everyone civilized

Or at least more civilized than they would otherwise be. They make the US more civilized as well.

But I think my point stands - given that there are several countries that could destroy multiple US cities within minutes, the US does not have "a near-immunity to blowback, and a near-zero concern for consequences".

axguscbklp··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
Thanks for that perspective - it's something I had not thought of.
axguscbklp··on On Killing Tanks
NATO also deliberately targeted Serbia's power grid and deliberately targeted a radio/TV station during the war. Both of those things would cause uproar in the US media if an opponent of US geopolitical interests did them.
axguscbklp··on The Geopolitics of American Fear
I don't think that the US could prevent a full-scale Russian or Chinese strike from causing massive damage. And I think that even the UK, France, and Israel could probably at least wipe out a couple of US cities.
axguscbklp··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
Sure. Here are a couple of places with sources.

https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/flor5z/please_sto...

https://www.mahoningmatters.com/regional-news/ohio-doctors-a...

axguscbklp··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
The numerous* stories that I have read recently about medical professionals writing themselves prescriptions for hydroxychloroquine so that they can have it available for themselves and their families suggests to me that the French trial is not the only reason to be hopeful about hydroxychloroquine's efficacy against COVID-19.

Sure, medical professionals are not necessarily any kind of super-rational savants, but I think it's unlikely that all of the medical professionals who are trying to hoard hydroxychloroquine are being irrational hysterics. They might be engaging in ethically questionable acts by hoarding hydroxychloroquine, but that doesn't mean that they don't know what they're doing from a self-preservation standpoint.

That said, it's not that I think they are necessarily trying to hoard hydroxychloroquine because they are convinced that it works - it's probably more that they want it on hand in case it turns out that it works. However, some of them may also have directly seen it help people, or may have heard or read about it helping.

Given that hydroxychloroquine has already been used for, as I understand it, weeks in treating people ill with COVID-19, I am actually surprised that there is not more anecdotal evidence about its efficacy. But I probably have just not been reading in the right places.

*Edit: I probably shouldn't have said "numerous stories", since "numerous" implies more than the number that I actually have seen.

axguscbklp··on WHO launches global megatrial of the four most promising coronavirus treatments
I dislike Trump, but even I can see that there is a subset of the media that has a conscious or unconscious principle of attacking him for almost everything he says and does. If he does X, attack him for doing X. If he does the opposite of X, attack him for doing the opposite of X. If he first does X and then does the opposite of X, first attack him for doing X and then switch and attack him for doing the opposite of X. If he makes peace, call him soft on our enemies. If he makes war, call him bloodthirsty. Etc.

This subset of the media also tends to lie about what Trump says. So, for example, a few years ago they insinuated that Trump had called all Mexicans criminals and rapists. Trump never had. A couple of days ago, they insinuated that Trump blew up on a reporter because the reporter had asked Trump what he had to say to Americans who were scared. In context and without selective editing, though, it seems a lot more likely to me that Trump blew up on the reporter because the reporter had just a few moments previously asked Trump if Trump's tendency to put a positive spin on things was giving people false hope.

This subset of the media has been accusing Trump of exaggerating the effects of hydroxychloroquine. But I have not been able to find any statements from Trump in which he promoted it one-sidedly as any sort of miracle cure.

Trump lies all the time, but that doesn't mean I don't see that a certain fraction of the media lies about Trump too.

I don't think it's a total collective effort on the part of the media to smear Trump, although I'm pretty sure that there are pockets of collective effort there. There are subsets of the media that uncritically praise Trump, so it's certainly not one-sided. There's probably also a clickbait profit motive behind some of the deceptive media coverage. It's a lot easier to take a Trump quote out of context and write a quick article making it seem like he said something horrendous than it is to actually do investigative journalism and thoughtful commentary.

As for whether such media people would care about millions dying? Well, did they care enough about the fate of Iraqis to be adequately cynical about Bush administration hogwash about WMDs that any intelligent teenager with an interest in war could have poked holes in? No. To add insult to injury, many of them actually started to fawn over the Bushes once Trump was in office.

>Note that those opposing Trump are on the left

"Left" is not well-defined. If you mean "left" as in socialist-leaning, then I would say that I doubt that a clear majority of Trump's opponents are on the left. Many are.

>and actually care about helping others

No matter how you define "left", the "left" has no monopoly on actually caring about helping others. And the "left" has plenty of people who talk a big talk about wanting to help others but who actually, whether they realize it about themselves or not, only care about power and use the talk of help as a disguise. All parts of the political spectrum have people like that.

axguscbklp··on Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coronavirus
I don't think that the post-9/11 terrorism threat was actually anywhere close to a best case for the erosion of liberties. Until and unless terrorists gain access to weapons of mass destruction plus the ability to deploy them, terrorism is a very minor threat to America. Terrorists might well at some point in the future get access to weapons of mass destruction and the ability to deploy them to the US, but that was not the case 19 years ago and almost certainly is still not the case now.
axguscbklp··on The Geopolitics of American Fear
Zeihan is an interesting counterweight to the "America is a declining empire" crowd of analysts, but IMO he goes too far in the other direction even while he makes some good points. This article doesn't even feel objective to me - it feels like a paroxysm of America-worship.

Statements like "America has a near-infinite capacity to act, a near-immunity to blowback, and a near-zero concern for consequence" are silly given that there are multiple independent nuclear powers in the world which are capable of striking the US mainland.

axguscbklp··on Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coronavirus
I know that the word "everyone" is now often used to mean "the vast majority of people", but I'm not even sure that the vast majority of people would have voted for reducing civil liberties in the aftermath of 9/11, had they been given a vote. The mainstream media did a good job of manufacturing the illusion of consent, but that does not mean that actual consent would have been given had it been asked for. For example, I often read people say thay the 2003 Iraq War was overwhelmingly supported by the US population, whereas polls from the time show that it was not even supported by a majority of poll responders.
axguscbklp··on U.S. to Iran: Coronavirus won't save you from sanctions
>[Brian Hook, the U.S. Special Representative for Iranian Affairs] also blamed Iran’s leadership for its coronavirus woes, saying that Iran “spends billions on terrorism and foreign wars” and that if it spent one tenth of this “on a better health care system, the Iranian people would have been much better off.”

Well, that's a bit ironic and hypocritical.

axguscbklp··on Chloroquine, past and present
But won't they be tied up one way or another producing something else, unless by chance they happen to currently be producing something that turns out to be important in the fight against the pandemic?
← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →