HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

axguscbklp

252 karma · joined January 16, 2020

submissionscomments
axguscbklp··on Chloroquine, past and present
I'm not suggesting immediately starting to dose millions of people with it. I'm suggesting massively ramping up production so that if it turns out to be useful, we can at that point immediately start dosing millions of people with it.

I think it likely that the cost of massively increasing hydroxychloroquine production would be a drop in the bucket compared to the total resources being spent on tackling the crisis. So even if the drug turns out to not be effective, the attempt to mass-produce it would still have been a rational gamble.

axguscbklp··on Chloroquine, past and present
It seems to me that we should immediately move to massively increase production of hydroxychloroquine. If it turns out to be part of a solution, great. If not, I doubt that more than a tiny fraction of the total resources dedicated to the pandemic would have been used up by the effort. There is no time to take things slowly in our situation. In any case, from what I've read on places like r/medicine, many people who have access to hydroxychloroquine have already begun to hoard it. So one way or another, if we do not ramp up production there will be trouble.

Hydroxychloroquine has been around for decades, so it's not like we would be jumping into a total mystery about its side effects.

It seems to me that, whether hydroxychloroquine ultimately turns out to be effective or not, it is the closest thing we have right now to something that might prove to be a very helpful medicine.

axguscbklp··on Stalin’s Danish Mystery
>The U.S. was imperfect too, of course, but most of the badness was non-policy like the My Lai massacre, or evil or wrong policies (e.g. segregation) which pale in comparison

I disagree. The biggest badness was support for murderous dictators and paramilitary groups in Iran (1953-1979), Chile (1973-1981), Iraq (at least from 1980-1988 or so), Nicaragua (during the 80s), and numerous other places. This was completely intentional, calculated policy that led to the death of thousands of people.

axguscbklp··on Recovering telemetry data from Venera-13 and 14
Question: why has the US not attempted to land on Venus?

Another question: how long could a lander made with the best modern technology survive on Venus?

Edit: oops! I just learned about Pioneer-Venus. Looks like the US has actually landed on Venus. Guess I should do more research before posting.

axguscbklp··on It's Still About the Applications
If the government wants to attract competent people, maybe it should first get rid of mass NSA domestic surveillance, purge the CIA of everyone who was responsible for extraordinary rendition, and try harder not to murder innocent people overseas. As things currently stand, I feel morally disgusted just paying taxes in the US. I definitely would never work in anything that even somewhat came close to the military or intelligence agencies.
axguscbklp··on Self-driving cars turned out to be harder than expected
Yes, harder than hype and deluded optimism expected. Plenty of people have seen through the hype and delusion for years now. Level 5 requires AGI. AGI is probably nowhere close to being realized - humans may well be centuries away from reaching the necessary technological level. Humanity might never get there at all. In any case, if humanity ever developed AGI, it would revolutionize the world. Self-driving cars would be one of the most boring and mundane applications.
axguscbklp··on Powerful Concepts for Understanding the World
I think that I am not a mystic if by mysticism you mean something like "forsaking logic and science for delusion".

I am a mystic, however, in the sense that while I have enormous respect for logic and scientific method, and I am usually one of the most scientific-minded and skeptical people in whatever environment I am in, I do not assume that science is capable of solving all mysteries of reality.

I see no contradiction between physics, on the one hand, and thinking that consciousness may be irreducible to physics, on the other hand.

There is no reason to assume that the nature of consciousness is in principle accessible to scientific investigation.

It may be that there is some fundamental limit that prevents us conscious beings from grasping the nature of consciousness - and that's if there is anything to grasp in the first place. Maybe consciousness is essentially axiomatic and irreducible.

I have loved science since I was young, but to assume that everything about reality is accessible to scientific inquiry and/or physical explanation is dogmatic, unscientific.

axguscbklp··on The AI delusion: why humans trump machines
A machine could emulate consciousness in the sense that we could probably in principle build a machine that acted, viewed from the outside, as if it were conscious. But we have no way to measure whether something is conscious or not so we would never really know if the machine actually was conscious, had interiority, had qualia, etc. (three different ways of saying the same thing).

There is no good reason to believe that consciousness is reducible to physical phenomena. I think that intelligence is almost certainly reducible to physical phenomena, but consciousness? No. Consciousness is a mystery that quite likely will forever be beyond the reach of physical investigation.

axguscbklp··on Powerful Concepts for Understanding the World
That's not really oversimplification though, it's more like making an assumption. But I agree that it's a minor point. I mainly brought it up in my other comment in this thread because the topic of consciousness fascinates me.
axguscbklp··on Powerful Concepts for Understanding the World
Wonderful essay, one of the best such compilations I've read. I see myself engaging in many of these thought patterns.

I'll add one in the spirit of "none of us are perfect"...

>..neurons creating consciousness...

Is an example of something I see frequently - otherwise very smart people who assume that consciousness is just an emergent property of physical matter and who ignore the hard problem of consciousness.

axguscbklp··on Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video]
Because of all the edge cases that humans can handle a good amount of the time because we have a lot of intelligence compared to any computer.

But I agree with you that if we meet in the middle, that could actually work well.

axguscbklp··on Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video]
I would say that I would feel comfortable falling asleep in a 5 while it is driving nontrivial distance and/or road conditions, but I would not feel comfortable doing so in a 4++.
axguscbklp··on Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video]
The thing is, I see no way to have full self driving without AGI. And I don't think humanity is anywhere close to developing AGI. Without AGI you can have level 4++ self driving, maybe, but not level 5.
axguscbklp··on Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video]
I'm not against it, I just think that it requires AGI and humanity is nowhere close to developing AGI. I think that AGI is somewhere between "50 years away" and "will never be developed by humans".
axguscbklp··on Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video]
>I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now?

Musk was bullshitting when he made that prediction. Maybe he did it because he had bought his own bullshit. Personally I think what's more likely is that he was cynically conning people.

In reality, I think no-one is anywhere close to fully self driving cars. I would be surprised if we saw fully self driving cars any time in the next 50 years.

The whole field of fully self driving cars has been astonishingly full of empty hype, for some reason often believed by otherwise quite smart people.

axguscbklp··on Volkswagen exec admits full self-driving cars 'may never happen'
Navigating off-road might actually be easier in practice for AI than navigating on roads, since off-road there are generally many fewer other cars to deal with.

As a rough rule of thumb, I'll call a car fully self-driving if, without any changes having been made to the road system to accomodate self-driving cars, I feel comfortable getting in the back seat, telling it to drive me to a certain house in a city a few hundred miles away, and falling asleep.

axguscbklp··on America’s aggressive use of sanctions endangers the dollar’s reign
The poster you replied to has a point, though. Trump certainly does seem to have many shady connections to powerful Russian figures, but the Trump administration's Russia policy is almost identical to the Obama administration's.
axguscbklp··on Volkswagen exec admits full self-driving cars 'may never happen'
Musk, for all his genuine achievements, is also a bullshitter. If/when his FSD prediction fails to come to pass, I expect that he will just say "Well, when I said FSD, what I really meant is..."
axguscbklp··on Volkswagen exec admits full self-driving cars 'may never happen'
If you have to modify the environment to make it easier for the cars, then you haven't achieved fully self-driving technology.
axguscbklp··on Volkswagen exec admits full self-driving cars 'may never happen'
Well yeah, of course. Full self-driving probably requires artificial general intelligence and it is quite possible that humans will never develop artificial general intelligence. The real surprising thing, for me, is how many otherwise intelligent people bought into full self-driving hype.

It's likely that if humans ever developed the sort of AI necessary for full self-driving, this AI technology would radically transform the world. Using it for cars would be one of the least important applications.

axguscbklp··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
Working around the house/village is still work. Male peasants for the most part don't work outside the house/village either. They usually work on fields that relatively close to where they live. And a large fraction of the women work alongside them. Older men and women - grandpas and grandmas, etc. - do a lot of the childrearing while the younger women work.
axguscbklp··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
Most people for most of history were peasants. Peasant women don't just raise children - they usually contribute to almost everything else that the farming economy requires, as well. Think of old photos of peasants/poor farmers. Do the women look like they have been spending their time just raising children?
axguscbklp··on Christopher Tolkien has died
IMO, to whatever extent the reverence exists, it is unjustified. The films are about as good as one can reasonably expect from big budget blockbusters, but to me they are somewhere between mediocre and merely decent cinema, with bombastic manipulative music, jarringly incongruent moments of lowbrow humor, lots of very fake-looking CGI, over-the-top almost comedically grotesque orcs, cheaply emptionally manipulative scenes like the Gondorian charge against Osgiliath, etc. They also have many good moments and many good filming decisions, but I wouldn't hold them up anywhere near the pinnacle of cinema. Don't get me wrong, I think that the books have many flaws too, although I like them a lot. I wouldn't say the books, good as they are, are at the pinnacle of literature either, although they may certainy be near the pinnacle of worldbuilding and are, I think, much much better than the films.
← PreviousPage 9 of 9