HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

banachtarski

2,796 karma · joined July 16, 2012

programming for ~20 years and counting. math background. generalist with some emphasis on machine learning, graphics, physics simulation, compilers, and server technology. I dabble in electronics and FPGAs.
submissionscomments
banachtarski··on Install Ubuntu 20.04 LTS on MacBookPro14,1
I'm absolutely NOT including open source drivers in my assessment. I'm specifically talking about drivers written by vendors who unsurprisingly do a better job targeting their own hardware.
banachtarski··on Install Ubuntu 20.04 LTS on MacBookPro14,1
macOS runs horribly on custom hardware, it just runs better than other commodity software.

Any application that pushes frames/performance would do better on Linux/Windows on the equivalent amount of silicon. What's missing because the hardware and drivers is so closed is the feedback loop between application/game devs and the vendors. If I have an issue with what I'm building, I can hop into a chat and immediately talk to Nvidia/AMD/Intel folks/etc. In some cases, they share code, in some cases they release a driver update. In pretty much all cases, the code I'm working on gets better. Apple lacks this feedback loop, and their drivers are garbage.

banachtarski··on A Taste of WebGPU in Firefox
Give me one example of a graphics API today on desktop where this isn't possible. Unless you're a console graphics engineer, you're shit out of luck if you really think you can stop client-side injection. Short of a kernel-mode injection like the crap Valorant is pulling, layer hooks and trampolines are literally how those APIs ship (D3D, OpenGL, Vulkan, etc).
banachtarski··on A Taste of WebGPU in Firefox
Stop propagating misinformation. Personally, I wish WebGPU had gone a slightly different way (thanks Apple :/) but it's definitely no way 1:1 identical with Vulkan.

Also your last point makes no sense. That's been the state of desktop graphics programming for years and years. You really don't control much as IHVs are always free to intercept calls and control things at the driver level.

banachtarski··on Running an independent Arch Linux rebuilder
proprietary drivers from nvidia are provided by the Arch mainline (core) though?
banachtarski··on Ask YC: We applied to S2020 and nobody looked at our videos?
.. more likely, the youtube view counting algorithm doesn't include embedded views.
banachtarski··on The smallest large display would be projected straight onto your retina
Your eyeballs are being bombarded with photons emitted by the sun and your monitor right now as we speak. Furthermore, you're perpetually bathed in cosmic background radiation.

A "laser" just means that the emitted photons are phase synchronized, but says nothing about the intensity. The range is also irrelevant. For a radially emitting source, intensity scales as the inverse squared distance, but assuming you control the output, it's a moot point.

banachtarski··on A Message About Vanguard From Our Security and Privacy Teams
Humans can and do in fact do all the things you suggest. False positives are generally to be avoided, and mitigations for reverse engineering are still required (anti debuggers, anti dll injection measures).

All the stuff mentioned like not sending positions of people who aren’t visible are typically already done, but sometimes the position is needed for reasons you don’t understand. Like some gameplay ability to suddenly see through walls, etc.

This thread just has a lot of backseat programming.

I think I would find your post a little less irksome if you approached it from a neutral questioning tone as opposed to “what about these obvious things every junior engineer learns” :/

banachtarski··on A Message About Vanguard From Our Security and Privacy Teams
You’re a bit out of your depth. Of course “trust the server” is preferred but many forms of cheats are purely client side. For example an aimbot that steadies your cursor on someone’s head or dodges automatically when a projectile is inbound. Maybe the client hijacks the UI to hide terrain and walls.

I’m not saying what valorant has done here is right, there are other things you can do. But you’re oversimplifying the problem.

banachtarski··on Ask HN: Resources to grok Emacs and use it well?
I'll be honest, my experience since has been that VSCode is... just better? I've been using vim/emacs for over 20 years now so it's a tough pill to swallow, but after trying out VSCode, I have to say that making it easy to program extensions with async functionality from the get-go was the right way to go. I think no combination of rtags, cquery, clangd, lsp, etc in Emacs/Vim/Neovim can approach the performance and quality of VSCode's C++ dev experience. And I say that having honestly tried every permutation of the above for many hours across many weeks.
banachtarski··on Wekan: Open-source, trello-like kanban
I'm not a casual user. The inline images functionality of org-mode sucks in comparison.
banachtarski··on Wekan: Open-source, trello-like kanban
... Can't tell if you're being facetious or not, but here's a sample trello board that mimics our workflow:

https://trello.com/b/TTAVI7Ny/ue4-roadmap

This is not a good fit for org-mode, despite what any number of org-mode zealots say.

banachtarski··on Ask HN: Resources to grok Emacs and use it well?
My experience with Spacemacs was the complete opposite. There's a ton of inconsistency with the quality of the provided layers which is why YMMV when using it. The C++ layers up till last year was an utter disaster and I don't know if it's been fixed since.

The WORST thing about spacemacs though is their absolutely broken release process. The master branch rarely upgrades with fixes applied to the develop branch, and the tacit recommendation is just to run "on the bleeding edge." I have no idea why spacemacs users tolerate this, but my productivity has since improved after ditching it.

banachtarski··on Wekan: Open-source, trello-like kanban
We use images/diagrams/LaTex/etc to communicate a number of tasks that are inherently visual, not to mention needing somewhere on the cloud to access it centrally.

As a casual org-mode user, I fail to see how org-mode is really relevant for a team-centric tool.

banachtarski··on A (possible) solution to Covid-19
Sorry but are you an epidemiologist or virologist? The armchair advice you're giving very much belies what established experts in the field are saying. It also ignores all the cases of respiratory and cardiac complications in not just the elderly. Is "very old" equivalent to "older than 20" for you?
banachtarski··on A (possible) solution to Covid-19
You’re ignoring the fact that this virus Is an order of magnitude more lethal than the flu, and I would guess that most individuals in poorer countries skip the vaccine altogether.
banachtarski··on IDA Home is coming
Note: I reverse in my spare time and have occasionally been called on to reverse at work. I find subscription based pricing for software like this completely disagreeable.
banachtarski··on I can't keep up with idiomatic Rust
How is Go anything like a C 2.0. It's more of a server-side scripting language if anything
banachtarski··on Nvidia Vulkan Ray Tracing Tutorials
I'm a single data point, but as a graphics engineer working on DDGI and having worked on SSR/SSAO, SDF shadows etc... I really do not care about the visuals of the tutorial haha. Clear greyscale images are honestly perfect for understanding exactly what's going on. The tutorial is meant to explain the mechanics, not dazzle you with a material shader.
banachtarski··on Nvidia Vulkan Ray Tracing Tutorials
You probably are not the target audience.

As a graphics engineer, the more compelling use cases of ray tracing are things like visibility tests, which can be temporally stabilized by adding a low-discrepancy noise to each sample and used to perform leak-free global illumination. Samples can be used to feed other aspects of the pipeline like generating soft shadows, or atmospheric effects, etc.

It's an API tutorial, for professionals in the field. Ray tracing is just one tool in the toolbox, not the alpha and omega of how the frame gets composed.

banachtarski··on China’s Digitization Endeavors: National Blockchain Platform to Go Live in April
Of course the CCP would prioritize a technology that gives it even greater observatory and regulatory powers. The article even mentions changes to the protocol to prohibit “unauthorized” users from viewing transaction histories and such.
banachtarski··on JITs are un-ergonomic
This article has a number of issues. JS with JIT is waaay faster than Python. Not “between python and java” as purported. Second, generalizing jits as “un-ergonomic” seems silly given that what’s being specifically looked at is benchmarking. But what makes this claim ridiculous is that nothing is easy to benchmark. Even native code is hard to profile and this is literally my day job. If the JIT makes your code that much faster, this strikes me as a pretty suspect complaint
banachtarski··on Getting started with bare-metal assembly
Why are webdev related topics so popular on Hacker News? I don't see pursuit of this topic happening in my anecdata of programmers I interact with in day to day life.

Oh right, not everyone is in my field.

banachtarski··on MIT to no longer consider SAT subject tests in admissions decisions
I did actually. I was the oldest of three.

I'm not saying the poor aren't disadvantaged. It's just that the disadvantages are more along the lines of attitudes towards education in the first place (along with everything else). There are also fewer people nearby that serve as an "example" on how to learn or get ahead.

banachtarski··on MIT to no longer consider SAT subject tests in admissions decisions
Anecdote: When I was younger, I used to take a public bus to a local bookstore and work through the SAT practice books (on separate scrap paper of course).
banachtarski··on Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12–Mar 16, 2020
> I'm not sure it's worth it.

It is. The quarantines/border-restrictions are not permanent measures, and acting swiftly is the correct way to nip it in the bud.

> Shutting down the country destroys everything.

Empty hyperbole. Death tolls in the tens of millions is a far worse outcome, as is stressing our current healthcare systems well beyond their capacities.

banachtarski··on Mac mini
Have used mac for many years. Never miss spotlight on Linux or Windows. First, you do have that functionality if you need it. Second, the spotlight indexing takes a non-trivial amount of CPU time and is honestly annoying when I need the juice to finish a render or compile code. My guess is you're just suffering from "unfamiliarity" syndrome.
banachtarski··on Giving Americans Money to Offset Coronavirus Impact Gains Support in Congress
Stock prices are leading indicators of future revenue. Not perfect indicators obviously, but the stock prices reflect lower sales/profits/etc due to reduced mobility, supply-chains etc.
banachtarski··on NPM Is Joining GitHub
Exactly. There are so many things different about today's MSFT. Another example is Linux support on Azure. People love their tin foil hats though.
banachtarski··on NPM Is Joining GitHub
Thanks you saved me a snarky comment
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →