1,435 karma · joined January 12, 2021
And this would not prevent you from explicitly licensing your code or writing to let people to train on it. But what it would do is say that if someone didn't explicitly license it then it is covered under the policy.
The idea is to keep it simple, so it wouldn't be based upon the specifics of training, just whether or not it used public data. Anything else would require companies to divulge trade secrets and that won't fly. And words are defined here as, well, words -- English words. There'd be a separate fee per pixel/voxel, and then a catchall for non-language/non-image models.
This proposed policy would say "well, if you're going to use public data for this use, you have to pay a fee because it's really all our data". Basically it's a mandatory licensing fee.
https://www.lightbluetouchpaper.org/2023/06/06/will-gpt-mode...
Gigin alone at the bottom of the hill / Our protagonist named Bill / Sets his sights on an anchor steam pint / All he needs is thirteen quarters / Congregated in his hat
I swear they must have a pipe straight from the brewery for how fresh it is there.
The two key factors: soil and sun. If you have to replace either, you're increasing your costs. Especially sun: if you use LEDs instead of solar illumination, it's hard to do it cheaply enough in the long run, nor produce calorie crops (as opposed to greens) -- there's simply an energy-in-energy-out balance that's hard to achieve.
Well managed traditional greenhouses can do quite a lot.
https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/12/fruit-walls-urban-fa...
https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/12/reinventing-the-gree...
Here are the takeaways:
* It'd be easy for Apple and Google to prevent downloads of TikTok for most users, which would also include app updates, as they have a significant amount of knowledge of users' locations and could prevent most users in Montana -- even those using a VPN -- from downloading the app or updating it.
* It'd be very difficult for Montana to enforce the other piece of the TikTok ban -- if "entity" in the bill means any company, they're stuck: the state has little ability to prevent side-loading of apps on Android and users who want TikTok can access app repositories hosted out of state. There's virtually no way for ISPs inside Montana to surveil all user usage to find out if they're trying to download TikTok from a third-party repository, and even if they could there would be legal issues with the state mandating this.
Fundamentally, this makes user privacy and security much worse.
* Apple, Google, and ByteDance could be aggressive and use the data they have -- all three have GPS data for most or all relevant users here (i.e. TikTok users on an iPhone or Android) -- and block requests to download or use TikTok from within Montana. And they probably will, unless they get a court to block the bill.
The one thing the bill banning TikTok doesn't do is the one thing that is desperately needed: actually protect user privacy, by banning the collection, aggregation, sale, and use of fine-grained user data -- by ByteDance, Meta, Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, or any other.
All complex technologies are really best understood as socio-technical systems. They depend on people and machines, data and economics, and, in the case of nuclear, especially fickle things like geopolitics and warfare. It's all about unknown unknowns, and not the engineering kind.
If it weren't for the unknown unknowns we are going to face in the 21st century from climate change alone (and not just the first order effects, but the second and third order effects on economics and geopolitics, which are basically unknowable), nuclear might make sense. But we have cheaper (solar PV + storage is cheaper, soon others will be too) and safer alternatives.
The easy test is this: if a country has a currency crisis, a coup, two back to back 1000-year storms, another pandemic, or any number of other major events, and the plant gets damaged and nobody shows up to work for a month, is everything going to be fine? Will someone break in and steal something dangerous? Will something dangerous leak out? With modern renewables the cost is low, the tail risk is basically zero, and the power is compatible with hard times.
Other systems such as Mastodon avoid running into these problems because of direct and implicit use of DNS for the namespace. (And use of DNS embedding in DIDs ends up undermining the value of flat naming.)
Solar PV and wind are cheap enough that overbuilding is easy. One might wonder what we can do with surplus power during times of day when we have too much solar (middle of the day) or too much wind (middle of the night) -- we can do desalination with the surplus solar (matches the demand curve of water use across the day and across the year) and convert wind to nitrogen:
https://wcroc.cfans.umn.edu/research/renewable-energy/wind-f...
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2022/12/reimagining-d...