HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

belugacat

1,221 karma · joined September 1, 2012

French/Californian designer in Tokyo
submissionscomments
belugacat··on Exploring the space-time-stench continuum, where no nose has gone before
A fundamental problem is that audio/video are quantizable in fairly cheap ways for recording (microphone/ccd) and playback (speaker/display), in very low dimensionality (typically 1-2 for audio, 3 for video)

Smell/taste exist in much higher dimensions, and it's unclear what both the recording as well as the playback "canonical devices" would be like. I've tried academic demos that give zaps to your tongue in order to recreate taste, and sure they sometimes triggered some faint taste for me but it still mostly feels like something zapping your tongue.

For smell, there doesn't seem to be much of a way other than having some sort of device with lots of tanks of various compounds for various flavor profiles that get puffed in your face, which you then have to refill as they get used up. A personal version of such hardware would likely be very cumbersome and expensive for limited upside? Some movie theaters do have such systems, but it remains a rare novelty.

Touch has a similar problem - all haptics feel like things buzzing under your fingers/in your hands, we don't really have direct paths to recreating the richness of tactility in the world. The one difference is that while the use cases for smell/taste seem pretty limited, touch is of huge relevance right now for ar/vr interactions.

When we're at the point where we'll be directly interfacing with brains though, things will likely be different. But that's not for a while.

belugacat··on Studio Ghibli set to become subsidiary of Nippon TV
Hayao Miyazaki, in the documentary "The Kingdom of Dreams and Madness" (2013):

Interviewer: "Aren't you worried about [Studio Ghibli]'s future?"

HM: "The future is clear. It's gonna fall apart. I can already see it. What's the use worrying? It's inevitable. "Ghibli" is just a random name I got from an airplane. It's only a name."

belugacat··on I think I kind of hate lazy loading
The infrastructure of Asian capitals is the best in the world, that's exactly the point - 99% of the world experiences deteriorated network (see comments in this thread to that point). It's frustrating when software isn't built in ways that are resilient to that.
belugacat··on LÖVE: a framework to make 2D games in Lua
Sorry I don't use Github.

The Play Store says "This app isn’t available for your device because it was made for an older version of Android". I'm on Android 13.

belugacat··on LÖVE: a framework to make 2D games in Lua
unsolicited feedback you might care about or not: it doesn't run on my Pixel 6A :(

shame, i was very excited to try it!

belugacat··on LÖVE: a framework to make 2D games in Lua
Link to the musical app?
belugacat··on Sweden brings more books and handwriting practice back to its tech-heavy schools
“Many authors have concluded that the weight of a school backpack should not exceed 10% of the child's body weight”

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4564613/#:~:tex....

The average 6 year old weighs 20 kg. The average 10 year old weighs 30kg.

https://www.disabled-world.com/calculators-charts/height-wei...

belugacat··on Sweden brings more books and handwriting practice back to its tech-heavy schools
Yes. From the article:

> “We believe the focus should return to acquiring knowledge through printed textbooks and teacher expertise, rather than acquiring knowledge primarily from freely available digital sources that have not been vetted for accuracy,” said the institute, a highly respected medical school focused on research.

Why were schools using unvetted materials in the first place!?

> it's not technology per se that's the problem

That said, handwriting practice is correlated to developing fine motor skills, which are documented to be in decline in children in a number of countries. Excessive time with (touch)screens is terrible on that front.

belugacat··on The meeting of the minds that launched AI
The mental gymnastics are beautiful and entertaining.

Google image "podium". Google image "computer". The vast majority of computers shown can be placed on the vast majority of podiums shown.

But again, as the other commenter points out, this is abductive reasoning.

In addition to getting lost in the irrelevant weeds of "these two objects serve very different purposes and have distinct characteristics", ChatGPT also fails to point out that there are 2 common definitions for podium - one made for lecturing, on which you could place most modern computers that aren't 30kg hunks of metal (all of my university lecturers definitely had computers on the podium). And one made for humans, on which you could definitely place any bulky desktop computer short of a mainframe.

What this really shows though is that LLM output is a mirror in which people will read mostly what they want to read which matches their narrative.

belugacat··on The meeting of the minds that launched AI
For breakfast, you say?

User:

I define a new word, the podition. A podition is any object that can fit on a podium. Is a computer a podition ? Why ?

ChatGPT:

The term "podition" is a newly coined word, and its definition as "any object that can fit on a podium" is quite specific. Whether or not a computer can be considered a "podition" depends on the size and design of the podium in question, as well as the specific characteristics of the computer.

If the podium is large enough and designed to accommodate objects of various sizes, then a computer could potentially be considered a podition if it fits on the podium without exceeding its space or causing any issues. However, if the podium is small or not designed to hold objects like a computer, then it may not qualify as a podition.

In summary, whether a computer is a podition or not depends on the podium's size and design and whether the computer can comfortably fit on it without causing any problems. The term "podition" itself is a new and specific concept, so its application may vary depending on context.

User:

Using common sense definitions of a computer and a podium, is a computer a podition?

ChatGPT:

Using common sense definitions of a computer and a podium, a computer is typically not considered a "podition." A computer is an electronic device used for processing and storing data, while a podium is a raised platform or stand typically used for holding notes, books, or supporting a speaker during a presentation. These two objects serve very different purposes and have distinct characteristics.

A computer is not designed to be placed on a podium, and it would generally be impractical to do so. A podium is meant for supporting objects like papers, books, or notes during a presentation, not electronic devices like computers. Therefore, in common usage and understanding, a computer would not be classified as a "podition."

belugacat··on He created the Katamari games, but they’re rolling on without him
The creator of Fruit Ninja released a fantastic video about the origins of the game:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=St5v2uI-Nis

I highly recommend it, it's a fantastic post mortem (they shipped the original game, from prototype to 1.0, in just 6 weeks!)

Similarly, he was just an employee at the game studio, and never made significant money from it (which he mentions led to confusion when seeking funding as he started his own company later - people kept asking "why don't you just use your Fruit Ninja money?").

Big fan of Keita, played all of his games (including the weird ps3/iphone nobynobyboy/girl), had the pleasure of meeting him in SF when he was working on Wattam, writing this from a laptop with a katamari sticker on it. One of my favorite designers.

belugacat··on Earning the privilege to work on unoriginal problems
> Whether or not any given approach works out comes down far more to the little details and nuances of what you're doing and how you're doing it, as well as a healthy dollop of circumstances beyond your immediate control.

This is the most important thing I've learned working for 15 years in tiny SV startups as well as the most successful company in the history of capitalism.

The main problem is you can't really teach what all those little details and nuances are (the tao that can be told...). You have to live it and experience it. Over time, you meet people who Get It (the founder of the aforementioned called them "A players"), and people who don't.

All you can do is focus on doing great work with the people who Get It, cutting those who clearly won't/don't, and investing mentorship in young people who seem like they're on a path to it.

belugacat··on The Dilemma of Icons
“Self explanatory” doesn’t exist. There are only icons that people have seen before (and recognize), and those they haven’t.
belugacat··on The Dilemma of Icons
In the case of the interface shown in the train video, the key thing the operator will rely on is the fixed physical position of the controls first, then their shape, dimension, and color.

The icons really aren’t going to matter as much. And I’d argue they’d probably be better off replaced by text labels. Imagine a new operator in a stressful situation being guided eg on the phone - how would you describe to them which of the 2 buttons with a center arrow with a curve to their right they should press, for the control panel at 4:31? You’ll end up saying “the center left/right button”, or “the one above the green P button” because those icons are pretty hard to distinguish.

Swap the icons between 2 controls one day, and watch even the most skilled operator make mistakes.

belugacat··on The Dilemma of Icons
Using the word “intuitive” is the hallmark of a mediocre interface designer.

You can’t make an “intuitive interface”. What you can make is an interface that is familiar, and consistent, which means people can reasonably anticipate what doing something they haven’t done before will do.

(Good interfaces should also allow for mistake recovery - eg by supporting universal undo - which is something everyone seems to have forgotten)

Even arrows are not uniformly perceived across cultures as showing direction (although you can safely assume most anyone who lives in 21st century globalized modern society will have learned to decode arrows fairly early in life).

The old quote goes that “the only intuitive interface is the nipple; after that it’s all learned” - but that quote was clearly by someone who was never around newborns, because lots of newborns have to be guided to breastfeeding.

belugacat··on Programmers should not call themselves engineers (2015)
Surgeons aren’t engineers, they’re technicians.
belugacat··on NY Times Rides in Waymo Robotaxis in SF
> does anyone really believe anymore that it will be cheap, given how expensive ride share services are?

I used to own a car in SF, and I definitely spend way less money every month on Lyft + the occasional weekend Getaround than I did on insurance/gas/repairs/the occasional tow or parking ticket when I had my car (not even counting initial acquisition).

Obviously depends on a lot of factors, but it’s not that clear cut.

belugacat··on So you want to learn physics (2021)
That’s a POV I’ve grown to adopt as I got older (like many, perhaps). I used to heavily privilege theory, believing that everything could (and maybe should) be derived from first principles.

Now I place the concrete over everything else; theory is nice when it can illuminate why the practice works. Otherwise, it’s just words.

The most frustrating is when I have friends who have derived their entire understanding of a subject I know as a practitioner (typically something tech/programming related) from watching YouTube videos/listening to podcasts.

Because they’ve heard hours and hours from experts, they have a feeling of deep understanding. But talking to them about this topic is extremely frustrating because their knowledge clearly has never had to be applied to the real world, and is grounded in nothingness, so they misunderstand lots, but they feel like they know what they’re talking about as much as you do.

belugacat··on Japan prefectures drift away from posting disaster warnings on X
I’ve been hoping for a Twitter Japan fork like there was for yahoo!…
belugacat··on Apple reports third quarter results
Putting the numbers in perspective is always interesting:

The best selling video game handheld of all time, the Nintendo DS (across all its hardware revisions), sold over 150 million units in its lifetime.

Apple typically sells this many iPhones in less than three quarters.

belugacat··on A world where people pay for software
It is amusing that your argument for software not needing “maintenance” is pointing out 3 pieces of software that had each received 20 years of maintenance by the time they reached the year you picked, 2003.
belugacat··on The tantalizing, lonely search for alien life
If we’re going full speculation -

Microbial life is probably not too uncommon, almost certainly present in our own solar system beyond Earth (and then the big question - does it always originate on its planet, or is cross planetary contamination a thing?)

Complex life that can build tools to send itself to orbit is probably a whole deal less common, but we’re not the only ones nor the first ones in the universe.

It’s just that the scales (time, distance, energy) involved are so wild that the odds of any 2 forms of life encountering each other is practically 0.

Well, if cross contamination between planets is a thing, the most likely way for 2 such complex life forms to interact would be for them to have developed in parallel in the same solar system, and then one discovering the other.

belugacat··on Did Airbnb kill the PM role?
There’s a reason why Airbnb is paying for as many LoveFrom billable hours as they can.
belugacat··on Purchase and manage domains directly through Bluesky
Engineers and designers and PMs are so smart and experienced and so eager to show each other how good at their job they are.

Thorough, complex, expansive feature sets are where those skillsets can shine; no glory in building something simple, to the point, and limited in scope.

Most products suck because people just cannot help themselves. It takes insane focus and control to override those tendencies when hundreds or thousands of people are working on a product (miss you Steve).

belugacat··on Make Your Renders Unnecessarily Complicated by Modeling a Film Camera in Blender [video]
Perhaps https://filmulator.org
belugacat··on Making Games
Andrei Tarkovski:

“An artist never works under ideal conditions. If they existed, his work wouldn’t exist, for the artist doesn’t live in a vacuum. Some sort of pressure must exist. The artist exists because the world is not perfect. Art would be useless if the world were perfect, as man wouldn’t look for harmony but simply live in it. Art is born out of an ill-designed world.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V27XlEDLdtE

belugacat··on Playing sounds of healthy coral on reefs makes fish return (2019)
Welcome to the world we have created. I have a number of artist friends who get accused of posting generated art when it’s theirs. It’s just the new standard from now on.
belugacat··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens:

“Within a couple of millennia, humans in many parts of the world were doing little from dawn to dusk other than taking care of wheat plants. It wasn't easy. Wheat demanded a lot of them. Wheat didn't like rocks and pebbles, so Sapiens broke their backs clearing fields. Wheat didn't like sharing its space, water and nutrients with other plants, so men and women labored long days weeding under the scorching sun. . . . The body of Homo sapiens had not evolved for such tasks. It was adapted to climbing apple trees and running after gazelles, not to clearing rocks and carrying water buckets. Human spines, knees, necks and arches paid the price. Studies of ancient skeletons indicate that the transition to agriculture brought about a plethora of ailments, such as slipped discs, arthritis and hernias. Moreover, the new agricultural tasks demanded so much time that people were forced to settle permanently next to their wheat fields. This completely changed their way of life. We did not domesticate wheat. It domesticated us.”

belugacat··on Why I started (and stopped) making games
The most visible title made with Godot in the last few months I can think of is Brotato.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/1942280/Brotato/

belugacat··on Releasing an indie game on 3 consoles at once and failing financially (2016)
One of the most inspiring things I heard was - if I recall correctly - the Dead Space director giving a talk at GDC.

They were talking how from the get go their mentality was - if we're going to make a horror game, it has to be the most fucking horrifying game anyone has played. If we make a horror game that's kind of scary but not that extreme, then what are we doing?

I've strived to carry that mentality in all my projects since.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →