HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

belugacat

1,221 karma · joined September 1, 2012

French/Californian designer in Tokyo
submissionscomments
belugacat··on Inkbase: Programmable Ink
> I've got an old Mac II ci that I picked up at a thrift store for $12 that came with an old version of Photoshop and an ethernet card that I keep around to remind myself of how little we've progressed. For a machine manufactured in 1989 with performance measured in MHz, it may be noticeably slower, but that's not the point. It's that we're doing the same tired twentieth century stuff we were doing 33 years ago, just slightly faster.

On a computer the size and weight of a paper notebook, with all day battery life, a display whose color quality/resolution/refresh rate were utterly unimaginable 33 years ago, I can have dozens of layers that are up to tens of thousands of pixels in edge size, use advanced AI to generate textures like grass/clouds/etc. or segment arbitrary objects from the background, recomposite all that in real time, etc. etc. etc...

If you haven't used a computer since 33 years ago I highly recommend doing so.

If your argument is that we're still making 2D pictures, well we've been making that for a few thousands (if not tens of thousands) of years. If you want to be making weird experimental 3D/4D/nD VR/AR/xR art stuff there's lots of great tooling for that too (but it won't run on your 1989 Mac...)

belugacat··on Inkbase: Programmable Ink
This is all very fertile territory, it's always good to engage!

I get your point about YouTube videos or Wikipedia pages being "more of the same", in a way. There's a kernel of truth to it, but I don't think that's entirely fair - just the fact that Wikipedia has hyperlinks makes it already immensely more valuable as a tool - and of a fundamentally different medium - than a traditional encyclopedia. Same for animated/dynamic/interactive graphics that are trivial to embed in a webpage but impossible to represent on paper or on a TV screen.

But point taken, it feels like computers somehow ~should~ enable something more radical. When pushing for the Macintosh in education in the 80s, Steve Jobs used to talk about how computers might one day enable students to ask questions directly to Socrates about what he wrote and have them answered, rather than not being able to engage with a text beyond reading it. I think that's what you're getting at.

Now what is really interesting about this is that it gets to the core of what we (think we) want from teaching - having a perfectly patient interlocutor to whom we can ask questions, who can clarify misunderstandings, guide our attention, etc. Maybe this is something that we'll be able to build given recent breakthroughs around language nets. I don't think we're anywhere near but it's an interesting lead for sure. A "Socrates chat bot" that could meaningfully answer questions and clarify confusion about what he meant would be very impressive.

Bartosz' work is utterly fantastic, and is part of a broader movement termed by some as "explorables" (https://explorabl.es). Explorables also (unsurprisingly) have their roots in the early days of computer science, where a handful of computer scientists and educators saw the formidable synergy between constructivist approaches to pedagogy, and software ("Mindstorms" by Papert is a seminal text here). There's plenty of cool work in that field from the last half century (which I contributed to in my own minute way when I was in grad school). That general idea - give students computer models to manipulate so they can intuitively develop a mental model for things! - has lots of work behind it.

But does that work effectively scale out, and translate to better student outcomes at a societal level? I don't want to say it's a big resounding no, but... it's not encouraging. We're certainly way past the optimism of the early 2000s OLPC when we thought that all we had to do was give students a laptop loaded with educational software to "fix" education.

To follow one of your points, the explorables website linked above has hundreds of them listed - if they could just be handed off to students and suddenly dramatically improve outcomes, teachers would certainly be doing that.

So we're back to our original question - if this is all stuff we've been doing and exploring for half a century, why isn't it more widespread? Why hasn't it meaningfully improved our issues? [0] Is it because we haven't done enough of it, because we're missing some key insights? Or is it because maybe it doesn't solve the problem in as a fundamental way as we would hope?

And that's where I tend to fall more into the latter camp - education is fundamentally a social process, learning environment matters a lot, students are not always going to be receptive and the role of the teacher is also knowing how to handle that. An adult can tell you "stop screwing around" in a way that computers (or an ideal Socrates chatbot) can't - that's also "education".

A 3rd grade teacher's biggest challenges lie more with keeping their (often oversized) class focused, teaching all the points they need to get to, trying to have a meaningful impact - any impact - on the students who come to school hungry or improperly clothed or fundamentally opposed to learning anything [1] because of a crappy family situation - than a need for more interactive materials.

Here's a nice short video I recently saw of a great math teacher in action; I encourage you to watch it.

https://www.youcubed.org/resources/summer-math-camp-the-dot-...

The value of the teaching here is not so much the content, which could easily be summarized in a sentence and few pictures. The pedagogical value here all comes from the teacher, and how she manages the class, gives everyone a voice, reinterprets their answer in the context of the original question and what she wants to demonstrate, etc.

My question to the reader: do you think this little math exercise for middle schoolers would be as effective as a webpage, no matter how interactive? Or does its value come from the fact that it is a social, embodied, cooperative process?

[0]: One thing that has been repeatedly demonstrated to raise student achievement: giving out free lunches. https://www.maxwell.syr.edu/docs/default-source/research/cpr...

[1]: Here's a fun one I've heard from French teachers: male muslim kids who openly defy female teachers because they were taught non muslim women are not supposed to be sources of authority.

belugacat··on Inkbase: Programmable Ink
I've worked in education (as a teacher), and in edtech, trying to build such systems. I used to share some of your views and frustrations.

Your post brings 2 thoughts to my mind:

1) I disagree with your characterization of "our best online knowledge resource". I assume you're talking about Wikipedia, sure that's one way to characterize it (albeit not the most genuine IMO). But Wikipedia is a tiny part of the picture; we also have YouTube (with millions of creators from all cultures/languages/fields), Khan Academy, the Internet Archive, your local library, and countless other resources. That's the beauty of the internet: it's decentralized. No centralized service can fulfill every single knowledge need because knowledge gets formed when an individual has to integrate multiple sources of information and reconcile it with their experience of the world (sorry, fans of Young Lady's Illustrated Primer; it was always a literary illusion). Otherwise it's not much more than just regurgitating propaganda.

2) Ultimately, software doesn't really matter for education. What matters is that kids have a physically safe (heated/cooled, with access to food, clean restrooms, etc) facility, and are under the guidance of teachers who are in an environment conducive to quality teaching (eg classes of reasonable sizes, administrators that don't micromanage them, etc). I've seen this "we just need the right interactive software to fix education!" fallacy so many times amongst tech people. Sure, in the hands of competent teachers who have the above, tech & software can enhance learning. But it's not the fundamental piece. And many, many schools (in the US and in many "developed" countries) lack those fundamentals. If you want to "imagine where we could be as a civilization", that's where you have to improve things.

Sorry, I know "it's not about the tech, it's about the people and basic physical environment" is a terribly boring answer for a hacker. But spend some time teaching, or building fancy software that ultimately doesn't do much for student outcomes, and I suspect you will observe the same.

belugacat··on Inkbase: Programmable Ink
I don’t see Engelbart’s work - and all other similar pioneering work that routinely gets brought up anytime HCI folks get together to wax poetic about what could be - as reminder of how much more progress lies ahead of us.

In fact, most of the things shown in those demos can be done today - perhaps in more narrow ways, but fundamentally we have collaborative document editing, video chat, complex live drawing tools, multi stream video editing, handwriting recognition, etc etc etc. All operating at scales that could only be dreamt of in these early days.

What it brings to my mind though is that software doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Writing software requires many hours of human effort, maintaining it even more so. Sustained, focused, organized human effort requires funding of some sort [0]. Software exists to solve problems, and in our globalized capitalistic economies, it means the value of software does not lie in reaching some paragon of pure academic composability/extensibility, but in solving concrete problems for people while meeting some arbitrary costs/tradeoffs.

This is why those “tools for thoughts” demos seem to always rehash the same ideas and get stuck circling around the same drain that Engelbart & Kay & friends charted 50 years ago; in the meantime, some industrial company you’ve never heard of is paying a few consultants big bucks to come up with “boring” Excel spreadsheets that are just as much “tools for thought” as anything else that humans use.

Now, am I satisfied with this state of affairs, and would I love to see what models for writing and maintaining software could exist in a non capitalistic culture? Absolutely not, and absolutely.

But that seems to me to be more the root cause of why we’re still chasing the Engelbart mirage over half a century later, rather than some fundamental/conceptual “progress” to be made.

[0] and speaking of funding, it is interesting to look at what funding environments those open ended “tools for thought” projects tend to come from; more often than not academia, or in the case of ink and switch, an independently wealthy PI. Places directly connected to money making ventures, like Xerox PARC or MSR, are short lived, and few and far between.

belugacat··on Artist feeds childhood diary into GPT-3 to have a chat with herself
It is her performing talking to herself. She's as much "talking to herself" than if she had written and then performed a play about talking to herself. The computer/AI aspect of it is "just" a prop for the performance.
belugacat··on Being OK with not being extraordinary (2021)
Existing systems - especially heavily ossified ones, such as academia - are the worst at rewarding exceptional novelty as described by GP. They tend to reward conformism (exceptional conformism, sure!).

If you feel like you’re reaching a glass ceiling, don’t be afraid to go outside that box. Record some lectures and put them online. Self publish a book. Start your own school. Etc. (The exact way you can color outside those lines will heavily depend on your context, but you want to be coloring outside the lines).

belugacat··on Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs
Some jobs birds have been forced/trained to perform through history and cultures, I'm sure I've missed a few:

Fisher: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cormorant_fishing

Hunter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falconry

Racer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigeon_racing

Mount: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_ostrich#Racing

Fortune teller: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ornithomancy

Fighter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cockfight

belugacat··on Apple iPhone 14 Pro Camera test
Look to the Fuji GFX 100S for the future of digital cameras. Large optics + a medium format surface area sensor at 100MP is not something phones can rival anytime soon (or perhaps even ever, given the physics at play and the form factor phones require).

Right now you need to drop ~$6k to get started with digital medium format, but hopefully that’ll be sub $1k a few years down the line.

belugacat··on PhD gets 5x increase in postdoc interview invitations by just changing his name
The post referenced:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32880510

As the comments show, the submission had other issues.

belugacat··on Mammals Won the Dinosaurs' World
Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens:

“Within a couple of millennia, humans in many parts of the world were doing little from dawn to dusk other than taking care of wheat plants. It wasn't easy. Wheat demanded a lot of them. Wheat didn't like rocks and pebbles, so Sapiens broke their backs clearing fields. Wheat didn't like sharing its space, water and nutrients with other plants, so men and women labored long days weeding under the scorching sun. . . .

The body of Homo sapiens had not evolved for such tasks. It was adapted to climbing apple trees and running after gazelles, not to clearing rocks and carrying water buckets. Human spines, knees, necks and arches paid the price. Studies of ancient skeletons indicate that the transition to agriculture brought about a plethora of ailments, such as slipped discs, arthritis and hernias.

Moreover, the new agricultural tasks demanded so much time that people were forced to settle permanently next to their wheat fields. This completely changed their way of life. We did not domesticate wheat. It domesticated us.”

belugacat··on Gen Z and the rise of influencer culture
Those are questionable parallels. Music, acting, sports, writing, etc are human practices many millenia old, recognized as such by universities, labor unions, etc.

Influencing on the other hand is primarily about being an intermediary for platform/advertiser relationships. If one were to stretch things a bit, I guess you could say they're performers deriving their income from private companies.

But even then there's probably still a little bit of a difference between a theater actor performing a role in MacBeth and a teen getting a commission off sneakers they advertise on Tiktok.

belugacat··on The great Miyazaki watch of 2022
> Keep Your Hands Off Eizouken!

One of the best animes I have ever seen. Celebrates the inherent deep joy in making, set in a low key solarpunk world. A breath of fresh air.

No surprise Masaaki Yuasa was involved, his latest movie Inu-Oh gave me similar feelings of ecstasy by combining off the walls psychedelic animation with a 14th century historical Noh theater inspired rock opera. So good.

belugacat··on Put it on the crazy pile: Ideas and creativity
In the “Office Ladies” podcast (where actresses from the TV show The Office recount their days working on it), they mention the writers had a similar “candy bag” they’d put ideas in when they couldn’t work them in the episode they were working on, from which to pull down the line.
belugacat··on In Remote Alaska, Meal Planning Is Everything
There is nuance to all of this obviously, as with anything cultural, but in short - yes.

Large swaths of the US population have been deprived of food culture for several generations now. There are many exceptions of course - Latino family bbqs in Southern California, or Cajun crawfish boils, are examples of food culture that’s well and alive that I’ve experienced personally. But you also have many Americans for whom the act of procuring ingredients and cooking is something so distant that it’s essentially alien - it’s been replaced by fast food, gas station food (frozen pizza, box of Mac & cheese), food delivery, etc. I’ve lived places where you had to easily drive 50-100 miles to find a farmer’s market - something unthinkable in Europe.

Nowhere is this more visible than in schools. In French schools, it’s not uncommon for the people making the food to make seasonal/local recipes, eat it with the kids, maybe even involving them lightly in the process. In the US, school cafeterias often are serving what is essentially gas station food.

(a funny side effect of that is Americans traveling abroad get their mind blown by foreign gas station food - see for example the sempiternal meme of tourists having their mind blown by the very mediocre Japanese konbini sandwiches)

Many have written about this, Michael Pollan is probably the most famous one.

belugacat··on The Algorithm for Hard Problems: Shake and Pull Gently
Interesting article, but you’ll notice he adjusts his grip around 0”12 because if he had kept just shaking and gently pulling they’d still have knotted. Similarly, the initial grip is already biased a certain way.

That human intuition about the physical system isn’t really captured in the algorithm. I’d be curious what rate of success a machine that truly just “shakes and pulls” would have in untangling headphones.

belugacat··on Talking about layoffs
As tech workers we're in a great position to move the needle a bit more towards a cooperative/worker owned model for our livelihoods and careers. That would address a lot of the problems here around the impersonality of it all, having to lose meaningful relationships, obscurity around business decisions, etc.
belugacat··on Did the early medieval era ever take place?
> substantially true, if overly harsh

That tracks with the professor being French.

belugacat··on Citybound – A city building game using actor-based distributed simulation
I agree about the siren song aspect, and how full system simulation is very non correlated to fun, but I think it’s one of those things where we haven’t seen the full potential yet - we’re still maybe a few computational leaps away from it.

Kind of like ray tracing, or voxel worlds; for the latter, Minecraft was a great example of a first game meeting that “computation required” vs “fun” slope intercept; Teardown is a more recent game that uses its voxel engine to enable novel gameplay that would be totally infeasible without it.

belugacat··on Ask HN: SWE who started an organic farm in Europe, where did you go?
Yes, that's one thing that surprised me, as someone who mostly grew up in a large french city and then left the country altogether during my university years - I had this image of the more rural areas as being completely dead - but like you say, tons of young local associations doing awesome things and cultural life going on.

I'm surprised that most of my neighbors in my 1800 people village are relatively young (30s/40s) with kids, again I had this image that it would only be old farmers.

belugacat··on Scarcity and precarity in small manufacturing
You can click on the domain name in the post to see the few other submissions there have been; the most successful one was the Experimental Music Notation thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17166055).
belugacat··on Ask HN: SWE who started an organic farm in Europe, where did you go?
Same as with everything in life, we never have enough time, so you get help from others, and you make sure to make time for what you want to do.

I guess I won't starve if my beans don't make it, which is a nice privilege for sure.

Also not having kids helps a lot with remaining master of your time and energy :)

belugacat··on Ask HN: SWE who started an organic farm in Europe, where did you go?
Also French, did the same thing (albeit in the Alps rather than the south :) after being very burned out living in a tiny San Francisco apartment during Covid, post LTR breakup.

Huge boost for my mental health - I can go for beautiful walks anytime I want, the local village has a huge sense of community, I've been spending more time with my family (which I'd neglected while building my career abroad over the last 15 years), the food is so tasty and all local, I'm very close (~30 min drive) to mid sized cities, and my cost of living necessities is not even 1k euro a month...

The one downside is that dating is pretty close to impossible. Pretty much anyone over the age of 25 has kids, and it's not in tiny mountain villages that you'll find people who are into the same kind of nerdy multicultural things that you are. (the postwoman is pretty cute but huh that seems like a bad idea). I've been back in the bay area for work since, but turns out "I spend most of my time on a farm in rural Europe" is a turnoff for city people, YMMV.

So definitely do it after you're partnered, if that matters to you.

belugacat··on No, DALL-E doesn’t have a secret language
Given that DALL-E is a giant matrix multiplication that correlates fuzzy concepts in text to fuzzy concepts in images, wouldn't one expect that there will be hotspots of nonsensical (to us) correlations, eg between "apoploe vesrreaitais" and "bird"? Intuitively feels like an aspect of the no free lunch theorem.
belugacat··on We asked 100 humans to draw the DALL·E prompts
The best, most concise description of AI generated content (whether textual or visual) I’ve read (I believe it was here on HN) is that “it gets to the topic, but not to the point”.

In other words, while GPT, DALL-E, etc. are good at making things that superficially match the prompt given to them, vaguely seeming coherent, the moment you inspect them closer they do not guide your attention, or create a broader artefact with inter coherent sub parts, the way a human artist/writer would.

It’s hard to tell if that’s an inherent limitation of approaches based on statistical sampling rather than “true understanding” or not. That criticism has held so far over the last decade of progress, so I doubt “more parameters/training data/resolution/etc” is the answer.

belugacat··on Research helps explain how Ritalin sharpens attention
There’s an argument that goes as follows: in a hunter/gatherer context, ADHD is beneficial because the natural world is so rich, an attention flitting around looking out for a potential prey hiding quietly in the trees, berries nestled in leaves, a predator that might lurk behind, etc… would be a good thing.

In a world where kids are expected to sit their butt on a chair 8 hours a day listening to a burnt out adult babble incessantly, not so much.

belugacat··on The singularity is close?
https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1210489109

This is what they’re referencing

belugacat··on Ask HN: Does anyone else question USB-C as an “improvement”?
I feel like 80% of my frustration with USB C would be gone if I could know, for any device, "is this charging as fast as it could"? Ideally that's a question that'd be answered by the software UI, but shockingly none of the many USB C devices I own displays that information.

I have a USB C cable that has a small screen built in to the connector that will display wattage, it's a really nifty product (search Amazon, there are a bunch of random brands selling them). I hope to see more screens/visual indicators built in to cables to communicate what's happening over the connection, that'd help with the problems you've outlined to an extent.

belugacat··on The Only Unbreakable Law [video]
This is kind of getting into weird semantics.

For what it’s worth I hold a BSc from a large, reputable UK university in computer science, not informatics, so it’s not as universal as you suggest.

I do also hold an undergraduate degree from a French university in informatique, a contraction of “information automatique”. Both words are equally important in the name of that discipline, and the “automatique” part is very much about process.

But we are debating the map here, not the territory.

belugacat··on The magic of the Japanese convenience store sandwich
We call that terroir. Bread isn't just bread - it's made from flour milled a certain way, made from a certain kind of wheat, that grew in a certain kind of soil, combined with a certain kind of yeast, a certain kind of salt, a certain kind of water. Ham isn't just ham - it's a certain kind of pig, raised in a certain way, that had a certain kind of diet. Cheese isn't... well you get it.

You're not tasting just 3 ingredients.

belugacat··on There was a time before Mathematica (2013)
He’s had tremendous success and impact through the work that his outlook on the world enabled. I can’t see how there’d be any incentive to update one’s self view in those circumstances.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →