HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bengillies

456 karma · joined May 6, 2011

http://bengillies.net
submissionscomments
bengillies··on Decrypting Amber Rudd
It's hard to know what's actually going on behind closed doors, but it sounds like the tech companies want to do something about it and are quite prepared to work with the government on a solution.

Of course, what that solution turns out to be is a separate issue. I trust Google et al to know what they're talking about wrt encryption far more than the UK government though, so actively working with tech companies is a huge step up from the previous position (though obviously a long way still to go).

bengillies··on Why traditional password managers are flawed
If you store settings related to password system requirements on a per site basis then you're leaking the existence of your account on that site, which often needs to be private itself.
bengillies··on Code I’m Still Ashamed Of
Ultimately though, we can only speak for our own moral choices. If you're happy with doing something unethical or illegal, then go ahead. If you're not prepared to, then don't. If you refuse though, then what happens afterwards isn't up to you and doesn't impact on your morals and/or character. The best you can hope for is to know that you played no part in the wrongdoing.
bengillies··on How Thatcher killed the UK's superfast broadband before it even existed
This isn't about deployment of broadband (though it's certainly related), it's about rollout of fibre, which can be used for other services (such as TV) as well.
bengillies··on The use of JIRA is (often) a symptom of a Management problem
Right and as it says in the title, use of JIRA is often a symptom that there is a problem with management. Nowhere is it stated that JIRA itself is the problem.
bengillies··on Stop using React for everything
> It is not the one-size-fits-all solution you are using it as. If your site has a dynamic form, you don’t need a freaking virtual DOM.

The main benefit of virtual DOM afaict is that it makes rendering on the server trivial without needing to jump through all the hoops that, e.g. Angular has to. Contrary to the post, this makes it ideal for such sites.

bengillies··on Think Retro: How HyperCard inspired a generation of future developers
People interested in Hypercard should probably check out the new, improved version of TiddlyWiki http://tiddlywiki.com/
bengillies··on Recent Train Times
At the very least it clarifies with actual metrics how terrible the service is.
bengillies··on Beyond Light Table
If they want to reach a billion people then starting off by targeting all 1 billion is probably the wrong way of going about it.
bengillies··on Banned for Life
Getting banned from publishing apps to the Play Store is reasonable and proportional. Getting banned from all Google services whether related or not seems a bit much imho.
bengillies··on Black families fight to get fair discipline for their children in schools
Without commenting on this specific case, it's often a lot more difficult and nuanced than simply what is best for that individual child. If you're in a class full of around 30 children and one child is misbehaving to the extent that they're a danger to others around them, then sure, ideally you'd spend the time with that child and do what's right and best for them, but in reality you also need to think of all the other children in the class and what's right for them and often, the amount of time you'd need to spend with such a child would unreasonably distract you from helping out the other 29 children which simply isn't fair on them. Often, punishment in such cases is simply there to enable the teacher to continue teaching the rest of the class (with the limited resources at their disposal) so that at least the majority can learn and benefit.
bengillies··on Poetica
As I understand it the idea is that your email address is your identity so you only need to remember that (which most people are capable of) rather than having to a) remember your username/password (which can at least be stored in LastPass, etc for you) or b) having to remember which one of the social login buttons to click on.

If you signed up with a yahoo email address for example, it would (I think) let you login with a yahoo account instead.

bengillies··on A symbol of British democracy, "The Queen shows us who isn't boss"
The Russian revolution is a much more recent example I think.
bengillies··on A symbol of British democracy, "The Queen shows us who isn't boss"
Not to say anything about anything else that he's done, but is search and rescue not a worthwhile thing to do then?
bengillies··on Ask HN: Everyone loves my startup concept, why is no one using it?
It seems like you've thought about the experience for end users, but I can't see a way to actually try it out (from an end user perspective) from your homepage.
bengillies··on David Cameron: TV crime dramas prove we need warrantless electronic surveillance
> "There's hardly a crime drama where a crime is solved without using the data of a mobile communications device."

All you can really tell from that statement though is that script writers enjoy adding in wiretapping, etc as it's both reasonably engaging to watch and really easy to write about. It says nothing whatsoever about actual policing or indeed the ramifications involved.

bengillies··on Nobel winner declares boycott of top science journals
It's probably worth pointing out that open access, while important, isn't really relevant to this discussion as publishers like Nature already embrace open access.

(disclaimer, I work for Digital Science, which is owned by the company that owns Nature)

bengillies··on Why GitHub is not your CV
> "OSS as a hiring filter biases your selection process toward white men"... not sure what to say.

OSS as a hiring filter biases your selection process toward people who are either paid to do it at their current job, or who have few enough prior commitments in the rest of their life to be able to afford to do it outside of work.

I'm not sure whether it biases towards white men or not, but I'm pretty sure it biases towards younger people and against people who are in enterprisey companies (or who work on private contracts).

bengillies··on Nexus 5 Teardown
Pretty sure it's more to do with most people likely not ever needing more than 16/32GB over the lifetime of their phone, meaning adding a microSD slot would be simply a waste of time, effort and space.
bengillies··on For modern development Javascript indeed is a shit language
Right and ClojureScript, for example, has full goroutines in it (i.e. core.async) if doing standard callback based async in JS isn't your thing.

Functionally, it makes little to no difference whether you're writing something that compiles down to JS or writing something that compiles down to its own runtime (assuming you turn source maps on your browser).

bengillies··on For modern development Javascript indeed is a shit language
- GWT - Dart - ClojureScript
bengillies··on Sir Trevor Editor
Well, theoretically IE9 users should all be automatically upgraded to IE10 anyway, so IE9 has less market share than IE8 at the moment (see http://www.netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx?qpri...).
bengillies··on Always return on events is faster, but why?
right. undefined is falsy, but it's quite different to false (i.e. undefined !== false)
bengillies··on Should I learn Java
I get that it's supposed to be funny but if you want to, for example, do anything on Android, then the answer is most definitely yes.
bengillies··on Confusing UI in iOS7
The problem with pretending to be someone unfamiliar with touch UI (and computers in general) is that whatever you claim to be confusing is still just conjecture. You claim one thing, Apple claims another. If you'd highlighted the parts that are genuinely confusing to you (and I'm sure they exist) rather than talking about rectangles v.s. red things in corners, or written up a walk-through with someone who realistically might get that confused (not denying they exist), then it would be easier to take this post seriously.
bengillies··on Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat
People generally won't be confronted with Nestle's questionable practices though, so it's likely a non issue. At any rate enough people either don't know, or don't care to make KitKat a popular enough brand for Google to do well out of it.
bengillies··on New iPad browser from Opera
At least override the scrolling in the right direction (i.e. horizontally)
bengillies··on Who Spies More, The United States Or Europe?
TL;DR: NSA man claims Europe more likely to spy on citizens than US. Uses study done without knowledge of PRISM (presumably) to back claim up.
bengillies··on [dead]
I fail to see what Mitt Romney has to do with this. Care to explain what exactly you're proposing?
bengillies··on US sends pre-emptive warrant to Ireland to stop Snowden flight refuelling there
It's perfectly reasonable to enjoy most of the things about a country and still find issues with it. It's also perfectly reasonable to question and complain about stuff when you think it's wrong. Not doing that, putting your fingers in your ears and running away is arguably the worse crime.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →