HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

benregenspan

413 karma · joined September 9, 2010

submissionscomments
benregenspan··on Show HN: Easy Email Encryption inside Gmail (Alpha, Open-Source)
While the security granted by this may be imperfect, "no real security" seems like a bit of a stretch. This eliminates the main pathways by which governments obtain access to email (subpoena of the service provider and straightforward interception of the mail as it is transmitted). Combine that with a webmail service like Gmail where the company providing it has a very real incentive to prevent code injection, and with browser vendors being exceptionally fast at finding and patching exploits, and it's hard to say that this isn't far better than nothing at all.
benregenspan··on A Dark Room - minimalist text-based game
It can be made a decent amount more difficult with some simple changes like obfuscating the source and also encapsulating all the object definitions and state in a closure, instead of putting it all in global variables. Of course I think that would violate the minimal spirit of the game and it's really cool to be able to see its source so easily.
benregenspan··on Microsoft Announces Direct Cash Payments For Vulnerabilities
"Redmond, Washington-based Microsoft (MSFT) and other software or Internet security companies have been aware that this type of early alert allowed the U.S. to exploit vulnerabilities in software sold to foreign governments, according to two U.S. officials"

From this and other assertions made in the Bloomberg piece, it seems very fair not to read this as conventional patch management, but as a special arrangement with intelligence agencies. And to read this as, yes, from time to time Microsoft's help does get the NSA into Windows boxes.

Now, we all know that tech reporting often leaves something to be desired. If you're saying the officials were wrong or quoted out of context, then that's fine. But it's not reasonable to dismiss this out of hand as some outlandish Alex Jonesian conspiracy theory.

BTW, obviously I'm not saying that Microsoft's bug bounty program is an NSA plot. It's a good program that every major company should have. I'm also not saying that they don't share bugs with other partners ahead of time, they obviously do. Just that from what the sources in this article (which again, did not originally appear on infowars.com) say, Microsoft does have a special arrangement with intelligence agencies and from time to time has shared bugs knowing they might be exploited by said agencies. The bug bounty program could find the sort of bugs that would (incidentally) be shared as part of this arrangement.

benregenspan··on Microsoft Announces Direct Cash Payments For Vulnerabilities
I don't see what's wrong with speculating about this. It seems to be a completely valid concern given the recent news that Microsoft has, in the past, shared 0-days with the NSA. It is not an outlandish conspiracy theory to think that, after being informed of a vulnerability, Microsoft could pass it on to intelligence agencies in advance of Patch Tuesday, giving them up to 2 weeks' time to make use of the exploits. "Past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior", and all that.

[edit]Link for reference, if anyone missed that particular news: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-said-t... [/edit]

benregenspan··on Torservers.net: Professional Global Tor infrastructure
(But to compromise many users, there might not be a need for a complicated, expensive large-scale attack -- if you can infect someone with malware, it renders whether or not they are using Tor moot).
benregenspan··on Torservers.net: Professional Global Tor infrastructure
Tor is open-source and its developers and supporters include the EFF, Jacob Appelbaum, and others who (if you can trust anyone at all) would not cooperate with government surveillance. But again, it's open-source and lots of security experts regularly look at the code, so it's not so much a matter of blind trust. The reason it was funded by the US government is described at http://cryptome.org/0003/tor-spy.htm -- not because it helps governments to spy on users but precisely the opposite.

The fact that it's very unlikely it was created as part of some conspiracy doesn't mean that it's impossible to compromise a Tor user's anonymity. I'm not an expert but as far as I know the most credible large-scale attack against it is still the one described in this paper: http://wesscholar.wesleyan.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1... . To be successful, it requires controlling a very large proportion of Tor's entry and exit nodes.

benregenspan··on Zynga to Lay Off 520 Employees and shutter NY and LA Offices
And indeed, that's why they've hired at least one behavioral psychologist. (http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1940668,00....)
benregenspan··on PayPal.com XSS Vulnerability
This seems like it's just plain XSS - it doesn't take advantage of a user's serverside session to forge an action on their behalf.
benregenspan··on Use Google Analytics on your blog? Check your bounce rate
That's the definition of a bounce. A visitor comes, they check out one page, they don't interact with anything (reading is not interaction), they leave. This might not be the most useful thing to know for many sites (a simple blog which doesn't have "recirculation" modules / isn't, like larger media sites, geared to having someone come and stay), but it certainly is a useful concept for media sites where pageviews are still king.

But even on a simple blog, bounce rate is a useful stat. Many bloggers don't just want people to come from Hacker News and stay for one article, they want these visitors to click around to related entries after they are done reading. Bounce rate gives a good idea of whether this is happening or not (unless you automatically count almost all visits as non-bounce by triggering an event after a brief time interval).

benregenspan··on Social login buttons aren't worth it
The title is total linkbait -- once you read through the article, it becomes clear that all the author is claiming is that social login buttons weren't the right choice for Mailchimp. They might be the right choice for others though: "Sometimes it makes a lot of sense, and other times it’s just not worth the trade-offs".

Although Mailchimp has a lot of users, it doesn't make sense to generalize conclusions from one SaaS business to the whole web. A private SaaS dashboard is a different use case from most consumer websites, where the goal of logging in with Twitter or Facebook is generally to attach your public identity to your posts or profile on the site, not merely to expedite login. And frankly, a private dashboard is a very strange place to add social login buttons in the first place. Although the "what login did I use?" issue comes up on consumer websites that make good use of social auth, it does so less often, because if you connected a third-party account to one of these sites, you did it for a reason and are more likely to remember.

benregenspan··on A web design masterpiece.....from hell.
Impressive, but when I'm looking for a fully immersive business homepage experience nothing beats http://industrialpainter.com/
benregenspan··on The Oxford Comma and The Internet
While I don't want to take an unfunny joke I made in the Hacker News comments too far and am sorry for hurting any British people's feelings, "drunk driving" does make sense as a literal description of an act, unlike "drink driving". "Drunk" is an adjective which modifies "driving" (which is used as a noun in this case).
benregenspan··on The Oxford Comma and The Internet
"And while there are many Americans who care deeply about their beloved comma, in the UK (outside of the OUP) it's rarely used."

The British call drunk driving "drink driving", which is nonsensical. Based on this fact alone, the rest of the English-speaking world should disregard their writing patterns when determining correct usage.

benregenspan··on Flight: A lightweight, component-based JavaScript framework from Twitter
Why not just use Flash?
benregenspan··on GIMP 2.9/2.10 Feature Preview
I used GIMP the same way up until recently. It worked for me, but switching to Photoshop has sped up a ton of common workflow -- slicing an image, turning on and off groups of layers, and similar. Also I've found that some small tweak to the PSD is almost inevitably needed, and it's worth the cost of Photoshop not to have to wait for an updated design from someone else.

I don't want to just hate on open-source graphics software - a lot of amazing work has gone into GIMP, it had fun things like content-aware resizing before Photoshop did, but Adobe has 1000X the resources to invest in usability and they've used those resources well.

benregenspan··on Websites Vary Prices, Deals Based on Users' Information
Why are Swingline staplers perpetual objects of injustice?
benregenspan··on The Five NYC Taxi Drivers who Refused My Fare
Was about to write the same thing. Taxi drivers aren't stupid and they weren't "fail[ing] to respect" the author, they want to maximize their earnings, they also want to get their cars back before the set shift change; if they're late they have to pay a fine (http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/12/nyregion/12taxi.html?_r=0).

The advice people are giving to just jump in the cab applies in the case where the driver's off-duty light is not on, but the rider looks like they're going to some part of Brooklyn (or wherever) that the driver doesn't want to go, and the driver is wrongly being selective. The situation of having to just jump in the car has never come up for me in Manhattan with an on-duty car, it has before in Brooklyn though.

benregenspan··on The Root Kit
Wasn't this already done in a truly exemplary fashion by Hackers (1995)?
benregenspan··on Need The Lord Of The Rings Timeline? It's On Your Mac
It would appear this was fixed upstream and OSX just hasn't pulled in the latest. http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=224407
benregenspan··on Free worldwide calls for a month
And all you have to do to get them is log into someone else's account!
benregenspan··on All the crypto code you've ever written is probably broken
This post does not go at all into the "why" of authenticated encryption. If you're interested in more of the reasons for authenticating, including actual attacks it protects against, I found http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2012/05/how-to-choos... to be a good explanation of this.
benregenspan··on Escape from Callback Hell: Callbacks are the modern goto
There are alternatives that don't require extending the language or having to work directly with a mess of nested callbacks. A bunch of flow-control libraries here: http://dailyjs.com/2012/02/20/new-flow-control-libraries/

This is definitely more hairy to use than if the language supported it natively, but not so bad, and can be implemented in a very lightweight way (this approach http://daemon.co.za/2012/04/simple-async-with-only-underscor... is a few lines of code on top of Underscore.js which a lot of sites are using already).

(PS: sorry if OP's article already mentioned this stuff, I can't load it at the moment)

benregenspan··on Rescue.js
If your minifier/obfuscator supports creation of source maps, it's simple. You just need to set a flag to tell it to create the map along with minified JS and you're good to go. UglifyJS2 and Closure Compiler are among those that can create a source map.
benregenspan··on How (And Why) I'm Circumventing Twitter's API Instead of Using It
Needless to say, this is an awful idea for anything besides a small personal project. PhantomJS or no, it's easy to detect this behavior, and also easy to understand why Twitter would be against it.
benregenspan··on Path menu in pure CSS3
Let's be clear: "security-conscious users" who turn off Javascript are a very small minority. If a site is geared towards serving developers or small startups, it might be serving this minority. If not, SEO ("how do I make this site readable by search engines?") will be a much larger concern than "graceful degradation for the benefit of the tiny few who care about security enough to disable Javascript or use NoScript but not whitelist my sites' scripts". Often designing something to gracefully degrade will serve both SEO and security-conscious users, but in cases where it won't (this case for example -- where Google decidedly doesn't care about the layout of the navigation items, as long as they're accessible to it), there's not much incentive to find a pure-CSS approach when a pure-JS approach might be simpler.
benregenspan··on Facebook is gaslighting the web. We can fix it.
But you didn't make a case either that Facebook is attempting to mislead users, or indeed that their actions are misleading users at all. A number of sites gate outbound traffic for security reasons, and the language Facebook shows users is totally consistent with this - it doesn't read "You are about to visit a dangerous site", instead it warns users in generic language of phishing, etc. The error here is attributing malice to a bug or annoyingly-implemented feature. That feature clearly falls short of any reasonable "badware" criteria.
benregenspan··on Facebook is gaslighting the web. We can fix it.
Agreed. I was expecting a much more substantial argument from Anil, but instead the post offers a list of disparate concerns without any real attempt made to link them together or to justify such strong statements. There are all kinds of explanations for discontinuing RSS import support and for malware warnings that do not point to nefariousness on the part of Facebook.
benregenspan··on Facebook is gaslighting the web. We can fix it.
But as lbrandy mentioned, this is in one rare case and appears to be the result of a bug. If this happened when most links were clicked leaving Facebook, you can rest assured that all publishers would be up in arms.
benregenspan··on Stross: Klout violates UK privacy laws.
As far as I can tell, the claim of automatically creating accounts is 100% false. So is that of automatically Tweeting or Facebook sharing.

If you sign in to Klout, you'll get fairly in-your-face pitches to invite friends to it. Should you choose to send such an invite, the friend you sent it to would have to respond to this and manually OAuth their account. Similarly, sharing an action taken on Klout to Facebook or Twitter is a manual process. I don't remember seeing any "dark patterns"* at work at all here - nothing is sent automatically, there's no sneaky small print or prefilled checkbox, etc.

It seems the author is also confusing account creation with the service requesting and storing public data from Twitter. Twitter's own privacy policy (https://twitter.com/privacy) is clear re: content being available to search engines and via API. If people do not want their Tweets to be available to search engines and third-party sites that comply with Twitter's policies, they can set their Twitter profiles to private, or can use a service that does not have such an open ecosystem.

* http://wiki.darkpatterns.org/Home

benregenspan··on Facebook privacy fuckup reveals who has your number in their phone
Then "privacy fuckup" is a somewhat hyperbolic choice of phrase for this, isn't it? And it's misleading to mention private investigators and law enforcement when the friend list is only shown after the phone number has been verified.

The potential privacy compromise here is that people who might've not wanted the user to know that they had them in their synced-to-Facebook phonebook, or may have a secret profile connected to said phonebook, could be unwittingly exposed to the user. As your example of the friend with the hidden gay profile shows, that can have alarming results. I'd say that example's bad enough and worth addressing (even if the answer is just better messaging about how synced phonebooks can be used) and that the PI/law enforcement talk is just muddying the waters.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →