HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

betterunix2

3,500 karma · joined September 18, 2017

submissionscomments
betterunix2··on AMD Ryzen 6000 Series Mobile CPUs Feature Microsoft's Pluton Security
"If the technology delivers value"

The technology does not deliver value for users. It has always been intended to benefit Microsoft and their media partners, with a bit of window-dressing meant to trick users into believing that they somehow gain from it. This is possible only because the current market for personal computers has almost no meaningful competition.

"I just removed a crypto-miner malware from an IT-illiterate friend's windows computer"

...and malware authors will use DRM systems like this to make it harder to detect their malware. Instead of, "Hm, CRYPTOMINER.EXE is spinning the CPU" it will be "Something seems to be spinning the CPU but the platform DRM is preventing me from figuring out what is happening."

"some level of platform integrity"

Except that this system does not ensure platform integrity. Sure, firmware and bootloader signing can protect against malware or at least give users the ability to reset their system to a good state, but we are talking about a DRM system and that is a very different story.

Of course, Microsoft's track record on bootloader security is mixed. They have been willing to allow major Linux distros to get a signed "shim" that can be used to bootstrap grub, but they also made a deliberate and arbitrary decision to forbid vendors of ARM systems from allowing users to disable secure boot. The result is that users who want to run their own bootloader, with whatever risk that entails, have less choice in hardware and are forced to spend more. So while UEFI was generally a win for end user security, it came with a strategic effort by Microsoft to exert greater control over user devices -- something which only benefits Microsoft and which was done only as part of their long-term effort to sell DRM to media companies.

The end of all this will be a world where everything looks like the "mobile" ecosystem or video game consoles -- users will not be allowed to run any software that Microsoft did not approve of unless they pay 4-5x more for a computer that has fewer restrictions. Sure, it will make life harder for malware writers -- assuming the approved software does not have tons of exploits -- but it will also mean that Microsoft's interests never get challenged. The only reason anyone will be allowed to run Libreoffice will be competition authorities, and in all likelihood software will be made available based on a user's region (so EU users get to run Libreoffice, but not US users). It will be a net negative for users and for the next generation of developers, who, rather than learning by staying up late with their own computers, will at best only be able to program on their school's computers and only if they are in a wealthy enough school district.

betterunix2··on Why might you run your own DNS server?
The Internet is not much older; it is reasonable to say that the Internet started in 1982 when TCP/IP was first standardized, though some would say that the Internet started a few years later with the creation of NSFNet and its interconnection with other networks.
betterunix2··on AMD Ryzen 6000 Series Mobile CPUs Feature Microsoft's Pluton Security
"A security processor that guarantees safety for critical data is a good piece of hardware for those that require such functionality"

I am not the first to point out that malware writers are a big beneficiary of such features -- it's a great way to avoid inspection/detection of their code.

"as long as it's optional"

DRM systems ultimately become de facto mandatory, even if they remain optional in theory.

"not controlled by a remote corporation"

Hardware DRM systems ("trusted computing") are inherently controlled by remote corporations; at the end of the day someone has to certify hardware-bound keys, and someone has to revoke leaked keys. Companies routinely try to obscure this crucial detail but if you dig deeply enough in the documentation you will inevitably find it.

betterunix2··on AMD Ryzen 6000 Series Mobile CPUs Feature Microsoft's Pluton Security
"I think it's the point that trusted computing is optional"

It is optional the way the Internet is optional; in theory you can live without it but no longer practical. If companies keep pushing these systems, eventually they will become a requirement all over the place. Microsoft's track record with UEFI bootloader restrictions makes it pretty clear what that future looks like: cheap devices used by the masses will be more heavily restricted, while those who can shell out 3-4x the money can get a computer that at least allows them to run whatever software they want to run.

"why should Netflix give you a full 4k stream when you've chosen to disable the widevine extension in your browser?"

Why should Netflix dictate what hardware and operating system I get to run? A basic design principle of the Web, which Netflix relies on to avoid having to provision set-top boxes for their customers, is that anyone can implement a client without first seeking permission. In an ideal world Netflix would have to respect the basic design principles of the Web and of the Internet in order to benefit from those systems, but we obviously do not live in an ideal world.

The largest companies in tech and media are trying to rewrite the rules of the consumer markets they do business in for their own benefit. For the entertainment companies DRM is a convenient way to avoid copyright laws (i.e. the part where copyrights expire and where fair use is a defense against infringement claims), and for tech companies DRM is a strategic play that allows them to control the devices they sell to users and monetize that control by selling DRM features to media companies. The legal and financial structures in place today encourage this behavior, and the concentration of power and lack of effective competition are making it possible.

betterunix2··on Tokyo: A big city that is also pleasant to live in
"Suburbanites shouldn't have to pay for city subway and potholes."

Then city residents shouldn't have to pay for the roads that make car-centric suburbs possible or the various subsidies given to rural residents. Honestly, one of the benefits of civilization is that we help each other out even when it does not immediately benefit us as individuals. Rural and suburban life would not be possible without cities, and cities would not be possible without rural and suburban residents.

Cities form naturally because of industrial operations that are more efficient when they are concentrated in a single place. Remote work changes nothing about it because there are still plenty of jobs that cannot be done remotely, including many of the jobs needed to support remote work (e.g. data centers, warehouses, intermodal terminals). Suburban life depends on industries that make no sense in suburbs or whose presence will ultimately transform suburbs into cities.

If suburbs were as superior as you suggest, cities would not be growing and real estate in cities would not be as valuable as it currently is. People are choosing to live, work, and raise families in cities more than they are choosing suburbs. Remote work has not changed anything and will never change anything. COVID-19 led only to a transient spike in demand for suburban homes that is already declining as people realize that the pandemic is already in its final stage.

betterunix2··on Interactive zero knowledge 3-colorability demonstration
As expected, since the confidence level is determined by the number of times the protocol is executed, not which edges are chosen. Each time you select an edge you are opening a brand new commitment to the (claimed) coloring of the graph, so even if you choose the same edge every time you are actually checking different commitments.
betterunix2··on The Background for CAR and CDR
Where are the search trees, heaps/priority queues, deques, and so forth in the Common Lisp standard? There are arrays, lists, associative lists, and hash tables, and a few scattered functions for manipulating trees of cons cells. Beyond that you are on your own, stuck either implementing textbook data structures and algorithms yourself or relying on third party libraries. Considering how well-developed the loop syntax and CLOS are, and even how many string manipulation functions are in the standard, I consider the lack of standardized data structures a pretty significant oversight.

I never said structs are a universal solution. It would make no sense to define lists using structs because lists already exist and are already useful as lists (and as stacks, which lists immediately give you). Sometimes a tree of cons cells works well and requires no further clarification. On the other hand, there are many cases where relying just on cons, car, cdr, and related functions results in hard-to-read, hard-to-change code. You are speaking of "usefulness" but I never doubted that you could get a working solution based on car/cdr, I said it is unreadable and I stand by that. You say that we are not talking about a specific use-case, but a function that accesses structured data in a very specific way without regard to any specific context or use-case screams "readability hazard."

Why should you dismiss someone who sees cdaddr and calls it an "unreadable monstrosity" as simply not knowing the language well enough? There is no need to get religious about a programming language. Common Lisp is a great language that I have been using for many years, both professionally and as my preferred language for personal projects. That does not mean that I should think everything in the language or everything that people commonly use are good ideas.

betterunix2··on "Widevine Dump":Leaked Code Downloads HD Video from Disney+, Amazon, and Netflix
George Hotz (geohot) was a teenager when he cracked the iPhone and was 20 when he cracked the PS3. So...yes, young adults certainly can extract keys if they have the time and motivation, and being young adults they often have plenty of time on their hands.
betterunix2··on The Background for CAR and CDR
A chain of first/second/rest/nth is also unreadable, as is the equivalent using plain car/cdr. Lists should not be used as a substitute for defining a structure with properly named slots.

I am a big fan of Lisp but it is an old language family that comes with some baggage. The "list processing" view of the language is part of that baggage. One of the greatest shortcomings of Common Lisp is the lack of standardized data structures -- no binary search trees, no priority queues, etc. The language encourages people to use lists as a one-size-fits-all structure, to the detriment of readability, maintainability, and often efficiency.

Sure, constructs like cdaddr have not created the mountain of bugs that we see from the "traditions" of C, but I suspect that has more to do with what you said: cdaddr is rarely used. Most professional Lisp programmers would find a better way to write their code, almost certainly using defstruct to define complex data structures and only using lists when they need list semantics.

betterunix2··on Ask HN: What is your spiritual practice?
"my Holy Book is the only religious authority"

Sounds like idolatry to me -- sounds like you are taking a book, written, edited, and organized by human beings, and equating it with God.

betterunix2··on Ask HN: What is your spiritual practice?
People who read the bible without any religious context, as if it was just a book, will almost certainly see only a disjointed and contradictory collection of ancient stories and writings. Without any religious context that is all the bible is. Oral traditions still matter and that is why Jews and Christians have such wildly different understandings of the Hebrew texts.
betterunix2··on "Widevine Dump":Leaked Code Downloads HD Video from Disney+, Amazon, and Netflix
There is something amusing about weaponizing the key revocation process like this...
betterunix2··on The Background for CAR and CDR
Note that "second" will not work as intended if you just have a pair; it access the second element of a list. I rarely find any use for anything beyond first, second, and rest; if I need to access nth elements I will likely switch to a different data structure.
betterunix2··on The Background for CAR and CDR
cdaddr is an unreadable monstrosity. Keeping it around for the sake of reusing good code from decades ago is one thing, but let's not praise it for giving programmers a compact way to retrieve a nested list. It is too easy to mistake "cdaddr" for "cddadr" in a large codebase and the bugs it would introduce will probably be very hard to deal with.

If your list structure is so complex that you are using cdaddr or anything like it, you did something wrong. You should use defstruct with human-readable slot names to create more readable and easier to work with code.

betterunix2··on Internet Sacred Text Archive
All translations are biased by the translator; there is no such thing as a translation that "transparently" conveys the meaning of the original. Even moreso when you are dealing with writings from an ancient culture, where much of the cultural context is likely missing.

For example, Genesis 1:1 is often translated as "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth..." but that itself reflects a particular translator bias. The medieval Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki (Rashi) said it should instead read, "When God began creating..." by comparing how a particular word is used in other contexts. There is a subtle but important difference in meaning between the two translations: the first implies creation ex nihilo (as it says creation occurred "In the beginning"), while the second allows for an eternal universe within which our current world was created (and which may have gone through many acts of creation -- such a belief has been common in the more recent past). Of the two it is not at all clear which more "transparently" conveys the original meaning of the text -- because that meaning would only have been obvious to someone living 2500 years ago in ancient Israel (or possibly in the diaspora in Babylon).

betterunix2··on There’s no such thing as a tree (phylogenetically)
Historically the square root of negative one arose more naturally than you might think; it is basically impossible to avoid it when you derive a cubic formula. Historically the work on complex numbers started as soon as cubic and quartic formulas were derived, because complex numbers emerge naturally and unavoidably from those formulas (even for polynomials that have only real roots). At first mathematicians were generally dismissive of the imaginary units and viewed them as "nonsense" terms that sometimes appear in some formulas and there was a lot of doubt about dealing with such terms (the same doubt you might have if someone divided by zero while solving some formula, even if they wind up finding the correct answer). Those doubts were completely eliminated by the proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra.

For what it's worth, you can avoid "imaginary" numbers entirely if you want -- you can do arithmetic on real polynomials modulo x^2+1, or equivalently on 2x2 real matrices of a special form.

betterunix2··on There’s no such thing as a tree (phylogenetically)
Some do, like the word "cat," which does (more or less) correspond to a monophyletic group, Felidae.
betterunix2··on About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffiliated
It will have no impact on morality because few people actually derive their morals from a religion, even if they claim to. Religions contextualize and validate morals that adherents hold regardless of their active participation, and some religions even take this premise and run with it (e.g. that people have an innate instinct to do what's morally right which is in tension with their innate instinct to do what's wrong).
betterunix2··on About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffiliated
I would suggest that it may be more related to the declining birthrate. Having just had a second child, I can say that kids have made me more active in my local religious institution, and I have observed the same among other friends with kids. I suspect that many people wander back to their childhood religion once they have kids, especially if their major cultural events are at least nominally religious (e.g. Christmas).
betterunix2··on Everyone on Earth is your cousin (2015)
I think it is better to speak of uniquely Neanderthal genes. Our genome must have been almost identical to the Neanderthal genome, given that interbreeding was both possible and that the hybrid offspring remained fertile. So it is likely that many people alive today do indeed have genes from the Neanderthal line, but those genes are either identical to human genes or so close that we cannot distinguish their Neanderthal original from ordinary variations/mutations.
betterunix2··on Everyone on Earth is your cousin (2015)
On some level, yes: we can generally distinguish human faces from chimpanzee, gorilla, and other primate faces. In general, though, our facial recognition has some quirks that make more fine-grained identification of relatedness hard. For example if I shave my beard it takes people a moment to recognize me, especially if I do not give them any clues. Also note that if we had a reliable way to identify degrees of relationship tribal marks would be far less common since tribal affinity could be detected automatically.

In general ape facial recognition is oriented toward familiarity, not relatedness. This makes sense given the patterns of social behavior in apes -- fission/fusion social groups, individuals leaving their childhood group and joining a new group as adults, etc. It also makes sense given that establishing trust (or degrees of trust) is one of the primary functions of facial recognition, and people often betray the trust of their close relatives. Familiarity is also more general, since we are often familiar with our close relatives but can also be familiar with others, and the complexity of ape social groups requires a more general kind of recognition.

betterunix2··on Avoiding Internet Centralization
Global outages or reductions in service quality are very rare these days. Regional outages happen from time to time but are not very common. Local outages are frequent, but irrelevant -- the Internet is meant to be resilient to local outages, which presupposes that local outages are a common concern. Obviously if you shrink your scope enough you will be able to say problems happen regularly -- considering only the connectivity in my home there are many incidents each year.

The most significant incident in recent memory involved a severed fiber optic line in New York City earlier this year, which affected the US Northeast in various ways. The impact was relatively short-lived, and despite living and working in NYC I was not personally affected at all -- even though I use Verizon FIOS and the line in question was operated by Verizon (a testament to how resilient Verizon's own network is). That is the mark of an extremely robust system -- a major, overly-centralized component (one cable carrying many supposedly redundant links) is destroyed and the effects remain highly localized and the impact is not universal even within the local area.

betterunix2··on Avoiding Internet Centralization
Some perspective: in 1986 the Internet experienced a congestive collapse that reduced the useful throughput by 3 orders of magnitude. End users noticed, and if it happened today there would be pandemonium.

The Internet has become so robust and reliable that end users take the network for granted. At this point most of the headline-making incidents involve services running on the Internet, not the Internet itself (at least in the US, EU, and other highly-connected regions/countries; there are still countries that can be taken offline by just one cable being severed, and their Internet users cannot take the network for granted yet). In my adult life there have only been a handful of significant, global outages/reductions in service quality on the Internet itself. Regional outages happen from time to time, though few are significant enough to make national or international news.

So yes, network-level improvements mean a lot to end users -- they mean that end users can rely on the network itself, and only have to worry about problems at higher levels of the stack.

betterunix2··on Avoiding Internet Centralization
"Internet routing requires addresses to be allocated uniquely, but if the addressing function were captured by a single government or company"

Technically it is so captured -- IANA is the root of the hierarchy that distributes both IP address assignments and ASN assignments -- and the RIRs are effectively centralized authorities in their regions. Thus far it has not been a problem.

With a larger address space and longer ASNs you could decentralize the entire process. Basically, subnets and ASNs would be hashes of public keys, and you would use a path-vector protocol where the NLRIs contain NIZKs proving knowledge of the secret keys and asserting who the NLRI was sent to at each hop (identified by ASN). It is not current being considered because (1) it would greatly increase the cost of routers and related infrastructure and (2) thus far there is no immediate need.

betterunix2··on Avoiding Internet Centralization
Uh...

1970: Early networks suffered from congestive collapse problems, routing protocols were slow to converge, computed suboptimal routes, and had count-to-infinity problems, only a handful of transit networks existed, domain names were managed by one dude broadcasting a file to everyone, little to no security infrastructure, etc.

2021: We have robust congestion control and queue management, scalable routing protocols that find optimal routes and have no count-to-infinity problems, DNS, large numbers of transit networks with a high level of redundancy, and at least some security infrastructure in key places (DNSSEC, RPKI, etc.).

Don't confuse web infrastructure and hosting services with the Internet itself, which is the network and which has never been more distributed or more robust than it is today.

betterunix2··on Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
My point is that victims will never actually have the peace of mind to know that imagery of their abuse is inaccessible. Once the pictures/videos have been taken the harm has already occurred and the victims will live out their lives knowing that "somewhere" "someone" is consuming those images -- even if they never see evidence of it. The harm is caused by the possibility of such sharing.
betterunix2··on Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
At least one so-called "grey area" involves teenagers wearing revealing outfits or posing in potentially sexual ways. As far as I understand it most police forces do not waste their time with such imagery, even though it may technically be illegal, because there is just so much unambiguous child abuse imagery to deal with -- teenage girls taking pictures of themselves is a lot less alarming than a 40 year old filming himself abusing a 3 year old.
betterunix2··on Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
We do hear about prosecutions, and the sites are run by criminals (as operating such sites is a criminal act). The police are better resourced and better able to identify users than almost all the forum operators, and in any case I doubt the majority of forum operators are interested in shaking down their users.
betterunix2··on Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
1. Honeypots are controversial and practically invite an entrapment defense. Better to have police infiltrate forums, identify people, and give prosecutors unambiguous evidence.

2. Calling people who view these images "monsters" contributes to a stigma that makes people hesitant to seek help before their urges lead them to abuse children.

2.5. If they are "monsters" and someone you know and love is not a "monster," what do you do when you discover that your loved one is one of those people? We go around asking why people look the other way; the way we reflexively dehumanize pedophiles is one of the reasons. We need to recognize pedophiles as human beings who have serious and potentially dangerous mental health problems, and instead of calling them "monsters" we need to reoriented ourselves to say "let's get this person help before they do something monstrous." Obviously a person who is actively abusing children needs to be arrested, but let's not forget that we are talking about people who actively consume imagery of children being abused, many of whom are not necessarily abusing children (yet).

betterunix2··on Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
"As explained in the article."

Was it explained? I saw plenty of discussion of the harm done to children, and the lasting emotional problems carried into adulthood, on the part of the people who abuse children. Then there were a few words from one of those victims who said that it is upsetting to know that images of his abuse are still circulated and consumed. It seems like a stretch to say that the existence of those images causes harm; at most it would seem that the possibility that such images exist complicates things for victims, but that the actual harm was and has always been caused by the actual abuse that occurred.

The fact is that nobody can ever know with certainty that child abuse imagery has been thoroughly deleted from ever storage medium on the planet; there are just too many computers in the world, too many ways for the imagery to be stored, transmitted, and shared. Victims will always have the possibility that someone out there is viewing such images hanging over there head no matter how many forums are taken down and no matter how many file sharing services remove files. It is one of the darker realities of the Internet age.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →