HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bhargav

521 karma · joined January 31, 2012

submissionscomments
bhargav··on Tell HN: Apple products come with ungrounded plug in India
People in this post (multiple threads) seem to think a little shock that doesn’t kill you is not necessarily unsafe. This is mind boggling to me. If one is getting shocked at all, this goes to show some sort of fault in a given device or in the household in which it’s being used period. It’s not safe because it doesn’t kill you lol.

Also — cool it with the subtle racism

bhargav··on Felt
The tech looks really really good. I can see that it serves the purposes in their demo well. May be just my ignorance, but I am failing to see how this will be a business yet.

The use cases are niche and basically require adoption from institutions.

The business model of allowing individuals to use, and allowing them to share, seems like a loophole to me. Per their FAQ, paid model will be for team collabs, which I would think is even more niche.

Hopefully they know better about this space then me. Best of luck Felt!

bhargav··on Tell HN: Coinbase now requires physical address of recipient in crypto transfers
It does have something to do with US entities. If the goal was anonymity, this move shows that it’s possible for it to be taken away by local entities. Imagine if all countries and localities did this.

Also: re your comment below a reply, yeah sure you don’t need Coinbase to trade crypto. coin ase is complying with local regulations, others will have to follow. So again, the original comment from OP around promises of Crypto is still accurate

bhargav··on GitHub user sends notification to 400k users
I assume you work in tech. Let's say you work at Netflix, are you pinging anyone and everyone to review each PR you make or are you assigning a few reviewers (or better yet, does it just auto assign owners based on CODEOWNERS)? Are you titling your PRs this way? How do you describe the changes?

Now imagine, everyone at Netflix made PRs the same way this author did. How do we make sure there is not a lot of noise? How do we collaborate well together?

I don't think you are being argumentative. I definitely think Epic games is at fault here, and that this points to issues in how they've setup teams and lack of guard rails on Github's part in terms of spam protection. But separate to this, the author's behaviour is not what I would want at a workplace I am at.

bhargav··on GitHub user sends notification to 400k users
> I have no idea why the user is even being mentioned in this headline. I haven't used GitHub in a while, and am unfamiliar with orgs and subgroups, but tagging a developer subgroup on a PR seems...a reasonable thing for a new contributor to do? How is it their fault that the developer subgroup has been hijacked by this organization to mean "Anyone who has ever signed the Terms of Service To View Our Code"?

At mentioning all admins and developers in general on a PR is bad etiquette. Look at the title of the PR here as well. "Merge ASAP"? What kind of attitude is that? Github should have some controls on notifications as should Epic games in how they manage their groups, but this highlights bad etiquette.

bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
Do you happen to have a few examples? I’m super curious! How many students were taking the course?
bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
We have slightly different opinions, but I thank you for taking the time to chat, and trusting that we can do so nicely.

The boards are to provide society comfort, but they enforce as you, said the minimum. Something just cannot be measured. This is very true in medicine as it contains a human aspect, as well as ethics aspect (I make more money if I see more people and give each less time).

When I was a teenager, I was losing hair due to Alopecia. My doctor at the time, who barely made sense (both of us were ESL) decided to put me on a course of prescription Iron pills. I was pooping black haha. Only later, I was told that I shouldn’t be taking it and that it was prescribed to me by accident by her because she had the file of another patient. Their last name was my first name, and they were pregnant female, I am a male.

The same doctor injected my mom with some drug and as she did, she said “oh shit” and “OMG” and decided not to tell my mom what it was. She tossed the bottle in hazardous waste box so my mom could not find out what it was. My dad was furious and made a scene as he and my mom naturally got worried. We went to this board and they said they did nothing wrong, and my parents were making a scene, and that we should find another doctor. So much for protecting my best interests and holding a bar.

These boards are mafia; another high profile thread about this is in HN right now. The boards are there to provide a facade of credibility.

> The point of these licenses is, in part, to protect society in professions where they are expected to ethically serve in the public good.

I don’t want to be called an engineer and opted out of license because I think most of engineers are doing the exact opposite. Working at companies that knowingly continue operating when we know it’s causing depression? Collecting data for users without them knowing?

Regarding equality of curriculum and standardization, I hear you. None of this is stuff we can ONLY get in school. I think the interview questions we all conduct at our jobs, or give when applying are doing just that. Checking minimum competency; tangentially I much prefer take home tests or something of that nature.

After this, I tend to think learning should be like gardening. Not all gardens are the same and they have different needs. You may need to learn more calculus if you are in robotics, but not if you are working on something really far from that. Another example, you might really need to learn about algorithms and databases if your job/interests require it.

bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
Sorry but I’m gonna be very blunt. I think sound pretentious as fuck.

> I studied because I wanted to genuinely understand how things work

I don’t think you do.

Genuine curiosity forged in one’s own mind. It is not something that can be bounded, repackaged as a curriculum, and sold in university. It’s like ether, it’s everywhere and can be captured by anyone, through multiple means.

University degrees for any professions are useless. Even in medicine! There are shit doctors and good doctors. Most people here would’ve run through a couple of them before picking one. I’ve been with my current doctor for 10 years now, because they are really good, empathic, and teach me rather than just pushing pills.

Software in my humble opinion works the same way. I care more about what someone does with the tools they have, rather than them being made of wood or metal or gold

bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
If the problem is large enough, I do submit that there are multiple (even many) ways of solving it.

I will also say that there’s problems where that is not the case. For example, we were told to write simulators for scheduling schemes (RR, MLFQ). Other than using different data structures (even that’s a bit of a stretch) not sure how much variance there will be.

Using the right tool for the right job is important.

Just above your post another author posted/cited results of a system that “never produced false positives”.

I think that cited number another author shared is probably correct but presumably, the tool is used in cases where problems are big enough to warrant it.

bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
I would let 100 people cheat if it meant I was sure 1 innocent student wasn’t punished unjustly.

People that don’t cheat may benefit in the future for not doing so.

I said May here because I generally found university education to be useless for myself. Instead, I wish I had met folks I consider mentors at work, earlier in my life.

bhargav··on My students cheated... a lot
That sounds great and all but I honestly have doubts about this software that detects similarities… there’s only so many ways to solve the bland questions that professors lift from books; kind of ironic. I’m assuming it’s basicallly doing AST analysis and it’s no smarter than eliminating things like variables being renamed.

They are basically stating that this “software” is 100% accurate. Furthermore it’s then left to whims of some TAs?

No algorithm can detect cheating unless the number of permutations are very very large (I.e being struck by lightening). Maybe one way to offset would be to use data as the student is entering the solution but that was never the case for us; just upload the source code to their custom made Windows app.

bhargav··on Show HN: I made a personal Movies page, tracking everything I've watched
You can checkout letterboxd.com. Does most of what you like
bhargav··on Back to India
That's fair. So the whole people greeting you and saying hello, sounds a bit more like an overstatement. Here, I was speaking more to the fact that you can have a better social life there in general. Most NRI (non-residential Indians) that were born in India, will have a larger extended family back home. This brings a lot more family events, gatherings, and I am sure, drama; something you can maneuver around I think.

The whole what will SOCIETY think of us, I think it really varies depending on what parts of India you are in. At least in India, cultures vary greatly even from city to city. I have heard very very progressive things happening in India, and also very regressive things. It just depends on where you are and how much f*ks you give personally. Who cares what a lady three doors down thinks? Let them think what they want.

I definitely see your side of this though, as that was my perspective before. Mine is a bit different at the moment, but might change in the future.

bhargav··on Back to India
The main advantage of India for me personally is a sense of community that I felt when I went back there after 8 years. Everyone in the society (i.e: I'd say equivalent to a street or a suburb) knows you and greets you. You go to the temple in the morning, and pickup some snacks along the way. In the evening, people go out to eat, meet their relatives, etc.

There are pros and cons of this sense of community as well, people can be nosy. However, coming back from India recently, I felt pretty depressed and alone. In North America, everyone seems like a busy worker bee that is working all the time. On the weekend, the bees explore a little bit more. Go hiking, or explore their other hobbies. But the sense of aloneness is something I never knew I had until I went back to India.

Aside: This was my first trip back after having done a few when I was young and hating those since I was just stuck in the house as a YA and had limited internet access. The country, the people, have come far from that and as an adult I have all the freedom to do whatever the fk I want too.

bhargav··on Ask HN: What is the most unique website you’ve come across on the internet?
http://example.com
bhargav··on Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health
Social media sites generally want a large user base. This approach sounds very technical so I'd imagine this being a big barrier to entry. PGP will make this even worse.
bhargav··on Why we went passwordless on our new product
I think this approach is fine depending on what your product is and who your users are. One obvious callout is that now your login is tied to the delivery of the email. The article claims passwords are an additional form of friction, but so is going into your email and then clicking on a link. Some people use mailservers which as abysmally slow, and you have also now increased the cost of your product by sending more emails through your provider.

For me personally, the least friction I experience in a site is one that asks me to put a password and a username on registration and login. Subsequently, if I can optionally enable 2FA from the settings/profile page, I am happy. I use a password manager so this allows me to use a given site pretty easily.

bhargav··on Why we went passwordless on our new product
Password reset ~= Magic link. The risk profile of this is no different than a password reset with no fallbacks such as 2FA.
bhargav··on Why we went passwordless on our new product
If you delete cookies regularly, I assume you are entering your password regularly? Do you use 2FA on these sites? I assume you have to go through the motions each time. What makes clicking on these links more annoying? Some 2FA (or confirm your identity) is done through email still.
bhargav··on Show HN: Khan-dl – Khan Academy Course Downloader
How often does that happen to you? I basically just watch Youtube videos all day, and often dig up old playlists and lectures. This hasn't ever been a problem for me. In my case, if I were to do it, this would basically be me being a hoarder :)
bhargav··on Learn Functional Programming Visually
The way this works technically is really great. Kudos to the developer. The game itself ... I do not think it helped me learn anything.
bhargav··on Show HN: Hurl – Run and test HTTP requests
Yeah I saw the file option. I think it will be nifty when we have to do large request payloads, but ideally for example the sample, `echo GET http://httpbin.org/get | hurl` we could do something like: `hurl -i echo GET http://httpbin.org/get`. I understand its a bit subjective :)
bhargav··on Show HN: Hurl – Run and test HTTP requests
I suggest adding an interactive mode!

Aside: I tried to go through the samples and was having trouble running them successfully.

bhargav··on Good sleep, good learning, good life
This page has been archived by the Wayback machine if folks are having issues accessing the mediawiki: https://web.archive.org/web/*/https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Go...
bhargav··on Ask HN: Clever ways to handle API access but avoid signup?
Reducing friction is a good idea but I would argue that asking folks to generate and send you a secret is likely the same amount as them getting an API key that you generate for them. You’ll also run into uncertainties in secret key formats that are used by disparate clients.

If you really want to: One alternative would be to generate a random JWT while the developers are on the website and ask them to secure a given JWT by adding their email, doing on boarding that way.

Addendum: In terms of reducing friction, if this is going to be a paid API, I would suggest adding a free tier that allows N requests before you either rate limit or cut off, and send an email to ask for a conversion

bhargav··on New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases
Yup. My point is some people might not even know that their database is accessible from the web lol. It’s pretty easy to follow a tutorial or get something OOTB that’s not secure, so we shouldn’t be saying we’re glad this happened. Even if it’s big businesses, what if said businesses were storing important data such as health records?

I think the learn by failing is a good mentality but was hoping we can be mindful of the fact that this harms more than just the “big bad man”

Edit: Addendum for a more thoughtful discussion, it would be great if these databases and tools provided some default security OOTB requiring no configuration whatsoever. Example: rather than creating user and password with root, is rather have some CMS site generate a random one!

bhargav··on New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases
This also affected people who use software for things other than businesses. People with IoT apps for their home, researchers, etc.

Our field is vast and there is a large variance in people just using the basics of CS and those who keep up with standards and best practices, etc.

Your statement is basically akin to someone saying that it’s fine for people to get robbed if they went out with their wallet; or worse.. killed.

bhargav··on PG: The biggest source of stress for me at YC was running HN
I don’t really think you can maintain a social media company at scale without having revenue to pay the people that maintain it.

HN doesn’t have ads because they are running HN at a deficit to get eyeballs on YC. Granted, to my knowledge, they haven’t suppressed any threads in their competitors; kudos.

bhargav··on People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee
I think you are calling for something like the Instacart Marketplace for restaurants. These already exists SkipTheDishes.com is one of them; they primarily do delivery.
bhargav··on Show HN: An API to store balances and transactions
Money and keeping track of it is a big problem. Depending on your problem though, its not fully always in your control. For example, we integrate with a discount calculation service that only supports values up to the 100ths. This means that we have to introduce rounding as an intermediary and then solve the "off by one cent" problem, after the fact.

In addition to the problem @joshuakelly mentioned, I think one of the challenges here will be to gain trust. Asking someone else to keep track of your books is a pretty tall ask. How does it affect a given company's auditing? What about SOC Compliance etc? I would suggest you try to address some of these things.

Best!

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →