HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bhickey

4,258 karma · joined July 8, 2010

http://bhickey.net
submissionscomments
bhickey··on Interstellar movie black hole implemented with Einstein's equations in C++
Nothing is forbidden, until you try to explain it. I come from the perspective that genre is a contract with the audience. Here _Interstellar_ is making a genre error.

Take _Star Wars_ for example. You don't need to know how the Force works. There's no suspension of disbelief because you've bought into the genre and its tropes. The Force is everywhere, Luke is atuned to it. We don't need to know anything else mechanixally. Then they rolled up with midichlorians and reduced the whole thing to jibberish.

_Interstellar_ sets a hard sci-fi expectation with a visually accurate black hole before losing the train of thought. Imagine if _Lord of the Rings_ spent 20 minutes discussing how the plate tectonics of Middle Earth gave rise to Mount Doom before veering off into the history of the eagles. It gives your audience whiplash.

bhickey··on Interstellar movie black hole implemented with Einstein's equations in C++
It was completely uneven.

Cooper sobbing as he listened to years of messages from his family? I wish I could've written that. The twist where Mann activated his beacon because he didn't want to die alone? Solid.

We need the gravity equation to get off Earth because the crops are dying? Love can escape a black hole through the tesseract? This is just patent technobabble nonsense.

Where _Interstellar_ fails is in exposition. Love is the most powerful force in the universe? The Fifth Element pulled that off by not pretending to be serious. Anything is permitted in science fiction, but once you commit to explaining it, you need to make sense.

bhickey··on Th64: Tiny Hash Function in C
On Monday I've got a fantastic hashing bug to show you.
bhickey··on Australia out of natural gas, pays gas companies to export its reserves
At my last house, I removed the gas stove and replaced it with induction. I had two motivations:

* Gas stoves are awful for indoor air quality

* Compared to induction, they're awful to cook on

bhickey··on The City of London which is not part of London (2016)
> especially some of the more corrupt and incompetent ones

Do you have particular boroughs in mind?

bhickey··on Donald Sutherland has died
Could be a mistake or they're counting posthumous releases.
bhickey··on Donald Sutherland has died
Incredible that his career spanned 60+ years. When I saw him in _The Dirty Dozen_ it must've already been thirty years old.

This got me curious about who had the longest career in Hollywood. Mickey Rooney came in near the top at 90 years. [0]

[0] https://www.imdb.com/list/ls058627770/

bhickey··on Will We Run Out of Data? Limits of LLM Scaling Based on Human-Generated Data
I doubt it. Language and human evolution operate on different time scales. We wouldn't be able to converse with someone from 13th century England. If anything I will expect selective pressure on languages—those that are easy to use are more likely to be adopted.

Secondarily, I would expect this effect to be swamped by other factors (e.g. conquest).

bhickey··on Will We Run Out of Data? Limits of LLM Scaling Based on Human-Generated Data
The human brain isn't randomly initialized. It's undergone 500m years of pretraining.
bhickey··on Engineer's solar panels are breaking efficiency records
It has nothing to do with safety. It's pure protectionism. The point is to keep small gas stations competitive by imposing labor costs on larger gas stations.
bhickey··on IKEA's retailer's solved global 'unhappy worker' crisis by raising salaries
This isn't a lack of understanding. It's the principal-agent problem.

Non-founder executives are usually rewarded for short term results. They'll deliver on this even if it means laying off the entire Python language team in the midst of an AI boom. The market is bad at distinguishing these growth hacks for sustainable business, so they'll see 4% quarterly growth and pile on under the assumption that the hockey stick is going up.

By the time reality catches up management has already cashed in their chips.

bhickey··on Deterioration of local community a major driver of loss of play-based childhood
The manufacturer should be jointly liable for producing a defective vehicle.
bhickey··on How Mount Everest killed George Mallory
Arlene Blum is another mountaineer author worth mentioning. She's written about her expeditions including Annapurna I, as well as her work as a chemist campaigning to ban toxic flame retardant from upholstery.
bhickey··on How Mount Everest killed George Mallory
Wade Davis was a speaker at the 2012 American Alpine Club meeting at the Ford Assembly Plant in Richmond, CA. He had a line that stuck with me: death is the price we pay for living. Side note, Davis is mentioned in at least one episode of the X-Files, owing to his work on zombies in Haiti.

These aren't Everest specific recs, but if any of you are looking for mountaineering reading:

_The White Spider_ by Heinrich Harrer

_The Beckoning Silence_ and _Into the Void_ by Joe Simpson

_Eiger Obsession_ by John Harlin. Part of my enjoyment came from my familiarity with the geography of the book.

_Solo Faces_ by James Salter, fiction, loosely based on Gary Hemmings and Royal Robbins.

bhickey··on Tail Recursion Elimination (2009)
> dynamically redefine functions even to violate lexical scoping

When would someone want to do this?

bhickey··on Recently increased prevalence of human forearm median artery: Microevolution
Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium we wouldn't expect a trait to go from 0.1 to 0.3 in a large population in four generations. This suggests that the trait is subject to selective pressure.

There are a lot of potential causes. In my estimation the two most likely causes—

First, hitchhiking. The mutation could be near some other beneficial mutation. The closer genes together on a chromosome the less frequently they'll be separated by crossing over events.

Second, it could have some other, presently unobserved cardiac effect that reduces infant or maternal mortality.

bhickey··on Wikimedia Enterprise – APIs for LLMs, AI Training, and More
> No, you were comparing a small part of technical infrastructure costs to grant cost.

I have no control over how WMF presents its expenses.

For years WMF foundation has run "we need money or Wikipedia will die" ads while spending a quarter of the budget on making grants. No one forced them to write that ad copy. It's progress that they've toned it down, but we shouldn't pretend that this criticism is surprising or completely unwarranted.

bhickey··on Wikimedia Enterprise – APIs for LLMs, AI Training, and More
> Secondly, if you're still just acknowledging Wikipedia hosting costs - and thus pretending there's (for example) no legal work necessary for it - I don't think people are getting through to you as they should.

From your phrasing (still) it seems like you might've confused me with the person you initially replied to.

I was comparing technical infrastructure costs to award/grant costs because most critics are going to view the former as essential and the latter as mission creep. I don't have any insight, nor do I have any inclination to criticize, your payroll.

bhickey··on Wikimedia Enterprise – APIs for LLMs, AI Training, and More
It isn't a question of the good work you do.

People care about Wikipedia, not the Wikimedia Foundation. The criticism arises from misleading advertising. WMF fundraising conflates the two, implying that _Wikipedia_ needs money or it'll die. Meanwhile the 2023 budget shows $3.1m in hosting expenses versus $24.4m in awards and grants.

bhickey··on [dead]
To encourage them to testify.
bhickey··on U.S. Congress Live Net Worth Tracker
Let them trade whatever they want — but publish their trades and delay execution for 48 hours.
bhickey··on I organized a 20-acre game of Capture the Flag
This would've been 2014, I played in a 100 v 100 paintball game in Western Massachusetts. It was February, so the snow was pretty deep. At one point I stepped through some ice up to my knee.

Rather than run straight up elimination, teams accrued points by holding positions at certain times. You've got the bunker at noon? That's a point. 12:05? Nothing. This led to us desperately defending objectives against 6-to-1 odds waiting for the ref to announce that we'd scored the point.

bhickey··on Parking reform legalized most of the new homes in Buffalo and Seattle (2023)
> Suburban roads also last much much longer (far less traffic).

Have you got a citation on that? I was under the impression that most road wear is caused by heavy trucking and water/frost heaves.

bhickey··on mRNA Cancer Vaccine Reprograms Immune System to Tackle Glioblastoma in 48 Hours
> That's just about most difficult population to determine primary cause of death for.

Nursing home quality, COVID-19 deaths, and excess mortality https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8776351/

At the peak, excess nursing home mortality was nearly 6000 per week. Quibbling about "died with covid" versus "died of covid" isn't a useful exercise. Dead is dead and the excess mortality came from somewhere.

bhickey··on mRNA Cancer Vaccine Reprograms Immune System to Tackle Glioblastoma in 48 Hours
Either would've been preferable to what was done. Waiting on a provably fruitless trial in the midst of pandemic is regulatory homicide.

Throughout 2020, more than 9% of all people in nursing homes died of covid. Depending on age case fatality rates were upwards of 50%. The vaccine should've been offered to these people on a compassionate use basis. Even at the time it was obvious that actual harm posed by the virus vastly outweighed any hypothetical risk of adverse vaccine reaction. Drastically expanding the vaccinated population through compassionate use would have rapidly provided efficacy and safety data.

bhickey··on mRNA Cancer Vaccine Reprograms Immune System to Tackle Glioblastoma in 48 Hours
Ideally this is what would happen. In practice there have been very public failures in being overly cautious and aggressive.

While Aduhelm reduces Aβ it has no clinically significant effect. Still, the FDA approved it. Mercifully it'll be discontinued in November.

The covid vaccine represented a huge policy failure by the FDA. While people in nursing homes died in droves we got small clinical trials. When you've got 90 year olds in a congregate setting facing a 50% chance of death, maybe it's time to stop pretending thalidomide may be lurking around every corner. The pediatric trials were just as bad. Due to their sizing it was statistically impossible to detect rare adverse effects. Yet, vaccination was delayed for children while these fruitless trials ran.

In my own experience I had a low cost, high throughput covid testing protocol ready to go in early April 2020. It took the FDA until August 2020 to provide templates and another month to grant emergency use authorization. We could've drastically ramped up testing when it was needed most of the FDA has treated an emergency like an emergency.

bhickey··on OpenVoice: Instant Voice Cloning
> What is a legitimate use case for this?

Voice loss.

bhickey··on Why are most sofas so bad?
Off gassing. Plywood is a big VOC emitter.
bhickey··on eBPF Documentary
iptables is definitely limited in comparison to eBPF, but that isn't the innovative step. BPF was around for more than twenty years before eBPF came around. Around 2013 I worked on a packet analysis pipeline that generated BPF code dynamically at runtime. eBPF isn't more scriptable than BPF in this sense. The language does add some opcodes and loops that weren't available in the original, but this is relatively modest.

The real genius of what these folks did was extending the usefulness of BPF beyond the network stack. Without a provably safe language it would've been impossible to enable flexible kernel tracing.

bhickey··on "Let them eat cereal" How "greedflation" fueled consumer ire against Kellogg
There's a shortage of competition. This in turn gives companies more power to set prices. Previously they wouldn't have had the same latitude to pass rising costs onto consumers. Instead this would've eaten into their margins. You can gripe about the term, but it's descriptive of a real phenomenon.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →