HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bhickey

4,258 karma · joined July 8, 2010

http://bhickey.net
submissionscomments
bhickey··on Interview with a Gladiatrix
Antigone? I remember reading about them somewhere. [0]

[0] https://acoup.blog/2022/12/30/miscellanea-whats-the-problem-...

bhickey··on Big landlords used software to collude on rent prices, DC lawsuit says
> step up cost basis for inherited property

Heck, there's no policy justification for having the stepped-up basis at all.

bhickey··on H-1B Visa Program Changes Aimed at Stopping Applicants from Gaming Lottery
They can remedy a labor shortage by paying more.
bhickey··on Stories told by Aboriginal Tasmanians could be oldest recorded
There are seven members with magnitude +5 or brighter. Pleione is close to Atlas (+3.6), making it difficult to distinguish with the naked eye.
bhickey··on AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes
I'm skeptical of their methodology.

The images they're showing are very similar to one another. All the pictures of Delhi are essentially clones. They're getting a picture of old man for "an Indian person" then jamming the same prompt again.

bhickey··on Would You Kill the Fat Man? [pdf]
You're responding to something I didn't say.

> The moral indulgence critique says, more or less, if you refuse to do it because you don't want to do something distasteful you're being a coward, not stupid.

bhickey··on Would You Kill the Fat Man? [pdf]
> Utilitarianism assumes we have all the facts, yet we never do.

All the facts, while helpful, are not necessary for utilitarianism.

> "effective altruism"

I think you're attacking a straw man. You won't find Peter Singer attacking people for engaging in suboptimal charity.

> there's this underlying assumption/insult that if you're not utilitarian, then it means you don't quite understand that 5>1, and therefore you're beyond stupid and shouldn't be part of the conversation.

You can certainly say you'd sacrifice five to save one, but you need to back it up. The moral indulgence critique says, more or less, if you refuse to do it because you don't want to do something distasteful you're being a coward, not stupid.

Rule utilitarians can coherently refuse to pull the switch. I happen to disagree with their moral framework, but they can mount a vigorous defense of the position. Personally I come down hard on the side of rejecting the status quo bias. Commiting to symmetry in moral decision making is useful for avoiding contradictions. I also don't care much for act utilitarianism, since it's susceptible to non-utilitarians putting their fingers on the scale (ex. "buy this magazine or we'll shoot this dog".)

bhickey··on Would You Kill the Fat Man? [pdf]
You're missing the point. These hypotheticals exist to interrogate our respective frameworks for moral decision making.
bhickey··on Would You Kill the Fat Man? [pdf]
There are variations of this (incredibly, incredibly boring) problem that consider this. The five people are workers, the one person is a trespasser, or they're all workers, or all trespassers and so on.

> It's not wrong not to kill the one man because you can't be sure of the situation.

People don't make decisions with perfect information. We make decisions based on the best information we have available. Refusing to sacrifice one to save five because you don't know how they ended up there smacks of making excuses to get out of making hard choices.

bhickey··on Would You Kill the Fat Man? [pdf]
Alone? No. Wrong? Yes.

The concept you're describing is known as moral indulgence or moral self-indulgence: When a person refuses to do the right thing because they want to keep their hands clean. When you're standing at the switch you have agency and should be prepared to own your action. "Five people were struck by a trolley because I lacked the moral fortitude to save them."

[0] https://cla.csulb.edu/departments/philosophy/wp-content/uplo...

bhickey··on It looks like the 23k year old human footprints at White Sands are solid
I was responding to the GP who incorrectly stated that there wasn't Polynesian gene flow to the Americas prior to 1000 years ago. The evidence of early admixture events is quite strong. No one thinks the Americas were initially peopled across the Pacific — please do pardon my imprecision!
bhickey··on It looks like the 23k year old human footprints at White Sands are solid
Well, it might've been from the Pacific. There's genetic evidence for Polynesian individuals in S. Amer prior to the settlement of Easter Island.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32641827/

bhickey··on You can now hail an Uber without the Uber app
Uber isn't replacing street hails. When you call a taxi company there's no certainty if or when they'll actually turn up.
bhickey··on US moves closer to underground testing of nuclear weapons without any explosions
While game theory is useful when developing nuclear strategy I don't think anyone takes MAD seriously: It isn't subgame perfect. Once the rockets are up, retaliation is no longer credible... because the purpose of the threat of retaliation is to discourage an attack in the first place.
bhickey··on Texas man sent to death row over junk science denied US Supreme Court appeal
In the first appearance of Superman, he breaks in to the governor's mansion to obtain a stay of execution for a woman wrongly convicted of murder.

https://whynotcomicbooks.files.wordpress.com/2018/06/action-...

bhickey··on Rhythm 0
Reminds me of Steven Millhauser's story _The Knife Thrower_. The titular knife thrower deliberately scars his assistant and audience members before pushing the act to the extreme to satiate the demands of the crowd.
bhickey··on Car allergic to vanilla ice cream (2000)
The story probably endures because things like this actually happen [0, 1]

0. https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/27/us/janitor-alarm-freezer-rens...

1. http://www.st-v-sw.net/Obsidian/Martin/gravity.htm (search sprinkler)

bhickey··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
Yep. Look at the failure of terror bombing campaigns. Rather than demoralizing civilian populations, it hardens their resolve to fight from London to Kyiv.
bhickey··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
It's baffling that the writer either overlooked or ignored this. Collective punishment transfers the cost of enforcement from the ruler to the ruled.

We don't need florid nonsense[0] or baby Hitler hypotheticals to explain it. The Nazis didn't engage in reprisals[1,2] on the basis of moral philosophy. One practical motivation was to alienate resistance from the remainder of the population.

[0] What’s clear is that when rulers enforce family punishments, the ruled shiver with terror. Don’t tell me these tactics don’t work.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lidice_massacre

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_Kondomari

bhickey··on Chicago’s parking meter disaster
Huh? I'm not being vague in the slightest.

Daley bulldozed the runway at Meigs Airfield in the dead of night.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/2023/3/31/23662485/miegs-field-...

bhickey··on Chicago’s parking meter disaster
You're talking about a guy who was so corrupt he destroyed an airport in the middle of the night.
bhickey··on Constant time stateless shuffling and grouping
How odd. That isn't even a hash function!
bhickey··on Constant time stateless shuffling and grouping
> The round function can use anything, including destructive operations, so a nice fast hash like PCG is a good choice.

PCG isn't a hash. Maybe they meant FNV?

bhickey··on The Federal Helium reserve is for sale
Or someone wants to exploit a natural monopoly.
bhickey··on Amazon CEO reportedly told remote employees: It’s probably not going to work out
He's going to get a very sudden lesson on adverse selection.
bhickey··on Misidentifying Talent (2022)
> it is just that guy had more opportunities than others

Due to nepotism.

bhickey··on An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-for-Art based mimicry
We should dismiss it out of hand. Any image that a human can look at can be fed to a neural net. It's just an instance of the analog hole.
bhickey··on Show HN: LLMs can generate valid JSON 100% of the time
> I don’t think OG’s paper is up to snuff on its lit review - do you?

Not in the slightest. Caching the logit masks and applying the right one based on where you are in your grammar is obvious. This is what I'd expect some bright undergrads to come up with for a class project. This manuscript could've been a blog post.

Although arXiv is displacing some traditional publishing, I think it's a little silly to try to hold it to the same standards.

I saw your argument for why you think it's relevant and I think you're overstating the case. There are a _heap_ of papers they could've cited.

As an aside, when can we stop citing _Attention is All You Need_?

bhickey··on Show HN: LLMs can generate valid JSON 100% of the time
I'm serious that the similarities between the papers are superficial.

I don't think it's fair of you to criticize the authors for not citing some obscure preprint, when that manuscript itself neglected to cite decades of prior, relevant work.

bhickey··on Show HN: LLMs can generate valid JSON 100% of the time
Both papers use the phrase "regular expressions" and there the resemblance ends. The linked manuscript uses regular expression to realize a grammar and then memoizes logic masks. I want to know why FlashText failed to cite:

Baeza-Yates, Ricardo A., and Gaston H. Gonnet. "Fast text searching for regular expressions or automaton searching on tries." Journal of the ACM (JACM) 43.6 (1996): 915-936.

Eltabakh, Mohamed Y., Ramy Eltarras, and Walid G. Aref. "To trie or not to trie? realizing space-partitioning trees inside postgresql: Challenges, experiences and performance." (2005).

Zhang, Yijun, and Lizhen Xu. "An algorithm for url routing based on trie structure." 2015 12th Web Information System and Application Conference (WISA). IEEE, 2015.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →