HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigger_cheese

1,210 karma · joined February 4, 2015

submissionscomments
bigger_cheese··on Google pulls the plug on uBlock Origin
It might be related to mobile phone users, as far as I can tell the chrome browser on Android does not let you install extensions. I imagine a huge swathe of chrome users are using it on their phone.
bigger_cheese··on SponsorBlock – skip sponsor segments on YouTube
I presume native advertising on youtube has more strict vetting (i.e. needs to comply with advertising regulations unlikely to be out and out scam etc) then creator sponsored content.

Some sponsored content seems like borderline scams to me I see a lot of creators shilling for stuff like "not a bank" banking apps etc.

bigger_cheese··on DOJ may want to break up Google
Does a browser need to make money? Chrome is mostly open source as far as I know. Maybe it could move to a model like Linux where you have a benevolent dictator overseeing things and if a company wants something supported in chrome they can fund a developer to make the work happen.

As far as security and support perhaps companies like Microsoft which use parts of chrome as basis for Edge could employ people who can fix issues upstream.

bigger_cheese··on Building data infrastructure that will last
I don't think we disagree (Report and dashboards are useful decision making tools), but in practice hiring external people to come in and build them causes more problems then it solves. In my experience processes on the ground can and will change and all of these pre-written reports and dashboards quickly become ossified and outdated.

If you take steps to make sure the data is properly stored and queryable stakeholders can maintain and develop their own reporting. Make the data understandable and accessible and reporting will follow. Human friendly schemas and such help a lot.

bigger_cheese··on Building data infrastructure that will last
One thing I often see in data people (particularly consultants) is that they are very focused on building reports and dashboards in my experience (manufacturing plant) Analytics should be the focus - if you get the analytical part right - make the data simple/easy to interrogate then the reporting can evolve naturally as a consequence.

Unfortunately I think the tools for a lot of this (exploratory data analysis) are somewhat lacking. I think we are starting to see new tools emerge - especially around Timeseries data that are promising but I don't think things are at the level where a non expert user can quickly glean insights from data in a frictionless way.

bigger_cheese··on How to debug your battery design
I did some lab work at my university synthetizing materials for Li ion battery anodes as part of my honors thesis in Materials Engineering almost 15 years ago now.

My side of the project mostly concerned the method we were using to manufacture the materials (I was experimenting with a technique called "Electrostatic Spray Reductive Precipitation"). When it came to analyzing what I had managed to make it mostly involved using SEM (with EDS mapping) and XRD. At the time it never crossed my mind to look into possibility of simulations it would have saved a lot of time as doing the analysis was very time consuming.

For the theoretical side I was guided by a postgrad student who used a physics software package to predict the intercalation of Li ions using Density of States calculations, most of what he was doing went way over my head but it involved him running code and then telling me "we should try to make something like this..." so I imagine this sort of package could help out a lot here as well.

bigger_cheese··on Why Discover is no American Express
I live in Australia when I first signed up for a credit card through my bank they issued me with both a Mastercard and an American Express card linked to the same credit account. It seemed to me they really wanted to push Amex as they offered higher reward points etc for using it, the problem was almost nowhere accepted Amex whilst Mastercard "just worked" everywhere.

Eventually my bank cancelled the Amex card and they no longer offer American Express. I never really noticed because I hadn't used it for years at that point.

bigger_cheese··on Joe Biden stands down as Democratic candidate
>I am concerned tho that preference voting (is that the right word?) gives people too many opportunities to screw up—there are too many things that can go wrong on the ballot

Here in Australia you number the box next to the candidates name from 1 to N this is not normally an issue for the local seat in the lower chamber (house of representatives) where there are a manageable number of candidates, but in the upper chamber where senators are elected on a state wide basis you end up with sometimes farcical situations like the infamous "tablecloth ballot paper" which had 264 candidates.

There has been some attempt to reform this such as forcing people/party's to pay a registration fee in order to appear on the ballot (this is done to cut down on so called nuisance candidates but it is arguably undemocratic, although I believe you are eligible for a refund of the fee if you poll above some threshold % of votes which is a fair compromise in my opinion).

bigger_cheese··on Deconstructing the Role-Playing Video Game
I think everyone will have a different definition. In my opinion the "Role Playing" element is the ability for the game player to make deliberate choices which alter the character progression.

It can seem somewhat arbitrary. But to me a game like Diablo, Cyberpunk or Deus Ex where you are given a choice (to allocate skill points or similar) which changes the performance/abilities of the character makes its "roleplaying".

On the other hand something like Zelda or Metal Gear Solid the game play tended to change more based around obtaining certain items or reaching a certain stage of game rather than any decision based character progression

Something like Bioshock blurs the line as you make choices about which skills to obtain which alters the gameplay.

bigger_cheese··on Lots of people in education disagree with the premise of maximizing learning
>motivation doesn't get results. Discipline does.

I think it depends on the type of motivation, when I think back to my time at high school (Australia in the 90's) there was a contrast between how English was taught and how Math was taught.

In my English class the teacher would assign the class a book, or a poem etc. Take this home and read to the end of chapter X before next class. At the start of next class the teacher would pick half a dozen random students and ask them questions in front of the class about what we had been assigned to read. These weren't the kind of questions you could bluff an answer to.

Believe me you were motivated to do the readings because no one wanted to get called up to the front of the classroom and look like an idiot by not being able to answer the question. You were motivated by fear.

In Math on the other hand we were given a textbook, told to go home and do exercises from the book to practice what we'd been taught. It entirely ran on the honor system no one checked to make sure we did the exercises, as a result I know a large portion of the class didn't bother. I wonder what would have happened if the math teacher were to have called up random students to front of the classroom and made them solve a problem on blackboard at start of each lesson.

bigger_cheese··on X debut 40 years ago (1984)
>professors had a rule that all programming assignment submissions must compile and run on their servers running Solaris

This is what made me learn Linux, my universities comp sci also ran Solaris and required the assignments run under that environment. This was in early 2000's I hated the university computer labs they were full of Sun Hardware they all ran CDE desktop environment which I thought was ugly as all sin (it looked incredibly dated by 2000's).

Someone in my class told me about SSH and that you could work from home. He gave me a stack of burnt cd's (with Mandrake - an old Linux distribution, which ran KDE) I was able to remotely work on my assignments from comfort of my home and I've been a Linux user ever since.

bigger_cheese··on Open Source Python ETL
I work in manufacturing (large industrial plant) and the data processes we have are honestly not great - mostly it is because there are a heap of legacy system and not a lot of commonality between our data sources we have a hideous mashup of Oracle, DB2, Microsoft SQL Server etc and different versions of the different databases. There's also more bespoke industry stuff like time series historians and SCADA systems/PLCs (ABB, Citect etc) to complicate the process.

From my experience SQL is basically the lowest common denominator everything speaks and even then the Oracle SQL dialect is subtly different to Microsoft SQL for example - things are subtly different enough it introduces frustrations.

There has been movement in last couple of years to hoist everything into a common "datalake" but my understanding has been that ingestion into this lake is not a simple process by any means and requires batch processes that need demanding compute resources and is slow (i.e. takes many hours and runs over night).

bigger_cheese··on Deterioration of local community a major driver of loss of play-based childhood
I think there is some generalizing here I grew up in an Australian City in the 90's.

Even back then kids weren't clamoring to play outside in the street. Or ride bikes etc (there was a clique at school who were skateboarders but not a widespread thing). I think it very much depends on the kids temperament, my experience as a kid didn't involve a lot of outdoors activities.

However my parents were pretty big on making sure I had exercise I played sport on the weekend (cricket in the summer and soccer in the winter) and it was non-negotiable my parents insisted on it. If not for sport I don't think I'd have spent any time outdoors at all.

I think Weekend Sport might be an Australian cultural thing does the US have weekend kids sports?

bigger_cheese··on The Mythical Non-Roboticist: Wouldn't it be great if everyone could do robotics?
>Highly constrain your inputs and limit what the robot is supposed to accomplish and you will have an achievable goal.

I think this is the key take away. I work in an industrial plant we have a large amount of things that are automated but I would say they are "dumbly automated".

For example we have automated cranes. This sounds fancy and sophisticated but the whole system is designed to be as dumb as possible.

The Cranes are overhead cranes that run on fixed rails. This immediately limits the degrees of freedom in which crane can move. The whole operation is to pick up object at location A, deposit it at B then travel back to A and repeat. It is always picking up the same objects, with same dimensions/weight etc.

The whole thing is designed to be as dumb as possible it does exactly one thing, I imagine if it suddenly had to pick up a different type of object with different dimensions it would require rewrites etc.

bigger_cheese··on An animated introduction to Fourier series
Internally yes they probably convert but it is not exposed anywhere, kind of like Chemical reaction you convert everything to Mols internally to do the calculations but externally you report all of the inputs as a mass.

The control system won't tell the operator to add an extra 0.3 mols of reactant or to tilt the furnace by Pi/4 radians

bigger_cheese··on An animated introduction to Fourier series
Output on control system HMI Scada screens for stuff like Tilt Drives are all in degrees as well, in this respect it's like the Kelvin scale. Control system doesn't display thermocouple readings in Kelvin either (at plant I work at Temperature setpoints are displayed as degree Celsius).

You might use Radians/Kelvin internally for ease of calculation but they aren't numbers you quote around or report things in.

bigger_cheese··on Why No Roman Industrial Revolution? (2022)
I'm a materials engineer, off the top of my head, the first thing that comes to mind when you mention access to improved metallurgy is lighter, stronger materials and the impact that would have on construction. That could have lead to larger, taller buildings, stronger city walls etc. Then then probably would be flow on effects since stronger walls means need improved artillery to siege a city etc.

But I think the article did a good job of highlighting that technology developments occur out of local circumstances and requirements. I am no history scholar but I understand the Roman empire was expansive, space wasn't necessarily a constraint so there probably wasn't a huge demand to build larger and taller buildings it would have likely been easier to expand cities outwards rather than upwards.

There was a good documentary series I watched years ago called "Engineering an Empire" they had an episode about the technology of Carthage (Rome's great rival), the series pointed out the city of Carthage had large multi-story buildings shared by several families, kind of pseduo-apartment buildings from what the documentary explained there was much more constraints on space in Carthage as it was very desirable to live inside the city walls this led to the development of this type of construction style. Because of these tall buildings there were more advances in things like plumbing, which was different to what the Romans had at the time. The show also pointed out that Carthage placed more emphasis on Naval power so they had relatively sophisticated harbor design, shipbuilding industries etc.

bigger_cheese··on Don't DRY Your Code Prematurely
This happens with SQL a lot where people copy and paste queries all over the place. Especially for reports, there's always the case where some quick and dirty report was thrown together in 20 mins ends up as something managers can't live without.

Making changes quickly get onerous when the query (or slight variation on it) is pasted into multiple places. Nowadays my org has started to use Power BI so there is also multiple dashboards that all need to be updated.

bigger_cheese··on TimesFM: Time Series Foundation Model for time-series forecasting
There is potential for integrating ML with time series data in industrial applications (things like smelters, reactors etc.), where you have continuous stream of time series measurements from things like gauges and thermocouples. If you can detect (and respond) to changing circumstances faster then a humans in control room reacting to trends or alarms then potential big efficiency gains...

Operator guidance is often based on heuristics - when metric A exceeds X value for Y seconds take action Z. Or rates of change if the signal is changing at a rate of more than x etc.

So in these areas there exists potential for ML solution, especially if it's capable of learning (i.e. last response overshot by X so trim next response appropriately).

bigger_cheese··on Book people think they know why 9-year-olds stop reading for fun
I think it helps if the parents set an example. I grew up in the 90's in a house full of readers, reading was normalized.

Until about age 10 my parents would read to my sisters and I every night. It was part of the bedtime routine. We would gather in my youngest sister's bedroom and my Dad would read a chapter from the book of the week to us before bed. It was mostly stuff like Enid Blighton and Roald Dahl, but I can also remember 'Treasure Island' and '20,000 Leagues under the Sea'.

As we got older it evolved into us reading for ourselves, all of us had a reading light beside our beds and it was normal to read in bed before going to sleep. It essentially became a habit I formed, to this day I still read in bed as an adult.

At least here is Australia, you used to be able to get a lot of things from the local newsagent. I was really interested in computers as a teenager. When my parents would send me to the corner store to grab bread or milk I'd buy a PC Magazine with the spare change and read it cover to cover, some of them would come with neat demo cds etc.

bigger_cheese··on GPT-4.5 or GPT-5 being tested on LMSYS?
Math and Science questions in general chat bots seem to struggle with.

I've asked the chat bot that Microsoft Bing uses (not sure what brand or version it is) Chemistry questions - In the format "Is the reaction between X and Y Exothermic under Z Conditions."

It will give a confident answer including things like chemical equations and citations that is blatantly wrong.

bigger_cheese··on PySheets – Spreadsheet UI for Python
Does it need to be live (i.e when database or underlying spreadsheet updates does it need to be reflected in real time on the dashboard) or are you ok with static display.

Live updating data is a pain I've messed around using javascript to force refresh html iframes on a timer. But I was never really satisfied with this. I've heard you can do things with websockets but that is starting to get too complicated for me (I'm not a programmer).

For static stuff one of the data scientists in my org pointed me to Streamlit (https://streamlit.io/) it's a python package I found very easy to use. Can easily combine SQL with CSV imports and display them all on one dashboard. Can use forms toggle butotns etc to control the display.

bigger_cheese··on Programming Is Mostly Thinking (2014)
Diagrams are what I tend to use as well, my background is Engineering (the non software kind) for solving engineering problems one of the first thing we are taught to do at uni is to sketch out the problem and I have somewhat carried that habit over when I need to write a computer program.

I map out on paper the logical steps my code needs to follow a bit like a flow chart tracking the change in states.

When I write code I'll create like a skeleton with placeholder functions I think I'll need as stubs and fill them out as I go, I'm not wedded to the design sometimes I'll remove/ replace etc whole sections as I get further in but it helps me think about it if I have the whole skeleton "on the page"

bigger_cheese··on Calculus Made Easy
When you mention linking to physics are you talking about Parametric equations?

i.e something like, Distance, Velocity and Acceleration with respect to Time.

Velocity is rate of change of Distance in respect to time (ds/dt) Acceleration is rate of change of velocity in respect to time (dv/dt)

You can derive the equations of motion v^2 = u^2 + 2as etc.

Things like the Bernoulli equation from Fluid Dynamics and a lot of other engineering principles can be derived this way.

bigger_cheese··on Descent 3 Source Code
Zork Nemesis one of my favorite games from the 90's was heavily inspired by Myst it was one of the first games I played where I felt immersed in the game world.
bigger_cheese··on A day in the life of a Walmart manager
I work at an industrial plant (steel mill) - "Walking the floor" is still taught to current managers I think it comes out of LEAN manufacturing or similar. It is supposed to be an informal thing, so not looking over people shoulders and writing things up etc.

I believe the idea is for the manager to be visible and approachable so people can feel comfortable coming up to the manager raising issues etc. If the manager is away off site in an executive office or similar then it becomes an added barrier for people to be able to approach them, to notify them about issues etc.

bigger_cheese··on U.S. Steel Shareholders Approve Sale to Japan's Nippon Steel
Thanks for sharing, good article. I work in the Steel industry but was not all that familiar with the US history, my experience from the last 20 years is that the JKT area (Japan, Korea, Taiwan) have been the leaders with innovative technology and operating expertise, more recently Europeans have been doing interesting things with Hydrogen/green steelmaking for example.

The feeling I get at the moment is the industry is very much entering a transitional phase, I think we are seeing the sunset of the Blast Furnace era, it's kind of where the open hearth furnace was at the dawn of BOF, something is going to have to replace BFs but it's still not 100% clear what the replacement is going to look like (or even if there will be a one size fits all replacement for Blast Furnace, it's possible that several processes will emerge suited to different regions) companies are reluctant to blink first and back the wrong horse. The capital costs are very high so backing the wrong technology and needing to pivot later could be ruinous.

Over the next 5 years or so I expect we will start seeing more (and larger) pilot scale projects but I don't think BFs will truly start getting displaced until early to mid 2030's. Companies still clinging to BF into the 2040's will be in trouble in my opinion.

bigger_cheese··on Using ClickHouse to scale an events engine
>You can always use different databases for different use cases.

Unfortunately this is not always realistic, especially in large organizations, I know where I am there is a big push from top (i.e the IT budget people) to standardize everything they want to simplify licenses, support contracts etc.

I may not be doing cutting edge stuff (I work at an Industrial plant) but we do have mixed data use cases where it could be beneficial to use different dbs but realistically I don't see it happening.

bigger_cheese··on Adventures Making Vegemite
Yes Bundaberg Lemon Lime and Bitters is excellent. I believe they were originally an alcohol company Bundaberg Rum, is a relatively popular spirit.
bigger_cheese··on The design philosophy of Great Tables
I Use SAS reports in my job pretty heavily I'm keen to find alternatives - this looks pretty promising.

One thing in particular I'm interested in but could not see an example for is if this will let you insert "break lines" i.e. for displaying sub totals and similar.

For example based on the demo, which shows names and addresses from census data it might be nice to be able to break at each change in postcode and display some summary data like a count of people found at that postcode or an average age (based on the DOB) living at that postcode or similar.

Otherwise conditional formatting is another pain point either using rules i.e. if value in column B is greater than a specified threshold make the entire row bold. Or automatically creating a color gradient to highlight the cells ala Excel.

For bonus points management types like things like red and green traffic lights (or down/up arrows) you can display next to kpi data in a table It's a gimmick but wins you points.

← PreviousPage 3 of 23Next →