HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigger_cheese

1,210 karma · joined February 4, 2015

submissionscomments
bigger_cheese··on Sam Bankman-Fried Convicted
I am Australian. When I was assigned Jury duty in 2016, my Company continued to pay me (I think this is a legal requirement if you are a full time employee), I showed my manager the letter from the court and I was instructed to enter a leave request via usual HR system we use - there was an option for Jury duty.

I was also paid by the court for attending jury duty (a physical check that arrived in the mail a few months later). It was not very much money (I think around $20 per day) - this money was supposed to cover things like Transport, parking fees and meals. In my case the trial was called off after 3 days so the check was for around $60.

Maybe if you are part time or on a contract it is different.

bigger_cheese··on The business of extracting knowledge from academic publications
I'm an Engineer (not a scientist) not sure how much is applicable to other fields but when I've been interested in what the "current state of topic X is" I have looked for recently published thesis on the topic, a good thesis will have summarized the papers for me (gone through all the churn of papers and highlighted the key points).

I think this is kind of what the author attempted to build (i.e. something that spits out the Literature review portion of a thesis.)

I think that's probably why graduate students were excited - they are the people who have to write a thesis at the end of the day.

bigger_cheese··on Rules of schema growth (2017)
Thankyou - good to know there is a name for the pattern I'm reading more about it now.
bigger_cheese··on Rules of schema growth (2017)
>Probably an unpopular opinion, but I think having a central database that directly interfaces with multiple applications is an enormous source of technical debt and other risks, and unnecessary for most organizations. Read-only users are fine for exploratory/analytical stuff, but multiple independent writers/cooks is a recipe for disaster.

In my org I've felt the pain of having centralized DBs (with many writers and many readers) a lot of our woes come because of legacy debt some of these databases are quite old - a number date back to the mid 90's so over time they've ballooned considerably.

The Architecture I've found which makes things less painful is to transition the the centralized database into two databases.

On Database A you keep the legacy schemas etc and restrict access only to the DB writers (in our case we have A2A messaging queues as well as some compiled binaries which directly write to the DB). Then you have data replicated from database A into database B. Database B is where the data consumers (BI tools, reporting, etc) interface with the data.

You can exercise greater control over the schema on B which is exposed to the data consumers without needing to mass recompile binaries which can continue writing to Database A.

I'm not sure how "proper" DBAs feel about this split but it works for my usecase and has helped control ballooning legacy databases somewhat.

bigger_cheese··on Linear Algebra Done Right – 4th Edition
I can second this, in my Engineering degree the Linear Algebra course (and the Calculus course) were both taught by the Math Faculty at my Uni.

The textbook we used was "Linear Algebra: And its Applications" by David C Lay 20 years later I still keep this textbook with me at my desk and consult it a few times a year when I need to jog my memory on something. I consider it to be a very good textbook even if it doesn't it doesn't contain any rigorous proofs or axioms...

bigger_cheese··on The End of the Googleverse
I was pretty fortunate. My Dad was a veterinarian who taught himself to program (in Pascal) he knew a lot about a certain era of computing - early 90's MS-DOS 386 era PC's. His tech skills kind of atrophied and stagnated he never really adopted to the Win 9x gui first era of computing but he still had his ear to the ground enough to tip me off about google.
bigger_cheese··on The End of the Googleverse
In the Pre-google days of the internet you used to have to play "search engine bingo" to find useful results I remember jumping between Lycos, Metacrawler, Altavista and Infoseek and it was still a coin flip if you would get useful results.

Search engines used to require you to use Boolean operators "+" "AND" "OR" "NOT" to filter search results. My high school library had a laminated card next to the internet connected PC (via dial up modem) explaining how Boolean operators worked and with suggested search engines to use (this was around 1996/1997).

The eye opener to me was my high school class was given an assignment to write about the upcoming "G8 Summit", Russia had just joined the G7 creating the G8 and it was a big news story at the time. I can remember how frustrating it was to find any results searching for things required constructing strings like "G+8+Summit OR Group+of+8+Summit"etc in sites like infoseek and still getting nonsense results. I found the information I needed to complete the assignment by going to public library which had copies of various daily newspapers archived I basically quoted newspaper articles to complete the assignment and concluded the internet was useless for finding information. I complained about my situation at home and my Dad Casually mentioned have you tried "google.com" next ay at school I typed "G8 Summit" into google and immediately got relevant results. I was a convert to google immediately it was so far ahead of every other search engine at the time it was like night and day.

bigger_cheese··on Ask HN: Why did Python win?
The main argument seems to be comments should left with the commit message and not "inline" i.e mixed with the code. Personally I make heavy use of inline style comments.
bigger_cheese··on Ask HN: Why did Python win?
>I haven't seen anything an "A-type" data scientist needs in R/SAS/SPSS that was intrinsic to the language and couldn't be ported to Python.

I don't know what "A-Type" is so I might be misunderstanding you.

For SAS at least in my Org what keeps it entrenched is Enterprise Guide and the associated environment. Having a drag and drop GUI to do the data extraction and manipulation and the analytical tasks makes it very easy for non experts to be incredibly productive. The people that use it here are Engineers (Non-software variety) and Finance accountant types. These people would not be productive writing python code (or R) but still need to use something heavier then excel for data analysis.

Over the years we have chipped away at parts of SAS with things like Power BI and Azure ML Studio but I don't see python playing in the same space.

bigger_cheese··on Ask HN: Why did Python win?
I run into this problem as well I'll often come across something I wrote a few years ago and struggle to remember why I wrote it that way.

I've learned to add comments to my code - from what I see commenting code is frowned upon by a certain subset of developers but I've taught myself that whenever I am doing something subtle or unintuitive to add a short comment explaining what the code is doing, for every potentially unnecessary comment I've added I've also saved myself time when I've had to come back to something months or years later and been able to refer back to the comment.

bigger_cheese··on SEC charges Impact Theory for unregistered offering of NFTs
In the case of Magic the Gathering in the 90's (the early days of MTG), Wizards of the Coast released a print run of cards the "Chronicles" set which contained reprints of cards from the earliest days of the game.

This caused a large controversy because the chronicles print run was massively larger than earlier print runs and suddenly there was an influx of cards in circulation where previously due to the limited print runs of the early sets these cards were exceptionally rare. This tanked the value of the secondary card market.

Due to the bad PR and negative attention this caused at the time WotC ended up publishing "The Reserved list" a list containing around 550 cards which they guarantee will never be reprinted.

This means for an iconic MTG card like "Black Lotus" there is a limited number of these cards in circulation and no new Black Lotuses will ever be printed.

The reserved list somewhat mollified the people that were baying for Wotc's blood at the time but now 30 years later it is more or less regarded as a mistake. There are a lot of armchair lawyers etc speculating on if they could ever renege on the reserve list and if it even represents an enforceable contract. WotC have basically refused to comment (possibly lawyers have told them not too).

bigger_cheese··on In the '90s I survived summers in Egypt with no AC. How would it feel now?
It depends where in Sydney you are - if you live near the coast it is quite livable. The outer suburbs can be absolute hell. Parts of Western Sydney etc can be quite bad in the summer. I remember hearing at one point a year or so ago Penrith was the hottest place on earth I think it hit 48C or something like that.

I grew up in Canberra (which is inland and sits in a valley) it was like living in a giant clay bowl all the heat settles in and is absolutely stagnant not much of a breeze to speak about at all. Summer there was pretty miserable (and winter as well).

I now live on the South Coast of NSW - I can get away with a ceiling fan and opening my windows, we get a regular afternoon sea breeze which cools everything down.

bigger_cheese··on Programmers should not call themselves engineers (2015)
>If a car has a poorly-engineered suspension and a wheel breaks off and someone gets killed, does the engineer at Ford who designed it get sued personally?

I believe the laws differ by country. In the above circumstance where I am based (Australia) the person who signed off (edit: certified) after reviewing the suspension design would assume the liability. And may get taken to court where you would need to demonstrate you followed best practices may be ask to supply calculations etc.

For example my company we are required legally to keep things like calculations and technical drawings on file in archives for things like above hypothetical.

edit: Article here: https://eea.org.au/insights-articles/make-defensible-safety-...

bigger_cheese··on Programmers should not call themselves engineers (2015)
>Having a set of defined rules to follow is not engineering

It is a part of being an engineer, but it is not the entirety of the profession (I'd probably use the word Standards rather than rules). I think the software world has standards to for things like networking etc - does it count as a programmer following a set of rules if he writes networked software? Maybe...

>The real meaning for engineer is someone who builds complex stuff that require years of learning and practice for the majority of the population.

I don't think this really fits either. Throughout my career I have spent very little time building anything, a large amount of the work is optimizing existing problems/products/processes (this is where tradeoffs the GP mentioned comes in) "How can this be made cheaper, How can it become more efficient, How can it be made lighter etc."

If I had to come up with my own definition it would be something like "Engineering is solving technical problems within an applied set of Constraints" - That probably does not apply to a surgeon - but could be applied to software.

bigger_cheese··on Programmers should not call themselves engineers (2015)
I'm a non software engineer so maybe I do have a chip on my shoulder, personally I don't really have a beef with what people call themselves, however I will say the distinguishing factor in my opinion between software and the broader engineering world is liability and the culture that exists around that. I am professionally held liable for any work I perform while calling myself an engineer. There can be potentially very serious consequences if I am found to have been negligent or to have not followed best practices.

In most parts of the software world I don't think there exists similar circumstances. I'm not sure if there are agreed industry best practices or certification requirements for most types of software development.

bigger_cheese··on Microsoft is bringing Python to Excel
How do you lock down Excel - that is the issue we have where I work and the main reason excel is strongly discouraged.

There are two main issues my org has battled with:

1.People basically turn excel into their own mini databases which causes a support nightmare.

2. This is strongly related to 1) Data provenance is a nightmare because so many people were passing around excel spreadsheets it became very difficult to track down the source of the figures people were using. User A passed their spreadsheet to user B who modified it passed it to User C who further modified it, passed it to User d from there some figures ended up in front of a manager and now we have a problem...

It's not so much a problem with Power users those are the types of people using python (or R) it's the tier of users below that level that cause the damage with excel.

bigger_cheese··on So you want to learn physics (2021)
Agreed, I studied Materials Engineering - Fluid Dynamics was one of the hardest subjects in my opinion. I liked thermodynamics it made sense to me, solid mechanics was a bit of a slog to get through (endless amounts of beam deflection) but fluid dynamics arrghh.

I chose to take a particle physics course as an elective in my final year - I was planning to specialize in battery and capacitor technologies and wanted to learn more.

The lectures were very different to Engineering much, much more theory focused(almost nothing on applications) it was my introduction to things like Hamiltonians, Wave Functions and Fermi-Dirac statistics. I'm glad I took the course I learnt a heap especially about semi-conductors it gave me a better appreciation and understanding of things we covered in my engineering degree like magnetism and phonons/heat transfer as well. But I will say it did feel like another world compared to Engineering - there was much less in common than I would have thought.

bigger_cheese··on ‘Baldur’s Gate 3’ Prepared for 100k Concurrent Players, They’ve Gotten 700K
I think you've hit the nail on the head here with the illusion of choice in some games it really feels like the story is on rails and your character had very little agency. Mass Effect series in particular I think is to blame for this the series became incredibly popular but the actual role playing elements were not really there - these games had a Hero/Villain slider and every conversation had basically 3 dialogue options, the edgy sarcastic reply, the goody two shoes reply or the neutral reply. You would arrive at same place on dialogue tree. The story proceeded the same way regardless of how you chose to act. Because of how popular Mass Effect was I think it had a warping effect on the genre.

Voice acting as well is another key thing I think easy to overlook but it helps a lot with the immersion and getting invested in the world. Pathfinder Wrath of Righteous was a fun game but lack of voice acting made it a slog to get through there were what felt like paragraphs of text to read through constantly. By mid way through the game I found myself skipping over a lot of it. Imagine if tabletop roleplaying the DM handed you a stack of paper to read every conversation instead of narrating what was happening - that was kind of how I felt.

bigger_cheese··on ‘Baldur’s Gate 3’ Prepared for 100k Concurrent Players, They’ve Gotten 700K
The difficulty ramps a fair bit at least in my experience I have just started act 3.

There are also zones later in the acts where they disable resting - this really impacts spell casters. You have to really ration your ability usage (rely on consumables for healing etc), somewhat annoyingly you have no real way of knowing how far through the no-rest zones you are (could be 4 or 5 fights in a row you need to get through or only 1 or 2). I'd often end these zones with big spells still in reserve cleric in particular with turn undead would have helped immensely in one area but I thought there would be another fight still to come so I saved it. This is somewhat true to tabletop D&D but left me feeling a little frustrated I think on repeated playthroughs these areas will be much less frustrating.

bigger_cheese··on An Introduction to APIs
I always thought of API in the sense of POSIX Or NFS etc. A common interface that existed across different libraries regardless of the vendors. Designed for interoperability.
bigger_cheese··on Whom the gods would destroy, they first give real-time analytics (2013)
This is something I have been grappling with for a while - I work with data in an industrial plant there is a lot of legacy data systems here and "data latency" has been a real issue - real time dashboards are seen by some subset of management as the holy grail, being able to look at any part of our plant and see what is happening in real time is extremely attractive to certain people.

For a longtime there has been a lot of resistance "real time is too hard" used to get thrown around a lot- what is really driving it in last two years or so are Machine Learning and computer vision applications. There has been a huge push to integrate ML models (for example live defect detection) into our operating process which has necessitated low latency access to real time plant data.

The data pipelines we've had to build to enable these ML applications have bough latency way down all over the place and have kind of bought other applications like real time dashboards with them for "free".

bigger_cheese··on Death Metal English (2013)
I always enjoyed Bolt Thrower's brand of Death Metal English - they had a kind of brutal minimalism to their lyrics.

"Spent Rounds, The Coffin Nails, On Your Empires Fall"

bigger_cheese··on Hollywood movie aside, just how good a physicist was Oppenheimer?
Other way around for me "Fermion" "Fermi-Dirac Statistics" "Fermi Energy Level" etc. There are a lot of things in physics named after Fermi not aware of anything named after Oppenheimer.
bigger_cheese··on ‘No way out’: how video games use tricks from gambling to attract big spenders
At the point where you reach the stage you need to start worrying about stash space in Path of Exile you are going to be many, many hours into the game. And once you purchase the enhanced storage space it is a permanent addition to your account. Personally I don't mind this form of monetization. As far as predatory strategies goes it is on the low end.

I played Genshin Impact earlier this year I was enjoying the game until it sank in just how predatory the whole thing felt - they had timegates baked into the game to encourage you to spend money - there was a limit to how much of the in-game currency you could earn each day (it was also a very low maximum cap). You needed to spend this currency to level up items and characters etc so it placed a deliberate block on how quickly you could progress and of course you could spend money to bypass this block. Not only that but because of how little of the currency you could carry it created a massive FOMO loop where you needed to be logging in everyday to spend your allotted quota ro you would miss out on making progress on your account.

bigger_cheese··on Refusing to teach kids math will not improve equity
>"But teacher, I'll always have a calculator". Damn right. A calculator and Wikipedia and chatgpt. Remembering the quadratic equation is literally useless knowledge to retain.

Memorizing the exact formula of the Quadratic equation may not be necessary - knowing that the quadratic equation exists and what it is does is the useful part. Even more useful is to recognize a problem and realize the quadratic equation applies to it.

Trigonometry or calculus are better examples of this. Memorizing every formula and then promptly forgetting about them 5 minutes after passing the test is not useful but learning the concepts and the fundamentals and how they apply to solving a whole slew of problems is the useful part. Algebra is extremely abstract (especially if you are a school pupil - "I'll never use this in the real world") but understanding it unlocks a whole lot of higher level conceptual ways of thinking and approaching problem solving.

You'll have far better success using a calculator (or chat GPT or Wikipedia) if you know not just what to punch into it by the why as well.

bigger_cheese··on There is no data engineering roadmap
>a lot of the problems that data teams face in my experience are around how to expose data to the organization in a meaningful, regular, digestible, actionable way. This means thinking about how to ingest and transform data and present it to end users for analysis (BI) in such a way that it’s not painful or arduous to consume it, and ensuring that it is clean and accurate

100% this. I basically work in this role in my organization. I'm not sure how typical my experience is compared with other people who call themselves 'data Engineers'. I'm usually put into the situation where I'm looking at how to capture a raw signal (out of an instrument, device or similar) and package it up as structured data and store it in some kind of meaningful format people can use.

Useful skills I think (other than SQL) are: -Some understanding of PLCs/SCADA/OPC communication world. -knowledge about Signal analysis/ DSP, Kalman Filters, Fourier Transforms etc. Especially useful when you need to store a raw signal as "data" of some kind. also increasingly useful when the underlying data is in some format like Video, Audio etc. -An Understanding of working with Time Series analysis can help with data transformation etc (downsampling a high frequency signal into lower frequency one for example).

Once you have captured the signal and stored it you move on to the second part how to make it available to end users in a meaningful and accessible way - this is where SQL knowledge and working with DBAs comes into it. In my experience it has become increasingly common you need to understand about cloud architecture etc as well. For example in my org more and more of our storage is moving to Azure so knowing how to navigate that stack and all the terms they use for things can help save a lot of time and frustration.

Lastly it can help if you are at least somewhat familiar with the BI tools the end users will be using to ultimately leverage the data.

bigger_cheese··on Proof you can do hard things
As an engineer calculus is pretty fundamental to my job. It underpins all sorts of stuff - Heat transfer, fluid flow, stress and strain rates, beam deflection, fracture mechanics etc.

I may not be solving differential equations by hand but I'm using knowledge about calculus everytime I reason about our industrial process.

The excel part is probably referring to solvers - where you plug in boundary conditions and spits out a solution. Edit - and excel or R (or Matlab) is what you use in lieu of needing to solve this stuff by hand.

bigger_cheese··on Proof you can do hard things
Rightly on Wrongly some areas of study have the reputation/stigma of being difficult attached to them.

Back when I was a high school student math (not just calculus - but the entire subject of mathematics) had this reputation as being a "hard" subject as a result scores of my fellow students just decided math is to difficult I'm not going to engage with this.

I suspect this is related to a fear of failure or kids being afraid of "looking dumb" in front of their friends - There was a definite "if I don't try then it doesn't matter if I can't do it." attitude, so they just switched off in those particular classes.

A lot of these attitudes carry forward into adulthood. I'm almost 40 and amongst my generation programming has a similar reputation. People I grew up with think if you can read or write code you are some kind of mystical wizard with powers beyond the understanding of mere mortals.

I see it today at my day job - I work as an engineer (the non software kind). I've seen my coworkers completely baulk at computer code I hear all the same things I heard back in high school. "This is too hard, I can't learn this stuff, I'm not going to bother attempting to understand it".

Fluid Dynamics was a hard subject (in my opinion), Solid Mechanics was challenging a dozen lines of python code is not on the same level.

bigger_cheese··on The 90s Developer Starter Pack
I had a 486 DX4/100mhz from around 1996 until 2001, I could not afford anything better - My Dad had a Pentium 166 but it was reserved for his work and was way more expensive then the 486 which was my personal computer, which I personally purchased for my own use - which in those days was mostly gaming.

The 486 was an absolute workhorse however one thing I do remember is it struggled to play MP3's in Winamp it would peg the CPU at 100% and made multitasking basically impossible. It wasn't until I upgraded from the 486 that I could play Quake and Mp3's at the same time.

bigger_cheese··on Let the internet be grimy
> is about filing off the edges and rounding all corners to make the world safer for the common denominator and i don't have to like it.

In my opinion it is about making the online world safer for advertisers. The advertisers are the real customers of the internet - users are just the product.

The evolution of the internet is being increasingly driven by profit seeking and most common way people try to monetize the internet is through advertising. That is primarily what drives censorship and moderation - a need to protect the advertiser's brands.

The old internet that so many people are pining for in this thread comes from a time before big ad-tech. All the old schools forums, newsgroups etc didn't care about making a buck - heck most of them probably ran at a loss. All of that was eaten by social media, there was a transition away from internet communities, to for profit businesses instead.

← PreviousPage 5 of 23Next →