3,313 karma · joined May 8, 2024
This scandal has felt like a litmus test for free market idealists vs realpolitik thinkers. Nvidia's board and Trump both knew about the spying allegations for over a year, allegedly. This is not a situation you can navigate with strong principles or a moral compass, you just have to follow the money.
Realistically speaking, "catch up to TSMC" is something that every single EUVL fab has failed to do despite tens of billions of dollars in investment. Spending money is the easy part, developing high-yield processes over a timetable of decades is the hard part. I think Nvidia and Apple both agree that paying TSMC to build American fabs is a smarter use of their money if they just want excess fab capacity.
My stake is trying to point out ban evaders. Feel free to audit my comment history if you want, it's pretty banal.
If Apple can't place DDR5 orders that outbid the HBM demand, then yeah, Apple Silicon is going to get fucked over by every vendor. They'll be laughing their way to the bank while Apple begs Californian courts to give them free RAM.
The proliferation of web-based enterprise software mostly stands to Windows and ChromeOS' advantage. macOS is the platform that has relied on "native" and "ecosystem" efforts that are becoming increasingly unpopular among consumers and industry pundits that don't like paying per-seat for software services. The Mac Pro used for render farms, on-prem hosting and cluster computing was depreciated completely, driving some of Apple's highest-margin customers over to Linux and Windows servers. Apple has absolutely began their Mac pivot to prosumer/B2C vending, and it's resulted in advertisements and SaaS slop invading macOS.
Lenovo will keep selling laptops because that's their product equivalent to the iPhone. Apple's equivalent to the iPhone is... well, the iPhone. If they see an opportunity to force Mac users into an iPad-esque experience, they'll take it in a heartbeat and play coy asking "what's a computer?" like the iPad advertisements. The Mac not an important product for Apple these days, the App Store is.
You tell me.
SK hynix, Samsung and Micron are all eager to squeeze Apple for the market price of DDR5. They won't build extra fab capacity for them because Nvidia, AMD and OpenAI will outbid them for future capacity. Products like HBM are overbooked right now too, which means that building an extra DDR5 facility might just end up feeding the enterprise HBM market.
And CXMT has refused Apple's business entirely: https://appleinsider.com/articles/26/08/06/chinese-ram-suppl...
https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=kidme5
https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=georgeg23
Spoiler alert: they're supply-constrained too. Their customers will pay to outbid Apple, just like how Apple outbid the industry on TSMC's 5nm node.
Apple would make more money investing in a CUDA-style architecture than they would by becoming a subsistance manufacturer for the pitiful margins of the iPhone, iPad and Mac.
Design, engineering capability and money are all a problem here, and the onus falls on you to prove otherwise.
It's nice to have these types of niches when they make you money. But the Mac isn't profitable like the iPhone is, and probably makes less money than the iPad does if you count aftermarket service sales. The further Apple drifts from their roots as a computer manufacturer, the more the Mac starts to look like a liability to them.
Apple's Last Stand is their prosumer segment, and once that's gone I don't think their vertical integration playbook gets them anywhere further. Their bottom line is dependent on finding new ways to make B2C profitable, which has resulted in subscription services like AppleTV/Apple Music/iCloud so far.
Do you have any FTC-associated quotes that confirm your claim that they approved the merger for GOP parity with Democrat-aligned media? I suspect not, that would be totally crazy.
Even so, DDR5 is so high-demand that it's likely that Apple can't outbid customers like Nvidia or OpenAI when they drive the margins they do.
Factoring in the increased cost of memory, Apple's threatened service revenue and the stagnation of ecosystem products like the Mac and iPad, I think they have a really challenging future to navigate. The whole "sell people a B2C ecosystem" business model is more threatened than ever.
Do you have a citation for that, or are you putting words into the FTC's mouth that nobody ever said?
What causes you to disagree?
Bitwig has so many tiny conveniences like this that I never bothered to renew my Live license. Native Linux support is the cherry on top.
Viral licenses like the GPL are a shot across the bow for anyone foisting downstream code and laundering it as their own features. Omarchy can still use Asahi's upstream code, but they generally shouldn't take credit for downstream work.
The top comment is correct to question the title, as it leads to more interesting HN comments than the driveby CEO pugilism that many bottom-barrel commentators participate in. Your response to the top comment is condescending and speculative instead of curious or informative. It seems to me like people are fulminating on both sides, and clearly Nvidia's board doesn't know the whole story either.
HN's title, as the top comment alleges, is extremely misleading as to what the board's goals are.