HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

biimugan

146 karma · joined April 29, 2018

submissionscomments
biimugan··on Palestinian activist arrested by ICE while expecting U.S. citizenship interview
He allegedly supports Hamas? Is that in the article somewhere? It seems to me people are simply making things up to justify what seems pretty unjustifiable.
biimugan··on U.S. cites its power to deport people for beliefs
I don't think you have the facts of the matter or the context right here. The government absolutely does not have the right to expel legal permanent residents without due process. And 'keeping their mouths shut' and pretending otherwise is not even remotely, feasibly "reasonable". The Supreme Court literally just ruled that residents with much less legal status than this person must be given due process -- an entirely obvious statement. But one which apparently needs to be reaffirmed by the highest court in the land because of how casually this administration seems to discard basic tenets of U.S. law. So you're just outright wrong.

The government absolutely did prevent this person from 'saying whatever he wants' -- he was essentially abducted from New Jersey and sent to detention in Louisiana without the ability to contact his family or his lawyer, or get any sort of hearing. It's only after the fact, due to the work of his lawyers and the public outcry, that he was able to submit a habeas petition. You seem to be downplaying how violent and seemingly corrupt the government's actions were in this case (I guess because you ultimately disagree with whatever you imagine this person did). Just because one Louisiana DoJ immigration judge sided with their own branch of government doesn't really lend plausibility to the government's case.

biimugan··on RFK Jr. forces out FDA's top vaccine scientist, Peter Marks
"Blue states" are not airgapped enclaves, completely distinct and separate from other states. And there's a lot of diversity just within those states. The approach you're suggesting is not remotely viable. People who vaccinate can still contract illnesses and die from those illnesses. Many people can't vaccinate at all. Herd immunity is an absolutely essential part of the public health benefit of vaccination.
biimugan··on New maps of the chaotic space-time inside black holes
Your first link goes to a 2023 arXiv pre-print that never landed in any journals as far as I can tell (could be wrong though). And there seems to be some controversy about whether Kerr's math shows what he says it shows.

This is the danger of trying to sensationalize science and putting any special weight on science influencers, especially ones who very often seem gung-ho about any story that challenges the status quo despite the evidence.

biimugan··on "Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies" – Executive Order
This whole situation really goes to show that both the judiciary and the legislature need to be greatly expanded -- probably by 10 fold or more. Even if you greatly reduce the size of the federal government.

The executive employs approximately 3,000,000 employees. The federal judiciary only employs about 30,000 total, and the legislature about 20,000 total. The sheer velocity with which the executive can ram through questionable directives *and have them executed upon* (despite the law) means the other "co-equal" branches of government are always potentially on the back foot. It's just a personnel game. Trump has only highlighted how absurdly easy it is to abuse this imbalance.

And after the Chevron and Trump decisions, it's only going to get worse and worse. I do think these Federalist Society types who pushed these unitary executive theory ideas have now created a monster. They've created a situation where the executive has immunity to simply apply the law however it wants, clogging up the judiciary with civil and federal suits, and where the Congress cannot pass laws fast enough or with great enough specificity to avoid defying Chevron or avoid executive misapplication. Meanwhile the executive has long since moved on from the original issue to the next 10 issues, and the next 10, and the next 10, while the courts and the Congress are still only getting started on the first few problems. And the executive will never really get "punished" for these actions because of its supposed immunity.

And presidential elections don't really help with this problem. Because one president has 4 years to drastically reshape everything, and the next president will spend all of their 4 years reverting it, dropping all the previous suits, creating its own litany of new suits, and rinse and repeat. The hysteresis of this process is too long and leads to instability and chaos.

biimugan··on Hell is overconfident developers writing encryption code
Only tangential to this post, but if you need a way to share secrets with your teams (or whoever), Hashicorp Vault is pretty decent. They don't even need login access. Instead of sharing secret values directly, you wrap the secret which generates a one-time unwrapping token with a TTL. You share this unwrapping token over a traditional communication method like Slack or e-mail or whatever, and the recipient uses Vault's unwrap tool to retrieve the secret. Since the unwrapping token is one time use, you can easily detect if someone intercepted the token and unwrapped the secret (by virtue of the unwrapping token no longer working). This hint tells you the secret was compromised and needs to be rotated (you just need to follow-up with the person to confirm they were able to retrieve the secret). And since you can set a TTL, you can place an expectation on the recipient too -- for example, that you expect them to retrieve the secret within 10 minutes or else the unwrapping token expires.

All of this has the added benefit that you're not sharing ciphertext over open channels (which could be intercepted and stored for future decryption by adversaries).

biimugan··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
This type of comment is another thing I don't quite understand -- as if no one but AI proponents have heard of the Singularity. "There's no point in investing in anything else" is a very presumptive, fact-free idea. It's just begging the question. Many promising false starts have occurred in this area. Predictions from technologists such as Kurzweil have been wrong more than they've been right.
biimugan··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
Right, but $500 billion in data centers alone is not likely to get you very far in the grand scheme of things. Endlessly scaling up today's technology eventually hits some kind of limit. And if you spend that money to discover some theoretical breakthrough that no longer requires the $500 billion outlay, then like I said, China will trivially be able to steal that breakthrough and spend much less than $500 billion to reproduce it. Is "getting there first" going to actually be worth it? That's what I'm questioning.
biimugan··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
I really don't understand the national security argument. If you really do fear some fundamental breakthrough in AI from China, what's cheaper, $500 billion to rush to get there first, or spending a few billion (and likely much less) in basic research in physics, materials science, and electronics, mixed with a little bit of espionage, mixed with improving the electric grid and eliminating (or greatly reducing) fossil fuels?

Ultimately, the breakthrough in AI is going to either come from eliminating bottlenecks in computing such that we can simulate many more neurons much more cheaply (in other words, 2025-level technology scaled up is not going to really be necessary or sufficient), or some fundamental research discovery such as a new transformer paradigm. In any case, it feels like these are theoretical discoveries that, whoever makes them first, the other "side" can trivially steal or absorb the information.

biimugan··on Twitch blocks creating new accounts from Israeli IP's
It's a simple answer. Businesses are amoral organizations that only care about a few things, some of them being profits and their image (which is tied to their profits). I would've been surprised if Twitch didn't suspend them given that the ADL and other powerful political organizations were exerting pressure. From Twitch's perspective it's such a minute price to pay.
biimugan··on Colorado scrambles to change voting-system passwords after accidental leak
Ultimately, people who complain about what methodologies, technologies, and procedures x, y, or z states, counties, or precincts are using need to contend with the fact that the only surefire way to reliably solve these issues is with federal standards, funding, and now, seemingly, physical security for poll workers and officials. But this level of centralization and funding is almost assuredly never going to materialize in the U.S. And the people who wield election security as a political cudgel know it's not going to materialize. How awfully convenient for them.
biimugan··on Twitch blocks creating new accounts from Israeli IP's
For anyone that's confused, there was an event at TwitchCon where some streamers (including one Jewish person) created a tier list. The tier list ranked other streamers according to whether they should be given a "pass" to say the word 'habibi'. The categories included things like 'Arab', 'Arab-coded', and at the bottom 'Loves Sabra'. Sabra, in this case, is a well-known brand of (supposedly not good) hummus (I don't like even good hummus, so I don't know). There's a conspiracy theory (subscribed to by OP) that 'loves Sabra' was actually some kind of code-phrase for a Jewish person because there's a similar sounding Hebrew word that refers to a Jew born in Israel. This led to a lot of people getting very mad.

I say this is a conspiracy theory because if you listen to even five minutes of this (pretty unfunny, admittedly) panel, it's abundantly clear that they are indeed talking about bad hummus, not Jews. In fact, they rank a few known Jewish streamers as Arab or Arab-coded -- i.e. allowed to say 'habibi' -- and vice versa. And, as mentioned, one of the panelists is also Jewish.

There's also the fact that I don't think most people would know this Hebrew word, but would definitely have heard of the brand. So if this is some attempt to promote antisemitism, it seems pretty lousy. If this was an attempt at antisemitism, it also doesn't make much sense to single out only Jews born in Israel. Antisemitism doesn't make this distinction (at least that I've ever heard). It usually focuses exclusively on 'global cabals' and the 'new world order' and conspiracies of that nature.

biimugan··on Uncensor any LLM with abliteration
Surely there's some difference between text that a human wrote with some purpose, even a nefarious one, and an AI writing text with complete amorality. To lump those two things together is missing the point entirely. When I read the writings of a human that I suspect might be derogatory or objectionable in nature, I can look that person up and get a better understanding of their world view, their politics, their past writings, and so on. I can build context around the words they're uttering. With an AI, there's no plausible mechanism to do that. Whether you like it or not, the vast majority of people are not skeptical of plausible-sounding falsehoods. And it's made 100 times worse when there's no mechanism for such a person to research what is being uttered. The vast majority of "objectionable" (if you want to call that) human writing is, at the very least, sensible in some context, and it's possible to learn that context to make an informed judgement. It's just simply not the case with AI. And when there's a media brand sitting at the top of the page, and there are advertisements, and it's in the news, and when there's trillions (?) in financial backing -- sorry, people are going to take what comes out of these systems at face value. That much is proven.

Personally I'm fine with zero censorship of generative AI. But then ban advertising about it, ban making false, unproveable claims about how great it is, require prominent legal warnings, make it much easier to sue companies whose AI systems produce negative societal outcomes, prohibit any kind of trademark or copyright on AI-generated material, and so on. But of course, nobody wants to do any of that, because that would ruin the cash cow. This isn't a censorship-gone-awry story. It's a story of companies trying their best to convince regulatory authorities to leave them alone.

biimugan··on Noam Chomsky 'no longer able to talk' after 'medical event'
What's the implication of this comment?
biimugan··on ArgoCD: Use of Risky or Missing Cryptographic Algorithms in Redis Cache
FWIW: The Helm chart has network policy in place:

https://github.com/argoproj/argo-helm/blob/main/charts/argo-...

If you're using a CNI that supports network policy (e.g. AWS VPC CNI on EKS, Calico, etc.), I think this should more or less cover you, but I haven't personally tested it.

I think it's also probably a better practice to install "control plane" type software like Argo on a different, dedicated cluster. Argo supports this concept (and can in fact manage deployments in multiple clusters remotely). This way your main mission workloads are completely segmented from your privileged control plane software. Just as another defense-in-depth measure

biimugan··on IAM Is the Worst
As a side note to all this: Can we please get rid of encoding policy logic in JSON or other proprietary policy languages? I just want Rego, man.

While we're at it, publish these IAM engines as public, open-source projects so that we can write proper unit tests. I don't want to call a policy simulator API.

biimugan··on IAM Is the Worst
CloudTrail is almost never useful on its own. So often CloudTrail will tell you something is denied and give you literally no other useful, direct information, especially as you start dealing with SCP-related denials. CloudTrail gives you a pile of metadata and says "here's everything, you figure it out". A mature audit solution would tell me the exact policy and line number that caused the denial and not play these guessing games.

The comment about out-of-the-box policies is true, I suppose, but hard to take seriously. Almost every policy example you encounter in the AWS documentation is insecure by default. They've gotten better over time noting this and pointing to better examples for different use cases. But it's still pretty bad.

biimugan··on Stop Demanding Dumb Answers to Hard Questions
There are hundreds and thousands of students and faculty in the U.S. I'm sorry, but a handful of examples is not really particularly convincing.

The survey results are interesting, but I think contradict the point you're trying to make in many cases. For example, the survey showed students felt less comfortable discussing abortion. An odd result if the claim is there's some kind of liberal oligarchy that's selectively punishing conservative speech.

biimugan··on Stop Demanding Dumb Answers to Hard Questions
Let me put it to you this way. All you hear about is what is reported in your media of choice. Having lived and worked on campuses before, I can tell you that these individual incidents happen A LOT, whether it's racism, anti-semitism, anti-Muslim attitudes, etc. Almost all of them end with slaps on the wrist because they're deemed one-off events. And almost none of them are reported on. Everything in the media is constantly focusing on anomalous events to drive reactions, just like the one you're having.

People need to step back and realize that the majority of students are 18-21 year olds. They are children. The student codes of conduct are meant to correct bad behavior, not to punish and expel students.

biimugan··on Stop Demanding Dumb Answers to Hard Questions
I don't understand how your claims here are relevant to anything.

In the hearing, Stefanik kept asking the presidents whether a call to genocide was considered bullying and harassment according to the respective universities' codes of conduct. That's a factual question that has an objective answer, which they gave multiple times: it depends if it's pervasive and severe. Which is exactly what those codes of conduct state, namely that a single instance of someone saying something stupid doesn't constitute bullying or harassment according to those policies. The phrasing 'pervasive and severe' comes directly from Harvard's code of conduct, for instance.

But Stefanik would then would casually change the context of her question, using 'bullying and harassment' in a colloquial sense instead of in the sense of her initial question (i.e. the codes of conduct). Why? Maybe to engender exactly the reactionary response that followed. To try and insinuate that the presidents actually think calls to genocide are A-OK under certain situations, namely when it comes to the genocide of Jews. To insinuate, as some (like you) have, that the presidents think some classes of minority populations are worthier of defense than others. To bring into question the utility of a liberal higher education entire.

I'll give her this: Stefanik was very successful (as evidenced by yours and similar comments, and by the mainstream media's reaction) in generating widespread, reactionary approbation. To some of the most banal, legalistic, administrator-speak imaginable. I'm glad this is the state of discourse in this country.

biimugan··on The Hypocrisy of Mandatory Diversity Statements
I would love everyone to just examine the specific situations as they arise instead of immediately jumping to Platonic discussions of merit and race and gender. Otherwise you're falling into a culture war trap that's completely unproductive.

The first problem is there's actually no injury here as far as I can tell. This person did not even submit the paperwork, and thus did not get scored, and thus did not get rejected. The entire thing is based around the assumption that he would get rejected.

But why would he assume that? Maybe it has less to do with his paperwork and more to do with his public activity.

For example, in this case, you have an individual who either tweets or retweets dozens of times daily (DAILY), frequently getting into online arguments. He's active in the conservative online outrage machine, retweeting and interacting with conservative personalities. He has a paid Substack where he opines about the cultural revolution ("Marxist" left unsaid, but obviously present), whether COVID was real, how "the Left" destabilizes society, and other conservative culture war issues. By any stretch of the imagination, this isn't a normal person. This is someone who is loud, addicted to Online Discourse, and who seems like they're looking to make trouble. If someone like this was a colleague, regardless of their political persuasion, I would steer clear of them. This type of person is often not pleasant to be around, and often fails to properly do their job.

biimugan··on A response to the git.centos.org changes
What is the evidence that the proceeds from contracts gained from this change will actually go towards the people doing the work? That's what I always wonder. After all, Red Hat also recently cut hundreds of jobs, similar to other tech companies. Those other tech companies also have their own just-so stories to try to explain why they're making certain decisions. Certainly most of those other companies don't have a large open source business in the same way as Red Hat. That they're all cutting (in one way or another) but all have different excuses is interesting. I do find it pretty hard to believe that the morality and ethics of properly paying engineers for their work has much, if anything, to do with it though.
biimugan··on Lula defeats Bolsonaro to again become Brazil’s president
Fascism is not just "expanding the size of the state". That's just incredibly naive, bordering on denialism. Substitute "the State" with "il Duce" or "der Fuhrer" in the statement you quoted. That's the true meaning behind the statement -- it's propaganda. You really don't need to take the words of notorious propagandists and liars at face value, especially on a subject that's been studied for almost 100 years now.

Mussolini and Hitler did not care about empowering "the State" for its own sake. The State was simply a vehicle to exercise a particular racial and/or political ideology and to gain personal power. If they could've excised state apparatuses and achieved power in some other way, they would've. Indeed, that's exactly what both dictators (though more so Hitler) did once they found the appropriate political leverage to do so. Everything is subordinate not to the State, but to the Fuhrer. The State itself was subordinate to the Fuhrer. You only need look at Hitler's public actions leading up to the war, not to mention the private memoranda, letters, and other documents, to see that. How many times did Hitler risk the complete destruction or occupation of Germany by the Versailles powers? How many times did he exclaim that if he failed, Germany would fail, and would deserve it? Hitler did not care about the State, he cared about his own personal power and legacy and maintaining the facade at all costs.

biimugan··on Lula defeats Bolsonaro to again become Brazil’s president
Nationalize elections? Use electronic voting machines exclusively? Literally the only reasons it works in Brazil (and things which will literally never happen in the U.S.)
biimugan··on Lula defeats Bolsonaro to again become Brazil’s president
Brazilian politics aside, just because Mussolini said it doesn't make it the definition. Of course Mussolini would describe it in such a way -- it's an incredibly self-serving definition. How else is a totalitarian dictator to mask the fact that his regime is entirely about his own personal power and not some Platonic ideal called "the State"? How else is he to rally normally sensible, everyday people around a cause other than to appeal to their sense of nationalism, probably the only commonality they all share? There's a very good reason Hitler was called Fuhrer and Mussolini the Duce. It should give you a very strong clue about the important aspect of fascism that your comment tries to elide
biimugan··on Unprivileged Docker Builds – A Proof of Concept
I don't think this is right. With RDS, for instance, you can reset the 'master' password from within the RDS console. (The RDS service itself retains the real superuser, the user RDS creates for you has some privileges dropped.)

Take EC2 as another example. If you have volume attach/detach permissions and EC2 start/stop permissions, you can stop an arbitrary instance, detach its root volume, reattach it to an instance of your choosing where you have login access, log in, add whatever you want to that volume (including rootkits, etc.), and reattach it back to its initial instance.

Giving someone AWS admin should be considered analogous to giving someone the keys to your racks in a datacenter. There really are many surprising ways that an AWS admin can take control of your infrastructure. Can you put countermeasures in place? Sure, but it's a huge attack surface

← PreviousPage 2 of 2