10 karma · joined January 23, 2019
I'm not taking someone's assessment at face value, I read it, considered the sources, considered pg, and am using it to build an understanding of his work.
You're pretty much spot on with this line. Most people are terrible public intellectuals, and of the people who identify as such, many are profoundly unserious and completely useless. This article is asserting that Paul Graham does not belong in the vanishingly small set of people one should consider as a serious public intellectual.
I’m responding to this claim, maybe we’re talking about different things? My point is really: What if the “work” is running trains to death camps? Shouldn’t employees object? If you believe climate change is as big a threat as scientists claim, I think workers building tools to help fossil fuel extraction have a duty by this historical argument to not “run the trains” or not just “focus on work at work”.
The fact that your nation lost stolen wealth does not absolve it of the crime of theft friend.
> But the theory that wealth is only a result of exploitation is completely wrong. Our wealth in the modern world is mostly the result of technological progress, not of exploitation.
I did not say that, you are straw manning my argument. I am saying that THAT wealth creation, incontrovertibly, was exploitative.
It's also important to remember that when comparing the magnitude of atrocities, both things were still atrocities.
> If you really want to go down that route - you are aware that the USA was taken away from native Americans, who died by the millions?
Of course and I believe those people are owed reparations both for their historically poor treatment and for the continuing violence they face (see standing rock)
Your nation quite literally carried out a genocidal project against non-white people so at this point I'm not even sure what you're arguing.
Yeah, that's gonna be a yikes from me dawg.