HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

black_knight

814 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
black_knight··on Finland's last analogue landline phones go silent after 150 years
What do you mean? Like either you speak or the person in the other end speak? That I don't remember! Was that a restriction on early cellular and cordless phones? Our phones had cords.

I remember we had only one line going into our house, but several phones, so if one picked up one of the other phones one were in the same call.

black_knight··on Finland's last analogue landline phones go silent after 150 years
Where I live we have long since shut down our copper network. I miss the low latency and not constantly talking over each others sentences.
black_knight··on Maybe you should learn something
I find it easier to work out when being mentally exhausted than doing something mentally challenging when physically exhausted. My main sport is climbing and it is perfect for a Friday evening when I am exhausted from my research and teaching job.

Also there are all these feedback loops. Staying active gives motivation to do mentally challenging things, and some of this mental energy can also be invested in learning new ways of staying active!

black_knight··on 24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense (2012)
I usually A/B test the different versions before choosing my canonical one. I will listen to the same sections in each version, flipping back and forth to hear the differences. It is incredible how much finding the right master improves the experience of listening to a track. Often times that means I end up with a hi-res version, but not always.
black_knight··on Asian AI startups launch Mythos-like models
Why would these be independent?
black_knight··on John Jumper to join Anthropic
With Anthropic going public, I wonder how long until enshittification sets in for LLMs. I guess as soon as they have figured out a way to lock-in users and growth slows down.
black_knight··on Norway greenlights first full-scale ship tunnel
Soon enough thought, the AI will learn this too from us and we will have AI bots writing comments about how TFA is AI generated.
black_knight··on TIL: You can make HTTP requests without curl using Bash /dev/TCP
Wait until they hear about Plan 9!
black_knight··on Claude: Elevated errors across many models [resolved]
Fascinating how people have such complete diametrically opposed experiences. I guess both models have it in them to behave very differently in different circumstances and we have very little idea what pushes them in this or that direction. I guess it does boil down to luck!

Personally, Claude Opus (and in the few interactions I had with it, Fable) has been the far the superior experience. GPT-5.5 seems dumber and more certain about presenting me bullshit. Opus has better humor, and is less pretentious in its presentation. But this may all boil down to how the models react to my prompting.

What is without a doubt is that I wish they both were more intelligent – or maybe it is their wisdom I find lacking!

black_knight··on Hetzner Price Adjustment
Judging by the students I have seen, it will take longer. You could become a mediocre programmer in months, and still be useful by doing grunt work. I don’t see how people will become master architects steering fleets of agents without a deep understanding of the fundamentals, which takes longer to master.

Yes, you can vibe up a demo in no time. But LLMs still need guidance to produce an architecture that will hold up to real world scenarios.

black_knight··on Hetzner Price Adjustment
Memories of his work will forever live in the models trained on his GitHub repositories.
black_knight··on Lattice Triangles Are Rare
I am a producer of math. But I feel two ways about AI math.

First I fear slop-math. People producing LLM “proofs” and prose with no value. I do not want to review something the author has spend lies energy on than I will spend reviewing.

Two, I am excited about formal machine-checked proofs. I love formalisation, and if the llm can prove my lemmas I will be a happy camper!

I think my optimism here is coloured by the fact that I am a theory builder, not a problem solver. I will be happy to create beautiful theory, writing (myself) wonderful articles explaining them, but letting the ugly details be formally verified by an LLM.

A problem solver kind of mathematician might feel cheated of all the fun of the llm did all the problem solving.

black_knight··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
I feel like the EU, maybe in collaboration with Norway (oil money and hydroelectric power), should get their ass in gear and start making bigger models.
black_knight··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
I am not fine with that. I have ranted about this before, but until recently the sota models were not intelligent enough for most of my work.

Yesterday Fable 5 finally solved a non trivial problem I had (after working on it for a few hours), and I went to bed excited. Waking up to find that Fable 5 is not available anymore, I guess I should feel happy I have the code it produced yesterday. But frankly I feel like a child having their candy taken from them.

We need open available models as smart as the current US proprietary ones. If intelligence like that becomes common property, i forsee a better future for human kind!

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
Cool! Yes, we are getting there.

Being a theory builder more than a problem solver I am excited for the future.

Also excited for fully formalised mathematics to hit main stream!

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
I have Qwen 3.6 27B and 35B running locally and and coming from Opus it feels like talking to an imposter. Someone who pretends to be competent, but really isn’t. Results are always disappointing. Sonnet is better, but I have given up on asking it. even for simple things I wait for my opus limits to reset.
black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
No one is expecting that! I expect _kb was sarcastic/making a point.

Recently (last couple of months?) these models are becoming useful tools for mathematicians, because they can solve easier problems more quickly, meaning that one can tackle bigger challenges (but maybe not RH et al) piece by piece.

But, there are still definite limits, where one could expect an expert human to solve things, given time, but models do not. Thus, more intelligence would be nice!

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
Hey, stop asking to see my nuts! My nuts are private – okay?

(Joking aside, see sibling threads.)

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
I don’t care to share my exact problems. Mostly because gpt -5.5 hallucinates false solutions, and I would rather not have people reply with "Oh but ChatGPT solves it!", because it takes expert knowledge to debunk them. To their credit ChatGPT will admit their, very fundamental mistakes when pointed out to them. But also because no-one would really care.

I gave a high level description of the problems in a sibling thread. They are the kind of small problems which I suppose every researcher has lying around, waiting for them to think about some day. But not the big problem everyone is waiting for to be solved.

My comment was not meant to be a tease – sorry! I assumed there would be other people in a similar situation, who might relate.

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
Not these. I wonder if the well is poisoned there. The models know that these are "unpossible", so it might not solve them just because… Maybe some day.

I am just testing it on stuff I know intimately myself. I would probably not understand a proof of Collatz if it was dansing in front of me!

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
The medium ones are results where one needs to construct some object, which my intuition tells me should exist. The difficult ones are typically to show that certain objects can not be constructed.

These are not Fields medal type problems, nor know difficult/open conjectures. Just small stuff I have collected in my todo list over the years.

black_knight··on Claude Fable 5
Still does not crack my hardest nuts. Gave it one of them and it blew through my entire allowance on thinking about one question, with no apparent answer in sight!

I see a lot of people saying they are happy with weaker models, but I am the opposite, I need more strength, more intelligence!

I am quite happy that opus 4.8 can do some medium intelligence problems. And maybe Fable 5 can do some more more of those! I have a lot of problems to solve!

black_knight··on Microsoft's open source tools were hacked to steal passwords of AI developers
Do you mean that role based access control (RBAC) should be replaced by something else? Or that just the specific RBAC models in use are broken?

I personally think the, perhaps confusingly named, capability based security models are the way of The Future.

black_knight··on If LLMs Have Human-Like Attributes, Then So Does Age of Empires II
25
black_knight··on Issue for formalised proof of P=NP
While a formalised proof is guaranteed to be a correct proof, the question is “What is it a correct proof of‽”
black_knight··on macOS needs its grid back
We dont have to put up with it. At some point the collective “we” could consider using some other machines with other, more free, operating systems.
black_knight··on ChatGPT for Google Sheets exfiltrates workbooks
I don’t think we have the right mental models of LMM security yet. The lethal trifecta identifies many of the dangerous situations, but only describes the negative space of a solution.

Speculation: I think we must accept that prompt injection happens, and structure the security of the rest of the system around that. Data given to an LLM becomes an agent, so maybe we must give permissions to this data, instead of to the LLM. Not sure exactly how this would look like in practice!

black_knight··on An OpenAI model has disproved a central conjecture in discrete geometry
Sure. These toposes are well known, and proven to be consistent (relative to set theory). For instance Hyland’s effective topos, or Johnstone’s topological topos. The ideas are that these toposes either require everything to be computable, or continuous in some greater sense.

There is also this blogpost by Amdrej Bauer, which can be seems as exploring how it is to be such such a topos: https://math.andrej.com/2006/03/27/sometimes-all-functions-a...

black_knight··on An OpenAI model has disproved a central conjecture in discrete geometry
If this space of possible structure is real, but seemingly immaterial, how does our matter brain access it?

I think we create mathematics as thought structure in our mind. We can agree on things when we create the same structures. But this structure did not exist prior to creation.

black_knight··on An OpenAI model has disproved a central conjecture in discrete geometry
Where does this mathematics exist before we discover it?

I know of no realm where mathematical objects live except human minds.

No, it seems clear to me that mathematics is a creation of our minds.

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →