HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bleah1000

288 karma · joined May 12, 2018

submissionscomments
bleah1000··on Margaret Mitchell fired from Google
Except you can't do that. The problem is Google has no idea that this is where the documents/e-mails went. All they can see is that a large number of documents and e-mails were sent outside of Google. I can't imagine Google would say, well it's okay if you take the law into your own hands. Any lawyer should be able to send a note telling Google to preserve the files for potential litigation. And given that she seems to have people sympathetic to her cause, it's unlikely that Google would be able to make all documents and e-mails she thinks are supportive of her case disappear.

Now, I can see if she wanted to take a few key e-mails out because any lawsuit needs some evidence or it might be quashed in summary judgement. So maybe that's what she thought she was doing, but it sounds like she grabbed a lot more than that. I would also really be wary of this because people can get death threats when e-mail that they thought was company internal are leaked out. I wouldn't be surprised that a bunch of e-mails will make it into a lawsuit with the people's names on them. Anyone knows that lawsuits can easily take an e-mail out of context to make it say something that is changed by the context around it. Even worse, company internal e-mails probably have a tremendous amount of internal company information.

There is no way that any company will just shrug and go, well if you sent it to yourself and your lawyer, then that it's okay that you might have sent out company secrets.

bleah1000··on Alphabet Union Alleges Contract Workers Were Silenced About Pay
The problem is this "Google Union" is a joke. They are more of an activist group than a real union, so it's hard to tell if anything they say is actually true. However, if this person was fired for the reasons the person says, then I applaud the union's attempt to make this person whole. Because I'm skeptical, I think the union does a lot of things to stay in the news cycle, so whether this is true or not, it's hard to know.
bleah1000··on Resume review process created by former Googlers while they were at Twitter
Has anyone verified that this is real? Some of it is kind of reasonable, but a lot of it seems so weird that maybe it's a list for a specific position, rather than for a general software engineer. Even then, it seems kind of dumb to require a certain GPA and some of the other requirements seem odd.

Also, it's weird to say that this was created by ex-Google employees. How would they know that? Maybe the person posting it is from HR, but I certainly wouldn't know exactly who created every document/policy at my company. It might have been presented by someone who came from Google, but I would hope this was produced by multiple people. You could probably say that at least one person who came from Google worked on it though.

bleah1000··on Tesla Claims Engineer Stole Secrets Just Three Days on the Job
The problem is that the engineer claims he only transferred some new hire information to his Dropbox. However, Tesla claims that he grabbed a bunch of other things like scripts and was attempting to delete them after he granted Tesla security engineers access to his Dropbox. I think we'll need to wait until more information comes out because either the engineer is lying or Tesla is lying, but it should be relatively easy to tell if they have Dropbox giving them information.

If the engineer did copy scripts to his Dropbox, that is a serious security violation. Nearly everywhere I have worked, you always get security training that says under no circumstances copy company stuff to a third-party system. Even if you don't have malicious intent, security folks have no way of tracking what you do with the stuff after that.

bleah1000··on Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down
That is not what the contract says (at least from the current lawsuit). Amazon has to formally give a notice that gives them 30 days. Amazon telling Parler that they are violating is not in accordance what most people believe the contract says.

Now it's possible that the contract has some other wording, or that Amazon will argue that they didn't need to be as formal as Parler thinks. But as this goes through the courts, we will find out more.

bleah1000··on Spotify's big bet on podcasts is failing, Citi says
I think they shot themselves in the foot over the Joe Rogan thing. I suspect that they could have increased subscriptions by a large amount, but there were PR disasters all over the place. I suspect that a number of people decided not to move because of how things were handled. Or at least the appearance that Spotify might ban or censor Rogan's podcast.

Right when the biggest hype for this acquisition was happening, all of the PR was negative. I wonder if as things cool off and no other issues occur, Joe Rogan fans will slowly move over, but time will tell.

bleah1000··on Facebook Has Been Showing Military Gear Ads Next to Insurrection Posts
We all know this is BuzzFeed ragebait garbage. This had died down somewhat, but there is always some story about ads on "controversial" content. This is a new evolution of that, where it appears to be "controversial" ad on "controversial" content. I'm sure we'll see another round of ads on "controversial" content again soon.
bleah1000··on Norway investigates 23 deaths in frail elderly patients after vaccination
Or, you avoid vaccines for people at high risk of dying from the vaccine. Then you let herd immunity work. The question is what percentage chance do you have of dying from the vaccine versus getting the virus. Unfortunately, that's going to be hard to tell.

We probably are not going to give vaccines to immunocompromised people because the chance of a bad reaction are likely higher than the chance of getting the virus. The people who died are likely now in the category of don't vaccinate.

bleah1000··on Amazon warned Parler for months about “more than 100” violent threats
That's not what they claimed. Amazon is claiming that Parler didn't remove them quickly enough and that the system Parler is using doesn't remove these kinds of comments fast enough.

Here's a video from a lawyer (a Canadian one, but he's been pretty good about American issues) that describes the Amazon response:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GB06JtDbtvU

bleah1000··on Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler
I think that this is a really bad idea. I believe that this is selective enforcement because on Twitter there is a ton of incitement to violence. I think it's worse on Twitter because it happens all of the time, and Twitter seems fine with it when it's far left folks. During the George Floyd riots in Portland, at least a few Antifa groups were using Twitter to organize their "protests". If you think that Trump's tweets were incitement, then those tweets were just as bad or even worse. Those protests didn't result in any police/feds dying, but a ton of police/feds were injured, and a lot of antifa type people were trying to kill, they just weren't very good at it.

But in my view, I see this idea that people are being radicalized through social media (YouTube, Twitter, Facebook) will be the same as the video games are causing violence ideas. I think what we are going to find out in the future is that allowing people to vent their crazy on the internet was more likely to let people blow off steam and wind them down. The few people who do act violently and vent about it on places like Twitter, were people who were already prone to violence. Kind of like in the video game blame game when people who were violent, the news always said that they played violent video games. In that case, those people were already violent and liked violent video games. Even those people who are "radicalized" by social media are probably people who could be radicalized by watching cat videos.

Now that's not to say that some people who are on the fence might be radicalized by social media, but I think it's also possible that more people are being deradicalized by allowing them to see all the things, bad or good. Of course, illegal threats should still be removed, but if these social media sites came up with a set of rules and actually followed them even when they didn't like the person, I think that would also go a long way to calming things. Some people will still cry about getting punished unfairly, but I think it's more likely fewer people will agree when they claim they were being persecuted when the rules are followed to the letter.

The biggest worry I have is that all of these deplatforming actions are actually going to lead to violence as people feel like they no longer have any way to express themselves. I really fear that tensions are escalating and these companies are making worse, not better.

bleah1000··on Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler
They are definitely becoming more and more radicalized, but I don't know where you get this white power stuff. Their leader is a minority and many of their members are black, and other minorities.

However, I think deplatforming them has made them more radical. I think that we are going to see this more and more, by isolating people and forcing them to go into places where there are no public postings, nobody is going to see how radical they get. You are going to lose some people but the really dangerous people will wind up reinforced in their belief that they are being persecuted, and if they think they have nowhere to go and nothing to hope for, I think we are going to start seeing some real ugly violence.

bleah1000··on Massachusetts to Ban Sale of New Gas-Powered Cars by 2035
This always feel like political theater. This is so far down the road that we don't even know if gas powered vehicles would be in wide-spread use in the US at that time. And how much do you want to bet that if they are, this date will just be pushed back.

And they are only banning new car sales of gas powered vehicles, so you could go to the next state to get a gas car, or buy a used car.

bleah1000··on Employers now allowed to take tips from waiters, split them with other workers
No, if their total compensation with tips winds up being below minimum wage the employer has to pay them enough to get them up to minimum wage. Do companies abuse this, probably, but according to the law they need to be paid at least minimum wage. Waiter/waitresses need to declare their tips to their employer so that they can make sure they are getting paid at least minimum wage.
bleah1000··on Nearly a third of workers don’t want to ever return to the office
The problem is there are people for which a commute actually isn't this hellscape that drives them to the brink of madness. For example, I've noticed that the commute to and from work provided a nice break to get into work mode or to decompress out of work mode.

On my drive in, I can think about the things I need to get done during the day, maybe think about how to solve a tough problem. I can organize my tasks, think about what to do first, etc.

And many times on my commute home, listening to music allows me to put the work out of my mind, so when I get home I can fully detach. Obviously, it doesn't work this way all of the time, but without this barrier while wfh it feels like I'm in work mode even if I'm not doing work any more.

There is really no one size fits all for everyone, and it sounds like the vast majority of people don't want wfh. And for those that do, I think it's a good idea to try and see if more wfh options can be made available for people.

bleah1000··on Technical phone screen superforecasters
While the author didn't put that data in the article, the very last bullet point claimed that this method increased diversity. I would be a bit skeptical of that claim without any evidence, but it doesn't look like they ignored that could be a problem.
bleah1000··on Australia has almost eliminated the coronavirus – by putting faith in science
I think it's way too early to declare victory. In fact, Australia was doing really well, then one of the provinces messed everything up, possibly due to some government corruption. We need to wait and see if this time, things work out.

Remember when everyone thought the US was doing so poorly and Europe was doing great, then suddenly there is a huge spike in cases in many European countries.

I don't think we will be able to do a proper post-mortem on the best strategy to handle covid until we reach herd immunity or a vaccine has been distributed.

bleah1000··on The Atlantic fully retracts story by Ruth Shalit Barrett
I noticed something very odd in the retraction:

"The original version of this article stated that Sloane has a son. Before publication, Sloane confirmed this detail to be true to The Atlantic’s fact-checking department. After publication, when a Washington Post media critic asked us about the accuracy of portions of the article, our fact-checking department reached out to Sloane to recheck certain details. Through her attorney, Sloane informed us that she does not, in fact, have a son. We independently corroborated that Sloane does not have a son."

I really hope this is not how any fact checking organization works. It appears the fact check was to ask the person whether the fact was true. If this was relatively crucial fact, couldn't they ask for some kind of evidence? I'm truly astonished at how bad some media outlets can be.

bleah1000··on Put not thy trust in Nate Silver
The article is way too long, and doesn't really talk about Nate Silver much.

However, one interesting item is the idea that there is no way to verify these predictions. Because they are forecasting one time events, there is no way to validate if their models are in the least bit accurate. If you have a X% chance of event happening and it doesn't, were you wrong? No because it wasn't 100%, and even if you are right, it's not terribly meaningful. It would be interesting to see if a site like five thirty-eight modeled all elections results, and then see how accurate they were across all of their predictions. Maybe you would have to look at all predictions with > 70% chance of happening and see if they got 70% of those correct.

However, in the end those predictions seem like they could be done by throwing darts at a dart board and we wouldn't really know.

bleah1000··on Former Google CEO Calls Social Networks ‘Amplifiers for Idiots’
I mean, Twitter recently censored a story from the New York Post. Then they came along and said, maybe they shouldn't be doing that. Even Facebook came out and said they would be slowing down sharing of this story.

Now, if they did this for every kind of sensational story, okay, but this very clearly seems to be a partisan issue. There have been a few Trump stories that are similarly sensational and were not censored the same way.

By the way, I don't know how much of that story is correct, but it's pretty clear they treated that story differently than anything else, and it leads to people becoming very suspicious of what these companies are doing. It's also very scary that Twitter or Facebook would just say, no this story from a newspaper can't even be shared.

bleah1000··on Preppers plan to scrub social media profiles post-election, kidding themselves
The only evidence of Trump being more authoritarian is maybe the number of executive orders he has signed. And many of those are being challenged or are in the process of being challenged in the court.

Where are you getting that he is more authoritarian?

This seems like a bit of paranoia, because if he was an authoritarian, he would invoke the insurrection act, and go into Portland or Seattle. He has not done that. If you are referring to the sending of agents into some cities, I think you may not have read closely enough. Those agents are not going out on the street (for the most part), they are doing paperwork and investigations. If you are talking about that "people snatched off the street", that happened once and there was a court case about it where only two instances found. You could maybe stretch that to say others happened that nobody knows about, but you need evidence of that before claiming this is happening all over.

I'm not a big fan of Trump, so don't make me defend him, but Biden is the one who initially pledged to force mask wearing across the country. I think he's backed down from that, but that is an example of an authoritarian dictate that should be scary to anyone. Remember, we are still mostly governed by each state government.

bleah1000··on Bombshell on Bribe Claims Threatens States’ Google Probe
This seems kind of a weird way to do it, unless they fear a cover-up. However, in the current climate it's hard to tell when people are doing something in good faith and when they are doing something where they have vague allegations and are doing it for political reasons to sabotage someone.

I hope that they do a thorough investigation and disclose the evidence so it's obvious whether this is a bad faith investigation, or a corrupt AG.

bleah1000··on Vilified early over Covid-19 strategy, Sweden seems to have scourge controlled
Because the system is completely arbitrary. There is no explanation of why 3 extra cases per XX people means you get indoor dining, but 3 less doesn't. All of the numbers that I saw where never justified, and seemed to be based on someone saying we need a few different tiers so that people think we know what we're doing.

I think the problem is that there is no easy formula for making these kinds of decisions. You need to look at the data and figure out what's going on before deciding what to do. For example, let's say someone has a big party and there are 100 new cases because of it. It wouldn't make sense to shut down indoor dining just because there was a spike. But on the other hand, if you saw 100 cases coming from a lot of restaurants spread out across a county, then you might consider shutting down indoor dining again.

bleah1000··on Formerly incarcerated software engineers built a no-police alternative to 911
This seems like an ad for this company without any real description about how it's supposed to work.

For example, domestic abuse calls can be the most dangerous for police, so how does not involving the police work? Who would show up to these?

How does choosing an agency help with homelessness?

In fact, what prevents the agencies getting these calls from turning around and calling the police themselves?

Maybe I'm being cynical, but I think this is not going to do anything. An app can't solve these problems, you need to staff agencies with people and train them to handle different situations. If you wanted to help, you might want to send specially trained people along with the normal police who handle certain types of situations. For example, sending someone who is an expert in mental health to many different calls so they can help identify and help handle situations with emotionally unstable people.

bleah1000··on New York City lockdown reduced coronavirus transmission by 70 percent
Maybe, but people don't realize that the subway was open during the entire lockdown. I would be extremely skeptical that the lockdown did anything at all since it looks more like New York achieved herd immunity (or close to it) rather than it reduced any transmission.

I've also not heard many people say lockdowns prevent transmission, rather they flatten the curve, but you still get the same number of people getting the virus. The flattening makes the amount at any one time much lower, so I would still be very suspicious of someone who said they were able to prevent people from getting it. Unless they are talking about a very specific group of people such as people in nursing homes.

bleah1000··on Stripe Employees Who Relocate to Get $20k Bonus and a Pay Cut
It's weird that nobody talks about what it means when you relocate. For Stripe it might not be an issue, but large companies probably have people in all different locations. This means that if you relocate to a place where someone else is already working, is it fair if someone moved there and is now being paid much more than you?

Also, what about if you had all women at a location and a man relocates there and gets to keep their higher salary. I think the women would feel that this is not okay either. This applies to any other protected categories where legal issues can come up.

There are other considerations when talking about salary, and whether people can keep higher salaries when they relocate from a place where there is high competition for employees and a high average salary to a place with lower competition for employees and lower average salaries.

bleah1000··on New Covid Cases Soar in Denmark, Surpassing No-Lockdown Sweden
This should surprise no one, but the article feels a little bit disingenuous. It's comparing Norway and Denmark to Sweden to make Sweden look a lot worse. But when comparing it to a bunch of other nearby countries Sweden is probably middle of the pack. In addition, it sounds like the spike is rather minor (Denmark sees a daily increase of 317 cases). It doesn't seem that bad yet, but I can't tell because the article leaves out information that's pertinent. How many cases was that before? What percentage of people are testing positive now? What group is testing positive (for example, is the increase in all age groups or in younger people who are less likely to have a bad outcome)?

In hindsight, it's probably likely that Sweden chose the best path (although faltering along the way not locking down older people as well as they should have).

Everyone was criticizing the US when the numbers started to go up, but a lot of other countries coming out of lock down are seeing the same thing. It's just not possible to come out of lock down without a vaccine and not see an increase in cases. But you really need to stop using that as your metric for success. Cases is a leading indicator, but you need to see who's getting sick, what's happening in the hospitals, and what percentage is testing positive.

The news can't help but pour fuel on the fire by highlighting every time the cases spike anywhere without actually doing real journalism and giving any other information. Just cases go up, time to panic.

bleah1000··on GitHub Won’t Help You with Hiring
Let's look at that chair analogy, you are presuming that someone can look at a finished chair and say it's a good chair, and the carpenter who built it is probably good. But in order to do that evaluation, you need to spend time examining the chair. And you don't have any guarantee that the chair was actually made by the person presenting it to you. Maybe someone else helped them build it, or they built it using step by step instructions they found online. My issue is that the evaluation can take a lot of time, and if you are not familiar with the project, it makes it really difficult to get anything useful.

If your hiring process always requires github code, then the chance of people faking it, or presenting code that isn't theirs is going to increase. And if you are looking at it for a project a candidate can discuss, you can do the same thing by choosing something from their resume.

In my opinion, it just doesn't add that much and will wind up taking up a lot of time. You would also need to decide when in the process you look at the projects. Doing a proper eval would still likely take hours for a small handful of candidates, so you wouldn't want to do it until a person was well down the interview path. And at that point is it really adding much more than you already know?

bleah1000··on Worries grow over a K-shaped economic recovery that favors the wealthy
Your post seems more like you are hoping that Iowa is going to suffer some terrible epidemic of cases, rather than talking about the data. You are speaking from the point of view of your parents, who are likely scared. For vulnerable people, they still really shouldn't be going out, and they have every right to be worried. But at some point, we have to say that the majority of the population that is very likely not going to be as negatively affected can be allowed to live their lives.

Looking at the number of cases in Iowa, they are slowly ticking up, but cases are a terrible way to determine if covid is getting to be a problem. You need to look at percentage testing positive, hospitalizations and deaths. And if Iowa is anything like California, Florida, and Texas, there will be a spike in cases among younger people, and a slow increase in hospitalizations. But it won't be as bad as everyone pretends it is, and in many cases, it won't help to start locking things down again or for the first time, you'll simply push the curve out. Nearly the same number of people will get sick, just over a longer time frame. In fact, that was the whole point of flattening the curve, it wasn't to stop covid, it was to push the cases out so that our healthcare system is not overwhelmed. The area under the curve would likely be similar to a non-flattened curve.

I don't see any evidence that Iowa will be overwhelmed, but perhaps you have better data that you can point to that shows everything going wrong.

bleah1000··on GitHub Won’t Help You with Hiring
Have you ever been able to look at someone's code and immediately figure out whether it's good or not? I think it can be easy to see if it's really bad, but sometimes it can be hard to tell if it's okay code, or really good code. The problem is that you might have extra information to make a hiring decision, but it requires orders of magnitude more time to evaluate.

For example, if the whole project is done by a single person do you evaluate their design and code? What if it was just a one-off project that they didn't care about so it has copy-paste code in a few places. Is that bad?

If you ask candidates to point out examples of good code, then is that really meaningful? What if a mediocre programmer can find a few places where they wrote some strong code. What if that code was made good through a strong review process?

I think the problem is that it's too difficult to determine if open source contributions are actually representative of the way someone will code in a job.

bleah1000··on Amazon drivers are hanging smartphones in trees to get more work
I always wonder in these kinds of articles how many people are doing this. The problem is that it is so sensationalized, that it could be that there are 10 people doing this, and it's not really a big deal. Or it could be that 50% of the people doing this work, do this. For example, the article says that it reviewed photos and videos of phones near Whole Foods and Amazon delivery stations. Okay, so how many phones did they find? How many people do they have personal knowledge doing this?

I've noticed that a lot of news articles tend to take a few examples of something outrageous, but never say anything about how widespread the practice is. I find it hard to be outraged or care unless there is some quantification of the problem. In any system, people will find a way to cheat.

Amazon is aware and maybe they are working on a way to fix this, but it's not clear Amazon has had much time to figure out what to do. Even if you think Amazon is evil and doesn't care, it takes time to figure out how to defeat this. Maybe they won't care, but at least give them some time to respond.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →