HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnchrch

2,474 karma · joined November 2, 2012

https://ben.church

https://github.com/bnchrch

https://twitter.com/bnchrch

https://medium.com/@bnchrch

https://keybase.io/bnchrch

submissionscomments
bnchrch··on Apple nears $1B Google deal for custom Gemini model to power Siri
Today I asked to my homepod:

> "Hey Siri, whens the next Formula 1 race in Montreal"

and she responds with the same infuriating answer I typically get

> "Hmm, I found some interesting results on the web, I can show them to you if you ask again from your iPhone"

I don't care what pride Apple has to swallow, or if they have to layoff 10,000 people.

I just want my device ecosystem to be able to do what its competitors have been able to do for a decade, or what Ive been able to build myself for the last 3 years. A working and useful voice assistant.

At this point Im convinced Tim Cook could sit at a terminal himself and ship a better version of what Apple has in an afternoon.

bnchrch··on A shift in developer culture is impacting innovation and creativity
I love the message, and generally agree.

Theres a layer of pessimism to engineers and hacker news that has been steadily growing (as I assume the average age increases).

To me it's hit a critical level and I have to disregard most negative comments here by default because I can no longer trust the average commenter to have a productive balance of optimism and curiousity.

----

On a different note, the point the author is trying to make is massively undercut by the ad spam all over their page.

It was so grotesque (and out of character for a dev blog) that my first assumption was that I had a malicious extension somewhere.

bnchrch··on Ask HN: Walled garden dwellers: What keeps you there?
Could not have said this better myself, so let me just add a little extra.

It works. Its polished. It’s ubiquitous.

But most importantly.

I don’t have to think about it. My 9-5 is deeply considering trade offs, configurations and debugging edge cases.

Why would I want to do that in my off time?

My only one complaint.

Please for the love of your bottom line Apple, fix Siri, jfc.

bnchrch··on Migrating to React Native's new architecture
While you might be right.

It seems like you didn't notice this was about React Native, the cross platform mobile app framework.

So "just write plain html" isn't a valid alternative unless you want to write a Progressive Web App instead. Which means you:

- Forego the App Store and need to ask users to bookmark your website

- Loose ease of access to device features (cameras, sensors, push notifications)

bnchrch··on My thoughts on renting versus buying
I've seen these critiques for years.

and while its not necessarily wrong, I believe it under weights a few points:

- Fixing your housing costs against inflation: You can't count on housing price increases, but you can count on inflation. If you buy a house and your mortgage payment is > rent. Overtime it will naturally flip. $1 no longer buys me a chocolate bar, and $800/month no longer gets me a 2 bed apartment.

- Leverage: I can't get a $700k loan to put into equities but I can for a home.

- Capital Battery: As I build equity in my home it can become an asset I take loans against to pursue other opportunities.

- Flexibility: Should I need to fiscally downsize I can still move out and rent out. Or rent a portion either via a suite or secondary unit

- Stability: No one can evict me into a hot rental market to suit their needs.

I wish more people talked about these points, selfishly so I didnt take so many of these articles at face value because in hindsight I wouldve bought earlier.

bnchrch··on AI might yet follow the path of previous technological revolutions
> The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise

> - Socrates (399 BC)

> The world is passing through troublous times. The young people of today think of nothing but themselves. They have no reverence for parents or old age. They are impatient of all restraint. They talk as if they knew everything, and what passes for wisdom with us is foolishness with them. As for the girls, they are forward, immodest and unladylike in speech, behavior and dress

> - Peter the Hermit (1274)

bnchrch··on NPM debug and chalk packages compromised
Good god. Not everything has to be about your opinion on AI.
bnchrch··on Apple rumored to be working on a smart home operating system version
In the past I used to get excited for any rum or, teaser or upcoming release.

However, in this apple era I can’t.

Why? Because I can’t count on them to deliver.

The M series chips, and air pods have been a smashing success.

But the fact that Siri is still behind even pre LLM state of the art is abominable.

Apple vision was innovative. But the forward facing display, and titanium parts that bloated weight and cost was a sign of deteriorating design thinking.

Their delivery is so inconsistent lately its hard to trust the known what they’re doing with their future.

bnchrch··on My 2.5 year old laptop can write Space Invaders in JavaScript now (GLM-4.5 Air)
You do realize your talking to the creator of Django, Datassette, and Lanyrd right?
bnchrch··on Ask HN: How do I prevent AI from reading/training off my content?
My honest advice? Don't bother with the things you can't control or don't matter.

Whether or not someone is using your data is one of them.

bnchrch··on Ask HN: US expats/nomads, how do you find remote-out-of-US jobs in US?
I can share my experience as a canadian who's been working remotely for US companies since 2016.

Typically I would either find a warm intro from a past colleague, or I would specifically find someone involved in the hiring pipeline at the company on Linkedin and say "Hey im so and so, and blah blah blah, im thinking of applying but would love if you could tell me more about the role and the culture before I commit"

From here, so long as you baseline can stand out as a solid engineer and communicator those US only barriers fall down.

This is why to someone elses point > if they’d hire you, why wouldn’t they hire someone much cheaper.

They'd hire someone cheaper certainly, provided they could find a person with identical quality, similar culture, and near PST timezones. Which is a fairly tall order in reality.

Its also why its not too uncommon to find Canadians pulling in near SF salaries while not having to relocate

bnchrch··on Why you should choose HTMX for your next web-based side project (2024)
I think your suffering from the same thing that makes 2014 feel like 5 years ago when its over a decade ago.

The framework landscape has remained relatively entrenched in React since 2016. Sure theres a few new ones time to time but nothings ever come close to unseating it in the same way it took over from Angular.

(Yes you could argue Nextjs but thats just react with a backend bolted to it)

bnchrch··on What the Fuck Python
Don't forget its transitive dependencies creating non-deterministic builds
bnchrch··on What the Fuck Python
Thank you! For years Ive been saying the sheer volume and fury by which Javascript is criticized is much more applicable to Python.

Both aren't perfect languages, and both are far from "the best" but it is maddening that Python get often picked as a darling when its implementation, ecosystem and tooling are fundamentally at odds with correctness and productivity.

bnchrch··on Ask HN: Is it time to fork HN into AI/LLM and "Everything else/other?"
No for three reasons.

One, lets be honest, hn wont do it, part of their secret sauce is that they don't change, and they know that.

Two, fragmenting the community would just reduce engagement and risk making both feel like a ghost town.

Three, LLMs are (one of) the forefronts of our industry. State of the art is advancing fast. It has properties that no one knows the best practises for. And it has implications that are wide ranging. To try and bury this because it has a lot of new developments goes against why most of us are on this site.

I believe in the meritocracy of the upvote button.

bnchrch··on Happy 20th Birthday, Django
Now Phoenix and Elixir are two technologies I love! But theyre admin offering is lacking. (Which is ok today in modern development and things like pgadmin)
bnchrch··on Happy 20th Birthday, Django
Same way I can hate the drivetrain of a car but love the interior! They're separate systems that co-habitate.

Specifically for python vs django, most of the things I dont like are actually attributable to decisions by the python team, not necessarily Django.

But many of the things I do like are attributable to the Django team.

bnchrch··on Happy 20th Birthday, Django
As someone today who is an unrelenting critic of python.

I have to say thank you to Simon and the Django community as a whole.

Its a wonderful "batteries included" framework that has launched many successful projects, companies, and careers. Mine included.

And I'd be lying if I didnt say I still use pgadmin as my benchmark for evaluating admin panels in other ecosystems.

What you all created with Django is amazing.

We'd all be much further behind in tech without it.

Thanks absolute heaps.

bnchrch··on The Architecture Behind Lovable and Bolt
Im always hunting for someone whos solved "sandboxing" because setting it up myself is so damn painful.

Anyone ever find a good product in this space?

Beam seems close, but not quite

bnchrch··on Most RESTful APIs aren't really RESTful
Did you just say "discoverability" is an issue with GraphQL with a straight face?

There are plenty of valid criticisms, but that is not one, in fact thats where it shines.

bnchrch··on Ask HN: What are some cool or underrated tech companies based in Canada?
Heres a few:

https://layerzero.network/

https://1password.com/

https://www.wealthsimple.com/

https://floatcard.com

https://www.postgrid.com

https://www.dapperlabs.com

https://www.wattpad.com

https://gusto.com

https://cohere.com

https://clear.co/ https://www.clio.com/

bnchrch··on François Chollet: The Arc Prize and How We Get to AGI [video]
No, but one thing is certain, in large human systems you can only redirect greed, you can't stop it.
bnchrch··on What do people use for on-call these days?
The biggest knock against pagerduty is its both expensive and doesnt have simple features like connecting Pagerduty schedules to slack user groups.

For example if I want to have a slack group that pings (not pages) to current oncall person

```

@oc-platform

```

I need to pay $25/month to a random third party slack app.

Its insane, do they even use pagerduty internally?

bnchrch··on The engineering interview process is broken, AI cheating is exposing it faster
Don't try and fight reality. You'll just end up tired, frustrated, and in the exact same spot years later.
bnchrch··on My takeaways from DjangoCon EU 2025
Just like Python itself, unfortunately yes.
bnchrch··on Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
FWIW you can pass to other arguments than first in this syntax

```

params

|> Map.get("user")

|> create_user()

|> (&notify_admin("signup", &1)).() ```

or

```

params

|> Map.get("user")

|> create_user()

|> (fn user -> notify_admin("signup", user) end).() ```

bnchrch··on Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
I'm personally someone who advocates for languages to keep their feature set small and shoot to achieve a finished feature set quickly.

However.

I would be lying if I didn't secretly wish that all languages adopted the `|>` syntax from Elixir.

```

params

|> Map.get("user")

|> create_user()

|> notify_admin()

```

bnchrch··on This is how Apple’s big Siri shake-up happened, per report
To me what is wild is how this has been obvious even to people outside of Apple for dare a say a decade? (The Echo was released in 2014/2015)

Its interesting that Tim Cook has let this go on for so long.

I would love to know what the conversations have been at the executive level over these years.

You can only imagine what kind of top tier level executive state craft had to have been pulled off consistently by Siri/AI leadership to keep things progressing in this broken way internally.

bnchrch··on We quit our Big Tech jobs after hitting #1 on HN and Product Hunt
Im someone from the US whos at a conference in Canada.

Just a good data point for you may not want to block on IP.

Particularly if you think of remote companies with Staff in other countries who are part of hiring for US roles.

bnchrch··on We quit our Big Tech jobs after hitting #1 on HN and Product Hunt
Also, I am based in the US but when I click the "Im hiring" button im told "Its only available in the US, give us your email and we'll let you know when we launch in your area"
← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →