HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnegreve

2,040 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
bnegreve··on `three = 1` in the linux sourcecode
Let me overthink this a little bit:

It seems to me that this quote makes a rather standard usage of the "Zeugma" [1] figure of speech. It consists in putting next to each other two things of very different nature. In that case we have the very technical problem of invalidating caches on the one hand, and the much higher level problem of naming things on the other hand.

That produces a rather stylish quote.

But if Phil Karlton was actually referring to the technical problem of assigning unique identifier as you suggest, the figure of speech is lost and the quote becomes less stylish.

So I prefer tho read "naming things" as the very general problem of naming things.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeugma

bnegreve··on Misleading Graph Generator
> It has nothing to do with graphs, graphs are are just visual tools.

To make a graph, one has to make decisions, these decisions can be legitimate or they can be biased. Biased decisions lead to misleading graphs.

The same goes for other types of content such as news articles, product reviews, war photos, etc.

Edit, to illustrate better: the author of the graph chose to overlap data on a logscale (transistor count) with data on a linear scale (life expectancy). The resulting graph shows two similar curves, that suggests that the two are strongly correlated. That's what I call a biased decision.

bnegreve··on How to Make Yourself Work When You Just Don’t Want To
That's how it should be, but I suspect that in most cases, people work simply because they are supposed to.

E.g. (quoting the article)

> If it is 2pm, then I will stop what I’m doing and start work on the report Bob asked for.

What's the long term goal here? Being in good terms with Bob? Keeping your job? Are those the goals that you should care about?

bnegreve··on Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax, scholar finds
> Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax, scholar finds

As the author of this work states it himself, this is a "proposed partial decoding" and it is "tentative and provisional".

But anyway, the methodology is interesting and the video is worth watching. Although I'd be surprised all his speculations are correct, it seems to be the way to go.

bnegreve··on Feed some real fish via this web app
> It's also unfortunate that you feel the need to manipulate others through condescension in order to feel superior.

Chill out, he said please.

bnegreve··on TCP/IP over audio
> Why bother writing new protocols? Just start with modem protocols and play with the frequencies.

Technically PPP is a point to point protocol which makes everything easier (no real addressing, no routing and so on). This protocol would be more comparable to wifi.

bnegreve··on x86 is Turing-complete with no registers
> But x86 itself also has a limit on addressable memory. So does C, because sizeof(void *) is finite. These systems are Turing-complete when you add an external tape using I/O, but so is a finite-state machine!

You could argue that I/O operations (which can emulate an unbounded tape) are defined in the C standard library, which is of course not the case of finite state machines.

So in absence of instantiation bounds C together with the C standard library IS Turing complete.

bnegreve··on Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI
I've seen some people talking about how they taught their robot to play ping ping, it's pretty amazing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SH3bADiB7uQ

Edit: The speaker was Jan Peters at ECML/PKDD13

bnegreve··on Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI
> Yes, because it is general purpose intelligence.

Right, but playing jeopardy is far more general than instructing a computer to sort an array, so why do you think that we are on the wrong path?

bnegreve··on Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI
> Well, artificial intelligence is a slippery term. It could refer to just getting machines to do things that seem intelligent on the surface.

But is "natural intelligence" any different?

bnegreve··on Books to Read in a Lifetime
> what did you expect them to do? Include foreign books that their English readers can't read?

I've spotted few translated books in this list, so I don't see why this is a problem.

>And no, just because a non-English book is great and worth reading does not automatically confer that same status onto an English translation based upon that book.

I disagree, I think good translations are pretty much transparent. Substance matters more.

bnegreve··on Your code may be elegant, but mine works
> 90 percent of the time, if you make it beautiful, it will already be fast.

In fact, I disagree with this. The reason is that "elegant" usually means "decoupled" whereas many optimizations actually consists in "recoupling" to take advantage of special cases or to share resources among various decoupled objects.

Designing software to be fast and elegant is actually quite challenging problem. Of course, that makes it even more interesting.

bnegreve··on Show HN: An API for gender classification
What's the training set?
bnegreve··on Boeing #12
No, I am not. You're right, nothing is absolutely necessary, there is not point arguing about this.

But let say that if I had to cancel one flight to save money / fuel, I would cancel this one rather than a standard flight.

bnegreve··on Boeing #12
Well, they do what they want, but three hours and 20 minutes with a 747, does sound like a waste of fuel to me.
bnegreve··on Why 'Sexual Mind Control' Is Rare in Nature
Is there a conflict? It seems probable the only purpose of surviving is to increase the odds of a successful reproduction.
bnegreve··on 1/9998 = 0.0001 0002 0004 0008 0016 0032 0064 0128 0256..
True, however, I am also surprised that it's getting this much attention.
bnegreve··on Announcing Stack Overflow in Portuguese
> I prefer the English wikipedia to my native one.

Yes, but obviously, you can read English. Most people can't.

> A good answer in English helps the whole [programming] world.

There is only about 1/10th of the population that speak English as first or second language[1]. I am sure that there are plenty of people that could use a good Q/A website where they can ask questions in their mother tong.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_numb...

bnegreve··on Why not kill -9 a process?
True, but that's still a good reason to avoid SIGKILLing your processes.
bnegreve··on Announcing Stack Overflow in Portuguese
> Fragmenting knowledge doesn't give much benefit.

What about Wikipedia? I think they are benefiting from being multi-language.

> English is the standard language for the IT for better or worse.

All programmers are certainly not fluent in english. Reading code/documentation is one thing, having a discussion / asking a question is different.

Most non native english speakers probably don't feel confident enough to ask questions on english speaking forums like SO.

bnegreve··on Why not kill -9 a process?
Not necessarily, processes spawned by bash don't necessarily have to die if you kill bash. For example if you use disown/nohup .. etc.
bnegreve··on Poll: Full-time software engineer salaries in Berlin
Of course it is, this is an online pool. The assumption that a uniform sample of developers from Berlin would vote for this is absolutely ridiculous. It scares me that so many educated developers consider this to of any significance.
bnegreve··on 2014 Gates Annual Letter: Myths that block progress for the poor
Come on, try to explain. HN is biased in many respects, if you never say what you think, you're just making it worst.
bnegreve··on Chrome Is The New C Runtime
In fact at the kernel level there are plenty of mechanisms that are comparable to exceptions, e.g. longjmps, software interruptions, signals ...

Edit: clarity.

bnegreve··on Why Do FM Frequencies End in an Odd Decimal?
> [Why] the first frequency-hopping protocols used 88 frequencies because that is how many keys there are on a piano

Well, it is a rather arbitrary reason but a valid explanation.

In the case of FM frequencies, the question remains ... why did they picked odd frequencies?

bnegreve··on Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard deviation
> The guy is a vile idiot of the worst kind: ignorant and aggressive.

Your comment is a bit irritating. I don't know the author of this blog post but I think he has a couple of valid points. You seem to dislike him for some other reasons. Feel free to share them. The blog post is still perfectly reasonable.

Anyway, I agree some of your comments as well, namely this:

> I can give hundreds when std dev is useful and mean deviation isn't. Anything when you decide what % of yoru bankroll to bet on perceived edge for example.

and this:

> Guess what though, taking the squares have a purpose: it penalizes big deviations so two situations which have the same mean deviation but one is more stable have different standard deviations.

But I don't see why this comment from N.T. is stupid:

>>>It is all due to a historical accident: in 1893, the great Karl Pearson introduced the term "standard deviation" for what had been known as "root mean square error". The confusion started then: people thought it meant mean deviation.

I actually agree that standard deviation is a confusing name, why do you think that's a stupid comment?

bnegreve··on Awful app review trend among Turkish users
> There's definitely a bump in 1-star reviews in Turkey.

Wait wait wait, the mere fact that Turkish has more 1 start review than the world average doesn't tell you anything about other countries individually.

It could be that most countries are above the world average except a couple of countries with almost no 0-star reviews.

If you want to make this point, at least give us the standard deviation.

bnegreve··on Teleportation on the command line
Nice. This quick and dirty trick has been in my .bashrc forever and I still use it:

    function md(){
        pwd > /tmp/md_tmp

    function gomd(){
        cd `cat /tmp/md_tmp`
so `md` marks the current directory and `gomd`go to the marked directory. Unlike bash builtins like pushd and popd, it uses the file system to store the marked directory so you can pop up a new terminal and just do gomd. (you can't with pushd/popd since the bash processes of the old and the new terminal are not related)

Edit: I see that your script uses links, I'll check this out.

bnegreve··on China surpasses US as world's largest trading nation
If you're suggesting that we take into account how well the wealth is distributed, then again, the US isn't a landmark. However it's hard to evaluate, maybe [1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equ...

bnegreve··on China surpasses US as world's largest trading nation
6 or 7 countries already surpasse the GDP per capita of the US [1], so that's not really a a landmark milestone.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP...

← PreviousPage 16 of 25Next →