HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnegreve

2,040 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
bnegreve··on What If Time Really Exists? (2008)
> There really is no point to wondering about the reality of time if it doesn't lead to anything we can test/influence or use to advance our understanding and so far there is none.

I think this is wrong. There are some (possibly many) such apparently pointless questions that eventually lead to actual experiments. I remember that Einstein's book's about relativity theory starts with such questions. Off the top of my head, questions such as "how could you prove that two events in different places have happened at the same time."

I'd also argue that the whole concept of science came from the Philosophers from ancient Greece trying to answer such unanswerable questions. But this may require a longer dissertation :).

bnegreve··on Choose Firefox Now, Or Later You Won't Get A Choice (2014)
Better can mean more than just "faster" or "more responsive". This post argues that Firefox is better in that it does not lock you in in the long term.

Since it is not as visible as responsiveness, it is useful to have these discussions so people can decide what really is the "best" browser to them with full knowledge.

bnegreve··on With Station F, Paris will have the world’s biggest startup campus
The number of millionaires is actually quite high in France [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millionaire#HNWI_population

bnegreve··on Fidel Castro has died
> Dictators that prosecute and murder their opponents,

Sorry, this is not a discriminative feature of dictators, non-dictators also prosecute and murder their opponents. (e.g. see any government involved in a war)

The difference is that you feel like they are right to do it.

bnegreve··on Brew commands send data to Google Analytics
> Some of the times it's to make the product better, or better targeted. Some other times it's just for spying on the users. Let's stop complaining

These kinds of complains are fine, I don't think we should stop them.

It's a bit like corruption in politics, it's not going to be solved anytime soon, but complains do raise awareness and prevent abuses. Who know what's going to happen if we stop complaining?

bnegreve··on Quick, Draw
BTW: this reminds me of detexify[1], the tool that can recognize latex symbols from handwritten drawings. Same problem.

[1] http://detexify.kirelabs.org/classify.html

bnegreve··on Quick, Draw
I think GP has raised a fair point. The landing page says: "Can a neural network learn to recognize doodles" but the game doesn't demonstrate that the ANN is able to recognize arbitrary objects.

It merely shows that it's able to pick the correct name from a finite list of possible names that could very well be small (e.g. 10 or 20 object names).

A better way to demonstrate that the ANN is truly able to recognize objects with good accuracy would be to ask a person to draw an unspecified object and guess its name.

If the goal is to acquire training data, they could still ask for a name in case of failure.

bnegreve··on Compulab Airtop – Natural Airflow Desktop
True, still it fits me because I run most of the stuff on remote machines. But I this can be a problem indeed.
bnegreve··on Compulab Airtop – Natural Airflow Desktop
I have been using a laptop and a docking station for a while now. I think this is the optimal configuration.

- no / very little noise

- no need to synchronize between work / home (Given that I also have a docking station at home, I essentially use my laptop as a portable hard drive with a screen)

- I can take my current work to meeting rooms anytime.

- ...

bnegreve··on Disruption is coming with quantum computing
> efficient quantum algorithms can be reimplemented with electronic circuits,

You can emulate a quantum computer with a classical one, but it takes exponential time.

If you could emulate them efficiently, quantum computers would just be another Turing machine, with all the limitations we already know. I think this is the whole point of quantum computers, they are different from what we already have.

bnegreve··on Disruption is coming with quantum computing
"Searching for a solution in a broad space" describes virtually every hard problem in computer science.

For example optimization problems are everywhere. In planning or in machine learning, just to name a few.

Having efficient ways to solve such problems would very definitely make a difference.

I agree that it's unlikely to happen anytime soon, though.

bnegreve··on So you think you know C?
Another C quizz, (which I find a little bit more interesting):

Will it optimize: http://ridiculousfish.com/blog/posts/will-it-optimize.html

edit: it's actually about gcc rather than the standard itself, still pretty interesting though.

bnegreve··on Show HN: Physics-based CAD
Cool, I think more applications should be using solvers like this.

What solver are you using? Is it solved server side?

bnegreve··on Why Tim Cook Is Steve Ballmer and Why He Still Has His Job at Apple
Luck is generally involved in success.

So maybe this is just regression toward the mean and hasn't that much to do with whoever is the CEO.

In other words, every very successful company is bound to be less successful later. Nothing really exciting about this.

bnegreve··on Google Has Dropped Ban on Personally Identifiable Web Tracking
> So opt-in becomes opt-out.

Hum, not exactly. With these new TOS, you can't assume that their will be a clear way to opt-out. ("it will depend on your account settings" is rather vague)

bnegreve··on An External Replication on the Effects of Test-driven Development [pdf]
To be fair, the abtract says "The results failed to support the claims." and the conclusion says "We recommend future studies to survey the tasks used in experiments evaluating TDD, and assess them with respect to the treatments.".

This is not a claim that TDD is useless.

bnegreve··on Why are Adults so busy?
Yes, good question. I think this is because nowadays, work is mostly a way to skew wealth distribution in your favor. Therefore people that can work more, do work more. That contributes to make them wealthier. The others, are unemployed.
bnegreve··on Advice I Wish I'd Been Told (1999)
HN is filtered. The main page is a list of article which have been selected and upvoted by small unrepresentative subset of the population. I agree that it's not personalized though.
bnegreve··on The first autonomous, entirely soft robot
"Autonomous" in the sense that it does not requires external power supply, rather than intelligent.

I agree that the title is a bit missleading, but the rest of the article is clear about this: (e.g. when they say: “Fuel sources for soft robots have always relied on some type of rigid components,” )

Edit: clarity

bnegreve··on The beauty of bitwise AND
> In the quote below, he names the AND function "f", which in itself is a bit strange. What's wrong with "and" or ∧?

'∧' usually denotes the logical AND operator, which does not operate on integer values, (i.e. writing 22 ∧ 78 = 6 is weird). So it's not a bad idea to give this function a different name.

He could have made that explicit though.

bnegreve··on Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says
Systematic bugs in self driving cars would be disastrous.

So if you see a Tesla car crashing on days with white sky, you want to know whether this can happens to you as well.

bnegreve··on If no-one helps you after a car crash in India, this is why
> I, personally, could not sit idly by and watch, or record, anyone suffering without attempting to assist.

We should be careful with this kind of statements. I remember that in Thinking, Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman describes an experiment which shows that most people don't actually take action when the responsibility is shared among other people. Of course most people think they would.

bnegreve··on Does not GPU compute
I agree but the article has an answer to this.

Since I don’t plan to run any DNA analysis or fintech simulations on my smartphone anytime soon, I am very satisfied having FP32/FP16 precision in mobile right now. And so should you.

bnegreve··on Startup Reading List
To be fair, reading comments on the internet is also a waste of time.
bnegreve··on Bullshit fighting
> So...peer review, then?

I'm guessing it applies to the way research money is attributed. Whoever follows the most recent hype gets all the funding.

bnegreve··on Bullshit fighting
> What field is this describing? Scientific papers?

Most likely yes. The author works in a scientific institute and has number of publications.

bnegreve··on Stoned drivers are safer than drunk ones, new federal data show
> Right now, there is none. ... a person going out on the weekend and smoking a lot (much like drinking most weekends or occasionally) is going to be really impaired.

I think the article is pretty misleading but the conclusion is clear: "There's plenty of evidence showing that marijuana use impairs key driving skills. If you get really stoned and then get behind the wheel, you're asking for trouble.".

The problem is that the legal thresholds for THC are so low that "stone drivers" are not actually stone, making the whole federal study flawed.

Here: "Several states have passed laws attempting to define "marijuana-impaired driving" similarly to drunk driving. Colorado, for instance, sets a blood THC threshold of 5 nanograms per milliliter. But that number tells us next to nothing about whether a person is impaired or fit to drive. "

If you look at the data, "any illegal drug" is also not correlated with more accidents.

bnegreve··on Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor
Every nation has protectionism.

Yes, that's my point. Not every one agrees with this and GGP's comment doesn't mention this fact.

So pointing out examples [..] contributes little to the discussion.

It adds examples of US protectionism so you can compare them with the ones from China that were mentioned before. Hopefully, this contributes to a more objective point of view. Why do I need to justify this?

bnegreve··on Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor
Interesting point, but to be fair China is not the only one to find ways to implement protectionism. The F35 program or even Nasa contracting SpaceX could be seen as examples of the US implementing some level of protectionism.
bnegreve··on If Philosophy Won’t Diversify, Let’s Call It What It Really Is
You're right, here's the quote:

Others might argue against renaming on the grounds that it is unfair to single out philosophy: We do not have departments of Euro-American Mathematics or Physics. This is nothing but shabby sophistry. Non-European philosophical traditions offer distinctive solutions to problems discussed within European and American philosophy, raise or frame problems not addressed in the American and European tradition, or emphasize and discuss more deeply philosophical problems that are marginalized in Anglo-European philosophy. There are no comparable differences in how mathematics or physics are practiced in other contemporary cultures.

← PreviousPage 9 of 25Next →