HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bokoharambe

55 karma · joined April 7, 2024

submissionscomments
bokoharambe··on The Silurian Hypothesis
It's not any particular technical development that separates humans from other animals, but the human relationship to technology as such. Humans only live by way of inserting external objects between themselves and nature, and they do this in an open-ended way. One could also talk about human self-domestication, and agriculture as a self-expanding ecosystem... Fire doesn't really capture the way humans actively modify their own conditions of life.
bokoharambe··on 'A fatal miscalculation': masculinity researcher on why Democrats lost young men
Trump is not the only/real alternative to liberalism even if he was the option that was given. That's why abstention won: no one wants the liberals, but no one sees Trump as different enough from them for him to earn their support.
bokoharambe··on 'A fatal miscalculation': masculinity researcher on why Democrats lost young men
Can't take this seriously when Trump barely got more votes this time around than he did last time. There has been no loss of young men. People are broadly feeling disenfranchised, and that's why the Democrats lost. If anything, this is a broad rebuke of liberalism without endorsement of the prevailing alternative.
bokoharambe··on Ask HN: Can calculus be taught without differentiating or integrating by hand?
You can develop muscle memory without rote memorization by doing exercises. There, you end up memorizing facts by solving problems and therefore building intuition. I agree that you need some level of memorization when you first "perform things," but if you're performing, it's not rote memorization.

Rote is memorizing integrals with flash cards. Building intuition is doing exercises. Might seem pedantic, but the difference is huge pedagogically.

bokoharambe··on Intelligence is not like height
It just seems strange to me that, like in the case of mental illnesses such as depression or Schizophrenia, scientists insist on looking for genes or even GWAS correlations and just aren't finding anything. At a certain point, you have to wonder if something other than genetics accounts for the observed heritability.
bokoharambe··on We must seek a widely-applicable science of systems
I feel like the real problem here is the way that research has to be sold in order to get funding (I assume the same was true in the 1960s). There is no inherent harm in trying to find a universalizing science, but market imperatives drive the creation of intellectual hypecycles with the associated booms and busts. That can then discredit entire fields.
bokoharambe··on Pop culture has become an oligopoly (2022)
I am fairly confident that people's agency is pretty low on the list of reasons why loneliness had reached epidemic proportions. There are very obvious cultural and geographic (and ultimately economic) factors at work that none of us as individuals ever really chose, but which have been decided for us. Anomie is not something that can be overcome through sheer force of will.

I know enough about my neighbors based on small glimpses of their lifestyle to know I will never want to or need to know them. I don't make friends with child abusers. And the reality is that those sorts of value conflicts are commonplace in contemporary American life.

bokoharambe··on Pop culture has become an oligopoly (2022)
I didn't mean to imply said local community has never existed, only that it no longer does. I'm not convinced that the cloistered, middle class, older, and predominantly white communities that exist in every medium to large city are capable of creating art of any substance. And the art they may create certainly could not be said to represent anyone in any general way.
bokoharambe··on Pop culture has become an oligopoly (2022)
Communities that are local =/= local community in a general sense. There are in some places participatory communities that (often older, middle class, family-oriented) people participate in, but I'm not sure those organizations can meaningfully be said to represent the localities they are present in.

When there's a loneliness epidemic that is especially pronounced with young people, it seems really silly to act like local community is a general institution that most people actively participate in. It might be true in your neck of the woods. It is certainly not in mine.

bokoharambe··on Pop culture has become an oligopoly (2022)
There is no "local community," so there is no local production in any meaningful sense anymore. I am nothing like my neighbors, never have been, and have never known very much about them in any of the places I've lived. That suggestion is entirely untenable.

Many indie works suffer from the same formulaic failings as popular works, so that doesn't seem like a solution either. The same old hero story with a black or gay protagonist is not suddenly more interesting, yet that's a large portion of what's coming out of the indie scene.

In the US, there is no solution. We are all shackled to the cultural carcass that is late modernity. Retelling the same stories we have for decades, just with different colors.

bokoharambe··on The Era of the Autodidact Is Here (2018)
I was thinking more along the lines of "does schooling have to be awful" than "should you go to school." I apologize for being unclear.
bokoharambe··on The Era of the Autodidact Is Here (2018)
Is it really necessary? I'm not seeing it.
bokoharambe··on I should have loved biology (2020)
Your post really demonstrates how different people can have very different experiences of the same field. I love biology too, yet I care very little about chemicals or chemistry, and I wish there was more of a track for studying biology while abstracting away from the biological particulars. An approach to biology focused on the large scale- ecology, biospherics, and life exists as a geophysical phenomenon, would be really nice. That's the sort of thing that I care about, and you really don't need to reference the nanoscale in detail for considering it.

I think we can all agree though that the unstructured memorization approach benefits 0 students.

bokoharambe··on The U.S. government may finally mandate safer table saws
Personal responsibility is a hard sell in a world where human beings are not absolutely sovereign agents. Regardless, the law isn't stopping you from driving without a seatbelt. I find it odd that you have such a visceral response to a class of laws that is violated quite regularly.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2