HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bonsaitree

624 karma · joined February 28, 2008

submissionscomments
bonsaitree··on Black Hat SEO Case Study: How Mahalo Makes Black Look White
Agreed. I think Merlin Mann has the best take yet on Scribd: http://tinyurl.com/yzl3mod
bonsaitree··on Digital subscription costs are bleeding consumers dry
Utter pablum. Slow news day? Ethically dubious journalist?

What consumer buys so many duplicative services?

Here's a piece of advice. Don't buy services that overlap in functionality. Don't buy items you can't afford to use. Consider the total cost of ownership.

The entire tone of this article is one of yellow "jurinalistic bias" and does not reflect accurate market research on consumer behavior let alone consumer need.

The author comes across as little more than a petty financially irresponsible, and technically ignorant, whiner.

bonsaitree··on You can always do less
Agreed. This is a nice doctrine to follow for an alpha release or a prototype/demo to shop around for investors, but ALL software used daily in the "real-world" grows in complexity over time.

This axiom holds true in everything from cardiac pacemaker micro-code ( http://www.freepatentsonline.com/5843138.html ), space shuttle avionics ( http://tinyurl.com/475kyv ), or my favorite current example of real-world purposeful constraint, SQLite ( http://www.sqlite.org/version3.html ).

bonsaitree··on Security by obscurity: The No Lock People
I guarantee none of these "No Lock" people have bothered to read the fine print of their insurance policies and they don't own firearms.
bonsaitree··on Record police with phone camera in Boston, get arrested
IME, extremely well, but see my previous comment on the general professionalism of Virginia police. I've had no personal experience with potentially litigious/confrontational law enforcement encounters outside of VA.

By immediately asserting your rights, the officer in question knows that they are not dealing with a person of "legal ignorance". As with communication in all social interactions, an assertive (but not aggressive) carriage, posture, positive eye contact, and tone helps a great deal.

Keep in mind that, in most contexts, when I see the triplet of a badge, an open-carry gun (the gun is key), and a police uniform, my default assumption is that of a PERSON who's sworn an oath and, consciously or unconsciously, respects SOME sort of legal authority given their avocation (though it may not necessarily be true).

FWIW, if you have any doubt, it's worth asking CLEARLY if the presumed officer in question has "sworn arrest powers in <insert municipality>". Police are allowed to lie, but they're not legally allowed to "assert police powers" such as arrest and/or detainment unless they have truly have them. In most U.S. state codes, there's a clear delineation between what constitutes a "lawful" and an "unlawful order" by law enforcement. Asserting police powers without being a sworn law enforcement officer is also usually a felony.

At worst, you may be severely inconvenienced for an "officer's safety" by being handcuffed and/or temporarily detained on-site, but you've preserved all of your rights under the law. Fighting temporary detainment is a "sticky wicket" and generally ill-advised unless you genuinely feel that your life or the lives of your family are at immediate risk (e.g. driving your pregnant wife to the hospital, etc.).

bonsaitree··on Protecting your email with 'AT domain DOT com' is making it easier to find
Why is this news?!

Follow Postel's law and simply apply (ever cheaper) horsepower to filtering on the back-end + gray-listing & white-listing. This IS NOT rocket science people.

If one can write a regular expression to parse the "obfuscated" content, it's just one more rule in a markov validation chain in a data mining script.

"...Same as it ever was..."--The Talking Heads

bonsaitree··on Record police with phone camera in Boston, get arrested
Nah. It's actually no biggie. I've only had to use it a few times. It came as advice from my lawyer after having been involved peripherally a few years ago, as a witness, in one IAD case.

I grew up around law enforcement (best friend's father was FBI, and current friends in Secret Service etc.). Also, in Fed-land (e.g. Northern Virginia) where nearly everyone's family is in some form of government/legal service, I suspect the public/police interactions are atypical.

As a result, talking to cops in both personal and professional contexts isn't a novel experience. IMO, Virginia also has professional cop culture.

I always recommend folks view this lecture given by Virginia's Regent Law School ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8z7NC5sgik ).

bonsaitree··on Record police with phone camera in Boston, get arrested
Sad. I'm surprised the first subject, a trained lawyer, didn't simply deny to answer the question concerning his camera. My standard response to any perceived intimidation by police these days is:

"I'm sorry Mr./Mrs/Sargent/Lt X, but I don't talk to police on material matters without counsel present."

bonsaitree··on Rackspace vs. EC2: Performance Analysis
Agreed. EBS is really where the rubber meets the road in scaling web apps for EC2--esp. a de-normalized datastore.
bonsaitree··on Rackspace vs. EC2: Performance Analysis
I was wondering why the text read a great deal like a VNR (video new release).

The analysis may be "independent", but the fine print at the bottom of the article indicates that it was paid for by Rackspace.

bonsaitree··on The $160 Lesson: Apps Beat Devices
I absolutely agree. A fact which further proves my point.

The comparison was being made to previous generations of digital TVs and set top boxes, not to generic home PCs or laptops. Similarly, look at the evolution of dedicated game consoles.

bonsaitree··on The $160 Lesson: Apps Beat Devices
Um, no.

Wow. This is simply an extreme over-generalization of a single use-case being applied to entire industries. The author of the article is also a VC with a vested interest in 'apps'. Shocker.

Nice press-hack Mr. Wilson, but present-day facts and digital computing history are not in your favor.

Moore's law and Gilder's law illustrate that a democratization of hardware and connectivity outpace the ability of generic software to be written to connect them.

The future is in MORE devices, not less.

Granted, the practical use-cases for "generic devices running task-specific apps" grows as interfaces become standardized and increased portable computing power allows for more near real-time workflows from non-dedicated real-time hardware. All modern TVs and Set-top boxes are really powerful computers running "video apps". We are finally arriving at dawn of the "univeral remote", but home media consumption is an extremely small sliver of computing.

Wherever safety, security, and low-attention/muscle-memory/real-time response properties dominate the workflow, a task-specific combination of hardware & software (e.g. a Device) works better. And those devices are getting cheaper and cheaper to produce every day.

For example, look at the large variety of input and monitoring Devices which come coupled with household products (stereos, garage door openers, cars, hot tubs, baby monitors, etc.).

Further from home, Internet routers used to simply be generic Unix boxes. Now routers run their own hardware platforms and dedicated operating systems. The same applies to industrial welding/manipulation robots.

Input used to come exclusively from serial line keyboard terminals. Now a whole range of dedicated input Devices (mice, trackpads, haptic probes, eye-trackers, isometric sticks) and their respective software drivers, provide the vast bulk of user input data.

People aren't going to trust the safety and security of their health, homes, cars, or children to the latest v2.1 update in the App store, but they'll (somewhat unhappily) wait on the latest firmware update while their Scientific Atlanta cable box reboots.

bonsaitree··on Can we stop the language bashing please ?
In short, no.

Granted, it's on the extreme end of high-noise/opinion scale, but "Bashing" is a natural component of the many evolutionary pressures exerted on any form of human memetic expression.

It's no different than literary or other forms of artistic criticism.

Be wary of ANY single idea or concrete instance of expression without a robust spectrum of discussion surrounding its merits.

bonsaitree··on New technology makes for more accurate guns
Did you read the same article and view the same video?

There were absolutely no mentions of "acquisition speed", nor precision of said sight picture relative to that speed, nor any trade-offs associated between these two critical variables in sight performance. A good sight tries to achieve the right balance between these values for the given application.

As a competitive shooter, I'm sure that Mr. Kraft has made these conscious trade-offs in his design, but none of these fundamentals are mentioned in the article nor in the accompanying video.

"No one has re-thought the basic principles of a pistol sight for a hundred years"

Really? 3-Dot? L.E.D illuminated? Fiber Optic blade? Is even a basic Wikipedia search beyond this author's reach?

http://tinyurl.com/y8p2sc6

IF the literal headline for an article is "New technology makes for more accurate guns", you had best back-up that claim with some credible evidence.

No evidence was offered or were ANY comparisons made against alternative sight designs--either on a qualitative nor quantitative basis.

This article was not authored. It is mere video stenography.

Before you judge the merits of the insult, I urge to to examine other works by Mr. Matyszczyk.

Is this the sort of journalistic standard to which a technology-centric site such as CNET wishes to give its imprimatur? Sadly, it appears so.

bonsaitree··on New technology makes for more accurate guns
A good sight is not just about absolute accuracy & precision, but about speed of acquisition of a "reasonable" sight picture given the existing context and time-task window for making the decision to fire.

In other words, a good optical 'combat' sight geometry tends to be very different from a good 'target' sight.

Both ghost-ring, for shoulder-mounted, and 3-Dot for hand-mounted (e.g. pistol) sights have already been tested extensively (in the lab) and field-proven for close-quarters and near-field target acquisition under actual battlefield conditions.

Some numbers please? A control please? FFS even a 1-sample comparison versus existing 22LR Olympic target pistol competition sight? None are to be found in this "article".

Not to take anything away from Mr. Kraft's work, but optical ballistic sighting is a field where one size definitely does not fit all.

Until then, this is nothing more than cheap 'pop sci' link-bait jurinalism from CNET. It must've been a slow news week for Mr. Matyszczyk--the "author" of the post.

bonsaitree··on Welcome to HN. Please, read 'Hacker News Guidelines.' We take them seriously.
It looks like I've been breaking the "use asterisks for emphasis" rule for years without realizing it.

I've always used _foo_ for code-specific articles, or FOO for a more general audience, and reserved foo for parenthetical physical actions such as shrug or bows.

My bad.

bonsaitree··on Claude Shannon
Not to pile on, but don't forget Paul Dirac:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Dirac who's eponymous Delta Dirac function is essential for signals (e.g. information theory) analysis.

Oh yeah. He also basically invented modern wave theory.

bonsaitree··on Do you use encryption? Beware of Windows System Restore
Granted this is a parable to prove a technical point, but encryption and steganography issues aside, NO professional investigative journalist would risk keeping such sensitive material at home. It's kept at the office, or rotated across multiple safe deposit boxes, multiple safehouses, or, at the bare minimum, an offsite dead/dry dump--NEVER at home.

Additionally, why did he even open the door in the first place?

If they have a warrant, and if the information is valuable enough, let them expend time, effort, and resources to physically break in while the critical files are scrubbed (i.e. securely deleted with multiple over-writes).

If he's paranoid enough, these days, it will never be permanently stored on hard disk media in the first place. Instead the project files will be on easy-to-destroy and physically tiny flash media.

If the information is valuable enough (especially with corporate backing and 'sources' laws protections in the U.S.) it's worth the risk fighting an obstruction of justice charge.

bonsaitree··on CrunchPad is 'steamrolling along,' will cost between $300 and $400
The criticism was directed towards Engadget's "coverage" of vaporware as mere video stenography--not statements by Techcrunch.
bonsaitree··on CrunchPad is 'steamrolling along,' will cost between $300 and $400
While I'd love Apple to have some competition in the forthcoming tablet space, this is PURE speculation put forth by an organization with ZERO history of shipping ANY manufactured devices.

Hey Engadget, why don't you wait for, I dunno, an actual realized working device (even in prototype form) before you devote labor and pixels to "covering" vaporware.

You're also not doing any credence to your editorial reputation by merely being YouTube podcast stenographers.

Add actual insight or you're wasting everyone's time and attention.

PRO-TIP: When citing, you can link WITHIN a YouTube video's time index using the "#t=39m" suffix. (Ex. http://tinyurl.com/yj26c4x )

bonsaitree··on Maybe it's time for personal servers?
AT ~$20/month why not have both?

One can setup dynamic DNS to map one's physical home server into the cloud. This gives you all the advantages of a legitimate POP whilst also providing the security, redundancy, and local audit-ability of your own hardware.

bonsaitree··on Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon
Aside from being sourced directly from the Rackspace blog, there are NO logical/technical reasons given for the the switch.

This is a pure PR puff piece.

Why is this even on HN in the first place?!

bonsaitree··on Slow capital by Fred Wilson
I have the upmost respect for Mr. Wilson, but no technology-centric VC fund with strategic investment goals in the sub-decade range could ever be considered "slow capital" by the Buffett standard.
bonsaitree··on If you had 5 dollars and 2 hours, how would you make as much money as possible?
This is merely an academic "bounding/framing" exercise in every sense of the word. Pure entertainment.

A better measure of business creativity would be to allocate the same fixed budgets of labor and materials to all teams and record revenue, profits, and judge the sustainability of the solution at the end of a more reasonable operational timeframe--say 1 week.

The "winning" teams operated under entirely different working budgets for materials and labor during their prep time and 2 hour window.

It's made even worse as the professor immediately demerits the 'party' example due to the costs of the party supplies and setup. Apparently, Stanford student time & attention is "free" for one team, but worth $650 for the other.

bonsaitree··on TSA Response to XKCD “Bag Check” Cartoon
As great as XKCD is, seeing the TSA respond to this cartoon is just as bad as CNN fact-checking the SNL sketch.

As someone with more than a casual familiarity with man-portable explosives (some R&D work on remote land mine detection), nobody with any modicum of sense would EVER confuse a bottle of drinking water with a bottle of liquid explosive. The latter have a very low vapor pressure, very different viscosity, and give off very distinctive odors. The most commonly obtained ones are also NOT transparent.

bonsaitree··on Programming language choice - sometimes there is none.
In truth, most of this conservatism is cultural rather than driven by any cost or fundamental technical issue.

Though heavy exceptions do apply when dealing with system call interfaces to hard real-time kernels used in avionics software and medical applications such as heart pacemakers.

bonsaitree··on Dirty Little Secret of Success
Glad that you noticed, or at least were made aware of, the full context of Zeldman's post via the public HN community and back-channels.

I urge some self-reflection via a few full listen-throughs of the early audio-only CalacanisCasts immediately following your tenure at AOL. It was especially galling given your impending fatherhood (congratulations btw.) and his current family status.

Given his near continuous contributions to the Web community over the years, Zeldman has more than earned the right for a little public venting.

bonsaitree··on Vim and Emacs modelines
A classic apples vs. oranges fallacy--which is main reason why these horrid comparison articles will never stop being published.
bonsaitree··on Dyson's overpriced fan and the Coandă Effect
The in/famous Dyson branding aside, I'd like to measure the fan's volumetric efficiency per watt compared to a conventional inline blade design.

In other words, how much air is moved at what speed given the electrical energy expended to drive the impeller.

I doubt seriously that it's much better than conventional fan designs given that it has 3 distinct regimes of airflow (intake duct, impeller blade, Coanda foil).

Additionally, though inline impellers can be quite efficient, having these 3 distinct vector flow regimes will bleed energy in de/compression inlet/exhaust artifacts (noise and vibration) so it won't be much quieter than a conventional design.

bonsaitree··on Calacanis Waits To Be Sued — But Angels Say They Won’t Oblige
See: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=881666
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →