7,786 karma · joined April 26, 2010
- On quantifying the benefits
This goes back to that fundamental challenge of deciding how you want to sell. IMO — and this is just me — trying to quantify aspects like feel is a fool's errand. Feel is experience; communicate experience. How do you do that? I would focus on producing materials that appeal to the senses. Photos and video, primarily. Find ways to communicate the experience of using your product. Create visual associates with environments and traditions that your target buyer will identify with.
- On competitors
I like that you've recognized the problems with that copy. I would make an effort to acknowledge that your product is different than what these other companies produce. You want to create the feeling that there's something better out there, but you don't want to insult the buyer's historical judgement. Focus on creating confidence, even when talking about competitors.
> If a person loves any knife they have, then it's a good knife.
You have to find a way to work this statement in to your copy. It is a garage door sized gateway to selling against your competitor's weaknesses. Your knives are designed to be experience; to be loved.
- On education
I'd break all this stuff up.
1) Knives 101 should not start with any content dedicated to knocking competitors. I would move that copy to a separate document titled something like "What's different about these knives?" Then speak to the differences. Use language that speaks positively about your knives, but avoids explicit negative statements about competitors. Speak to the absence of the positive attributes your knives possess in your competitors' products.
2) When authoring your site's education materials, start from an outline and drill down in to details. As the details emerge, a structure should appear. You'll find lots of "one of these things is not like the other" moments. The content will naturally organize itself.
3) Don't overdo the education portion on your marketing site. Maybe you need a separate resource for education. I've been fortunate to work with some really incredible marketers, and any time I insisted that I needed to educate someone, I got shut down. Hard. I know it's a passion, but you may need to break it out in order for your marketing site to be effective.
- On markets
Maybe selling to chefs and home buyers is similar, but they strike me as very different. I would imagine that a chef is going to have a much greater depth of knowledge and feel for what they want. A chef will probably want to shop by steel type, because they will already be familiar with at least some of the types.
Your ability to execute on both through a single site will stretch the limits of simplicity. My business is business procurement. Care to venture what the the sell through rate would be if we sent a consumer through our business procurement process in order to buy something? I'm not sure if negative sell through rates are possible, but we'd give it a good run! Likewise with professionals (chefs) vs home buyers. I would expect that the pro is going to come to the table with far more knowledge than a home buyer. They're not going to be compelled by an authenticity play. This is a tool for them. They're likely to know what they want and will value the ability to quickly find what they're looking for at a good price.
You'll know whether I'm overstating the difference. You should make that judgement call though.
- On pedigree and tradition
Anyone who finds the pedigree and tradition elements of your product bullshit-y is not your buyer. They might speak loudly, but they're irrelevant. Based on the feel of your site, I'm guessing that you don't care to be Walmart or Target. The people who don't give a shit about pedigree and tradition are going to buy a knife at a retailer. They'll never value the qualitative aspects of your product, so you should discard their detractions.
- On videos
I think you're headed the right direction. I don't have any specific recommendations for you, unfortunately. The "Man at Arms" katana video is the most relevant thing I've seen to traditional Japanese forging techniques, but it's not at all appropriate for your site. Too bad the "The Birth Of A Tool" video isn't traditional Japanese. That's exactly the kind of video I would shoot for when selling to consumers.
I think your overall idea and product selection is really spectacular. One of my brother-in-law's went to Le Cordon Bleu and is building a career in fine dining, so I have some exposure to his knife obsession :) If you'd like to keep in touch, feel free to email me. My domain is bradlanders.com, and my email is [my first name] @ bradlanders.com.
- Glaring Issues
You're selling a high-end product. The carousel at the top of the page has a video of a man hand forging a blade with a "Learn More" button. When I click that button I get... A page full of knives. WTF?
I am immediately left with the impression that the person who built this page was not connected to the message being conveyed. The result does not match my expectation. That is a deadly sin to commit on a component of the website that is front and center.
- General Sales Feel/Pitch
Buttermilk has to decide how it is going to sell. Are hand forged knives technically better than precision automated manufacturing? If so, I need a clear explanation of these advantages in language that equates to objective data.
Currently, when I click on the links to learn more (knives 101, why carbon, etc), I'm given a mix of information-overload and a message that seems set on convincing me that the decision I'm about to make is going to be really complicated. Maybe it is, but as the seller, it's your goal to make me feel confident in my purchase as quickly as possible; not bury me in knowledge.
It doesn't help that you start out with a pitch that is very likely to put off many prospective buyers. For example, our household has used a set of Wusthof knives for the last five years or so. We "upgraded" from a set of (crappy) Oneida knives that were horrible. My wife adores the Wusthof knives.
It is very difficult for me to trust information from a source that tells me how horrible these knives really are. This directly contradicts my experience, and degrades my confidence in the speaker. It tells me that the person speaking has a perspective that is incompatible with mine. Maybe I would drop $300-$500 on a kitchen knife, but I wouldn't take this speaker's word for it.
# Selling High-End Stuff
Maybe it's not about specification or vague technical superiority at all though. There are parts of the copy that give me this sense, but it's not consistent. IMO, if someone is going to spend $300 on a knife, they're going to do so because of an attachment to aspects of the product other than objectively quantifiable specification. As the seller of a high-end product, you need to identify these subjective, qualitative strong-points of your product and lean heavily on them. If the knives are hand made by Japanese craftsmen, then you're sitting on one of the most compelling "authenticity" plays in the product world. Leverage that shit!
Here are some examples of videos that aren't necessarily selling something, but they create a strong sense of desire by illustrating the product's authenticity.
The Birth Of A Tool. Part III. Damascus steel knife making - https://vimeo.com/56287630
I don't just want one of those knives; I feel compelled to own one. It wouldn't matter what the product is. When I watch that video, I feel like I'm part of the process. The quality of the product takes a back seat to the authenticity of the product. I'm not saying Buttermilk should ignore the objective advantages of carbon steel versus stainless, but I am saying that I think it's a smaller part of the story.
Hattori Hanzō Katana (Kill Bill) - MAN AT ARMS: REFORGED - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNuEDtnVdeM
This video has a lot more of a "NatGeo" feel, but if you listen to the language used by the smiths, it's very compelling. Especially the guy talking about the Japanese philosophy as it relates to forging and toolmaking. Very compelling stuff. Fare more so than a list of steel types.
Sometimes an object is more than the physical thing. Its story contributes to its desirability. Given the product you're selling, you should be taking advantage of that fact.
How to Knock Off a Bag - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a11wlngpuSY
Last, but not least, if you're going to say bad things about your competitors, you have to get creative. This classic from Saddleback Leather is a master course in making your competitor's products look like garbage without diminishing your own credibility.
However, the position you're taking puts you on the side of: people should be allowed to fly drones in an area where aircraft are responding to an emergency (a wildfire) that puts other lives at risk. Any drone not flying in coordinated effort to actually put out the fire is of a priority that is very, very distant to that of the firefighting aircraft. At least by my measure, and I'm in the camp that believes the TSA should be abolished.
Any statistical analysis of helicopter bird strikes won't negate the fact that having drones in the area of operation increases the chance that a pilot may lose their life to a collision with a drone that serves no purpose than to populate YouTube with riveting footage of a disaster. Is an increase of even 1 in a million worth that? Not by my account it isn't.
The Tesla is a 4-door sedan that you could easily use to pick up business partners from the airport. You might as well compare the tesla to a BMW HP4 (superbike).
http://www.zeroto60times.com/2-second-cars-0-60-mph-times/
The Tesla is the only sedan on the list. The majority of the cars are mid/rear engine super cars or track-day cars that you wouldn't care to drive every day. Any way you slice it, this is remarkable company.
It's easy to shrug off questions like this, placing them in the category of "if it were feasible, someone would obviously be doing it already", but it's still interesting. Having read a pretty extensively about how steam locomotives work, and some additional reading about steam power in general, it's interesting to read this article and catch small windows in to the overall progress of steam during the era. For example, reading the remarks about closing the steam circuit reminds me of the progress made in condensate and heat recovery developed in steam power at the time. Really remarkable to see that in something as small as a car.
As an academic exercise, I think it'd be really cool to develop a "steam powered auto challenge". Of course, no one is going to get behind it because steam is not a green technology, but sometimes we can learn important lessons from the past. Working on a completely unrelated technology and studying its progress can teach us lessons about the development of current technologies.
Otherwise you've set the bar at 0% error rate, which is unrealistic at scale.
Yes.
The worst thing MS did with IE was implementing proprietary, and very aggressively protected, solutions to common problems. Developers, excited about the new features, rushed to support what they felt was the next generation of web technologies, only to get caught in Microsoft's trap. Once they held the marketshare majority, they stopped innovating.
Safari is nowhere close to a majority player in the market (not even on mobile). Thus, it could never be considered equivalent to the evils of IE.
Whether this is "better", depends on what you need. I don't know about your systems, but I use fail2ban for protecting several different administrative systems, so I'd still need it. Thus, I won't be switching. However, if you only need SSH monitoring, this is worth a close look.
I'm not saying it's ok or that it's a good justification. I'm just saying that there's a clear difference in the way people will weigh one against the other under different circumstances.
But you're right. You may never be convicted. Go ahead and try your luck.
It almost certainly violates Facebook's ToS though.
I'll vouch for that. However, I really wonder whether automated testing is something that needs to be in the hands of people who are more comfortable with Excel and less comfortable with, say, YAML?
Also, I'm not sure if it's the responsiveness of the website being tested that makes this so slow, but it takes a very long time for the tests to complete. Line up a couple hundred tests and you're looking at very long run times. That's going to inhibit adoption for anyone who knows how quickly headless browsers can complete integration tests.
Do you happen to know what altitude firefighting aircraft fly at when they drop? It would seem that 500' AGL would be on the high side if you expect the fire suppression material to hit anywhere near the target site in any reasonable level of concentration. I know nothing about the subject matter though, so that could be a bad assumption.
Imagine you are in standing in a bedroom, and someone asks you, "Why are you in this bedroom?"
Does you answer look like this?
"I walked in through the front door, passed through the living room, down the hall, then used the door to enter this room."
Or like this?
"I was feeling kind of sleepy, so I figured I'd come in here and lie down on the bed."
The former is not a perfect analogue for the Superuser answer, but perfect analogues are difficult to come by.
Your observations are poignant. There is strong incentive to treat everything as a commodity these days. Part of our business is in helping buyers structure their RFQ documents so that the product or service can be competitively sourced. In the government sector, however, we rarely participate in this process.
Governments must purchase based on their state and local laws, which often ties their hands. A local school system may want to purchase better quality chalk for a reasonable premium, but the laws pertaining to procurement frequently prevent them. It's a really bizarre circumstance where public perception of government waste has resulted in laws that eliminate buyers' ability to cut deals that are better for everyone. I'm not saying it's impossible; it's just much easier for a procurement officer at a local government to follow the standard process (which prioritizes price) than it is to fight for quality.
There are pockets of innovation, however. Our eRA platform stands out because we offer the ability to incorporate non-price factors in to our ranking algorithm. This gives a buyer the ability to "weight" one bidder over the others. We developed some of our most advanced features jointly with local governments in Arizona. I'm not sure I should name names, but there are people doing really great work out in Arizona.
We have even considered founding a separate not-for-profit organization whose entire purpose would be to assist local governments in improving their procurement laws so that there would be a better balance of good sourcing practices and the ability to incentivize quality over price where appropriate. That's a huge challenge though. You frequently end up directly opposed to special interests with very deep pockets and a financial incentive to keep procurement laws just as they are.
1: If you're wondering: http://www.eauctionservices.com
Think about how applications like Siri work today. They have a very superficial appearance of AI, but they're not terribly convincing. Apple is making progress though. Siri surprises me all the time; in a good way. Periodically, I'll try something new; and occasionally, Siri delivers. It's progressive enhancement.
Fast-forward 25-50 years. Where is the line between what we have today and "true" AI? I keep quoting the word true because I believe the phrase "true AI" is apocryphal in the way the author uses it. True AI can mean many things. Two possibilities are:
1) We gain some deeper insight in to the mechanics of human consciousness, and set out to replicate that in software. When we achieve that, we've achieved "true AI".
2) We never really understand human consciousness, but we keep chasing the goal of convincing AI. That is, AI that seems human. In this chase, we achieve a convincing enough level of AI that the questions raised in the article — and in the movie — become relevant.
I believe the latter is a more likely scenario than the former.
Looking forward 25-50 years again, let's examine a future where Megacorp™ keeps iterating their AI product. Samantha could be just another major (vis a vis SemVer) release. In Megacorp's testing, the AI was very convincing, and they believed they had a leg up on the competition. They hadn't realized just how effective their new software was though. In testing, the software's access was limited to the sandbox of the testing environment, which used samples of information. Once released on to the Internet, with access to a vast number of connections and information, the software reaches levels of convincingness (a proxy for intelligence) that the authors hadn't anticipated.
...but that doesn’t change the fact that we’ve spent all our time
mired in the world view of a neurotic middle class man whose only
real problems, and only real interest, are his dysfunctional
romantic relationships. Jonze has taken what would in truth be a
revolutionary event in human history and shrunk it down to an
episode of Dr. Phil.
I hate to be so cynical, but have a look at the world around us. Wouldn't it be so perfectly human of us (as a society on the whole) to overlook the emergence of true AI while we ponder our navel? That is exactly the type of complication that Samantha is referring to. We have the capacity for rationality, but we're not 100% rational. That's what makes us human. That is, IMO, a major theme of Her.PS - I am 100% certain that somewhere in the societal background, there is a Hacker News that exists in the world of Her. This community identified that this new software was a "game changer" early on, and many arguments ensued with regard to how this new AI will impact the world. Society at large, failed to notice.