Thanks for caring about this done in a respectful, creator-first way.
7,435 karma · joined June 18, 2008
brad at ycombinator dot com
Thanks for caring about this done in a respectful, creator-first way.
We're pushing up fixes tomorrow that (we hope) make it a lot clearer: https://brave.com/rewards-update/
(Sidenote: Thank you for the Hedge Maze puzzles in the Keep. They were a gaming highlight for me last year.)
Thanks for caring about this being done in a respectful, thoughtful way. We'll keep trying to do better.
We'd love another shot at winning your interest. Thanks for caring about finding new ways to get creators paid.
Thanks for your passion for creators and for those of modest means and with disabilities. The internet is awesome in part because it's a place where everyone and anyone can contribute.
The bottom line is that it will be much much much clearer that unverified creators are not participating in Brave Rewards and what happens to any BAT tips a user tries to send to one. We'll also not be using any creative assets at all from unverified creators like their Youtube images. In the post we also commit to looking into whether to block attempts to tip unverified creators altogether.
Thanks for your feedback.
As it says in the post, we're definitely planning to talk about whether to block attempts to tip unverified creators altogether.
Thanks for your feedback!
Thanks for your feedback. We shipped UI that sent the wrong message about unverified creators. Understood. We're hustling to get fixes in place and talking more about what we can and should be doing.
We shipped confusing, poorly considered UI and are hustling to get it fixed. Thanks for your feedback.
We shipped confusing, poorly thought out UI, got a bunch of negative but really thoughtful feedback, and are moving quickly to get things fixed.
We've spent a lot of time discussing the feedback from threads like this and tomorrow a bunch of changes will go live. Please take a look at this blog post detailing them: https://brave.com/rewards-update/
Thanks for jumping into the conversation. Also thanks for all the stories on HN over the years.
These changes will make it very very clear when creators are not participating in Brave Rewards and will ensure no creator assets are being used.
In response to your other comments, I feel good assuming we're somewhere in the general brand feel of the EFF and Firefox. Brave has never once told people to speculate on the price of BAT (we get asked to do so about once a day and refuse because that's not what we're about). Also, yeah, we've shipped a browser used by 5m people a month around the world. There's a long way to go still but it's a start.
Thanks for your feedback.
Brave is about to push up a number of hotfixes to our code that address people's concerns. You can read about them here: https://brave.com/rewards-update/
You'll see an express commitment to consider whether to completely block out tips to unverified creators/publishers. That's not a thing we could fix overnight but we're acknowledging it might be the best move and committing to looking into it.
One of the items listed is looking into blocking all tips to unverified publishers altogether. We hear people's concerns and are going to look into it. In the meantime we've dropped all creative assets (photos) for unverified publishers and are also adding a clear alert saying unverified publishers are in fact not-participating yet in the program. Screenshots in the link. Thanks for your feedback and for caring about this being done properly.
Thanks for your feedback and suggestions.