HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bsoles

1,059 karma · joined November 28, 2023

submissionscomments
bsoles··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
> I will vote for and donate to candidates who also want to fight ...

Fight for what? I bet to change one or more of the things that I have mentioned above. I have said "nothing will change" unless these things change; I didn't say you/we shouldn't do anything.

bsoles··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
Why would you claim that my statement is defeatist? It is just acknowledging the reality of how things work nowadays without saying anything about giving up. If anything, it cautions people that change will not come easily and to be prepared for it. I vote, give money to political/public causes, to go meetings of my federal representatives, post my opinions on HN, ... I am just being more realistic about my expectations.
bsoles··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
> So the solution here is straightforward: every government grant should ...

People who write such sentences have no idea what they are talking about or are being intentionally naive for whatever reason.

Just because your one-sentence solution reads simple doesn't make the actual solution simple. Because such a solution involves changes to laws, changes to entrenched interests, changes to distribution of money involved in the whole system, and changes to balance of powers between stakeholders. Unless the push for such changes is significant enough to overcome the current state of affairs (due to public opinion, redistribution of power or money, etc.), nothing will happen.

bsoles··on Dyson settles forced labour suit in landmark UK case
Dyson is Juicero of vacuum cleaners. So much "tech" for something so simple. A $100 Home Depot shop vacuum works as good if not better.
bsoles··on Smartphone market forecast to decline this year due to memory shortage
Back in the day, I was running AutoCAD on a 386 PC. Now, a single Firefox tab consumes 500MB of memory. That is progress for us.
bsoles··on Implementing a Z80 / ZX Spectrum emulator with Claude Code
Even on a specific STM microcontroller (STM32G031), the LLM tools invent non-existent registers and then apologize when I point it out. And conversely, they write code for an entire algorithm (CRC, for example) when hardware support already exists on the chip.
bsoles··on ChatGPT Health fails to recognise medical emergencies – study
>> "securely" (my emphasis) connect medical records and wellness apps” to generate health advice and responses.

No, no, no, and no. Are we going to never learn. Sharing medical data with AI tools is going to come back and bite you.

bsoles··on US orders diplomats to fight data sovereignty initiatives
"When Mexico sends its people, they're not sending their best. They're bringing drugs. They're bringing crime. They're rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.” - Trump

Just replace Mexico with America. There must be some Freudian issue going on with Trump here.

bsoles··on You are not supposed to install OpenClaw on your personal computer
If only I knew enough finance about making a lot of money from the impending collapse of this AI stupidity and the stupidity of AI grifters. I would put real money on it if anybody has suggestions.
bsoles··on How to stop being boring
People who are normally perceived as non-boring (like talkative, outgoing, friendly-by-default people) are usually insufferable for me.

People who are initially perceived as boring (like quiet, introspective, focused people) are more fascinating if you can get through to them. Unfortunately, I have no such skills...

bsoles··on No Skill. No Taste
If you vibe coded any software, by definition, it means you have no skills and no taste.
bsoles··on Can a Computer Science Student Be Taught to Design Hardware?
>> "Either we hire good CS people who have the basic understanding of EE, and we train them to become good engineers, or we hire good engineers who are good in CS, and we try to upskill them on the CS side."

The former (CS -> EE) is very unlikely to happen at a large scale than the latter (EE -> CS). It is much easier to teach EEs to become (albeit, often bad) software engineers, than teaching CS student to be good engineers.

Also, the former (CS -> EE) will not happen in academia because of (1) turf wars, and (2) CS faculty not having any understanding, nor interest in electronics/hardware/engineering.

I once proposed to teach an IoT class in the CS department of a major university in US, the proposal basically fell on deaf ears.

bsoles··on Stop generating, start thinking
Outsourcing their thinking is going to be the stupidest thing humans ever did and we won't even be smart enough to understand that this is the case.
bsoles··on We tasked Opus 4.6 using agent teams to build a C Compiler
The title should have said "Antropic stole GCC and other open-source compiler code to create a subpar, non-functional compiler", without attribution or compensation. Open source was never meant for thieving megacorps like them.

No, I did not read the article...

bsoles··on Why more companies are recognizing the benefits of keeping older employees
I am on the same boat. I left management to go back to a senior IC role in my early 50s. I am perceived as an important contributor in my company, but I am 90% sure that no big company would ever hire me. I am also pretty sure I cannot pass LeetCode these days even though I work on implementing scientific algorithms that actually get used by major engineering/manufacturing companies around the world.
bsoles··on See how many words you have written in Hacker News comments
I feel like a perfect realization Goodhart's Law is about to happen to move up our rankings.
bsoles··on English professors double down on requiring printed copies of readings
I asked my students in a take home lab to write tests for a function that computes the Collatz sequence. Half of the class returned AI generated tests that tested the algorithm with floating point and negative numbers (for "correct" results, and not for input validation). I am not doing anything take home anymore.
bsoles··on Two kinds of AI users are emerging
There are, proportionally, more lawyers than software engineers in prison I would claim. Code of ethics doesn't really mean much.
bsoles··on They lied to you. Building software is hard
> Why are you so certain that LLMs/AI can't be used as a tool to learn and grow?

Because every other post in here, for example, starts with "I vibe coded..." and not with "I learned something new today on ChatGPT".

bsoles··on Soldering Prototypes with Enamel Magnet Wire (2020)
> ... regular wires with plastic isolation, but those can be a pain to strip, even with a semi-decent stripping tool.

> Boil away a millimeter or 2 of enamel without cutting the wire off the spool.

The person spends 18 seconds (see the video) to "boil away" and tin the tip of the enamel wire, yet complains about using a wire stripper to strip the wire in 5 seconds.

I mostly use breadboards even with microcontroller stuff (at 16 MHz, or so), and never run into any problems for constructing semi-permanent circuits. The PCB version of breadboards (https://www.adafruit.com/product/571) also work pretty well. There area also little PCB adaptors to integrate surface-mount components on breadboards that work well.

bsoles··on They lied to you. Building software is hard
Over the last 25 years of building commercial software, but being a programming enthusiast since I was 15 years old, I came to the conclusion that self-improvement (in the sense of gaining real expertise in a field, building a philosophy of things, and doing the right things) is in direct opposition to creating "value" in the corporate/commercial sense of today.

Using AI/LLMs, you perhaps will create more commercial value for yourself or your employer, but it will not make you a better learner, developer, creator, or person. Going back to the electronic calculator analogy that people like to refer to these days when discussing AI, I also now think that, yes, electronic calculators actually made us worse with being able to use our brains for complex things, which is the thing that I value more than creating profits for some faceless corporation that happens to be my employer at the moment.

bsoles··on Are we all plagiarists now?
The reliability of all AI tools with potentially severe consequences for people needs to be tested using adversarial patterns. This is nothing new, yet the mentioned article fails to do that. They test the happy paths and find the results to be satisfactory for themselves.

It is very common in academic investigations to achieve results with more than 95% accuracy, let alone 90%, when in the real world the same AI tools fail miserably.

So, yes, this is the nightmare scenario that I am afraid of where a simplistic "investigation" will be used to justify the use of unproven AI tools with real life consequences to people.

bsoles··on Are we all plagiarists now?
> The false positive rate is 0. The tool never says human writing is AI.

That cannot be true as it would be easy for a human to write in the style of AI, if they choose to. Whoever is making that claim is lying, because money...

bsoles··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand [video]
This is just sad to read. AI makes all of us stupider by the day, no matter what the tech bros and wanna-be billionaires of HN tells us...
bsoles··on How I estimate work
Anybody who worked with a local contractor knows that their estimate and the reality has no correlation.

When you ask for a firm estimate, you are basically asking to be lied to, and the contractor happily complies by telling you a lie.

bsoles··on How I estimate work
Ever heard of Big Dig in Boston, for example? Or the Joint Strike Fighter?

Estimations in government contracts are as ridiculous as in software. They just pretend to be able to estimate when things will be done, when, in fact, the contractors are as clueless.

Not being able to say "it is impossible to estimate", does not mean your estimate will be correct. That estimation is usually a lie.

bsoles··on Design Thinking Books (2024)
> Not sure what you've been sold, but there are no special rules or rigid methods.

I am not intentionally trying to be argumentative, but

- I have seen UX designers refer to a team of developers as "my developers" and I take it negatively.

- I have been into countless design sessions where the UX designers conducted a weird formalized session with cards, sorting, voting with colored stickers, and assigning equal votes to newly hired participants and senior domain experts. They were beyond stupid.

bsoles··on Design Thinking Books (2024)
As many other people on HN, I am an advocate for software engineers and I think it is important that software engineers themselves develop expertise and become owners in their particular fields of application, their processes, etc.

Attempts to undermine their role and turn developers into simple cogs in the machine rub me the wrong way.

I perceive (you might disagree) that Design Thinking, Agile, Scrum, and similar things as attempt for designers, PMs, etc. to insert themselves into the process, not as equal partners, but as people with elevated privileges over software developers.

I don't necessarily disagree with the idea and ideals of Design Thinking. I disagree with the practitioners and their perception of themselves as something special over software developer.

I also think that my original analogy at the top is perfectly understood by a lot of people here as much as I understand the type of people on HN.

bsoles··on Design Thinking Books (2024)
It is the practice that matters, which is the "designers" trying to elevate their position to something more special by inserting their special rules into the design process, often at the expense of other people involved, including the experts.

"Working with the experts" always turns into weird formalized brainstorming sessions or other rituals, where the designer defines the process and the rules, and others' role is just to be little players in the game, but not the referee.

This is nothing new. We have seen the same thing with PMs and "scrum masters" inserting themselves into the software development process with shit like Agile, Scrum, etc.

If design thinking is just a problem solving approach, experts and practitioners in the field are perfectly capable of doing that. We don't need the shamans of Design Thinking to guide the process.

bsoles··on Design Thinking Books (2024)
> ... my masters was in signal processing

But, you are making my point for me here. Most data scientists don't get masters in signal processing. You are also acknowledging that gaining expertise in a particular field was worth pursuing.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →