HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

c517402

260 karma · joined August 30, 2016

submissionscomments
c517402··on Mathematicians Tame Rogue Waves, Illuminating Future of LED Lighting
LEDs and photovoltaics are both PN junctions. I wonder why they don't mention making better photovoltaics, or why their landscape function can't be used to improve photovoltaics.
c517402··on Professors’ unprofessional programs have created a new profession
I think there is a perspective that has been overlooked in these comments. It is that the "professors' unprofessional programs" are probably very understandable to someone who deeply understands the science/engineering concepts the programs represent. Especially, if you get some history about what was developed first and what order features were added, the spaghetti starts to become much more understandable. Of course, after passing through the hands of multiple grad students the code should probably be refactored, but how many of you recode a big framework just because it isn't perfect for your situation.
c517402··on When did software go off the rails?
IMHO, there is no Software Engineering. There is only Computer Science. There is none of the discipline that comes from engineering, and only the messiness that comes from science. The heroes in software are Computer Scientists and everyone wants to be a Computer Scientist. No one wants to be a Software Engineer. It isn't even clear to me that Software Engineering exists in a clearly defined way. Maybe a manager or director imposes their will on a group somewhere and engineering is done.
c517402··on A Systematic Analysis of the Juniper Dual EC Incident [pdf]
Let's not get crazy. Sharks? Of course, it's Dolphins.
c517402··on Dijkstra was right – recursion should not be difficult
IMHO, the first problem of summing a generalized array of numerical elements is not best solved recursively. I suggest sum(flatten( )) is better and uses less overhead. The subsequent problems under discussion more strongly require recursion.
c517402··on Pigs are smart and sensitive, yet we continue to justify killing them for food
And yet the wild population still needs to be controlled.

http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/a-plague-of-pig...

c517402··on Physicists Just Generated a Particle That Acts as Its Own Antiparticle
I have personally been producing particles that are there own anti-particles since childhood. And, I continue to do so as I write this comment. Photons!
c517402··on Scientific Realism in the Age of String Theory (2007) [pdf]
If you follow your Wikipedia link and then follow the link for Green's function two times, you come to the article that points out that Green's function methods only work on linear differential equations. The multipole method you refer to is based on the Green's function and only works for linear differential equations. Einstein's equations are non-linear. Trying to quantize a non-linear theory leads to problems that no one has yet resolved. You should also note that non-linear differntial equations do not support superposition; that is, the solutions cannot be added to yield another valid solution. They are not additive. So, the method you suggest fails because it does not meet the criteria you refer to.
c517402··on Scientific Realism in the Age of String Theory (2007) [pdf]
IIRC Feynman was also concerned about the infinities as well, but ultimately pragmatic. The infinities bother me as well. But, on reflection classical point particles produce forces that approach infinity as they become close, so the quantatization reflecting this seems reasonable. Please see my other comments.
c517402··on Scientific Realism in the Age of String Theory (2007) [pdf]
"untreatable infinities in calculations of particle interactions due to the possibility of point particles coming arbitrarily close to each other." This is actually very misleading. As mentioned in other comments, QED has "infinities in calculations of particle interactions due to the possibility of point particles coming arbitrarily close to each other," but these are treated via renormalization. QED (Quantum ElectroDynamics) is the QFT (Quantum Field Theory) based on Maxwells equations of Electromagnetism. Maxwells equations are linear partial differential equations and when converted to a quantized form, via QFT, the infinities can be dealt with by Renormalization. Einstein's General Relativity equations are non-linear partial differential equations and when converted to a quantized form, via QFT, the infinities cannot be dealt with by Renormalization. The quote makes it sound like classical point particles "coming arbitrarily close" is the problem with quantizing gravity(General Relativity), but the same problem exists in QED and yet QED yields a viable theory through Renormalization. The real difference is that Maxwell's equations are linear and Einstein's equations are non-linear. OTOH, the non-linearities in Einstein's equations do not become important until the particles are very close.

So, IMHO the quote is correct but misleading.

c517402··on Dotsies (2012)
It seems like the correspondence should be something other a-z. Something like making the vowels or more common letters more distinctive. E.g., making the vowels the lightest weight, that is make aeiou use the single dot letters dotsies uses for abcde.
c517402··on Ask HN: What's your favorites conferences?
Brazilian School of Cosmology and Gravitation, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

http://www.ceacbrasil.com/bscg/

Unfortunately, not there this year.

c517402··on How misaligning data can increase performance by reducing cache misses (2014)
Old Cray computers had the best memory bandwidth when the fast dimension of an array was of length 64*n +- 1.
c517402··on Should Community Colleges Abolish Algebra?
There was a time when a good Liberal Arts education included Calculus because it was considered one of the great achievements of Western Civilization.

The article says, "Their thinking has led to initiatives like Community College Pathways, which strays away from abstract algebra to engage students in real-world math applications."

My interpretation of this is that the article authors are math illiterate enough not to know that "abstract algebra" is thing.

How sad to think that some people think that community college intermediate algebra is so abstract that people can't get it.

c517402··on What is “Open Recursion”?
This article is great and IMHO is an example of the internet at its best. The article author, who knew and understood the intellectual development of the book where 'open recursion' was first used, explained, in the context of the book, exactly what the book author meant. Subsequently, we get the internet at less than its best when commenters quibble and squabble over terminology.

Read the article and ignore the comments.

c517402··on Maryam Mirzakhani’s Pioneering Mathematical Legacy
The article does a very poor job of describing her work. Does anyone have links to something understandable?
c517402··on Battle for the Internet
So, the diabetic guy goes to McDonalds and they are out of ice as well. He explains his predicament to the manager who says, "Sure, we will sell you a bag of ice when our machine has made more." But, then there is a nice big competitive market for ice. So, your tear jerker story about ice is probably a poor choice for comparison.
c517402··on Battle for the Internet
Texas State Highway 130 - You can pay the toll, drive your Farrari at 100 mph and have only a small chance of being pulled over. You can drive at 95 mph on one stretch and have zero chance of being pulled over.

From Wikipedia: "The highway is noted for having a speed limit of at least 80 mph (130 km/h) along its tolled section. The 41-mile (66 km) section of the toll road between Mustang Ridge and Seguin has a posted speed limit of 85 mph (137 km/h), the highest posted speed limit in the United States."

c517402··on A Huge Diamond Mine That Helped Build The Soviet Union (2014)
The article says that helicopters can't fly over the mine. But, the end of the runway is close by and the flight path is almost tangent to the edge of the hole. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mirny,+Sakha+Republic,+Rus...
c517402··on Why People from Manchester Are Mancunians, Not Manchesterians
People in Phoenix are referred to as Phoenicians. Which has always struck me as a misnomer.
c517402··on Lee-Gardner Amendment would reduce supersonic fuel burn
For an Advanced SST the quote near the end is, "Advances in aircraft technology suggest that sonic boom amplitudes for this type of aircraft, also referred to as a High Speed Civil Transport (HSCTJ or the "Orient Express". could be made substantially lower than first generation SSTs. potentially to the point that overland flight could be acceptable."

I'm not sure what to make of Fig. 10. I'm sure they are accurately plotting their equations, but the impulse for the SST is a minimum at 50,000 feet and increases for higher altitudes altitudes. The impulse for the HST generally increases with altitude. OTOH they discuss the N-wave forming in the far field and maintaining its shape, but also broadening which seems like it would reduce the impulse just like the overpressure.

The references 31-33 have alot of data. Here is a link to the first one: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/196400...

PS - If you are getting three digits of accuracy eyeballing Fig. 10, you must have gotten a much cleaner copy than I did. ;)

c517402··on California solar power output sometimes exceeds predictions
The turbines engines used for natural gas based electrical power production can be throttled up and down over a wide range. IIRC from maximum power down to about 15%. But, no you do not want to just shut them off. There are natural gas based diesel generators that can be turned on and off, but being Diesel engines they really only run efficiently over a small power output range and you control how much power is generated by how many you turn on. You need rows and rows of the Diesels to match the power from a gas turbine and each diesel needs to be individually matched into the power grid. So, there are reasons to go with gas turbine electrical power generation to meet peak power demands. OTOH, CA is tearing down recently built plants because of over capacity which is just crazy and obviously a boondoggle for the electric companies. But, building the plants was driven by the craziness that immediately preceded it; CA's NIMBY driven under capacity and being forced to meet peak power demands by buying outrageously priced power from out of state. Just bad planning, more bad planning, and certainly more bad planning to come.
c517402··on Lee-Gardner Amendment would reduce supersonic fuel burn
Thank you for the link to the stackexchange discussion. I read it and the Wikipedia and NASA pages it links to. Based on the Wikipedia link the calculated second table by the stackexchange author is incorrect. The Wikipedia article points out that the path of the N-wave will generally be curved upwards due to the temperature gradient from altitude to the ground making the distance longer. The path of the N-wave is not going to be the cone normally depicted. But, there are two things not discussed in the Wikipedia article that I think will also play a role in the magnitude of the sonic boom. 1) As altitude increases, air density decreases; meaning that for a given speed a smaller number of air molecules will be displaced thus reducing the magnitude of the sonic boom at the ground. 2) The sharp N-wave close to the supersonic source is not a soliton and will undergo dispersion reducing the over pressure. That is, as altitude increases and the distance to the ground increases, the N-wave is going to spread out into more of a layed-over-S wave reducing the magnitude of the sonic boom.

With regard to the SR-71 making record setting flights and flying at the limits of its flight envelope to do so(100,000+ feet or "the edge of space"), I think the sonic boom at that altitude may not be noticeable to human hearing.

I know the that the SR-71 and the Space Shuttle have produced very noticeable sonic booms, but what isn't answered is at what altitude did the sonic booms become noticeable or annoying. It seems to me that with all the things that reduce the the magnitude of a sonic boom that it may be possible to fly supersonic without being annoying and slow down to subsonic to takeoff and land. It might also be possible to design the aircraft body to promote dispersion of the N-wave.

Typo edit

c517402··on Lee-Gardner Amendment would reduce supersonic fuel burn
"Pilot Lt Col Ed Yielding and Reconnaissance Systems Officer Lt Col Joseph Vida took off at Palmdale, California and landed at Washington-Dulles a scant hour, four minutes, and 20 seconds later."[1]

I don't remember any sonic boom complaints when this or other record setting SR-71 flights over the US occurred. If you are flying in thin atmosphere the magnitude of the sonic boom at the surface should be much reduced. So, maybe it would be ok to fly supersonic at 70,000+ feet. Of course, it might be disconcerting if you were flying subsonic at 38,000 feet.

[1] https://www.google.com/amp/jalopnik.com/the-sr-71-blackbird-...

c517402··on Study: Tesla battery production releases as much CO2 as 8 yrs of driving on gas
My friend who is a highway engineer would disagree with you. He says that roads will last a very long time as long as the shear limit of the road is not exceeded, but that once the maximum shear is exceeded the road will deteriorate. So, semis that do not exceed their weight limit are not a problem, but hauling a bulldozer around on a flatbed with four axles when it should have six will really do damage. It makes sense to me because my experience has been that when anything is operated within it's design limits it can last a very long time. So, unless the cars you are talking about have very narrow tires, I don't think they will be the problem you propose.
c517402··on Investing in Julia Computing
From the performance graph, it looks like they should be investing in Fortran.
c517402··on An 89-year-old Reinventing the Train in His Backyard
Maybe it could be used for those kiddy trains at amusement parks.
c517402··on Pistol sights
Instead of using convolution to produce the imagery, I think it should be produced using fractional Fourier transforms. IIRC fractional Fourier transforms are mathematically equivalent to Fraunhofer and Fresnel diffraction integrals. Although, the convolutions look good.
c517402··on Thursday night Mountain View power outage the result of a drone crash
This is timely:

https://xkcd.com/1846/

c517402··on Dasung Paperlike Pro: E-Ink Monitor with HDMI connector [video]
This was a very old workspace. About every two cubicles there was a 15"x15"x8" box that sat on top of the cubicle wall and took about a minute to come up to full brightness. The top of the box was open and light reflected off the ceiling tiles down to the work area. I don't know who made them. They generated a fair amount of heat, but not enough to be uncomfortable. Twenty years ago they were probably twenty years old. In the five years I was there I never saw one burn out.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →