HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cabinpark

170 karma · joined February 3, 2014

submissionscomments
cabinpark··on Raytracing a Black Hole
Nice introduction. My colleague works exclusively in raytracing around black holes (although he uses the Kerr metric) and he has produced some really cool images.

I highly recommend looking at the literature for really cool images with more complicated black holes.

cabinpark··on Einstein Notation applied in programming
True. I'm just a lazy relativist though ;)
cabinpark··on Einstein Notation applied in programming
Since these are Euclidean spaces, the difference between contravariant and covariant indices is non-existent. So it doesn't matter whether the indices are upstairs or downstairs.
cabinpark··on Leaked Palantir Doc Reveals Uses, Specific Functions and Key Clients
I've attended Palantir tech talks before and they try to "hide it". Everyone in the room knew and the person giving the talk kept talking about the other uses of Palantir beyond government things. However all the examples they use were based on war scenarios in Iraq.
cabinpark··on The Man Behind Common Core Math
I think the greater problem is not with the standards (which I know nothing about) but with who is teaching it. I have talked to people who are elementary school teachers who know nothing about mathematics, yet they are given the task to teach it to children. They have little understanding of why the mathematics they teach is important and useful. If you don't give children a solid foundation in their formative years, they will always struggle with mathematics.
cabinpark··on How to Learn Efficiently
I was very lucky, from an early age, to be told that I should focus on learning how I learnt. I figured out how I learnt best in high school and never looked back. Now I have no problems learning any skill becase I know how my brain learns things and thus can cater specifically to it.

Unfortunately there is no catch-all method to learning and it is something you have to discover for yourself through exploration and good old trial-and-error.

cabinpark··on Should digital monopolies be broken up?
Why is it the government's job to tell companies they cannot be monopolies, especially in non-essential services?
cabinpark··on Should digital monopolies be broken up?
No one is forcing you to use Google, Facebook, Amazon or any other Internet website. End of story for me.
cabinpark··on Calculus with pics and gifs
I don't believe it was borrowed as it is something that is definitely taught in courses. I remember learning it at some point early on in my mathematics education.

I definitely know I knew it by my vector calculus course (2nd year) where we use the various named theorems to translate between the differential and integral forms of Maxwell's equations.

cabinpark··on The Cost of Waterloo Software Engineering
And that's why they have 8 month co-ops in addition to 4 month co-ops.
cabinpark··on A Unified Mathematical Language for Physics and Engineering (1996) [pdf]
I don't think it's that uncommon. The advanced GR course I took used tetrads and spinors. It seems to me that this is rather standard for a graduate GR course.
cabinpark··on Fluid Tests Hint at Concrete Quantum Reality
I agree and disagree with what you're saying. I agree it is laziness and bad science that physicists stopped caring about the philosophical underpinnings of quantum mechanics but I disagree that it was because quantum mechanics not being the ultimate theory.

The reason most physicists don't think about the philosophical underpinnings has more to do with the way quantum mechanics is taught. Many of the founders were interested in the philosophical questions but after WWII you can see a sharp decrease in that aspect and more of the hardcore calculation and the philosophy kind of disappeared. Here [1] is a great talk that discusses this very point. Unfortunate for quantum mechanics because understanding the philosophical underpinnings is critical to understanding what quantum mechanics says and doesn't say. But, thanks to things like quantum computing and better experiments, interpretations is becoming more mainstream since there are experiments being planned (at least when I was heavily involved in the area in 2010) that would be able to test some of the claims made by different interpretations.

>We are all waiting for a better theory of physics. Of course rewriting the quantum theory in different forms, like this attempt, might help in getting there.

To me this is a contradiction. If we are all waiting for a better theory, then why are we re-writing the theory? A critical part of all the interpretations I've encountered [2] is making different ontological claims about quantum mechanics. Take Bohmian, which posits a guiding wave. Sure we can make some of the mathematics nicer, but we can't go very far without explaining what this 'guiding wave' is, which itself is rather ad hoc. Plus, how do we rectify it with Bell's theorem on hidden variables? To me, we can't really begin re-writing quantum mechanics without inevitably running into ontological statements.

But I still agree with your premise. I believe that by pushing the limits of quantum mechanics both scientifically and philosophically we will get a better grasp of what things to look for / where to look, for a deeper theory. Case in point, wavefunction collapse. Some might consider it a huge problem of quantum mechanics, but if you take a different ontological view, wavefunction collapse isn't that interesting or important. So maybe wavefunction collapse isn't as important and trying to develop a theory that doesn't have it is the wrong idea.

[1] http://pirsa.org/08090000/ [2] http://pirsa.org/C10002

cabinpark··on Reasons to use Haskell as a Mathematician (2006)
What does this mean? I've seen this before and I don't get what it means.

Look more like the actual equations? Can you give me a concrete example of Haskell code that solves a simple PDE?

cabinpark··on Reasons to use Haskell as a Mathematician (2006)
> The central fact is that even though it is technically possible, it is considered bad style in Haskell to access or update individual array elements.

And another reason why Haskell will not fair well. A lot of numerical mathematics is linear algebra which involves, almost exclusively, updating array elements.

I'm sure Haskell is good at some things but for many of the types of problems that numerical analysts face Haskell's paradigm just doesn't make sense. Especially when we have languages like Fortran/Matlab which were explicitly designed for computational mathematics.

cabinpark··on Calculus for the Practical Man
Not really. Intro calculus hasn't changed much in the last 100 years beyond becoming more and more streamlined.

Although in a newer book you might see more modern applications and maybe some more streamlined proofs.

cabinpark··on Calculus for the Practical Man
Most introductory discrete mathematics textbooks should cover basic graph theory.
cabinpark··on Calculus for the Practical Man
Sorry if I am sceptical but I don't really believe your claim that you were able to obtain a sound working knowledge of calculus from the Principia.

For one thing, Newton barely makes use of calculus in the textbook and instead opts for geometric methods. And even with that, he is not rigorous at all because rigor hadn't been discovered yet. I wouldn't even put it on the same level as modern textbooks since so much had yet to be discovered about calculus.

I would not recommend the Principa to anyone except for historical interest. Everything in that book has been said more concisely by other people in the three hundred years since it was published.

cabinpark··on Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top Universities
Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top US Universities

I was expecting universities from all around the world but this is just the US.

cabinpark··on The Dropout Fallacy
Another interesting point is looking at the time of graduation. There is a big difference between a high school diploma in the 1960s vs the 2000s thus making it an unfair comparison. Back then it was much easier to go places without a diploma whereas nowadays, it is certainly possible, but much much harder.
cabinpark··on The Dropout Fallacy
Zuckerberg, Gates, Gaga, and Dell all had upper class parents and attended exclusive private high schools. Jobs was brilliantly smart but did come from a lower class family. Oprah comes from a very poor background and did make it successful. However she works in a completely different industry so I don't think it's at all fair to compare her to the tech folks.
cabinpark··on The Dropout Fallacy
I agree completely. I am very fortunate to have been taught a young age on the importance of learning how to learn and is something I was able to work out in my early teens when life is a lot simpler. I absolutely ate up university because I discovered that I loved reading textbooks and would go to the library all the time and pickup advanced books in my field and read them. Going to lectures was then a nice way to fill in the missing gaps.

I have found that all the successful people I know had a similar approach to learning. Instead of being complacent with education, they made it work for them, whatever approach that may be. A crappy professor would be fixed by either going to a different lecturer, seeing the professor after hours, discussing the subjects with upper years, going to the library, and so on. Basically, they took control of their education and made it work. Reading the biographies of all the people mentioned in the article, I get the feeling they were like that as well. The fact they dropped out is almost completely irrelevant to their success.

cabinpark··on Hadoop's Uncomfortable Fit in HPC
I guess, but at an HPC conference I went to last year there was a big session on Hadoop and introducing it to the researchers as a potential alternative for certain tasks. I also believe that technologies take a lot longer to penetrate academia then industry given the nature of academics so I don't doubt Hadoop's slow acceptance into the HPC community. Look at GPUs for example. They've been around for a while but it's really only been in the last few years that the tool has been put into the toolkits of researchers.

I do know one professor math professor who just a few hundred thousand on a Hadoop cluster to experiment with numerical algorithms. Talking with him, and I trust his opinion since he does research specifically in high performance linear algebra, was that he thought the technology was very appealing and can be an excellent addition to the repertoire. However there is still much work to be done since numerical linear algebra (which is the backbone of almost every single HPC calculation) using the Hadoop framework is very young. I believe it'll take a few years for researchers to determine whether or not Hadoop could be a useful tool for solving the types of problems academics do or whether it's just not as effective as the current tools.

cabinpark··on Why bad scientific code beats code following "best practices"
Apparently people didn't like what I said. But I stand by it. If you are using the built-in random number generator in your simulations you are doing something VERY stupid.

The built-in random() is not a good source of random numbers for scientific purposes. I've heard too many stories about how people don't think about the random number generator, only to have it bite them in the ass.

cabinpark··on Why bad scientific code beats code following "best practices"
If you are a computational scientist who is using random() for any part of your simulation, you are an idiot.
cabinpark··on Scientific computing’s future: Can Haskell, Clojure, or Julia top Fortran?
Absolutely! Has anyone written a server in Fortran?
cabinpark··on Scientific computing’s future: Can Haskell, Clojure, or Julia top Fortran?
I think people forget that Fortran was designed to only do mathematics. I don't know of any other languages that are designed just to do number crunching and nothing else. Even though C is very low level, you can write almost anything in it. Even MATLAB/Julia are able to do more general purpose programming which Fortran doesn't really allow.

The more domain specific you are, the better you are at that one task. This is where Fortran excels and why it won't be replaced any time soon.

cabinpark··on Scientific computing’s future: Can Haskell, Clojure, or Julia top Fortran?
I was going to write a long post but you really summarised my thoughts exactly. Haskell and Clojure don't even make my list of scientific programming languages.

My old university switched from C++ to Python for teaching the physicists, which I think is a good move. For many scientists, Python has most of the tools they need to do their research effectively and there is no need to go into the more work-horse languages of C/C++/Fortran. If they need the more work-horse languages of C/C++/Fortran, there are plenty of resources available.

The supercomputing consortium at my old university were also making a big push towards Python (over MATLAB) and, I think this is good, teaching scientists how to write and maintain code. Software Carpentry regularly came through and gave weekend sessions on tools like version control (which I have seen more and more scientists use) and how to write readable code.

I think people are recognising the need to teach the basics of software engineering to scientists and it is catching on in Canada based on what I've seen from Compute Canada (the group in charge of all the academic supercomputers in Canada). I think as the current generation, who are now being taught to use these tools early on, becomes professors, we will see even more of this. Unfortunately it will take time but it is changing.

cabinpark··on The Challenge of the Brachistochrone
That's a poor reflection on his education then. Even the purest mathematics majors I knew still were aware of the applications of most of what they learnt.
cabinpark··on The Challenge of the Brachistochrone
What are multivariate differential equations? Is that another name for partial differential equations? If so, then I assume your office mate was joking?
cabinpark··on The Challenge of the Brachistochrone
Unless you misunderstood your professor, what they said is entirely and utterly wrong. Calculus of variations is one of the guiding principles of modern physics. Pull out any textbook on quantum field theory or general relativity and there will be a section dedicated to using calculus of variations to derive the equations of motion. Heck, for a lot of theories, writing down the action and deriving the equations of motion from the Euler-Lagrange equations is the first thing you do.

Plus calculus of variations is closely related to differential geometry, which is a massive field. Same with control theory, another massive field with close ties to differential geometry and calculus of variations.

I have no idea what point your professor was trying to make.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →